Is blog commenting good or bad ?

[paulrigby]

Commenting in blogs with our site link is good or bad method?

I heard that doing commenting in blogs with our link is not good and there is a chance to become spam, is it true? especially in google search engines.

[raviv]

Hi
Make sure the blog you comment on is in the same niche as your site.

Look at the posts and judge the quality. If the content is of good quality, then pick out a post that interests you and make a comment that enhances the post. In other words, add something of value to the discussion.

At the end of the day it is not the number of blogs you comment on. It is the quality of the links you acquire by commenting on thematically related good quality blogs. Do not worry about the link being nofollow or dofollow or whatever. Make sure the blog sits on a good strong domain in a good neighborhood.

The blog owners of such blogs will be careful in approving comments as they are passionate about their blogs. Quality matters and not just quantity.
Best
Raviv

[hilhilginger]

If you want to drive traffic to the website without considering the PR then It is good practice to do blog commenting. You will get direct traffic from these links if your content is related to your service or an offer.

[rosesmark]

A simple advice - enable the moderation feature and manually delete all comments.If you don't like

[Velant]

Blog commenting is definitely good if you do it properly, i.e. post really helpful comments, not just anything for the sake of getting links. Think GIVE, not only RECEIVE.

In terms of getting link juice to boot you rankings, you need to post on DOFOLLOW blogs, as most blogs by defualt are Nofollow.

Another smart considerations to bear in mind when commenting are:
1. Comment on blogs related to you niche and try to bring in value in your comments.
2. Try to comment on pages with little comments (I'd say under 5), or the link has little value.
3. Comment on Blogs with Good Alexa rank (indirect indication of traffic). Even if you don't get link juice because of two many outbound links on the page, you may get some traffic from the blog.

Anton

[Richard Goldie]

It is good if you make the comment worthwhile. Much better to get approved for a site that doesn't have a thousand comments. So take a bit of time and works out well.

[davidhill9991]

Yes blog commenting helps to increase inbound links as well as it also help to increase the website traffic.
But you should check weather the blog allows do follow attribute or not. If you comment on no follow attribute blogs , You are not going to get any thing of it. So make a list of do follow blogs, try to write relevant comment on the topic or relate to the post. Otherwise blog admin won't approve your post.

[Sukhdeepak]

Blog commenting is very good for website promotion. Blog commenting increases inbound links and helps us in promoting our website on search engines. The links must be do follow.

[thunderseo]

most definitely yes... but you really have to make sure that the blog you are commenting to is relevant to your niche. And provide a non-spammy comments.

[Chris Kent]

Do not drop links in your actual comments but only in the url field.

Many blogs assume that a link dropped in the comment field is spam.

[BestwaY]

Commenting In Blogs Is A weapon with two-edged If You Comment In Spam And Random Way Google Will Put Your Website in Sandbox

Be careful With This Type Of Links Building Just Make A Comment Ever Day With Relative words In that Blog

[khenmhike]

It always depends on the content of the comment. If the comment is not related to your post, it might cause a bad effect to your blog.

[ablee]

Blog commenting is definitely beneficial. Like others have said make sure you are commenting on blogs that are related to your niche and that your provide good intellectual thoughts.

[allsystems]

Originally Posted by Chris Kent

Do not drop links in your actual comments but only in the url field.

Many blogs assume that a link dropped in the comment field is spam.

would you say if you put your link in the area where your name is then you would be safer and its not regarded as spamming?

[pethanks]

It is good but of course don't make it looks spammy. Having that kind of method will boost your ranking.

[masterlogisticsuk]

Off course the blog commenting is very beneficial.As if we comment in other but related blogs then it is the good source of the link buikding and good for our site and search engine ranking.But make sure that the blog provides do follow link then only it is good for your site otherwise google would not crawl your site and you would not get google's benefit.

[LoginBD]

Blog commenting is obviously very good for your site....Bcs it will bring visitor to your site on the other hand it will create back link for your site.But you must be careful that the comment should be related with the written post, you should to do SEO not Spamming.....

[logoonlinepros1]

Comments on Do follow blog is very helpful to get backlinks fast from it.
There is also some plugins available like commentluv and other..

[paulina261184]

Originally Posted by paulrigby

Commenting in blogs with our site link is good or bad method?

I heard that doing commenting in blogs with our link is not good and there is a chance to become spam, is it true? especially in google search engines.

Hi,

It is not always the case. You can feel free to comment in blogs but at the same time ensure that you have answered their question or commented to the blog with relevance. I am an SEO expert myself, and have commented hundreds of blogs with my links but hardly very few have been deleted.

Best Regards,
Pauline
school of seo international

[samual james]

Originally Posted by [LEFT

paulina261184[/LEFT];3339976]Hi,

It is not always the case. You can feel free to comment in blogs but at the same time ensure that you have answered their question or commented to the blog with relevance. I am an

SEO expert myself, and have commented hundreds of blogs with my links but hardly very few have been deleted.

Best Regards,
Pauline
seo school of international

Try to ask some question or do discussion, don't spam blogs.

[oclane]

Of course Blog Commenting is good. Its a good way to get backlinks to your site. The only thing you should consider before doing it is if the blog you're posting at is a do follow one and your comment. Make a good and informative content which can be approve by the blog moderators.

[serem]

Thematic blog commenting is good for a website. Go for do follow blog commenting. You will get backlinks for your website and SERP ranking.

[workwithcherry]

It is definitely good for traffic and ranking provided it is helpful and non-spammy

[kangen]

Originally Posted by hilhilginger

If you want to drive traffic to the website without considering the PR then It is good practice to do blog commenting. You will get direct traffic from these links if your content is related to your service or an offer.

I agree to you on this post, very great post.

[GeraldGigerl]

Blog commenting works and is powerful. The thing is that most people
do it the wrong way. The check out some blog which actually are not
related to their website. Besides they leave a random comment, post
something that is not congruent with the post etc.

The sense of blog commenting is to provide value to the website
owners blog.
It´s not about posting 48 comments per day with stuff like:
Great post, will do something about it!

Rather thinking about how you can relate to what the publisher
stated in his post.

For instance: You contemplate leaving a blog comment on a
blog that is about Michael Jackson.

You might want to post something like:
"In my opinion Michael Jackson has been one of the greatest
in the music industry. He inspired countless people with his
uniqueness. It´s a pity that he passed, and left his fans sad. "

You can go deeper here, but this is just how it works.

Build fewer backlinks but high quality, because if you don´t
add value, the blog owner won´t even publish your comment.
This means = your work is for ****ing nothing.

That´s were most people go wrong.

Hope this helps!

Gerald

[angelarah]

blog commenting is good, but only if it is substantial. show that you have actually read the blog post and say more than 'great post, thanks!' that just shouts spam.

commenting on blogs also helps you engage with other people in your field and potentially help you make solid connections.

[SingerRinging]

I welcome comments on my blog. I mean, how else are we going to interact?

I'm good at ignoring negative comments, and I learn a lot from the good ones.

When I leave a comment, I usually include a link because I feel I have something valuable to offer the community. If a comment is negative, it's pointless to leave a link. But you can learn a lot from others' links!

[Kurt Abel]

Blog commenting is a great way to get both links and traffic. But you have to think of this like any other transaction. The blog owner is giving you a valuable link. In return you need to add something of value to his site.

Ask a question, tell him why you agree (or disagree respectfully), expand on what he is talking about. Don't just write nice post, or I like your theme. That's spam, and no blog owner wants a page full of those comments.

As long as you are offering something of value, it is a great way to get links.

[Sue McDonald]

The best comments must be relevant to the post. For you the best sites to comment are those that have a high PR.
If you disagree with the post let the writer know - why but do not do it in an arrogant manner. If you have a good point of view, the owner of the blog may appreciate reading what you have to say.

[Aki Fagno]

It actually depends on the way you do your comments. It won't be measured as spam if you comment properly on the post. As much as doable don't endorse. Acquire the initiative of the content and give your thoughts.

[MrPolarZero]

commenting in blogs with your link is not considered as spam, not unless you post several comments on one particular blog. Basically, blog commenting is a good way to promote our blogs and build quality inbound links.

[billspaced]

There is nothing wrong at all with posting relevant comments that add value to the user experience on blogs!

I don't care if they're "do follow," in my own niche, or what, adding to a conversation that you are truly interested in has 3 distinct benefits:

1. You make a contribution. People actually respect you for that, which *may* lead them to
2. Trust you or be curious enough to check you out (you'll get direct traffic) and
3. You will get a backlink.

If you're goal is to get a backlink, please follow #1. Getting a variety of links back to your site is a sound SEO strategy--just make sure you actually give something in the conversation.

[sijugk]

I do blog commenting. Before commenting on a blog I will check whether the blog is in my niche. Second thing is whether they give dofollow links or not. If you are looking for link juice don't waste your time with commenting on noofllow blogs. If you prefer popularity of your blog, then feel free to comment others blogs without checking whether they offer dofollow links or not. Always add value in your comments.

[Watch Store]

You should provide good, informative comments to blogs with a high pr rank.

[Captain Dynamo]

I definately use blog commenting. scrape competitor sites for PR 4,5,6,7 dofollow blogs and then place non spammy comments. Espcially high PR .edu sites, the best!

You need scrapebox for the job and learn exactly how to use it.

[John Baron]

imo its only good for indexing , you wont get much SEO benefit from it besides that .

[agravity]

Nothing is bad till you do it in proper way and limit. So, keep it doing

[craigcdz]

Originally Posted by paulrigby

Commenting in blogs with our site link is good or bad method?

I heard that doing commenting in blogs with our link is not good and there is a chance to become spam, is it true? especially in google search engines.

blog commenting is really good and give instant results. it is the most helpful activity to improve your SERP's but comment on high pr and instant approve blogs.

[SamyPong]

hi,
It is really good not because of getting a live links but the quality of exchanging ideas in every human possesed.
thanks,
samy

[SEO Coach]

blog commenting is a no-brainer from a back-linking point of view - and all references to getting links in your niche are spot on...

however no one on this thread has outlined the real reason for commenting, and that is to get to know the blogger!

real bloggers love great comments and notice people who are adding value to the conversation...

leave 8-10 great comments, then approach the blogger about doing a guest post....

this is the real power of commenting on blogs because then you start to not only get backlinks but you borrow traffic as well, and possibly find regular readers and visitors to your site...

[seo-expert]

Make sure you add value to the blog that you are commenting on. Not the generic "thank you for this great blog" post but something that would interest others that is related to the blog.

Be sure to post on blogs with contents that are related to your site(s). Adding some target keywords would help.

[ayushiinfo]

blog commenting is definitely good we get more back links via blog commenting ..some blogs are give more links to our site but we post valuable commenting then only moderator will accept

[iphonesupport]

it is good method for getting back links, find various blogs that allow commenting. do commenting with link and anchor text. if comment is approved it will give you strong back link for your website. so blog commenting is very good practice in seo

[aidanjb1]

It is still a powerful method. The main thing is to try to comment on blogs relevant to your niche and make a real comment, not a spam comment...don't write just 1 line saying "thank you" and expect it to get approved permanently.

Hope this helps.

[paulrigby]

Hi aidanjb1, how could google read the comment which is written in one line as a SPAM comment, ?

[julie9999]

Blog commenting is very good for every sites and blog. Only take care blof should be most relevant and there should be no bad links in that blog which can harm ur site.

[MonsterMarketing]

Blog commenting is defiantly not a bad thing. The only way it can be bad is if it's spam. But even then, your getting back links. If you properly comment on blogs, you will gain more unique traffic then if you were to spam.

[mygold]

Blog comments make just back link not make traffic. Why you comments on that site? Your comments my be spam if they does not like this.

[calfred]

Blog Commenting Best Practices

- use your real names (aka human names) and not your keyword
- make sure you add value when writing comments (no spammy comments like thanks, thank you, nice post. At least, write 3 sentences to show you really cared about the blog post)

[jack jastin]

In my opinion, Blog commenting gives you a way to get inbound links for your site but it will not be beneficial until unless your commenting is at somewhere having quality and worth.