Badly in need of Expert suggestion about Blog Commenting.

[Arav]

So, as there was no response to my similar thread,I've to post it here againg.
The problem is after writing a RELEVANT and STANDARD (long enough,not Spammy) comment, when I submit it for posting, the comment doesn't appear after reloading or a Blank page appears. So, I got suggestion that it might be due to ''Akismet'.
Then I went through some Akismet testing pages and did comment there with a link into it according to the authors suggestion. There my comments appeared though with a 'Awaiting for moderation' tag. But it appeared, means I'm not being banned by Akismet.(According to the test procedure).
But the problem is these tests couldn't assure that I'm Free from Akismet's action. Because, several times I found no result like above with comments even with No link within it or at name url. That comments were not a SPAM from any view, but still didn't appear.
I heard apart from me, many peoples are having the same problem.
So, now I'm badly in need of an Expert's suggestion of how to get rid of this "Frustrating Nasty" situation and get comments approved, at least appear fro moderation.
Suggestion from those guys who have been overcome this problem is Really appreciable.
Thanks.

[eurekapsycrille]

I have gone through the same situation. But I don't consider it as a big issue. Why? Because some blogs are allowing you to write your comments but when you submit it, it disappears. I think because of the moderation.

But don't think that the moderators are not reading your comments. They do read it, but mostly they are not allowing comments to be posted on their blogs specially if it has a link pointing to your site.

In my experience in blog commenting, I think there's no technical issues about this matter. It's all up to the moderators if they want your comments to get posted on their blogs. In this case also, the value of your comments will be useless if they don't want it to get approved.

So, in order for you to not get really frustrated, don't expect too much in blog commenting. Yes, they do have a great value when it comes to SEO, but in one condition: if and only if it gets approved. So just leave comments and do not expect too much. if it gets approved, it's good. If not, then go and find another blog to leave your comments.

[Arav]

Originally Posted by eurekapsycrille

I have gone through the same situation. But I don't consider it as a big issue. Why? Because some blogs are allowing you to write your comments but when you submit it, it disappears. I think because of the moderation.

But don't think that the moderators are not reading your comments. They do read it, but mostly they are not allowing comments to be posted on their blogs specially if it has a link pointing to your site.

In my experience in blog commenting, I think there's no technical issues about this matter. It's all up to the moderators if they want your comments to get posted on their blogs. In this case also, the value of your comments will be useless if they don't want it to get approved.

So, in order for you to not get really frustrated, don't expect too much in blog commenting. Yes, they do have a great value when it comes to SEO, but in one condition: if and only if it gets approved. So just leave comments and do not expect too much. if it gets approved, it's good. If not, then go and find another blog to leave your comments.

The Technical issue comes front because this is happening mostly for Wordpress blogs. I've tried with very Relevant comment which contributes to that topic without any sort of link with it,still same things happens.
At wordpress forum I read that even some of the blog owners are unable to post comment in their own blogs! Many of them want readers to post comment without any sort of registration or moderation,but it's not being possible for them too!
Actually the Frustration arises when I see the success rate is only 3-4%.
Anyways, thanks for sharing your experience.

[eurekapsycrille]

Originally Posted by Arav

The Technical issue comes front because this is happening mostly for Wordpress blogs. I've tried with very Relevant comment which contributes to that topic without any sort of link with it,still same things happens.
At wordpress forum I read that even some of the blog owners are unable to post comment in their own blogs! Many of them want readers to post comment without any sort of registration or moderation,but it's not being possible for them too!
Actually the Frustration arises when I see the success rate is only 3-4%.
Anyways, thanks for sharing your experience.

If that's the case, then the problem is in the wordpress blogging platform itself. But the thing is, there are thousands of blogs to leave your comments that are not using wordpress.

Also, we have nothing to do with it if that's really the problem unless the wordpress platform owner recognize our agony in leaving comments in their blogs. Actually, there's nothing to worry about with that matter.