Wannabe Neophyte Copywriter Seeks Critique

9 replies
I was encouraged yesterday, by several people, to write a sales letter promoting myself as a potential, Wannabe copywriter and post it here.

Here it is, (and please try to be gentle in beating the tar outta me):



Dear Mr. Jones,

This is Gene A------ in Knoxville, Tennessee (I go by Geno), and I'm writing to make you an offer. Picture Vito Corleone in The Godfather saying, in his low-key, raspy voice, "I'm gonna make you an offer you can't refuse. Kapish?"

My offer revolves around a simple premise; I want to be a copywriter for you and your company.

Now, why would you consider my proposal? This is a reasonable question. Let me start, briefly, with my education, background and experience.

I have none, zero, zilch, nada.

I did say "briefly", right?

So, this begs the question, "Why would I, Conrad Jones, entertain your ridiculous offer?" and "Why should I even continue reading this letter?"

Okay, that was two questions, but I will strive to answer them to your complete satisfaction. Bear with me.

First I'll give you the reasons to continue reading my letter and consider the offer; then I'll get to the actual offer you won't be able, in my humble opinion, to refuse.

Reason 1 - I'm a CREATIVE SOB, humble and self-effacing too, and I can write.
Reason 2 - I can be extremely persuasive, as I suspect you're beginning to realize.
Reason 3 - I'm fierce and tenacious, like a hungry Pit Bull. You can't beat or discourage a hungry Pit Bull now, can you? You ever looked into the eyes of a hungry Pit Bull? Hopefully not, but you get the picture; case closed!
Reason 4 - I can tune in to human nature... peoples' hopes, fears, desires and hidden, secret motivations. I'm a living barometer of human nature. I can even sense that you, in fact, are warming up to me now, as you read.
Reason 5 - I'm originally from Brooklyn, New York, and I not only survived, but thrived. Need I say more?
Reason 6 - Lastly, but certainly not least, I don't even know the meaning of "NO!" That word is not in my dictionary or my vocabulary, although I used it here just to make a point.

NOW, for the offer you can't refuse:

Simply give me a shot, either with a real, defunct or "make-believe" project, and see what I can do. As long as it is not tech oriented (I am not a techie kinda guy)... as long as it's something I can examine and see what it's about and what goodies it offers... I'll tear into it like that hungry Pit Bull, and crank out creative, compelling, call-to-action copy. Can you see the dollars rolling in?

If I can do this for you, and you're happy, you've got yourself a grateful, hard-working, loyal, neophyte copywriter. If I can't, you simply say, "Don't call me, I'll call you," or, "Let's have lunch sometime," or, "The pink slip's in the mail," and I'll slink away, never to be seen or heard from again.

You cannot beat this offer.

If I'm good, you gain and you get to bring happiness and fulfillment to a fellow human being. The humanitarian in you surely wants to leap at this opportunity.

If I'm lousy, which frankly is an unimaginable scenario, you can enjoy the simple pleasure of giving an arrogant loser the ole heave-ho.

This is truly a win-win proposition.

There are no promises or commitments to make, no money down or easy payment plans.

If you like me... you keep me... and gladly dig into your bank account eventually. If you conclude I'm bogus or a no-talent, Wannabe pretender, you simply show me the door and tell me "Sayonara, pal. Maybe you can get on with Walmart."

There you go. Those are the reasons and the offer. There's no way you can lose! You won't even have to give me a credit-card number. No money-back guarantee coz you don't pay unless we play. Totally risk free!

I'm ready to roll when you are!

Best Regards,
Geno
#copywriter #critique #neophyte #seeks #wannabe
  • Profile picture of the author Andrew Gould
    I'm not the person to help you with this Geno, as you're about as far from my ultra-conservative style as it's possible to get.

    But I did tell you I'd give you my thoughts:

    Don't work for free.

    You typically want to be asking to talk, not trying to sell them.

    Rather ironically, given that you're going to crank out call-to-action copy, there's no CTA.
    Signature

    Andrew Gould

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10485969].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author angiecolee
    I mentioned the common mistakes most new copywriters make, and you've made them.

    Good news - that means you're completely normal. What you do from here is what will distinguish you as a copywriter, though. You can always use constructive criticism (even when it stings) to find a way to improve.

    I'm not saying my way is the right way - but buried in criticism you usually will find nuggets of ideas that resonate with you. Use them.

    That said...

    I got to this line before I stopped (I skimmed the rest for the purposes of this critique): "I'm gonna make you an offer you can't refuse. Kapish?"

    1) pretty corny. I get appealing to something pop culture and typically associated with common knowledge, but so far this creative SOB is using someone else's lines to stick out.

    2) You don't get to ME until the second half. Blunt truth: prospects don't really care about you. Everyone out there is looking for someone who can solve or help solve their problems.

    So far you've told me you have zero experience, you've shot yourself down before building yourself up, and you haven't given me any indication that you get what kind of problems I have or have any ideas on how to solve them.

    This whole letter is about me helping you, in a nutshell. I'm busy. Business owners and marketers are busy. Find a way to help the busy people, and you're much more valuable than the hundreds of hungry newbies constantly asking for help.


    EDITED TO ADD:
    Check out the critique checklist at the top, in the stickies. It may help clarify some of what's being mentioned in the replies to your post.
    Signature

    Aspiring copywriters: if you need 1:1 advice from an experienced copy chief, head over to my Phone a Friend page.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10485984].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Genocris
      Great feedback, guys. I appreciate the time, wisdom and effort.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10485997].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author kk075
      Originally Posted by angiecolee View Post

      I got to this line before I stopped (I skimmed the rest for the purposes of this critique): "I'm gonna make you an offer you can't refuse. Kapish?"
      I did the exact same thing...I never made it out of the first paragraph. The last thing you want to do it tell a targeted reader that you're going to sell them something. Nothing past that point will ever get read- it goes straight into the trash.
      Signature

      Learn to sell like a pro through Web Synergy's marketing blog.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10486346].message }}
  • I would stick to being a Neophyte Copywriter over Potential Wannabe Neophyte.

    Cuts to the chase quicker.

    I appreciate your jokes right at the start, but I figure busy potential clients will not.

    You hit them with your name, an a.k.a., a suggested tone of voice, then philosophize to no great effect.

    Then comes a list of qualities wherein you have the audacity to tell the reader how to feel about you, followed by your terms an' conditions for the shot this person is clearly stoopid not to give ya.

    Now, there is no problem with takin' this angle once in a while, but your subversive wit gotta make the reader pee themselves.

    If you are gonna go down this track then I figure you gotta prune this down to half its length an' demonstrate you are a CREATIVE SOB by unleashin' more strikin' quadrupeds than Pit Bulls.

    Done well, an' pitched at people who can handle this kinda stuff, it is an option.

    Mosta the time though, people gonna want you dished up straighter, pitchin' for their exclusive benefit.

    So alla your reasons an' offers gotta be reconfigured so they speak to your prospect an' their needs.

    Sadly, that means a generic catch-all pitch won't work.

    But that does not stop you generatin' a broad template into which you can drop the necessary specifics for each submission.
    Signature

    Lightin' fuses is for blowin' stuff togethah.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10486080].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
    Genocris,

    Target your marketing.

    Pick a niche.

    Narrow down to solving a specific problem for that niche.

    THEN you can mail them a letter stating that you'll solve this specific problem that they know they have.

    The more you niche, the more you'll earn.

    Generalists have to compete with everybody.

    They can't say in a few words what they do and who they help.

    Figure out your target market.

    Find out what problem(s) they're complaining about that you can solve through copywriting.

    Articulate that to them in your prospecting letter.

    Be confident about your ability to solve the problem. People want to do business with competent people; only psychopaths want to do business with subordinate runaways. Drop this "I'll work for free" nonsense. It's entirely unnecessary.

    And get that CTA in there.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10486358].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author ewenmack
      Geno, let's work through this together
      so as to make it work.

      First lets both agree the object is to get an advertiser to phone you...
      can we agree on this?

      Then let's see who is the ideal person on the other end of the phone...

      He invests heavily in advertising. Many different media.
      Why? Because any small change you make for him means lot's of dollars in return, therefore he can justify your fees that a small time advertiser couldn't.
      Simple maths plus you make more money for the same amount of work.

      Next criteria for your ideal client is already using direct response advertising.
      This is so he already is a believer in what you do. So many try to persuade, convince and cajole non believers...it's a recipe for frustration for both parties.

      Now we know a bit about who the ideal client is,
      let's move on to profiling his daily life so we work
      within those constraints.

      Well he's very busy running a multi-million dollar enterprise.

      He gets angry at his time being wasted by pests.

      He will welcome as a guest if you understand his world,
      demonstrate you do, get to the relevant point very quick
      and it's not something he has heard before.

      Tough task you say.

      That's your challenge, he's got a business to run,
      if you have something that you know he will want to hear,
      then give it to him, straight.

      So now you have your outcome you want, you know what you are up against,
      so let's hatch a plan to achieve it...are you with me?

      Good.

      So grabbing his attention is the first job, then keeping it.

      So what will be relevant?

      Will a current ad he's running in the newspaper
      would be a good start.

      He's got money tied up in that sucker.

      He's probably got good or bad feelings about it.

      So, let's cut out a copy of it for visual and emotional impact.

      That's your attention grabber.

      What comes next is crucial to keep his attention.

      So you'd reference it and move into creating curiosity around
      a BIG benefit.

      You hint it, don't fully divulge it so that creates enough tension in the reader
      to get the reader to phone you so his curiosity is satisfied.

      Balancing that is taking into the consideration of risk.

      Another words, is he going to have his time wasted.

      Let's back yourself by removing it.

      Part of the message is creating high status for yourself.

      If Elvis or Obama walked into his office, they'd have his full attention.

      You walking in to see if he has a job for you,
      low status, would rather you didn't come into his life,
      another words, a pest not a welcome guest.

      So a couple of ways of doing it is communicating you are busy
      and in demand. A person of high status is always busy and in demand.

      So let's see an example of what this would look like...

      Saw your ad in Knoxville News Sentinel.
      Got 3 ideas which gets your phone ringing with more buyers...not callers who ask, "how much are your ...".

      All three cost nothing to implement...one has to do with adding the letter s to a word in your headline...just that alone tripled response
      for a advertiser...I know, hard to believe.

      If you want these three ad response boosters so you get more bang for your ad dollars, give me, Geno, a call on xx xxx xx and they are yours free. "What's the catch?"

      If you like the extra money these simple changes make you, gratis, then you'll love what else I have...like competition eliminator secret, the phone caller who asks for price blocker, and what to add on to the sale
      so you get more dollars out of every buyer...just to name a few profit boosters you are going to love.

      I get paid by implementing these and more, simple tweaks for advertisers who are driven to turn advertising into a big money maker.

      First I need to "show you the money" before you insist I take time out of my busy schedule to work my magic on your advertising, your business.

      7 minutes is all it takes to see if indeed this is all b.s.,
      or real.

      If you think I wasted 7 minutes of your time, I'll donate $100 to your favorite
      charity.

      That number again, xx xxx xx. If the line is busy, please keep calling.


      There you go, the thinking required to get the outcome you are after.

      Best,
      Doctor E. Vile
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10486564].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Genocris
        Doctor E. Vile,

        Awesome stuff, Ewen. I so appreciate this input and the time it took you to do that for me.

        There is one thing you said, tho, that I don't quite agree with:

        Originally Posted by ewenmack View Post


        If Elvis or Obama walked into his office, they'd have his full attention.
        Now, I agree that if Elvis walked into his office, he would get real attention, especially in light of how decomposed and ratty he'd look. Even his sequined, white suit would look grungy and crappy.

        Obama walking in? Don't really know how much attention he'd get.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10487327].message }}
  • Elvis AND Obama - an' we are all sprayin' our current reality with the squirt of unrestrainable diarrheaf********x.
    Signature

    Lightin' fuses is for blowin' stuff togethah.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10487959].message }}

Trending Topics