One More Time - Is My Copy Good Enough?

13 replies
Hey warriors,

Ok, I got a copy critique from Harlan D. Kilstein

And I added some of his suggestions and was wondering if I could get some more opinions?

I have not launched it yet but anyway here it is:
TrafficInstitution!

Please be as honest as can be as I want to make this really good before the launch..

Greately appreciated..

Dennis
#copy #good #time
  • Profile picture of the author IRON_STRONG
    Honestly bro, the first thing i did was scroll down to see the testimonials. then i noticed you only had one. i think your biggest barrier is going to be the social proof aspect.

    i may not be the *ideal* customer, but being around IM for a while and being one who is trying to truly make it work for me, like so many who are, if i dont see enough HARD social proof as in, "

    "I bought X, i used X and X did this"

    i dont even waste my time. i have bought way to much stuff that has great claims with no backbone.

    as far as the copy it sounds like it would be a great product and it is quality but like i said, anyone who is like me and doesnt see someone with a website who actually got ranked, like you guarantee - will pass it up.

    my .02 cc's
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[219407].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Bruce Wedding
      Originally Posted by IRON_STRONG View Post

      i may not be the *ideal* customer, but being around IM for a while and being one who is trying to truly make it work for me, like so many who are, if i dont see enough HARD social proof as in, "

      "I bought X, i used X and X did this"

      i dont even waste my time. i have bought way to much stuff that has great claims with no backbone.
      If you've "been around IM for a while" then surely you know that testimonials on an IM sales page are about as credible as Oprah Winfrey selling a diet book. A day does not pass without someone making a post here asking for testimonials. Nor can you find a major IM marketer's page without testimonials from all his JV partners and friends.

      Testimonials are not required to sell. BottomLine proves that all the time. PROOF is required to sell and it comes in many forms. A lot of them are more credible than testimonials. Let me give you an example:

      If I'm selling software that creates a sales letter, would you prefer to see a testimonial from a friend of mine saying it's good or a Camtasia video of the software creating a sales letter? Seeing is believing my friend and the video is indisputable evidence.

      And videos are not the only form of proof. There are credentials, income proof, demonstrations, photos. Use your imagination.

      ETA: I looked at the page and it is filled with proof. Good job.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[220821].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Dennis Cheesman
    Yes, I don't have the testimonies up yet as it hasn't launched and I am just getting everything together..

    Testimonies are coming

    Dennis
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[219449].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author IRON_STRONG
    other than that i think the sale copy is damn good - maybe a bit ify on the headline, i really prefer short concise and benift driven only, but thats just me, i have a new direct mail piece thats fabulous that really consists of 4 words.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[220230].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author rapidshare
      See my post on the other thread.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[220242].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author J. Barry Mandel
    Dennis,

    It's coming along.

    I'd make some adjustments above the fold to start...

    1)Check your spelling in the pre-head
    2) Try a different color headline to help make it pop - green?
    3)Use italics in your sub-head to break it up and make it easier on the eyes

    Since automating the process is the #1 benefit I think that THAT should be part of the headline, because the way the headline is written does not speak to the reader. Remember the reader wants to know what your product will do for THEM. They don't care about discovering what you did and what happened to you- they just want that to happen to themselves!

    You could word this like...

    "Now You Can Take Advantage of How I Got All 14 Of My Websites On Page 1 Of Google, Yahoo, MSN, and Five Other Search Engines Within Two Weeks by Having the Whole Process *AUTOMATED* for You - for FREE!"

    Doing this would free up some clutter and it still drives the point hom that you want to make.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[220758].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Dennis Cheesman
    Thanks a lot for the comments...

    1)Check your spelling in the pre-head
    2) Try a different color headline to help make it pop - green?
    3)Use italics in your sub-head to break it up and make it easier on the eyes

    I tried the green in the headlines hows it look now? I also put up two headlines on the site that I am trying..

    Which one pulls you the best?

    Headline #1
    Headline #1!

    Headline #2
    Headline #2!

    Dennis
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[220956].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Bruce Wedding
      You're a lot closer with headline #2 for 2 reasons:

      1. Its about THEM, not you like your current headline
      2. You're driving home your USP, which is "automation"

      My overall comment is, why do I need a membership site to learn these things? Why can't I learn it in one shot. You need to convince me what I'm getting monthly to interest me.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[221109].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Dennis Cheesman
        Originally Posted by Bruce Wedding View Post

        You're a lot closer with headline #2 for 2 reasons:

        1. Its about THEM, not you like your current headline
        2. You're driving home your USP, which is "automation"

        My overall comment is, why do I need a membership site to learn these things? Why can't I learn it in one shot. You need to convince me what I'm getting monthly to interest me.
        Hi Bruce,

        Thanks for the comment..

        I added a little more of the benefits you will be getting, is that what you ment?

        I hope I didn't destroy it by adding more, making it longer?

        I added from the bolded:

        It's Your Turn To Get A Piece Of the Traffic Pie!

        To the testimony of Jason...

        Or is it not clear what I am offering?

        Again, thanks for the comments

        Dennis
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[221154].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author J. Barry Mandel
      I like headline number 2 Dennis, but the sub-head area is too congested.

      Remove this and you should be good to go IMO:

      ... At Traffic Institution, We Won't Just Tell You or Show You How It's Done - We'll Automate the Whole Process for You - for FREE!



      Originally Posted by Dennis Cheesman View Post

      Thanks a lot for the comments...




      I tried the green in the headlines hows it look now? I also put up two headlines on the site that I am trying..

      Which one pulls you the best?

      Headline #1
      Headline #1!

      Headline #2
      Headline #2!

      Dennis
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[221347].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author kkchoon
    The sales letter is nice, just add more testimonial and some videos...
    Signature

    Powerful Indexer That Makes Your Backlinks Count ==> Nuclear Link Indexer

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[221132].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Dennis Cheesman
    Hello Justin,

    Ok, I removed it

    Dennis
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[221379].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ecoverartist
    It just makes my day when somebody like Harlan Kilstein reviews something I wrote and doesn't have many adjustments to make! *happydance*

    Launch that site already Dennis! I want to see what kind of conversions you get with it!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[228393].message }}

Trending Topics