Why Isn't My 4 min Sales Video Working? Help!

15 replies
Hi 'all,

I created this (disguised) video sales letter on Youtube. It links to a squeeze page which then has another, longer sales video.

So far, with over 150 views, no sales.

What is wrong with this video? Is the narration too slow? Does it come over as too salesy? Is the information too basic?

Any copywriting advice much appreciated.


Cheers,
Max
#min #sales #video #working
  • Profile picture of the author John_S
    Apparently you missed the thread where video just works and is going to sweep sales letters into the dustbin of history.

    First, how many of the 150 were actually fire fighter candidates ...and how many wanted to check into becoming a firefighter?

    Next, it's not a "disguised" video sales letter. It's trite, obvious, and most transparently holding back information whilst giving a big, fat, sales pitch. The script seems to consist of exactly two sentences, repeated over-and-over -- search engine spam style.

    Don't keyword stuff a video ...say something. And this takes four minutes to say just about nothing. If anyone did expect information upon watching this, they felt cheated by the end. If they feel cheated before they buy, what exactly do you expect them to then do?

    "Why do you want to work for us" sounds like a generic scrape of every employment guide for any job ...ever. Okay, if they stop by the station and get a ride along, but you reveal nothing about what you're looking for in doing that research.

    It sounds like it was written by a Craigslist flunky for five bucks who has barely ever seen the outside of a fire station. The stock photos don't help.

    Nothing sounds like an inside tip. And there is zero which uses the strengths of video.

    It would never enter my mind to do anything but find a list of candidate fire fighters to mail to. This is a targeted product, not a mass access video. But you can try ditching the stock photos, do live location shots. Use video to make it seem as though you've actually had some experience getting access to fire stations and personnel. Interview fire fighters, and reveal some actual information.

    To sum up, the video lacks credibility. It doesn't offer anything, visually or verbally that would indicate you're an expert. Everything (not) in it screams you are an outsider and have not one little bit of insider information. One successful direct response headline is, "They gasped when I sprayed beer on my lawn. But you should see my golf-course green grass now!"

    Gives away INFORMATION, right in the headline. That's how it's done. Oh, and if you insist on using video -- make a video. Don't make a "video sales letter."
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815229].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Paul Hooper-Kelly
      Hi Max,

      Well, you did ask ...

      The first thing that comes across is the music, which sounds like it's an old cassette tape that's being played backwards.

      Music has an important part to play in a video, because it touches the emotions - and folks are moved by emotion. So you need to fit it to fit the subject. Not a problem with all the superb royalty free music around.

      I suggest you go here:

      Royalty free music clips, background music loops

      ... for 'Building The Nation', or a similar patriotic music to fire up your viewer.

      You can download a single track for a few bucks. If it's not long enough, simply paste the track into your time line as many times as you wish.

      I would suggest dropping the volume level during the narration and bringing it up again at the end with a picture of the happy, newly appointed firefighter to end the video.

      It's not so much what the narrator says so much as the way he says it. First he should put some enthusiasm into the idea of being a firefighter hero.

      Then he should be more specific and say that X% of candidates have their dreams shattered because they fall at the first hurdle - the interview.

      Then explain "It doesn't have to be like that" and paint an emotional word and visual picture (smiling new firefighter) to make them want to click your link to find out more.

      You might get some ideas from this sales letter I wrote:

      ADI Part 3. Learn EXACTLY What You Need To Pass!

      This is in a similar vein, because it covers the interview/test to become a driving instructor.

      I didn't create the video script - that was already done, but you'll see the delivery is crisper and more enthusiastic.

      Also you can get some ideas for a different angle for your video script from my text sales letter. Note the specific mention of the failure rate. That certainly needs to be in your video.

      Warmest regards,

      Paul
      Signature
      If you want to stack the copywriting deck in your favor with tricks and hacks producing winners like: "$20K in three days" "650 sold" "30% conversion", then you might like to know I'm retiring and will spill the beans to two people. More info here.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815486].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author NewbieWarrior
        THANKS, Paul. Extremely constructive criticism. This will help me a lot. The narration on the flat side, I agree.

        I think I bought one of your products a long time ago.

        Cheers,
        Max

        Originally Posted by Paul Hooper-Kelly View Post

        Hi Max,

        Well, you did ask ...

        The first thing that comes across is the music, which sounds like it's an old cassette tape that's being played backwards.

        Music has an important part to play in a video, because it touches the emotions - and folks are moved by emotion. So you need to fit it to fit the subject. Not a problem with all the superb royalty free music around.

        I suggest you go here:

        Royalty free music clips, background music loops

        for 'Building The Nation', or a similar patriotic music to fire up your viewer.

        You can download a single track for a few bucks. If it's not long enough, simply paste the track into your time line as many times as you wish.

        I would suggest dropping the volume level during the narration and bringing it up again at the end with a picture of the happy, newly appointed firefighter to end the video.

        It's not so much what the narrator says so much as the way he says it. First he should put some enthusiasm into the idea of being a firefighter hero.

        Then he should be more specific and say that X% of candidates have their dreams shattered because they fall at the first hurdle - the interview.

        Then explain "It doesn't have to be like that" and paint an emotional word and visual picture (smiling new firefighter) to make them want to click your link to find out more.

        You might get some ideas from this sales letter I wrote:

        ADI Part 3. Learn EXACTLY What You Need To Pass!

        This is in a similar vein, because it covers the interview/test to become a driving instructor.

        I didn't create the video script - that was already done, but you'll see the delivery is crisper and more enthusiastic.

        Also you can get some ideas for a different angle for your video script from my text sales letter. Note the specific mention of the failure rate. That certainly needs to be in your video.

        Warmest regards,

        Paul
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815685].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author RickDuris
      Chris,

      Are you a firefighter? If so, how long have you been one?

      Before I offer some ideas, it would help to know that first.

      - Rick Duris
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815551].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author NewbieWarrior
        Rick,

        I'm not a firefighter, just an affiliate for a firefighter's product. I actually bought that product myself (didn't get it free) and studied it to try to get into the mind of the prospect. That's how I got information for this video.

        I have experienced the frustation of trying and failing to get into the civil service, until I studied for the interview. So I do have some qualifications in that regard, but not as an actual firefighter.

        Max


        Originally Posted by RickDuris View Post

        Chris,

        Are you a firefighter? If so, how long have you been one?

        Before I offer some ideas, it would help to know that first.

        - Rick Duris
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815624].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author RickDuris
          Originally Posted by NewbieWarrior View Post

          Rick,

          I'm not a firefighter, just an affiliate for a firefighter's product. I actually bought that product myself (didn't get it free) and studied it to try to get into the mind of the prospect. That's how I got information for this video.

          I have experienced the frustation of trying and failing to get into the civil service, until I studied for the interview. So I do have some qualifications in that regard, but not as an actual firefighter.

          Max
          Hi Max,

          That was really helpful to know.

          One more question. Is the product being sold just about getting past the interview stage or is it about all the steps of becoming a firefighter?

          Thanks,

          - Rick Duris
          Signature
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815650].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author NewbieWarrior
            Rick,

            Its to get past all the stages of the firefighter recruitment process, including the CPAT. And get the written job offer letter. The vendor of the product apparently has contacts within fire departments to the recently hired, and he interviews them.

            Cheers,
            Max

            Originally Posted by RickDuris View Post

            Hi Max,

            That was really helpful to know.

            One more question. Is the product being sold just about getting past the interview stage or is it about all the steps of becoming a firefighter?

            Thanks,

            - Rick Duris
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815704].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author pickthat apple
        I don't think I would want to be saved by a firefighters which took the job just because he was brilliant at the interview...
        Having said that I don't dislike the video.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815645].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author NewbieWarrior
      Thanks, John_S, for the feedback. A bit harsh, even acidic in places, but invaluable feedback. I did feel deep down it was on the salesy side and a bit weak in content. I needed to hear this from a third party.

      I was slow to realize this as everything in the video was taught in a workshop that I signed up for after one of Keith's webinars. The stock photos, the lines, the music, the strategy - all followed the formula given in the workshop. I just followed along, assuming this guy knew what he was doing.

      Well, that guy who was on Keith's webinar (no names here, he's a high profile member of this forum) dropped out of the workshop's forum, where students go to seek his help. He hasn't been seen in three weeks, and well before the workshop ended. He said he was buzy and his grandma was sick, and disappeared. He never got around to evaluating this video and left me in the lurch. I didn't get the chance to re-calibrate the video.

      My big takeaway lesson here is think it out for myself and get help on this forum. This is another push along the learning curve. Yes, I did learn something from that guy's $197 workshop, but yes, I still need to fill in many missing pieces of the puzzle myself along the way.

      Max



      Originally Posted by John_S View Post

      Next, it's not a "disguised" video sales letter. It's trite, obvious, and most transparently holding back information whilst giving a big, fat, sales pitch. The script seems to consist of exactly two sentences, repeated over-and-over -- search engine spam style.

      Don't keyword stuff a video ...say something. And this takes four minutes to say just about nothing. If anyone did expect information upon watching this, they felt cheated by the end. If they feel cheated before they buy, what exactly do you expect them to then do?

      "Why do you want to work for us" sounds like a generic scrape of every employment guide for any job ...ever. Okay, if they stop by the station and get a ride along, but you reveal nothing about what you're looking for in doing that research.

      It sounds like it was written by a Craigslist flunky for five bucks who has barely ever seen the outside of a fire station. The stock photos don't help.

      Nothing sounds like an inside tip. And there is zero which uses the strengths of video.

      It would never enter my mind to do anything but find a list of candidate fire fighters to mail to. This is a targeted product, not a mass access video. But you can try ditching the stock photos, do live location shots. Use video to make it seem as though you've actually had some experience getting access to fire stations and personnel. Interview fire fighters, and reveal some actual information.

      To sum up, the video lacks credibility. It doesn't offer anything, visually or verbally that would indicate you're an expert. Everything (not) in it screams you are an outsider and have not one little bit of insider information. One successful direct response headline is, "They gasped when I sprayed beer on my lawn. But you should see my golf-course green grass now!"

      Gives away INFORMATION, right in the headline. That's how it's done. Oh, and if you insist on using video -- make a video. Don't make a "video sales letter."
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815596].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Hans Klein
    A few comments:

    * 150 views is nothing, especially if the wrong, untargeted traffic is coming to it. You want to be getting lightning targeted traffic from Google. Look for terms to optimize for where videos are ranking well.

    * Rather than a video you put together with what appears to be minimal effort (you chose speed over quality), prout together an honest review. Introduce yourself, tell how you stumbled across the topic, why the topic is so important that they do right (the interview is "make or break") who the video is for, and deliver a few tips that the reader is looking for in a clear, transparent, and easy to understand way. Imagine you're standing in front of the viewer one-on-one and were having a conversation about how to ace the interview and get the firefighter job. Then, at the end, you may tell them where to find more information because you simply just don't have time to tell them everything they need to know.

    * Yes, you can improve on the music.
    Signature
    The Montello Group
    Copywriting | Publishing | Training
    Your Premier Conversion Collaborative
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815641].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RickDuris
    Chris,

    ok, got it.

    If you really want to make a go of this, here's what I would do.

    Interview firefighters and record the conversations. Tell them you are doing a research project on how to become a firefighter and you are interested in their experience.

    This will allow you to get into their mindset. You'll understand their motivations and the challenges and learn the words they use.

    ------------------

    Now here's a key piece to the puzzle: The people buying your product are not firefighters yet but they want to be badly. Badly enough, they'd be willing to spend money learning how to do it.

    So as a part of your promotion, you have to get them salivating about becoming a firefighter over and over--and your course is their only solution.

    -------------------

    Now here's the best part:

    Here's what you say:

    "There's a myth out there when it comes to becoming a firefighter. It holds a lot of well meaning people back from fulfilling their childhood dreams.

    Many people think that the only way to become a firefighter is to have inside connections. Maybe it's a firefighter friend. Or maybe it's someone in the family who already is a firefighter.

    They wrongly believe somebody has to refer you in, somebody has to mentor you and guide you through the process, lead you through challenging gauntlet of becoming a firefighter.

    It's true, connections DO help.

    But if you really want to be a firefighter, you don't absolutely need them. There are ways of getting that coveted firefighter offer letter and dramatically increasing your chances of being on a fire team..."



    What you could do is create a video about this one single myth that holds people back. DO NOT SELL PEOPLE THE PRODUCT IN THE VIDEO. At the end of the video, just say if you'd like to learn more tips about becoming a firefighter, especially if you don't have inside connections, just go ahead and click the link below.

    - Rick Duris
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2815859].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Don Schenk
    Hey Max,

    Others here have given you good advice.

    My first impression was to ask why are you using photos of people dressed in suit and tie and in an office enviornonment? That would go totally against your prospect's mental image of fire fighters. The images don't match your market.

    Then the music started to put me to sleep. It is slow, dreamy, and sounds like elevator music from 20 years ago.

    You have a very pleasant voice for doing the voice-over audio, now just put more enthusiasm into your delivery. It is sleepy just like the music.

    Think of music videos - how are they paced? They are fast and exciting.

    Now think of a Billy Mays short 2 minute TV advertisement. It too is fast paced and exciting. There is a reason for this - it grabbs attention and holds it.

    You don't need music in the background throughout the video. A short, exciting music intro - 5 seconds or so - then just voice will get your message across better.

    You suggest to viewers to go talk with local fire fighters before going for the interview. You need to go talk with several fire fighters, at a few different fire stations to get a better mental picture of what your viewers would like to see - what it is that will grab and hold the attention of fire fighter wanabees. Put images consistant with that into your video.

    You need flames!

    :-Don
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2816111].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author NewbieWarrior
      Thanks, Paul, Rick, Hans and Don for the feedback, and being kind.
      Thanks again to John_S for the wakeup call.

      Video is such a strong medium, I don't thing I could promote this product with moving images as an internet marketer. I have no first hand footage nor on-the-ground information. Savey viewers can instantly pick up I'm an outsider trying to break in.

      I'm going to a PowerPoint presentation style video with minimum use of photos and will tighten up the narration to give more content.

      Jim Edwards has a product on PowerPoint sales letters I might get. (Anyone having success with this product, please let me know.)

      I really appreciate everyone on this thread taking time out to help me out.

      Cheers,
      Max
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2818897].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author HassanAjmal
        First lets get your hook right.
        You start off with some very boring and slow music. Don't do that.
        Get them pumped.

        Next, within the first 15-30 seconds, ask them something thats going to really hook them in.

        Maybe something like....

        "I've got a question for you. If I let you in on the 3 secrets needed to dramatically increase your chances of getting that firefighting job - would this video be worth your time?"

        I dont know, thats one hook formula that worked for me.

        Also, your sound is not that great. Get a pop filter because your p's are making big popping sounds and it sounds very unprofessional. They are only like 12 bucks or something.

        Once you record, speed up your sound a little, to keep the pace going. People have very short attention spans, keep it moving and people will stick to hear it all.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2818962].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author vbcannon
    Valiant Effort. I would do all I could to get it to 30 seconds
    Signature

    Happy to Learn. Happier to Help!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2819271].message }}

Trending Topics