Please do not critique this.

18 replies
**I posted this and then read a thread about how people hate people asking for critiques. Sorry for that. Where is the post delete button? So I am not asking for a critique here, especially from the pros, but a short comment would be nice such as TRASH IT, ALMOST THERE, SEND AS IS, FATHER MY FIRST BORN Also, to those who think I am looking for something for free without working for it, I have read nearly everything on here,and books,and great copy writing, I even critique the ads on TV, magazines, and I keep the junk mail I get. **

**AGAIN--PLEASE DO NOT READ** Let this post go to post hell. Nothing to see here. Please move on.**

Hello Warriors,

This is my first attempt at a sales letter. The setup is: I am going to send a sales letter to restaurant owners and attempt to get them to sign up for a text marketing service of which I am an affiliate. I will be using hand addressed envelopes and will include a dollar bill with the letter (to pay for their two weeks trial). Now I know this isn't an opportune way to make a lot of money but my real reason for doing this is to learn and improve my copywriting skills. If it pulls well then I have something to show. Please critique and be brutal. Also, this is only one page long. Thanks.


Do These Numbers Mean Anything to You?

219, 97, 80

It means: If you're not using text message marketing then you aren't doing all you can to market your restaurant.


Dear Mr. Smith,

Let me show you, (AT MY EXPENSE) just how easy it is to market to your customers using text message marketing. Not only is it easy, but its cheap too. Imagine marketing to your customers any time you want for just a few cents each. Sound impossible? READ ON.

There are an estimated 219 million cell phones in the U.S. and growing every day. 97% of all texts are read almost immediately. 80% of cell phone users have their phones with them all the time.

What does this mean for YOU?

It means: If you're not using text message marketing then YOU are missing out. You, Me, and your customers are bombarded daily with advertising and offers. We've become immune. But, send us a text message, and immediately, unconsciously, we reach for our phones. Its powerful!

Even better, your customers won't mind a text message from you (within reason of course) so don't feel like you are invading their privacy. In fact, they have to give you permission by signing up for your text marketing and they can choose to quit anytime.

So how does it work?

The company I recommend you use is called YEPTEXT. Go to their site at yeptext.com and sign up for their 2 weeks trial. Its only $1 (hence the dollar bill I gave you) and you get one Yepword (that's the keyword your customers use to sign up with you.), and 25 texts. Use these 25 texts to try the system. Try it on your friends, employees, and family. Now when you sign up, be sure to use the referral code "25NOW" and you will get 25% off your first order. That means you make 25 cents just for trying it. You've already made money.

Now, you are already behind the 8 ball so don't waste any more time. Go try it now and you'll thank me later. If you find you don't like making money, do nothing and your trial will expire in two weeks.

Sincerely,

SpankinNewbie

PS. Want to see how it works? Got your phone? Text the word "25NOW" to 51134.
#copywriting #critique #critique my sales letter #letterplease #newbies #sales #sales letter
  • Profile picture of the author Andrew Gould
    Well, here's the short comment you wanted:

    Scrap it and start again.

    But because that's nearly worthless on its own, I'll expand for you:

    Where's the benefits? Why should a restaurant owner use text marketing?

    Sell the result, not the service.

    Re-write the letter focusing on the prospect and what's in it for them.

    And some more minor points:

    If you're using a grabber, mention it up front.

    Don't try for a clever headline. At the moment yours is simply a statement with no incentive to keep reading.

    You don't tell me how it works, instead you try to close. And it was a confusing close at that (and why would any business owner care about making a quarter?)

    Who are you, why should I trust, or even listen to your recommendation?

    Its needs an apostrophe when it's short for "it is".

    If you'd like me to expand more or have any questions, feel free to ask.
    Signature

    Andrew Gould

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5799381].message }}
    • Yes, follow all of Andrews advice.


      In the pitch you say - "Even better, your customers won’t mind a text message from you (within reason of course)"

      My concern is unsolicited text's do interrupt peoples privacy and they do mind.

      You're really going to have to handle that objection - every which way.

      To somehow make it evaporate as much as possible.

      Not easy.

      It might help - by suggesting the right kind of texts to send - with great information, fabulous offers or incredibly interesting news that people will genuinely appreciate.


      Steve
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5799494].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author SpankinNewbie
      Originally Posted by Andrew Gould View Post

      Well, here's the short comment you wanted:

      Where's the benefits? Why should a restaurant owner use text marketing?



      Re-write the letter focusing on the prospect and what's in it for them.

      And some more minor points:

      If you're using a grabber, mention it up front.

      Don't try for a clever headline. At the moment yours is simply a statement with no incentive to keep reading.

      You don't tell me how it works, instead you try to close. And it was a confusing close at that (and why would any business owner care about making a quarter?)

      Who are you, why should I trust, or even listen to your recommendation?
      This is great Andrew and thanks for taking the time to answer. Having re-read it with your advice I see that you are dead on. I will try again and re-post and will hope for more feedback.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5799988].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author videolover7
    Originally Posted by SpankinNewbie View Post

    **I posted this and then read a thread about how people hate people asking for critiques. Sorry for that.
    No need to apologize. Newbies and pros alike have been asking for critiques on this forum for a long time.

    And as you can see from Andrew's and Steve's responses, respected copywriters are happy to help.

    Just ignore the haters.

    VL
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5799548].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Adriian
    "SEND AS IS." Looks good.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5799715].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author gjabiz
    Teaser copy needs to get them to open it before they throw your dollar in the trash.

    Restaurants Are Getting 14% More
    Business from Smart Phones...
    Discover this NEW Strategy


    If you are going to Use Robert Collier/Gary Halbert technique, you need to tell them right away why there is a dollar attached...go to Halber's site and read his newsletters.

    Dear Gordon Ramsey,

    The reason you now have a crisp new dollar bill in your hands is because...blah..blah

    Restaurants are discovering how the New Smart Phone can give them an increase of between 14% and 67% business...on any given day they want.

    You may not want new business on Saturday, but how about on
    Tuesday, or Wednesday?

    Do you have room in your restaurant to serve an additional 10 to 30 new customers any day of the week you want? (This might make decent teaser copy on envelope)

    Because if you do, you can easily tap into one of the hottest and fastest growing methods restaurants are using to increase their bottom lines by 14 to 25% a year or more. HOW?

    They are using Smart Phone "texting" to give special deals to those who have opted to receive them.

    One simple text message could bring in a flash mob of customers, at the exact time you want them to come in.

    blah.blah.blah...

    YOU introduce what you are doing way to soon...no SIZZLE for them...and these guys are busy...even if their restaurant is empty.

    Your letter is asking them to do too much. They'll stick your dollar in their pocket and throw away your letter. YOU have to make it easy and quick...and I seriously doubt if ANYONE would take the time to go spend your dollar on what you want them too.

    My opinion, the letter should be used to get an appointment so you can do a brief demonstration right after lunch...about the only time of day you will catch them...and everyone and his sister knows that is the TIME to sell them something so stand in line or get put off.

    YOU need some facts and figures about how this texting thing is working for other restaurants. You must establish yourself as an expert on the subject and why 15 minutes of their time could lead them to more customers and more profits.

    Scrap this letter, or test 100 of them. If you get zero response, you'll be out maybe 240 bux with printing postage and dollar bills.

    You appear to be inexperienced at this, although I could be way wrong.

    I'm not even sure how you make money doing this...but, if it is going to be worth your time and energy...


    FIRST make it worth theirs. As you it have written now, it will annoy the hell out of them, except for the dollar.

    gjabiz
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5799970].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author SpankinNewbie
      Gjabiz,

      Thanks for that outstanding critique and the lesson on copy writing. I have printed all these wonderful critiques and will put them to good use. I am new at this and I find the only way I can learn is to do, make my mistakes, and learn so more. So I may be just dumb enough to send out 100 of these...Or, I can count on the kindness of you good people to guide. Thanks again.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5800010].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author SpankinNewbie
      Originally Posted by gjabiz View Post


      I'm not even sure how you make money doing this...but, if it is going to be worth your time and energy...
      gjabiz
      Not trying to make real money from this. I just want some real world direct marketing copy writing experience. If I hit get it right and the letter gets good response then I know I am on the right track--if not--keep reading, writing, and studying.

      Thanks again
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5800049].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JerryKuzma
    Hey mate,

    This is just a quick note to encourage you to keep it up. No matter what kind of salesletter you wrote, or re-write, don't get discouraged.

    You are to be commended for putting your copy up here for input in the first place--it is a brave thing to do!

    Writing is like any craft----it improves with study, use and polish....

    BTW, there are a lot of very strong opinions on WF about what works and what doesn't, so sift it all carefully.

    But there is always a need for encouragement....pass it on...

    Jerry K.
    www.JerryKuzma.com
    Signature

    ***********GRAB THIS FREE REPORT! *******
    "How to Make Money by Writing Short Books and Articles"
    Discover over 27 different ways to EARN by writing high-quality content from home!
    CLICK HERE to get your FREE copy!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5802519].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author SpankinNewbie
      Hey Jerry K.,

      Thanks for the encouragement. Like my Granny used to say, "Humble Pie is very nutritious. Any man that eats a piece a day will be stronger for it." Very wise old woman.

      I am currently working on the revision, taking the advice here and from some of the masters.

      Thanks again,

      SpankinNewbie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5803361].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author SpankinNewbie
      Here's a progress report for those following.

      I have scrapped the letter and have gone back to the writing tablet.
      I have thought through the product's benefits and have narrowed who the letter will be sent to. I will target restaurant owners who are using printed coupons to bring in business. I have found an expert who says that mobile coupons bring in 10x more redemption than printed coupons. And since mobile is so much cheaper than print I have come up with a new headline. Here it is.

      Get 10x More Coupon Redemption and Spend 95% Less Doing it.

      Headline with a promise. Copy writing 101. Next I will show how this promise is fulfilled.

      Should I continue with this or go back to the writing tablet?

      SpankinNewbie




      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5803492].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author SpankinNewbie
    And then Step 2: Show a need.

    Get 10x More Coupon Redemption and Spend 95% Less Doing it.


    Dear Mr. Smith,

    There's no doubt about it, coupons work. That's why you and every other restaurant use them to bring in business. But, with the costs of print advertising continuing to rise and the redemption rates continuing to fall, YOUR ROI is shrinking. But there is a solution.


    Step 2: Show the need.

    Here, I am trying to soften up the restaurant owner by telling him that he is doing the right thing by advertising his business by using coupons. Then I lump him in with every other restaurant: now he's not special. Next I give him facts about the costs of advertising and the redemption rates which he will agree with (now this will be true for most but not all owners). Then I move from the heart to the wallet with shrinking ROI and next comes the solution.

    Is this a good start?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5803662].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Andrew Gould
    It's better, you're moving in the right direction.

    You don't want a period after your headline as you don't want your prospect to stop reading and I think you can phrase it a bit better like:

    How To Cut Your Coupon Costs By 95%... and _______

    or a more aggressive version:

    Slash Your Spending By 95% _______

    I didn't do the second part of your promise as I'm not sure about the word "redemption" - is that the wording restaurant owners use? If so, then it's fine, otherwise you want to speak their lingo.

    And when you're writing a headline don't just write one as the first one, or even the first few, you come up with will rarely be your best.
    Signature

    Andrew Gould

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5804284].message }}
    • And the good news is - the coupon technique helps handle the "f****** annoying" text objection.

      (You always expect a text to be from someone you know - not an intrusive ad)

      But now they are getting someone worth having - providing the discount is good.


      If it were me - I would start the text by saying something like - "Apologies for disturbing you - but honestly we thought you would like to see this..."

      Many will disagree and say "just sell the damn thing" - but because the text was unasked for - a bit of empathy might help increase the response.


      Steve
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5804351].message }}

Trending Topics