Are you a copywriter?

21 replies
Are you a copywriter?

If not, please stop posting your opinions on this sub forum.

Not to be rude, but the fact is, you don't know what you're talking about.

Thanks.

VL
#copywriter
  • Profile picture of the author simplewriting
    Good Point! But there are many members who come here to "discuss" the art and are new to it. Correct me if I'm wrong...

    But, I think your post was in regards to novice or non-copywriters offering critiques and advice to people who post here asking for it.

    right?
    Signature

    You're only as good as your last sentence...

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6432803].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Karson
    Everyone should be honest but at the same time everyone has to start somewhere bro.

    This is where a lot of people come to learn!

    And for all you new copywriters out there write away, get critiques, then put it to the test with split testing!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6432815].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BudaBrit
    Ah, but what of us who would love to copyright in the future, understand the basic mechanics of the craft, but wish to learn more from the masters that exist on this forum.

    We still may be able to offer advice to others - we may, for instance, know something useful about how a certain type of manager reacts to a sales letter - so why should we not offer valuable opinions? Yes, there are some spammy posts creeping in, but they soon disappear thanks to the nature of this forum

    But some of us wish to pick some brains, and what is wrong with posting and asking for a critique?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6432991].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Neil AM
      Originally Posted by BudaBrit View Post

      Ah, but what of us who would love to copyright in the future...
      Learning the difference between copyrighting and copywriting would be a good start.

      Snark aside, I think the OP's more talking about people offering advice without the basis of any experience, not people asking for copy critiques or talking about how a market they're a part of might respond.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6433177].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BudaBrit
    Bah, I was taking a break from writing about copyrights, must've been playing on my mind

    Doesn't look so good now, first spelling mistake on here, I think

    Ah well.

    How can he tell how experienced they are, however, just because their opinion clashes with his own? Are there some simple rules that a copywriter needs to follow? And surely these rules are there to be broken...
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6433523].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dannybuntu
    Originally Posted by videolover7 View Post

    Are you a copywriter?

    If not, please stop posting your opinions on this sub forum.

    Not to be rude, but the fact is, you don't know what you're talking about.

    Thanks.

    VL
    Which begs the question, who is existentially a copywriter? Does anybody confer a title like, I dub thee, sir Mr. copywriter. Jouster of words, champion of literature, proficient in the art of stringing words where they seem to not to belong to each other.

    I'm curious because I'm not a copywriter.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6433636].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Joseph Robinson
      Banned
      Originally Posted by dannybuntu View Post

      I'm curious because I'm not a copywriter.
      It's a super secret ceremony, and there's pizza afterwards!
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6435025].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author videolover7
      Originally Posted by dannybuntu View Post

      Which begs the question, who is existentially a copywriter? Does anybody confer a title like, I dub thee, sir Mr. copywriter. Jouster of words, champion of literature, proficient in the art of stringing words where they seem to not to belong to each other.

      I'm curious because I'm not a copywriter.
      Copywriter - A person who writes advertising text

      VL
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6435368].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Joseph Robinson
        Banned
        Originally Posted by videolover7 View Post

        Copywriter - A person who writes advertising text

        VL
        Where's the limiting factor in that definition that you seem to be seeking? If we use that to define a copywriter, then none of the people you seem to not want to be participating can realistically be kept out. Anyone can write advertising text, they just might not be good at it.

        As a self-proclaimed copywriter yourself (because surely you didn't start a thread about people not commenting if you didn't feel you were qualified to comment yourself?) shouldn't you know a bit more about wording things the right way?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6435606].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author videolover7
          Originally Posted by Joe Robinson View Post

          Where's the limiting factor in that definition that you seem to be seeking? If we use that to define a copywriter, then none of the people you seem to not want to be participating can realistically be kept out. Anyone can write advertising text, they just might not be good at it.

          As a self-proclaimed copywriter yourself (because surely you didn't start a thread about people not commenting if you didn't feel you were qualified to comment yourself?) shouldn't you know a bit more about wording things the right way?
          Good try... but you didn't do very well pushing the "VL gets defensive" button. LOL

          Content writers certainly have their place. That place just doesn't happen to be at a copywriting forum offering opinions on copywriting.

          VL
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6435844].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author digesource
            Originally Posted by videolover7 View Post

            Content writers certainly have their place. That place just doesn't happen to be at a copywriting forum offering opinions on copywriting.


            So.., a content writer cannot also simultaneously be a copywriter?

            Exactly what is the definition of a copywriter? Aside from poor/good quality.

            Come to think of it.., quality is really the prevailing issue here, isn't it?

            The next question is.., who decides the level of quality for EVERYBODY?

            Now we're playing with the concept of freedom, equality, and free speech.



            Darin Walker
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6437872].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Joseph Robinson
            Banned
            Originally Posted by videolover7 View Post

            Good try... but you didn't do very well pushing the "VL gets defensive" button. LOL

            Content writers certainly have their place. That place just doesn't happen to be at a copywriting forum offering opinions on copywriting.

            VL
            Cute, but don't evade the question. If we follow your definition of a copywriter, what limiting factor (if any at all) stops someone from posting here? Anyone can say that they are a copywriter. You have no way to verify unless you know what their customers are buying.

            Now they very well may be crappy copywriters; but that is an entirely different conversation.
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6440550].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author Kay King
              : a writer of advertising or publicity copy
              Not to be rude, but the fact is, you don't know what you're talking about.
              You didn't "mean" to be rude. If you are expressing a concept you don't mean - where's the "writer" part?

              I earn a living writing - but I stay out of this section most of the time. Yes, there are some uninformed questions and answers. There are some excellent copywriters who post, some posturers, and some egos looking for a place to land.

              Don't mean to be rude but you don't get to decide who is allowed to post (or where) on a forum unless you own the forum. Oh wait, that IS what I meant....I must be a writer.:p

              Seriously, I agree with part of what you posted - but you can ignore any threads you think are beneath you. You can put that person on your ignore list so you never have to read the drivel.

              kay
              Signature
              Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6440650].message }}
              • Profile picture of the author videolover7
                Kay,

                Copywriters write conversationally.

                And whew, that's been such a relief these last few years. The writing snobs lost me a long time ago with sentence diagramming.

                VL
                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6441307].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author The Marketeer
    Originally Posted by videolover7 View Post

    Are you a copywriter?

    If not, please stop posting your opinions on this sub forum.

    Not to be rude, but the fact is, you don't know what you're talking about.

    Thanks.

    VL
    What if a copywriter posts their opinions about topics they are intellectually challenged about?

    Should we then ask copywriters to stop posting their opinions about non copywriting topics as well?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6437124].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jomuli3
    Originally Posted by videolover7 View Post

    Are you a copywriter?

    If not, please stop posting your opinions on this sub forum.

    Not to be rude, but the fact is, you don't know what you're talking about.

    Thanks.

    VL
    I understand your feelings VL

    I at times feel the same way when I read certain responses to threads. However, we have little to do about it. There are regulations/rules on forums. I, however, have not come across one that forbids forum members from expressing their opinions about certain issues raised in threads. I am a copywriter too. I tolerate them and try to help them by responding to a threads like I am doing.

    We should not feel too tired to correct our fellow warriors. They are more knowledgeable than we are in some other areas. Let us enlighten them. They will also enlighten us in another sub forum.

    Now, there is a difference between copywriting and article/content writing. Content is mere subject matter. In a forum like this one our main subject matter(content) are articles. We do not use articles to directly sell something. There is, therefore, no copywriting done when writing articles.

    I know one of the cheapest and effective ways of attracting web traffic is through article marketing. One could write articles and post them on syndication sites. The articles are, conditionally, supposed to have a back link to the web site of the author. In that way the author has chance to get web traffic to his site, Articles, I repeat, are not meant to sell directly. They could assist in the process of making sales by attracting prospects.

    A Copywriter is a person who writes words for advertising purposes. Copywriting is any writing that offers a product or service for sale. Copywritten material is strictly intended to SELL something. It might be in a form of a sales letters, advert, brochure, product description etc.

    An article can be written within an hour.

    A sales letter, on the other hand, might take several days or weeks to craft.

    A copywriter must thoroughly know the product he sells. This knowledge will help him skillfully derive benefits from its features.

    He/she must understand the audience he/she writes for. He/she has to determine the age group, sex, earning power etc of prospects. He/she must figure out their wants and needs. This will enable one tone his/her letter appropriately.

    To write persuasively, the copywriter comes up with attention- grabbing headings. He/she makes strong promises which he/she later proves in the body of the letter.

    The copywriter follows a hidden structure to excite his/her prospect from one level to another. Hidden because its parts are never mentioned in the letter. A trained copywriter, however, can isolate, identify and name them.

    He/she rationalizes the prospects' buying decisions and throws stunning emotional blows to finish his/her opponent off. He/she uses guarantees and premiums to quench any remaining resistance to buy.

    The copywriter steps on his/her defeated opponent's motionless body with one leg. He proudly and victoriously raises his hands --- the sales is irresistibly sealed.

    In a nut shell a copywriter does his/her work that way and makes fat checks land on his clients' table.

    The power of copywriting is beyond measure. Can you imagine that the most successful sales letter ever written earned one company over a billion dollars? The sales letter was promoting a journal! This highly persuasive and irresistible sales letter was written by Martin Conroy.

    No wonder earnings from copywriting projects are higher than those from article writing ones. The determining factors, among others, are the amount of time it takes to write one letter and the earnings one letter could bring.

    Why do some warriors make the mistake of calling article writers, copywriters?

    The word copy could be attached to a lot of things. A copy of that book, newspaper copy, copy of an article etc.

    Why not calling a writer of a copy of an article a copywriter?

    Well, the answer is given above --- one is meant to SELL something the other is not.

    A word of advice for those who might not be enough knowledge in a subject --- try to get some basic knowledge of a subject under discussion by doing a bit of research before posting your response.

    I hope this helps our fellow warriors who are not copywriters --- a copywriter is not an article writer!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6439743].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BudaBrit
    It is your penultimate sentence that really says it.

    Do you research! By all means contribute if you can actually have something to add, but I would never correct or give advise to someone about American Football, for instance.

    From my point, the differences between the two come down to one thing:

    An article educates, it tells the reader more about a subject so they can feel enlightened.

    Sales copy persuades, it comes as close as it possibly can to physical forcing them to buy using simple words.

    A great article, therefore, is not as far from copy as you may think - inform them the right way, and they're going to want your product, aren't they?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6440466].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author digesource
    The way I see it is..

    A copywriter is: One who is writing something to get a reader/prospect to TAKE AN ACTION or BUY something.

    A content/article writer is: One who is writing something to EDUCATE the reader/prospect on a subject.

    I know there are a more factors, details, aspects, and responsibilities that define and distinguish these two roles, but this is the most basic definition I currently understand about them.

    As always, my mind is open for learning.



    Darin Walker
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6441819].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Ken Hoffman
    It's amazing to me the insignificant things people spend their time and energy arguing about. Then again, when you start a thread with an ultimatum with no authority, I guess people will respond. Ironically, I highly doubt that starting this thread will do anything at all to gain compliance to your request.
    Signature
    http://www.warriorforum.com/warriors...ost-sales.html
    Professional Direct Response Copywriting
    50% Off Limited Time Offer!
    "http://www.profitproducingcopy.com"
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6441853].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author digesource
      Originally Posted by Ken Hoffman View Post

      Ironically, I highly doubt that starting this thread will do anything at all to gain compliance to your request.
      I think you are right about the "compliance" aspect of your statement.

      However, I have noticed, even with some negative threads, that it tends to generate clarity on an issue when people get involved in it. And clarification is the content of learning. While I disagree with the attitude and statements of the original post, I appreciate all the knowledge that has been developed as a result.

      NOOO.. this is not a plea for rude and negative posters to come out of the woodwork!

      Just sayin

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6442007].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author videolover7
      Originally Posted by Ken Hoffman View Post

      It's amazing to me the insignificant things people spend their time and energy arguing about. Then again, when you start a thread with an ultimatum with no authority, I guess people will respond. Ironically, I highly doubt that starting this thread will do anything at all to gain compliance to your request.
      Just curious... what was the ultimatum?

      VL
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6442059].message }}

Trending Topics