23 replies
I was on LinkedIn today in a forum for copywriters, and we were discussing copywriting and rates that many clients want to pay.

John Graham Seeliger made these comments. I thought I would share them with you:

"About five years ago a photographer colleague put into words what I'd begun to experience: that his clients wanted more but were offering less. I was happy to hear it, because I thought it was just me. Though as we all know, it's been going downhill since then...

"...Companies don't have the budgets they used to, and the market is way more competitive. Also, the consumer base has shrunk as people lose jobs.

"...the trend toward picture-plus-logo-only ads of the last several years has caused large numbers of marcom execs to believe that copy is no longer necessary. And the truth is that the larger part of the market simply DOES NOT READ any more...you only have to look at the spelling, grammar, structure and content of Facebook/YouTube/Twitter/Comment posts to recognize the state of your audience today."

What do you fellow copywriters think of his comments. Regarding videos, I believe that is happening, as more and more sites are using video to present their products.

But is copywriting dead? Is it unnecessary? What do you think?
#copy #dead
  • {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591211].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author shawnlebrun
    Harry,

    It really depends on how you get clients and "where you fish"

    I've found that here on the WF, there's always someone willing
    to write it for less... and there's an entire glut of "marketers"
    who don't value copy... and will indeed shop for the lowest price.

    However, the big clients, the ones making money... they still
    value good copy and will pay for it. Yes, those jobs are much
    harder to land... because the competition is so stiff.

    But just like any field, if you become known as someone who
    can produce winners, you'll get plenty of business.

    One thing I've been doing a lot of the last few years is
    working with local businesses... folks you can talk to,
    meet in person, establish a relationship with, and then
    work closely with... offering more value in the way of
    overall business growth strategies and not just copy.

    For example, I work with a lot of local realtors, spas, gyms,
    and other businesses. But instead of just copy, I help them
    with low cost marketing and advertising like display ads,
    social media marketing, email marketing, etc...

    So, instead of just copy, I help them in all areas of their
    marketing... which increases my value. So instead of fighting
    for a $500 copy job here on WF... I can make $3,000 to $5,000
    working with local businesses, helping them in all areas of their
    business growth.

    Like with any market, I just think you have to adapt and change
    with the times, and I've had good luck transitioning from straight
    copywriter to overall business growth strategist... which then also
    helps me share in the growth of the companies I work with.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591392].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author hhhusted
      Originally Posted by shawnlebrun View Post

      Harry,

      It really depends on how you get clients and "where you fish"

      I've found that here on the WF, there's always someone willing
      to write it for less... and there's an entire glut of "marketers"
      who don't value copy... and will indeed shop for the lowest price.

      However, the big clients, the ones making money... they still
      value good copy and will pay for it. Yes, those jobs are much
      harder to land... because the competition is so stiff.

      But just like any field, if you become known as someone who
      can produce winners, you'll get plenty of business.

      One thing I've been doing a lot of the last few years is
      working with local businesses... folks you can talk to,
      meet in person, establish a relationship with, and then
      work closely with... offering more value in the way of
      overall business growth strategies and not just copy.

      For example, I work with a lot of local realtors, spas, gyms,
      and other businesses. But instead of just copy, I help them
      with low cost marketing and advertising like display ads,
      social media marketing, email marketing, etc...

      So, instead of just copy, I help them in all areas of their
      marketing... which increases my value. So instead of fighting
      for a $500 copy job here on WF... I can make $3,000 to $5,000
      working with local businesses, helping them in all areas of their
      business growth.

      Like with any market, I just think you have to adapt and change
      with the times, and I've had good luck transitioning from straight
      copywriter to overall business growth strategist... which then also
      helps me share in the growth of the companies I work with.
      Thanks Shawn. I appreciate your comments. After reading them, I have to say I admire your way of doing business. If a person can offer more than copy to a business, that makes them more of an asset.

      I think I'll take that same approach here in my local area and see how it goes.
      Signature

      -----------------------------------------------------------
      Harry Husted
      http://www.creatingwords.com
      With 20+ years’ experience, I can help YOU stop struggling to stand out, with a more dynamic marketing message, SEO, an attention-getting e-book, or a catchy jingle of your own to reel in those prospects.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591442].message }}
  • You can probably find enough copywriting in a 50 mile radius of your house to last you 100 years.

    Here's one example. Many businesses (most?) have a strange habit of forgetting about past customers that haven't bought in a while. I don't know if they get too busy or don't know how to get them back or what their deal is.

    I do know you can write an ad with an irresistible offer (email or direct mail) to get these customers back. Arrange a percentage of every new dollar the "found" customers spend.

    I'll bet if you visited 10 stores at the nearest strip mall you'd get one to take you up on your offer.

    Writers complaining about rates are not marketing hard enough, or are not positioning themselves clearly enough to provide any differentiation. And if you show people you can make money for them, eventually the tide turns, and the business starts to find you.
    Signature
    Marketing is not a battle of products. It is a battle of perceptions.
    - Jack Trout
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591483].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author hhhusted
      Originally Posted by Joe Ditzel View Post

      You can probably find enough copywriting in a 50 mile radius of your house to last you 100 years.

      Here's one example. Many businesses (most?) have a strange habit of forgetting about past customers that haven't bought in a while. I don't know if they get too busy or don't know how to get them back or what their deal is.

      I do know you can write an ad with an irresistible offer (email or direct mail) to get these customers back. Arrange a percentage of every new dollar the "found" customers spend.

      I'll bet if you visited 10 stores at the nearest strip mall you'd get one to take you up on your offer.

      Writers complaining about rates are not marketing hard enough, or are not positioning themselves clearly enough to provide any differentiation. And if you show people you can make money for them, eventually the tide turns, and the business starts to find you.
      You might be right. In NYC, businesses are hurting big time. However, if I go on Google, I can find all the local businesses, contact them by phone, and set up a meeting with them by Skype, unless they are within a block or two of me. I've done that before and can do it again.
      Signature

      -----------------------------------------------------------
      Harry Husted
      http://www.creatingwords.com
      With 20+ years’ experience, I can help YOU stop struggling to stand out, with a more dynamic marketing message, SEO, an attention-getting e-book, or a catchy jingle of your own to reel in those prospects.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591518].message }}
      • Originally Posted by hhhusted View Post

        You might be right. In NYC, businesses are hurting big time. However, if I go on Google, I can find all the local businesses, contact them by phone, and set up a meeting with them by Skype, unless they are within a block or two of me. I've done that before and can do it again.
        Sounds like a plan. I don't know how far you can travel but it's fun to meet with local businesses, start a conversation and see where it goes. For me it breaks up long hours at the computer.

        And I'm 110% confident I can help them make more money. I've met very few business owners that don't have leaky marketing.
        Signature
        Marketing is not a battle of products. It is a battle of perceptions.
        - Jack Trout
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591561].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author hhhusted
          Originally Posted by Joe Ditzel View Post

          Sounds like a plan. I don't know how far you can travel but it's fun to meet with local businesses, start a conversation and see where it goes. For me it breaks up long hours at the computer.

          And I'm 110% confident I can help them make more money. I've met very few business owners that don't have leaky marketing.
          Amen to that. Just like the X-Files (The Truth is Out There), money is the same thing. It is out there, we just have to know where to look. For that, having someone to direct us can help.
          Signature

          -----------------------------------------------------------
          Harry Husted
          http://www.creatingwords.com
          With 20+ years’ experience, I can help YOU stop struggling to stand out, with a more dynamic marketing message, SEO, an attention-getting e-book, or a catchy jingle of your own to reel in those prospects.

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591570].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author copyassassin
      Originally Posted by Joe Ditzel View Post


      Here's one example. Many businesses (most?) have a strange habit of forgetting about past customers that haven't bought in a while. I don't know if they get too busy or don't know how to get them back or what their deal is.
      Joe,

      There are two main reasons why:
      • Insecurity of owner on why they left
      • Lack of a system to take lost customers


      Insecurity of owner on why they left
      As a business owner myself, it's painful to ask why a client left me. Because it's either 1) price, 2) they didn't like me, 3) I messed up, 4) or some logistical reason.

      But, here's the main reason why business owners don't go after lost clients: fear, insecurity, doubt, lack of self-confidence, or lack of self-worth.

      That's the enemy here.

      Here's the solution. Tell your client you'll handle every detail of this campaign. They won't have to hear one negative comment. They won't have to FEEL the anger of former clients.

      Now, eventually, the client will ask why the clients left. And you have to frame is as "The Business didn't...." "The service lacked....." NEVER make it personal.

      It hurts too much.


      Lack of a system to track lost customers

      Most businesses do NO tracking at all. No database. No CRM system.

      YOU can be the solution. Offer this service. And offer it this way, "I'll pay for this system to be designed, implemented, and every little detail. And I want X% of gross on every sale."
      Signature

      The Most Bad-Ass Tax Reduction Strategist for Internet Marketers who HATE paying taxes. See my happy clients

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7597819].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Alex Cohen
    What do you fellow copywriters think of his comments. Regarding videos, I believe that is happening, as more and more sites are using video to present their products.

    But is copywriting dead? Is it unnecessary? What do you think?
    Who do you think writes videos... plumbers???

    Videos are written by copywriters and product owners who know how to write copy (persuade).

    Any video not written persuasively does not make many sales... if any at all.

    Alex
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591921].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author hhhusted
      Originally Posted by Alex Cohen View Post

      Who do you think writes videos... plumbers???

      Videos are written by copywriters and product owners who know how to write copy (persuade).

      Any video not written persuasively does not make many sales... if any at all.

      Alex
      Video creation is different. I'm talking about actual written copy compared to video.
      Signature

      -----------------------------------------------------------
      Harry Husted
      http://www.creatingwords.com
      With 20+ years’ experience, I can help YOU stop struggling to stand out, with a more dynamic marketing message, SEO, an attention-getting e-book, or a catchy jingle of your own to reel in those prospects.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7591970].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Matt Ausin
        We all know that writing long ass copy isn't the only thing copywriters do.

        Who do you think writes most Facebook and Twitter posts for companies? Copywriters.

        (Someone already mentioned videos - they also have to be written first.)

        As for the 'grammar and spelling nowadays' argument... That's just that, grammar and spelling. If you're indeed selling to the audience that talks like that, well, just adopt their language just like you would when writing for any other niche.

        If anything... now there are MORE things to write than ever.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7592096].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author ERPLeadsWriter
        Originally Posted by Ken_Caudill View Post

        It's an artificial distinction. Video and audio begin with the written word. There's no inherent advantage of one medium over another.
        You said it. Although, perhaps that distinction is the reason why people think copywriting is 'dead' (or at least undervalued). People don't seem to see how words are behind a lot of things they take for granted (whether it's ads, books, movie scripts, concept descriptions etc).
        Signature
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7598998].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author wrcato2
    Copy writing is far, far from dead. You will still need a copy writer to write scripts for video sales letters. Write copy for commercials, for advertisements, ect.
    It will never die.
    I would like to see the ceo's write there own copy and then within 6 months they will be true believers of copy writers. But it will only be when their business is flat broke and they are borrowing from China or worse selling out Al Jazeera.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7592134].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author hhhusted
      Originally Posted by wrcato2 View Post

      Copy writing is far, far from dead. You will still need a copy writer to write scripts for video sales letters. Write copy for commercials, for advertisements, ect.
      It will never die.
      I would like to see the ceo's write there own copy and then within 6 months they will be true believers of copy writers. But it will only be when their business is flat broke and they are borrowing from China or worse selling out Al Jazeera.
      That's why CEOs hire copywriters. They know they can't write.

      Bob Bly once said that copywriting won't die as long as businesses keep alive. In other words, there will always be a need. The problem is finding gigs that pay you well over those that offer low pay.
      Signature

      -----------------------------------------------------------
      Harry Husted
      http://www.creatingwords.com
      With 20+ years’ experience, I can help YOU stop struggling to stand out, with a more dynamic marketing message, SEO, an attention-getting e-book, or a catchy jingle of your own to reel in those prospects.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7593648].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author AndrewCavanagh
    If you're focusing on copywriting that produces results...real
    trackable sales...then the rules change.

    When the person who hires you is keeping track of the conversion
    of a sales letter he also knows how much more he can make if
    your copy has a higher conversion.

    And he's going to be highly aware of which copywriters are more
    likely to produce a higher response.

    If you're not talking about strategies that might increase response
    with these kinds of prospects then you're not even in the game.


    Bottom line: the clients who pay a lot of money for copy are looking
    to get a big return from that copy.

    So if you want high paying copywriting gigs you need to be focused
    on getting real results for your clients.

    It's not about finding someone who'll pay you more, it's about
    helping your clients make more money. When they make more money
    they'll have more money to invest with you.

    Kindest regards,
    Andrew Cavanagh
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7592174].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author hhhusted
      Originally Posted by AndrewCavanagh View Post

      If you're focusing on copywriting that produces results...real
      trackable sales...then the rules change.

      When the person who hires you is keeping track of the conversion
      of a sales letter he also knows how much more he can make if
      your copy has a higher conversion.

      And he's going to be highly aware of which copywriters are more
      likely to produce a higher response.

      If you're not talking about strategies that might increase response
      with these kinds of prospects then you're not even in the game.


      Bottom line: the clients who pay a lot of money for copy are looking
      to get a big return from that copy.

      So if you want high paying copywriting gigs you need to be focused
      on getting real results for your clients.

      It's not about finding someone who'll pay you more, it's about
      helping your clients make more money. When they make more money
      they'll have more money to invest with you.

      Kindest regards,
      Andrew Cavanagh
      I totally agree. When your sales copy can provide very high conversions for your clients, you are definitely a wanted person. That company will do whatever is necessary to keep you busy.
      Signature

      -----------------------------------------------------------
      Harry Husted
      http://www.creatingwords.com
      With 20+ years’ experience, I can help YOU stop struggling to stand out, with a more dynamic marketing message, SEO, an attention-getting e-book, or a catchy jingle of your own to reel in those prospects.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7593658].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Robert_Rand
        "Daddy, daddy there's a boogey man in my closet!"

        "Now son, we've gone over this... there's no boogey man."

        "But John said so!"


        Seriously though... this question, AGAIN?

        C'mmonnnn maaaaannnn! (Chris Carter voice)
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7594145].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author hhhusted
          Originally Posted by Robert_Rand View Post

          "Daddy, daddy there's a boogey man in my closet!"

          "Now son, we've gone over this... there's no boogey man."

          "But John said so!"


          Seriously though... this question, AGAIN?

          C'mmonnnn maaaaannnn! (Chris Carter voice)
          If you don't like reading it, skip over it. It is a legit question.
          Signature

          -----------------------------------------------------------
          Harry Husted
          http://www.creatingwords.com
          With 20+ years’ experience, I can help YOU stop struggling to stand out, with a more dynamic marketing message, SEO, an attention-getting e-book, or a catchy jingle of your own to reel in those prospects.

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7594522].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Mark Andrews
            Banned
            Originally Posted by hhhusted View Post


            If you don't like reading it, skip over it. It is a legit question.
            Which question has already been asked here at
            least once before.

            If you missed it first time round click on this link...

            Copywriting Is Dead Part One

            When creating new threads, at least try to be
            a little bit original
            instead of riding on the back
            of topics already posted up in the past with a
            high number of replies.


            Mark Andrews
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7594648].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author sethczerepak
    Dude, it's all relative. If you invest for value and hire a decent copywriter, you're going to spend money but you're also going to make it. Then you'll have more money to invest on a great writer, then you'll make your profits, then you'll have more money to invest...etc.

    Works the other way too. There are companies winning and companies losing, then there are companies that are just squeaking by. It's always been this way, it always will. There are just more of us now.

    Same deal with copywriters. Those who can write, but can't sell won't be able to charge premium fees. So they'll work with companies who have to hire cheap. Companies that have to hire cheap usually never make enough money to invest in a good copywriter. It's a tireless downward spiral (or a friggin' merry go round of a rat race).

    Cheap attracts cheap, value attracts value.

    Low copywriting rates aren't a bad thing either They separate the mere writers from the writers who can SELL. Maybe writing doesn't pay all that well anymore. But if you can sell with words, you'll never be without work....or money.

    Unless of course, you have some life controlling habit that sucks up all your money, but that's another story.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7597701].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author copyassassin
      Originally Posted by sethczerepak View Post

      Dude, it's all relative. If you invest for value and hire a decent copywriter, you're going to spend money but you're also going to make it. .

      Seth,

      You sure about that?

      "Decent" :confused:

      "Decent" means average to me, buddy.

      And average is, well, average. Average price. Average service. Average results.

      And here's the problem with average: losers weight "average" downward. There are more losers in a market than winners. Therefore, average means you're going to lose.

      Now, if you want to lose money, and the subconsciousness is funny thing, then go for "decent".

      There are many "decent" copywriters on this board. However, you will need a translator when you speak to them, and call them at odd hours because they live 12 hours ahead of you. And of course, they have no real contract laws there, so, good luck to you. Have fun with "decent".

      Adam
      Signature

      The Most Bad-Ass Tax Reduction Strategist for Internet Marketers who HATE paying taxes. See my happy clients

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7597835].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author copyassassin
    What do you fellow copywriters think of his comments.
    hhhusted,

    I think marketing is breaking into the "haves" and "have-nots".

    Or, more simply put, the demand at the high end is higher, and everything else is becoming a commoditity.

    This a great time to be excellent. And everybody else is S.O.L.

    Better positioning, better credbility, better results, better professionalism will always be in demand.

    The question is this:

    What does it take to be in the
    Top 1% money earners for 2013?


    Don't benchmark average. Don't benchmark above average. Don't benchmark good.

    Go for excellent, or go home.

    Adam
    Signature

    The Most Bad-Ass Tax Reduction Strategist for Internet Marketers who HATE paying taxes. See my happy clients

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7597776].message }}

Trending Topics