Please, help critique my copy

15 replies
Note: The copy is meant to be a phase in my plan to launch a copywriting service. I want to collect more testimonials, in exchange for writing for four marketers. I appreciate your comments. Please, be blunt. I'll try not to cry. I'll try.



A Lethal Weapon and an Offer No Smart Marketer Should Refuse

Dear Smart Marketer,

I grew up in a home where I saw a gun every day.

So, am I going to unleash virtual violence, now?

No. Don’t be afraid.

It’s all good news…for you.

This is about a great offer.

It’s for you, and 3 other smart and fast marketers.

But, first things first…

…seeing as you may be wondering what’s the connection between marketing and lethal weapons.

A hunter and a movie addict

See, my dad liked to hunt!

It’s strange that some folks enjoy killing animals.

I don’t.

I am a movie-addict.

GODFATHER…is one of my faves.

I’ve watched it 4 times. It’s a work of art.

Do you recall that part where Mary was shot, as people came out of the opera? And, the haunting strains of Cavalleria Rusticana, wafted in the background, deepening the grief our delicate hearts were suddenly plunged into?

But, let’s leave the Cosa Nostra and focus on moolah.

I’d like to make you an offer. But, don’t be scared. I’m not going to use a gun.

Relax.

I promise you, I’m not going to use a gun.

If you give me a tiny chunk of your time, I will craft response-boosting copy for you.

FREE. Yes, you read that right. No moolah needed today. Keep your wallet.

Do you know what will happen after you start using the copy I’d craft for you?

Your money worries will start melting away like snowflakes in the sun.
I have tasted ‘financial freedom’. Trust me; it’s not an elusive ideal.
I experienced it for a while; it’s one of the most blissful states in the world.
No more money worries.
Financial freedom!
You can buy whatever you want (that’s when I got a superfast BMW, I like slicing through the wind.)

I was a banker, in a previous incarnation. But this is not about me.

It’s all about you.

Let’s make you more moolah.

I made a similar offer to this one, a few months ago. I wrote copy for free, for a few lucky people. I received a lot of requests. Sadly, I could not fulfill all of them. This is a chance to improve my Karma.

Let’s hit ‘refresh.’

Once again, I’m offering you world-class, response-boosting copy for FREE.
I’d like to say my motivation is purely altruistic. I’d like to say that.

But, it’d be a huge lie.

I am trying to collect more testimonials. I intend to launch my paid copywriting service, soon.

I want to give you a taste of what we can do together, when you retain me, later, to craft compelling copy for you.

Are you leveraging the power of testimonials in your marketing and sales? I’m glad you said, yes.

What you’re Gonna Get

• If you give me a tiny chunk of your time, I will craft response-boosting copy for you. FREE of charge…in exchange for your testimonials.
• Peace of mind – knowing your copy is being handled by a real salesman
• Soon, your money worries will start melting away like snowflakes in the sun.
• You will have more time –-- to do whatever your heart desires.
• You will accelerate your journey to financial freedom.

You’d like that, right?

I hope you’ve got a good product or service. I hope you’ve got a system in place to measure conversion, and, above all, I hope you’re truly customer-centric. That’s one of the key components of the DNA of highly successful marketers.

First, let’s quickly talk about magic.

Oh, you wanted me to continue the talk of moolah, right? Not to worry. There’s a method to my slithering prose.

Yes, let’s talk magic. And, you’d see the connection, soon.

“Are you watching closely?’’

Come a bit close. I’d like to ask you a question.

Yes, closer. Nothing to be afraid of…

Oh, you’d like to know what’s hidden in my left hand. It’s not a sword. I swear. It’s not a sword. It’s a magic wand. I decided to hide it in my sword’s sheath. That's the honest truth.

Here’s my question: Do you like magic?

Ok, great. I like it, too.

Magic!

I love its colorful aura, unpredictability, and strangeness. You’d agree with me that it is a short, suspense-filled trip to an alien but refreshing world.
We know it’s not real, but we enjoy it, and that’s its reward. Life is tough, so, it’s nice to take a break once in a while…from the drudgery of unfulfilling work, and the most dreaded monster in the world…bills.

Bills!

That’s one of the monsters you and I will keep in its place when I start writing copy for you.

Do you remember the first magic show you ever saw?

I remember mine…

It was in high-school, at Mount Carmel College (over three decades ago) -- a strict catholic school. We spent most of the time on work, work, and more work.

A magic show was a rarity. It was almost like Haley’s Comet – which comes once in 75 years!

We jumped for joy, when our English teacher, Father James, told us that a magic show would be held a week from that day!

We like the priest, a Brit, -- of course he’s a tad strange – he talks to flowers, he hugs trees, he’s always with a cigarette (the awful smell) -- and most of the time, he wears that dull dress, priests are compelled to wear.

For most of us: boys between the ages of 10 and 12. It was our first opportunity to see a real life magician. The first magician I ever ‘saw’ was probably the count, on Sesame Street, or the pied piper of Hamelin…

As we waited for that special day to arrive, time crawled like a sick snail.
Then, the day came…

The bald magician looked ordinary, a tad on the heavy side, he was of average height and he could pass for a bean-counter -- and his cloak was brown (not my fave color).
It turned out to be an unforgettable day! My world changed when he started the performance.

The experience taught me that first impressions are not always correct.

But, we’re supposed to be talking about marketing…how to make you more moolah.

I’m sorry, I got carried away.

Are you still with me? Hey!

Hello!
If you’re still here, that’s awesome.

Effective marketing is also magical. You could start with little, engage a copy alchemist, who knows how to turn words to cash… and within a short-period, you’d make your bankers incredibly jealous.

Effective marketing is magic.

But it is no illusion. It’s not fantasy. You go home after a magic show, and all you have to show for it are warm memories and a slightly leaner bank balance…

With effective marketing, the impact may last a lifetime, and its effect can be life-transforming.

When you have a great conductor at the helm of your copywriting…your bank account overflows. A tsunami of abundance fills your life. Most of your dreams are now easily realizable. Your fears fade away.

Smart marketers know how to orchestrate different elements to get winning promotions.
Copywriters are a dime a dozen! You need someone with real –world experience of sales and marketing. Someone who knows what is at a stake and who can understand what you’re trying to achieve because they have been there several times. Someone who has tasted blood!

Someone who has sold on the streets – in the cold, harsh realities of face-to-face interactions (not a wimp who has been hiding behind a computer, all his life)…
…You need someone who is constantly studying all the great books on copywriting and marketing…and all the winning promotions. Someone who is on the train bound for the land of perpetual improvement…

A Serial Salesman

I have sold the following in the past:

1. Soap
2. Christmas gift items for children
3. A device for optimizing fuel consumption
4. Nylons
5. Software
6. Internet services
7. My writing services
8. My consulting services
9. An online directory
I still sell 7 and 8

I am sorry; I ought to have introduced myself.

Forgive my manners.

My name is Michael Newman.

I graduated from a top – university, 22 years ago, and I have been privileged to work in different sectors (publishing, hospitality, banking, technology)...as an accountant…later I left the bean-counters and became a writer, salesman, and marketing manager.
My degree is in accounting, but I’ve had a flair for writing since I was 13.

(I thought I’d make more moolah being a bean-counter). I was bored to death! So, years ago, I went back to my first love.

My father was a researcher – so I grew up in a home where knowledge is revered. It’s not a surprise that conducting in-depth research is one of my strong skills. I will use that skill in working on your copy.

After graduating from the university, I went for a 4 month course, for entrepreneurs, and one of the areas I fell in love with is STRATEGY. I’m highly familiar with the works of Jay Abraham, Chet Holmes, Michael Porter…

Eleven years ago, I was a part-owner of a small advertising agency. Our focus was brand advertising. I was the in – house copywriter (and strategist).

Fortunately for me, around that time, I came across the warrior-forum and AWAI (they have awesome training programs for copywriters) …and I started learning about direct response copywriting.

It dawned on me that advertising is not about awards, cute slogans, ‘creativity’, and clever language…

I was enchanted by the magic of direct response copywriting…of being able to use words to elicit specific action.

Like a magic wand.

Kinda like when the pied piper had all the mice at his beck and call! You and I can arrange some words, and a horde of customers will start following you.

You’d like that kind of magic, where you’ll make out like a bandit. You’d like that.

Real magic!

Direct response copywriting lured me into a cult…of a rare group of marketers who have only one mantra…advertising is salesmanship. It’s about results.
‘We sell, or else.’

I get you results, or else.

While working on your project I will invest my whole heart and soul.
I live and sleep with words. I know they are truly magical. They are extra-ordinary.
But let’s shatter a myth: copy is the most important thing you need, to make a lot of moolah.

It is not true.

Copy, alone, will not bring in the moolah you’d like. The quality of your product, the nature of the offer, a responsive the mailing list, the media employed for the promotions are all key elements.

When you have all those in place…

…then, let’s focus on crafting copy that will release an avalanche of gold for you. And, we must measure its impact. We must.

You need someone who will not just write copy, or swipe some other promo, you need someone who understands the hidden strategy behind the copy and who can give you advice, someone who knows what makes copy work.

You need someone who has been on both sides of the table, a salesman, a marketer, and a strategist. The revered Jay Abraham says: strategy trumps copy. Trust me, it’s true.

Effective marketing and copywriting leverages research, it reflects a deep understanding of your product or service, your prospects and customers, and your competition.
Let’s compose compelling cash-generating copy for you…and open the gate to financial freedom.

Copy that sucks …or one that rocks… The choice is yours.

In your service
Michael Newman
Copywriter and marketing consultant

P. S.

So, how do we roll?

You send a detailed brief…to newmanmo2@gmail.com

Please use the subject: LETHAL WEAPON. I will respond asap.

Once we’re on the same page, then, the laser-focused rays of unfaltering devotion will be focused on your promotion. As if, you paid me $1,000.

But, this one is FREE. It’s on the house.

A limited time offer for the first 4 smart and fast marketers…

I’d quickly take some time to learn your business.

I will devote my time to understanding your product (I may ask for a copy), your target market, competing products, industry…then, I will start my magic.

The copy will not be more than 5 pages (It could be less – It’s a function of the type of copy required.) I can write in a purely formal way, too. It depends on the best way of ‘speaking’ to your target market.

Turnaround: 7-10 days (It could be less. It’s a function of the nature of the copy you’d like.)

With me, you get a pro with street- smarts, a marketing and sales background, and a strategist.

My ‘virtual’ mentors are many, but let me just share four with you, to give you an idea of the kind of company I keep. They are Gary Bencivenga, Michael Masterson, Claude Hopkins, Chet Holmes, and Jay Abraham.

You get riveting, response-boosting copy crafted for you.

Marketing is not only magical…it’s a lethal weapon!

Let’s get started now.

You’ll be glad you did.

A tsunami of abundance awaits you.
#copy #critique
  • Profile picture of the author ewenmack
    Michael, it lacks specifics, curiosity and building value.

    Now if you were to talk about a advertising
    method widely used in the 60's by ad agency Olgivy And Mather,
    $350,000 worth of Facebook advertising was spent testing it
    and this secret method beat the pants off every previous
    Facebook advertising approach.

    "You want have to pay anything like that to get this breakthrough secret.."

    See, how it's dropping in specifics, up to date tests that sound like a new breakthrough
    and you are the one having more value than the guy
    with the money.

    Of course, you don't stop there, you keep leaving a trail
    of pearls so the greed glands are bursting to breaking point.

    Never fully divulging what the secrets you hold.

    See how you've boosted your status?

    Without testimonials.

    Without looking needy.

    Without waiting to get high fees.

    Think of you as the guy who holds the secrets
    to so many valuable things and you keep dropping
    hints as to what they are.

    The Wizard with magical powers.

    Go dig those potions out of your lab
    and pass on to the world what they have done,
    not how they do it.

    Here's a name for you...Merlin!

    Best,
    Ewen
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9494489].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Newman
    Thank you very much for your comments.

    Best regards.

    M.N.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9494586].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Chriswrighto
      Hi Michael,

      Hope you're well.

      Here's a bit of what I think, starting with your headline...

      "A Lethal Weapon and an Offer No Smart Marketer Should Refuse"

      It's not specific enough... what is this lethal weapon? What's it going to do?

      And the curiosity of being a "lethal weapon" isn't enough to make me read on either.


      "I grew up in a home where I saw a gun every day.

      So, am I going to unleash virtual violence, now?

      No. Don’t be afraid.

      It’s all good news…for you.

      This is about a great offer."


      I see what you're trying to do here... create an open loop so people are compelled to read on... It's a nice idea.

      But in this case, it's become irrelevant and closed when you say "No. Don't be afraid". It's waffle... small talk that people don't have time for.

      "I am a movie-addict.

      GODFATHER…is one of my faves.

      I’ve watched it 4 times. It’s a work of art."


      Rambling, needs to be made more concise, maybe removed all together.

      "Do you recall that part where Mary was shot, as people came out of the opera? And, the haunting strains of Cavalleria Rusticana, wafted in the background, deepening the grief our delicate hearts were suddenly plunged into?

      But, let’s leave the Cosa Nostra and focus on moolah."


      I have no idea what this means... at all.

      And even if I did, it could be written better.

      This is all before...

      "If you give me a tiny chunk of your time, I will craft response-boosting copy for you."


      Now, THIS is where you get into it! Now I finally know what you're selling... what you can do for me... why I'm even bothering to read.

      "I have tasted ‘financial freedom’"

      Tasted? So not anymore? Something feels wrong here.



      So that's a small critique to give you an idea of how to improve it. Some may feel "small" but it's what makes the difference.

      From a macro view...

      I'd echo Ewen.

      And I'd add by saying that you need to stop rambling...

      At best it takes the "kapow" out of your copy... at worst, it confuses the reader. Either way, they're gone back onto Facebook.

      Hope this helps,

      Chris

      "The Baby Faced Assassin"

      P.S. Good luck!

      P.P.S. One more thing... "A tsunami of abundance"... who wants that? These big words scare people most the time, especially when one's associated with a major loss of life. (Yeah yeah, the baby faced assassin... make a killing online... whatever ).
      Signature

      Wealthcopywriter.com :)

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9494836].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Newman
    I appreciate your in-depth critique.

    I will make the necessary adjustments, when I've had all other critiques.

    Guns and assasins :-)

    Cheers,

    M.N.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9494896].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author angiecolee
    TL;DR.

    I got through the first part and was immediately turned off.

    What if your prospect doesn't get the movie reference? What if they're not a fan of guns or killing animals? There are a lot of people you're turning off right away.

    I echo the sentiments shared above.
    Cut, cut, cut. Get it TIGHT. Talk about benefits, your experience.

    Filler does you no favors.
    Signature

    Aspiring copywriters: if you need 1:1 advice from an experienced copy chief, head over to my Phone a Friend page.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9495310].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Newman
    Thanks.

    I will cut those out.

    Best regards,

    M.N.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9495340].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author sethczerepak
    Hi Michael,

    I like what you're aiming for with the metaphor.

    Couple big problems though, let's start with your headline...

    A Lethal Weapon and an Offer No Smart Marketer Should Refuse

    Anytime you write a headline, ask yourself how it would look as a stand alone classified ad in the back of a magazine (read by your target market) with an action mechanism at the end.

    Take yours for instance...

    A Lethal Weapon and an Offer No Smart Marketer Should Refuse
    GO to ______ to FIND OUT MORE

    See the problem?

    It doesn't communicate anything. It just confuses the reader.

    Your headline should be able to stand on its own as a full "ad" for your sales letter. This means, it should be clear, interesting and relevant enough to get a response.

    If it's not, it won't even sell them on reading the first line, and you're dead in the water.

    If I saw this, I'd think: "Gun ad? Knife? ....no ...'marketer...' " WTF is this guy talking about?

    Confusion is the one thing you should NEVER do in your ads.

    I've seen effective ads that made people laugh, cry, get their panties in a twist....I've NEVER seen an effective ad that confused people.

    But, assuming that they read on...

    Originally Posted by Michael Newman View Post


    Dear Smart Marketer,

    I grew up in a home where I saw a gun every day.

    So, am I going to unleash virtual violence, now?

    No. Don’t be afraid.

    It’s all good news…for you.

    This is about a great offer.

    It’s for you, and 3 other smart and fast marketers.

    But, first things first…

    …seeing as you may be wondering what’s the connection between marketing and lethal weapons.
    Too late.

    You needed to show that connection IN THE HEADLINE and tied it to a CLEAR and SPECIFIC benefit.

    Now, it just sounds creepy and awkward. You're also creating too much work for the reader by introducing two seemingly unrelated ideas and trying to fuse them into one idea.

    In marketing, your best bet is to start with a very clear, interesting and singular idea (called a hook).

    You can expand on the idea from there, but trying to tie to seemingly unrelated things together just sounds like you haven't developed the connection well enough in your own mind.

    Again, confusion.

    And what reward is there for sticking around to see the connection anyway?

    Gun Violence and marketing?

    By now, the only person who MIGHT still be reading is a serial killer (or a copywriter critiquing your page).

    I'm not saying you can't position yourself as the "Marketer's Secret Weapon..." or whatever you're trying to do.

    But where's the benefit for the reader?

    I guess you'll explain that later. But most reader's won't guess.

    They'll just hit the back button. If you're going to tie two ideas together, make them these two...

    1) Your promise to the reader.
    2) Something interesting about your brand or offer.

    ...and make it VERY clear how they're connected:

    Originally Posted by Michael Newman View Post


    A hunter and a movie addict

    See, my dad liked to hunt!

    It’s strange that some folks enjoy killing animals.

    I don’t.

    I am a movie-addict.

    GODFATHER…is one of my faves.

    I’ve watched it 4 times. It’s a work of art.

    Do you recall that part where Mary was shot, as people came out of the opera? And, the haunting strains of Cavalleria Rusticana, wafted in the background, deepening the grief our delicate hearts were suddenly plunged into?

    But, let’s leave the Cosa Nostra and focus on moolah.

    I’d like to make you an offer. But, don’t be scared. I’m not going to use a gun.

    Relax.

    I promise you, I’m not going to use a gun.

    If you give me a tiny chunk of your time, I will craft response-boosting copy for you.

    FREE. Yes, you read that right. No moolah needed today. Keep your wallet.
    .
    Wow, um. Okay, dude, in all seriousness. I was gonna keep going.

    I usually do one in-depth critique a week, and you were the lucky winner...but holy s**t Michael.

    I'm outta here.

    You need to seriously rethink your positioning AND your offer.

    Offering FREE copywriting services is a bad idea for dozens of reasons, all of which have been discussed on this forum.

    I'm going to let you do the Googling, cause I've got another critique to do, but that's not even your biggest issue.

    If I saw THIS ^ letter, I wouldn't hire you even if you PAID ME to do it.

    You probably WOULD have to hold a gun to my head.

    I'm not afraid of guns either...or killing animals.

    Hell, I'd club a baby seal for a good pair of boots and every swingin' dick in my neighborhood had a gun stashed under his dashboard.

    But, whatever you tie your brand to becomes the thing which shapes your customer's perception.

    If I suggest that you go to a restaurant because they have "steaks the size of toilet seats," ...what will you think?

    "Wow, big steaks. I love steak. Let's go!"

    ....or...

    "Ugh, toilet seats!"

    I'll stay it again...

    Whatever you tie your brand to becomes the thing which shapes your customer's perception.

    Right now, you're creating an impression of the creepy serial killer who sits in his mom's basement all day reading guns and ammo and eating lucky charms cereal out of a human skull.

    BTW, who wants Lucky Charms now?

    Again, association.

    On a positive note, I like your unconventional thinking on this.

    Most great ideas start out sounding crazy at first...but it's all about how you communicate them.

    I'd suggest starting again.

    This time, throw out the guns and the violence and start with what the customer wants.

    Then, tell them how you're going to deliver it WITHOUT subjecting them to the thing which they fear MIGHT happen if they hire the wrong writer.

    Think clear first.

    Clever later...or never. yeah, clever never works (<--that was clever :-)).
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9495864].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Newman
    I truly appreciate your taking the time to offer an in-depth critique.

    I will definitely improve the copy, based on the suggestions I've been given.

    Best regards,

    M.N.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9496712].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author max5ty
    Ummm yeah, I'm not feeling this. The letter or the offer.

    You say it's free.

    I read this as a potential client, and I'm thinking it could just possibly, by judging from what you've wrote, turn out to be the most expensive sales letter I'd ever use.

    I'll give you my critique as a potential client.

    There are times when "free" can be very costly. This has all the signs of being one of those times.

    I'm not prepared to blow a wad of cash on a free sales letter from you.

    First, the letter you wrote is complete nonsense. Everything from a movie to a magician to snowflakes melting, to guns and hunting...it's all about you...it's all about the free you are offering.

    I'm the one that's going to whip out my Visa card to pay for the ads. I'm gonna spend hundreds or thousands working on getting people to take a look at my product. You're going to whip together something in a week and waste all the money I'd spend on advertising. No thank you. Your "free" would cost me.

    Let me edit your letter and take out all the nonsense:

    "Hey guys, I'm wanting to be a copywriter. Don't have any achievements yet, but I'd like you to foot the bill with your own money to test out my sales letter. After you've paid out of your pocket...if it does good I'd like a testimonial."

    What a crock.

    But let's just say you get a customer that wrote an ebook on the mating rituals of the fruit fly, and spends no money on advertising. Let's just say they're going to do links or some crap. From what I've read, your "free" would still be losing them money from lost sales.

    Your big plan of "free" is only free to you.

    You're not ready to write sales letters yet.

    When it comes to asking other people to pay for the testing of your sales letters...you need to start showing and doing less telling about some nonsense your customer could give two hoots about.

    What have you done for yourself with your sales letters? If you write so good why haven't you got your own product and made a fortune?

    I did a post about how anybody could get their own product and sell it...even gave a link to a website.

    Don't tell me what your gonna do for me unless you've already done it for yourself. Don't use my money to learn.

    You said you wouldn't cry, and you said you wanted us to be blunt...there you go.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9497284].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Newman
    I sought the critiques, because I am trying to improve the copy.

    I will pick the positive and specific elements in all the critiques, and I will improve it.

    I've got a tough skin. Bring it on.

    I will pick the SPECIFIC areas, others have pointed out.

    Thanks for taking the time. Your critique gently swayed away from the objective and specific :-)

    M.N.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9497782].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author max5ty
      Originally Posted by Michael Newman View Post

      I sought the critiques, because I am trying to improve the copy.

      I will pick the positive and specific elements in all the critiques, and I will improve it.

      I've got a tough skin. Bring it on.

      I will pick the SPECIFIC areas, others have pointed out.

      Thanks for taking the time. Your critique gently swayed away from the objective and specific :-)

      M.N.
      I give you credit for taking my critique like a pro.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9499847].message }}
  • Others have (rather expertly) critiqued the copy.

    Here's what concerns me before I even got to your copy -

    The copy is meant to be a phase in my plan to launch a copywriting service. I want to collect more testimonials, in exchange for writing for four marketers


    Don't do this.


    Testimonials are good. And you should get them. Use them if you want. Many don't believe them. Some buy because of them.


    I never use them (because of NDA's and the copy is © for the clients - they paid and the copy is theirs)


    So, I wouldn't be slogging all hours working on 4 pieces for free.

    It's much better making a good living writing for fees.

    Why not do the same.


    Steve
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9500311].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Newman
    Thank you.

    Getting paid is a more enchanting consideration :-)

    I will improve the copy dramatically.

    Best wishes,

    M.N.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9500603].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Newman
    I thank everyone who contributed.

    I also thank the person who sent me a PM, and pointed me to a great copywriting book.

    Best wishes,

    M.N.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9502716].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JonMills
    Vague buddy and poor use of sub-headlines.

    Be clear. Clarity always wins.
    Signature
    http://www.thecopywriterwhisperer.com/ Persuasion at it's best!
    http://www.affiliateorganizer.com/ Organize your entire online business - Super affiliates give it the thumbs up!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9504607].message }}

Trending Topics