Was just offered $350 for this domain.... Sell or hold?

by 49 replies
So I have owned the domain whyg.com for many years, Out of the blue I get an offer a couple of weeks ago for $150 (which I never responded to), then Yesterday, same guy offers $350. The various valuation sites seem to value it between 850 and 1500, but I have no idea how accurate those sites are.

Any thoughts?

Thanks in advance!
#freemarket.com discussion #$350 #domain #hold #offered #sell
Avatar of Unregistered
  • Profile picture of the author Victor Nguyen
    Banned
    [DELETED]
  • Profile picture of the author greatdn
    the free appraisal sites arent very accurate unless there has been a previously reported sale for the same name. I would say that the $350 offer is fair but is on the lower end of the market value for such 4 character domains.
  • Profile picture of the author SeoWrecker
    The domain valuation tools means nothing . It is nowhere close to worth 850-1000$
  • Profile picture of the author greatdn
    A domain name is worth what someone will pay for it. I have seen 4 character domains similar to this sell in the past for $3000, but those sales are very rare and are typically purchased by companies which are looking to re-brand their online business with an acronym. I took a moment to search acronymattic.com to see how many abbreviations may relate to your name whyg.com, it returned only 1 result. Having said that, i would say the likelihood of receiving $xxxx for this domain is low. If you are able to, contact the potential buyer and get more info about who he/she is and why they want the name. Is likely a domain trader looking to buy the name for $350 and resell for $450-$550. If it is a business looking to acquire the name, you could probably get a bit more out of them. Tell them you were planning to develop the name and would need a more educated offer from them if you were to sell.
  • Profile picture of the author getsmartt
    Thanks all, appreciate the input
  • Profile picture of the author DRP
    Those valuation sites are ALWAYS wrong, so do not use them to determine the value of your domain.

    There's no website hosted on your domain, so the domain is not worth much at all. It's only worth whatever someone's willing to pay for it. So the $350 is a handsome offer, especially since it's not a premium domain. Premium domains would be like Pizza.com, which are obviously worth more than yourwebsitehereisawesome.com just on face value alone.

    Domains that have websites on them are valued most reliably by their income multiples...which is a product of the website's yearly profit compounded over said multiple.

    So I'd advise you to take the offer, unless you have other plans for it.
  • Profile picture of the author ArielT
    I think its value is higher than $350
  • Profile picture of the author l0st
    This is an interesting .com offer consider why the name is valuable?
  • Profile picture of the author Adam Yunker
    It really depends on how much it's value holds to you.. Do you need it? If not, I'd say sell it.

    Maybe the guy has a website he wants to create, but for some reason need that domain name.

    I'd say put it on Flippa and send him a link to your auction and says he can bid on it or buy it through the "Buy it now" price. So you don't get scammed.

    Just for safety measures.

    That's my 2 cents..

    Hope that helps

    Take care, Adam
  • Profile picture of the author GlobalTrader
    I received the same set of emails - same amounts - for two 4 letter domains I have owned for some time now - not to reveal his entire email address (which is all the contact info he has provided thus far) but the first part of his email is "dino" @ - let me know if yours is from the same name?

    Personally, I have filed both emails away until next year - maybe there will be a couple more upticks until then.
  • Profile picture of the author Yosheena
    Sell it now You're getting $350 out of the blue.
  • Profile picture of the author marketinguk
    [DELETED]
  • Profile picture of the author renatomerro
    [DELETED]
  • Profile picture of the author sbwebmaster
    1. Never use an automated appraisal.

    2. LLLL .coms are going up in value.

    3. $350 seems like a reasonable reseller offer for this domain. As with any domain sales, you can get more money from an end-user but how long will you wait.
    • Profile picture of the author renatomerro
      Originally Posted by sbwebmaster View Post

      1. Never use an automated appraisal.

      2. LLLL .coms are going up in value.

      3. $350 seems like a reasonable reseller offer for this domain. As with any domain sales, you can get more money from an end-user but how long will you wait.
      Prices are depends on the consonants and vowels on the name.
  • Profile picture of the author richinca
    My advice, Hold it.

    4 letter domain names are going up each day that's why you're getting contacted.
    Don't sell unless you need the money or get a better offer.
    • Profile picture of the author DRP
      Originally Posted by richinca View Post

      4 letter domain names are going up each day that's why you're getting contacted.
      That's NOT true at all! kfgv.com or the OP's whyg.com has ZERO value even though it has 4 letters. The 4 letters is really irrelevant! The only way a 4 letter domain would be worth anything on its face value would be a word...like play.com or cars.com

      The amount of straight up BS on this forum is completely unnerving.
  • Profile picture of the author allegandro
    Easy calculation

    The domain itself will cost you 2-5$ a year.
    So even when you wait 10 years to sell it, it will cost you just 50$
    If you not sold it after 10 years, you have lost 350$ plus 50$, so your risk is 400$
    But also you will always be able to sell it for a minimum of 100$.

    Now your risk has become 300$ tops

    Set a goal price for your website, let’s say 1500$

    Now is is calculating the odds, if you think that you have a 20% chance you will sell it in the next 10 years for 1.500$, then keep it and wait.
    If you think nobody will buy it, or the chance is lower than 20%, sell it now.
  • Profile picture of the author DanyUzi
    [DELETED]
    • Profile picture of the author ArielT
      Originally Posted by DanyUzi View Post

      i want to sell few domains please help me I am new in this field so i dont know how to sell domains

      I am waiting for your replies
      If they are saleable domains, you can list them on a Marketplace or make a private sale

      Sites where you can list your domains for sale: Flippa.com, GoDaddy.com, NamePros.com, FreeMarket.com, Sedo.com, etc

      Look for potential buyers to let them know you have those domains for sale
  • Profile picture of the author DanyUzi
    [DELETED]
  • Profile picture of the author shahidcg
    [DELETED]
  • Profile picture of the author revenue27
    If want to develop the site , and some content inside you can hold it, but if don't have time to develop it you can sell it, use flippa or sedo to sell

Next Topics on Trending Feed