turbohips

This is a un-biased review for Bookmarking Demon. To be fair you must know that I'm running on a very fast computer and have FIOS internet speed. With that said the times listed should be any reflection of slow processing times due to my computer or connection. Now there is some user input required on only a few of the sites that required captcha input. The instructional videos are very simple and easy to understand. With all the training done, I started tracking everything I've done to give a fair evaluation. So let's begin:

I've listed everything below in steps as this is what you're supposed to do.

Step 1 account creations
1 hour to create all account with a 95% success ratio.
Out of 95 accounts only a few didn't go though but this was expected as sites constantly change.

Step 2 email verification
10 seconds to download all emails
7 minutes to verify all account emails - note that 3 showed not verified in the email status but once checking on the sites, they were in fact verified already. Also, it would be a good idea here to wait at least 10 minutes to let all the emails come in before verification.

Step 3 add pages for bookmarking
This was actually fairly fast and very easy to do. I was surprised at how the program works and how much control it gives you with regards to spamming controls. It allows you to decide on how hard you want to post your site links. I selected the lowest setting and it took roughly 1 minute to process. I now have 347 bookmarks selected for a full run of 5 pages.

Step 4 let the bookmarking begin
In all of the steps so far, I have not adjusted any of the standard settings for the time adjusters. I left everything as the program was originally installed thinking this was probably the best settings. With that said these times will reflect perhaps a longer than standard processing time should you decide to alter the settings. For example, some of the steps require up to a 90 second load time. Of course this time is reduced as the page loads and only take a few seconds. OK so I don't confuse people, I did change only one thing and that was the amount of pages to be loaded at one time which was 10. The muti-threading option helps speed things up significantly.

56 minutes total
242 submissions successful
105 submissions failed
1 program crash
tons of captchas I had to solve

Step 5 ping stuff
OK finding ping servers took me 10 seconds on Google. I added 23 servers to ping and loaded up my list. Easy enough and pretty straight forward. I also only had 23 pages auto loaded for some reason to ping. Strange but maybe I missed something here. I was under the assumption that all of the bookmarking sites that I just created would also be automatically added. Anyhow it only took roughly 2 minutes to ping all 23 pages on all of the 23 servers.

My Evaluation
After giving this program my good old college try I found it somewhat useful and at the same time not what the sales page makes it out to be. Again, I know that there are no software automated platforms that are 100% of what they say on sales pages. Thinking about the time I spent to get accounts created, verified, links bookmarked and pinged, I can honestly say wow it's a major time saver. I've also used SENuke last month and gave that program a good test run. As for SENuke, the account creation was much faster. Both of them require captcha solving so that still sucks. The bookmarking was much faster and had a higher percentage of successful submission with BMD over SENuke. There is only the one time charge for purchasing BMD which is much better than the monthly for SENuke. I've gotten my money back from SENuke so no lose there. My only decision is to see if BMD really cuts the mustard.

If I take the approach that BMD is really only for getting links noticed and indexed quickly, then I think it's a great price for what it does. If I think that it will get me higher SERP's then I'm greatly mistaken. Being this was my first run with the program, I have no clue how long the accounts will stay up for. I did use a Google email account that I've had for years to reduce the risk of that getting banned. After a few more weeks I'll run a back link check to see if I got any results from using this software on one of my sites. I highly doubt there will be any significant differences but hell what do I know. I am also wondering if I now have to ping all of the bookmarks that this program made for me. Being that they weren't automatically added onto the ping list that might be something I have to look into.

So for this one site that I'll be testing, I've already created roughly 250 profile back links from high PR sites that I know have yet to be indexed. If this program works as advertised then all of the profile links should get crawled, indexed and show drastic improvement for my site. I'll keep you all posted as thing progress.

On a side note, it this posts is useful information to you, please hit the thank you button below.

turbohips

OK well now it's been one more day since I started this experiment. I've actually updated 3 different websites with bookmarks from at least 150 profiles that I've made to see if the results were shared amongst all 3 sites for a better evaluation. The funny thing is that one of the sites started to improve while two of the sites did actually worst. I'm guessing this is part of the famous Google dance and perhaps in the next few days all 3 sites will improve from where I first started.

Again to play devils advocate it could also be a result of my profile links getting indexed without the bookmarking efforts. Only time will tell and I'll continue using the software to back link to my other profile links that I've already created.

Day 2 results
OK well I decided to add 80 more links to bookmark and here are my results:

Used a different IP to mask my footprint
14 successful
66 failed due to account deletion or something silly

End results were very poor and with such a suddenly poor result I'll be asking for my money back. I'm guessing that many accounts were deleted due to spam detection even though I masked my IP address and only back linked one site at a time. Very poor showing for this program.

kaene

what about the decaptcha support? doesn't the last version include decaptcha support so you don't have to enter manually the captchas?

kimperino1985

Sounds good.. but are trying to sell Bookmarking Demon here on warrior forum?

djleon1

Hmm- His second post says he is asking for a refund as he was not impressed with the success rate so I doubt he is "selling" it. Anyway thanks to OP for their review.

xxxJamesxxx

I've got it but I'm not too impressed with it either.

The captcha thing really does my head in as well

ShaneRQR

Yes, it does. It costs $1 for 1000 captchas, I think.
I haven't tried the service myself, so I can't say anything about success rates etc.

turbohips

You guys are correct in that I'm NOT selling this software nor would I recommend it. They did refund my money quickly and without any issues. Too bad their software wasn't as good as their return policy. Almost all of my accounts have now been disabled since I tried the software so none of my links that I created are now showing. I've wasted a ton of time. Thanks BMD.

paperfreak

For anyone using BMD at the moment Version 5.2.0.0, can you tell me if you have this same issue:

When I create a new project, it copies all of the accounts from all of the previous projects into the new project.

Absolute pain in the rear end. Driving me insane.
So far no reply from support as to if this is normal or an error.

ShaneRQR

I think it's meant to do that. Simply deactivate all the accounts you don't want to use in the profile. The activated/deactivated settings are saved for each individual profile.

bcongl

How does bookmarkingwiz compare?

Jeff Klein

Thanks for the review.

rmljbm

I just purchased BMD 1 hour ago,and they have yet to send me the License key..Anyone who bought before tell me if this is normal. I have emailed support twice in the last hour to no avail. hmmmm

Thanks,
Jeff