petermike

Hello,

I am going to purchase either Social book marketing demon or Magic Submitter which do my fellow Warrior Forum peeps recommend?

I like that Social book marking demon is a pay one time but Magic Submitter does look easier to use. Based on the presentation i'm leaning toward Magic Submitter but Social Bookmarking demon does look good. I don't know what to do right now any help would be greatly appreciated.

filfy

I have both tools and I can say that they are great tools to have, depending on your needs. If you just need to bookmark, then you are probably better off with BMD (Book Making Demon). Its rather stable and allows you to integrate multiple accounts, so you can bookmark randomly from multiple profiles to different sites. At this time, Magic Submitter does not allow this, but from my understanding they are working on it.

Magic Submitter is a great tool for multiple marketing methods. You can do article marketing, social bookmarking, web 2.0 blog creation and marketing as well as bookmarking. I think the real strength is in the designer mode where you can add your own sites. I'm hoping that more people get involved and grow a marketplace for magic submitter like the one that is taking place for sick submitter.

If you are trying to automate some SEO tasks for your sites then you may be better off trying out magic submitter which may provide more useful SEO tools. If you just need something for bookmarking then get BMD.

jesus72knight

If all you want to do is bookmarking then BMD is for you. It's one heck of a tool. But if you want to utilize other functionalities then Magic Submitter will work like wonders.

xxxJamesxxx

I currently love BMD

James

youallnome

One more to throw in to the mix!

I'm thinking of taking a look at magic submitter too. My research suggests its getting better; started out with some bugs and the developer (fellow warrior) has "jumped all over it" to help members.

It has a trial price to, so not much of a risk for the first 30 days.

However, I have to throw one more into the ring. seNuke. I'm using this and have been for 3 months. I use it daily and it is very good at what it does.

The early feedback I saw had some problems. A bit buggy. Some warriors have even said they hate it. Why that is I cannot work out. It has never let me down.

So consider looking at seNuke as well.
It is definitely one you should research. The price tag seems to be the main reason people shy away from it. It can seem expensive. Over $40 more per month than magic submitter.

I'm about to test magic submitter for myself.
I'll keep you posted.

Wishing you the best of decisions!
John

Janet Walker

You are comparing apples to oranges. Magic submitter would be comparable to SeNuke.

I have Magic submitter and it by far is the most value for your money. Anytime I ever ran into difficulties because I did not know what I was doing, Mr. Krulic (the developer) helped personally. When you use a product like Magic submitter or SeNuke there is a pretty large learning curve to become fluent in all of different operations that it performs.

Diane S

There are two levels available at bookmarking demon. The beginner level is great for learning the software. I like the ping function inside Bookmarking Demon and also the drip scheduler.

cypherslock

Another vote for Magic Submitter. Why do just one thing, when you can do all of it in one place. I'd add to your toolbox though: Article Marketing Robot, and Scrapebox.


EDIT: I've used BMD it IS good, but for pure value even at a monthly cost, Magic Submitter is tops for me. Just the idea that you can add your own sites is worth the cash.

HiAbby

Magic Submitter looks like a really cool tool. I haven't really used it, but I've used senuke.

Will be interesting to try out.

MikeFriedman

There is no better bookmarking software out there than BMD.

It doesn't do everything Magic Submitter does, but from just the bookmarking standpoint, Magic Submitter cannot hold a candle to it. Neither can SEnuke or SEO Link Robot.

If you are looking for more functionality and want to be able to do things like create Web 2.0 sites, then look at SEO Link Robot or Magic Submitter.

I had been using SEnuke, then Magic, and now I use SEO Link Robot. One-time fee and works great. Magic would be my second choice. SEnuke used to be great, but the site creation fails around 30-35% of the time. For $127/month, no thanks.

The profile creation on SEnuke was nice, but has been spammed to death. I like Sick better for that. $20/month and you can add all your own forums.

BarberShop

what does MagicSubmitter do?

cypherslock

Magic Submitter. Take a look and try the trial. The sales page is actually quite specific about what it does. It also has videos so you can truly see and make an informed choice. this was one reason I tried it. The other was Alex (the developer) himself. Takes time to help, listens and implements user feedback. The training is insanely good and always added to. I believe there is more training this week as well. All video. the user guide was just updated as well. Yes I'm impressed. It all depends of course, what you want. If you want a dedicated bookmark tool, then look elsewhere, but if you want one that does video, articles, RSS, forum profiles, Bookmarking and document sharing sites (new), check this out. I personally love it and to me it is worth the 67 a month.

BarberShop

Thanks.

"Legally hack your way to the top of Google"

More like causing the red-flag and getting sent to the sandbox.

cypherslock

LOL...SENuke does similar. It is sales copy. And anyway, it is just a tool. All in how you use it. It is a fast content distribution tool, nothing more.

pethanks

I have not tried magic submitter yet but this social bookmarking demon is very nice. I love it

MikeFriedman

Using any of these tools is not going to get you into any sandboxes.

Mike Anthony

I am evaluating it and like it very much but don't know if its really worth $67 per month. Stretching the expenditure out to six months thats just short of $420 or over $800 a year. Thats article robot, Scrapebox, Demon book market and more with plenty left over for someone who doesn't own that stuff already.

So it comes down to adding my own links which is pretty important to me the way I do SEO but then again I can use a macro recorder and get that without the monthly expense. That and the fact that I like how its all integrated in there. Alex should just throw his spinner in there as well. Its not complete in the article marketing world without it integrated in.

Good software though and I may just decide its a keeper.

Jon Shawcross

MS is a great tool and I have had some incredible success on it. I have recently ranked 2 local keywords on Google UK, dominating 7 places on one and 8 on the other within 48 hours of submission!!! OK, agreed, they weren't the most competitive terms in the world, but given that once i had created the content, spun it and added it to the scheduler in MS (a truly amazing piece of kit), i simply forgot about it all together. MS worked whilst i was out for dinner, sleeping and working on other machines on different projects.

My only real complaint is the video submission tool is nothing short of hopeless. Several times I have tried to use it now and submissions failed to over 90% on every occasion. Still, i like to do my video marketing mainly solely via YT anyhow, so a manual upload, followed by a huge amount of MS backlinking gets the job done.

I moved over from SE Nuke around 6 months ago. Was fed up of everything failing all the time, its just isn't worth the money (did i mention Magic Submitter is almost half the monthly price of SEN??)

Before anyone asks, i am not affiliated with MS what so ever. I just think its a great product. I have tried many (and invested a LOT of time in learning how to use properly - YES, it IS a steep learning curve - on ALL of them) and this one wipes the floor with the rest.

Diane S

Glad you are happy with Magic Submitter. Just want to be sure you know you can add unlimited social bookmarking sites inside of Bookmarking Demon, and unlimited article directories inside of Article Demon.

But maybe I did not read your statement correctly...?

cypherslock

You can add unlimited sites to any of the services. And even add your own services and associated sites. Try it, trust me, you'll like it.

Mike Anthony

Do they have a trial anywhere?

cypherslock

Right on the main page: Magic Submitter

billykrush

I was thinking of buying SEO link Robot but it seems every one on here pretty much likes MS. I've tried SEnuke for a few months but like every one else the price is a little too much for my liking.

I'm hoping Alex gets back to me about the yearly special because I'm keen to give MS a proper go.

Thanks for every ones comments.

bk

energytimes

What about Magic article writer?

cypherslock

If you don't want to pay the yearly fee for The Best Spinner, MAR is an excellent alternative and one time fee. couple it with the magic token database and it is almost as good. There is also the free alternative, SpinnerChief. Try that one out as well and see which suits you best.

aj113

I've gotta say the MAR magic token database is pants. No better than autospinning using any other software. Hardly 'magic'.

Dani723

I stopped using SEO Link Robot because you can only have one set of SB accounts at any time. Now that I use Demon instead, it hardly matters.

I would switch back to Link Robot, (still a one time fee!) or perhaps try Magic Submitter, after all the good things I've heard, were the new version of SEnuke not coming out soon.

Yes I know, they've been saying that months, but I've scouted the creators Facebook page and he's been including status updates about it for a while, they entered the final stage of beta testing on the 10th January, so it's not unreasonable to think that it should be in perhaps a months time or less.

It seems like the best software for backlinking often comes with the ability to add your own sites. I'm have amazing success with Article Marketing Robot and Bookmarking Demon, in part, because they both let you do this. I would imagine combining that with Magic Submitter, and adding lots of new sites into all of them is probably the winning combo of a good few of the top IMs (plus Scrapebox and indexation software of course).

Mike Anthony

No I was referring to trials for Bookmark demon or article demon. I tend not to buy software I can't run through its paces

Flareman

I bought Magic submitter about a month ago, but unfortunately I'm not really seeing a lot of backlink juice coming back to my site. A free service that I use, backlink spider, seems to be giving me more backlinks than what I submit through Magic Submitter. This is getting a bit discouraging.

Can any other Magic Submitter users offer some tips on how to get backlinks from MS quickly?

Chris Sorrell

MS has a pinger and loads up your url's so you can ping them. Have you checked that out?

Flareman

Yes I have. I always end my MS session with a ping to all of the sites I submitted. Are you able to get MS to effectively give you consistent backlinks?