Affiliate software: RAP vs. Post Affiliate Pro

14 replies
I have to admit, I'm a bit confused by all the different affiliate networks, softwares and shopping carts.

Right now I'm looking at Rapid Action Profits and Post Affiliate Pro 4.

From what I can see, RAP has instant commisions while Post Affiliate Pro has a more advanced system for multi-tier affiliate programs.

Other than that... what is your experience from any of those, and which is preferred by affiliates? Instant commisions or multi-tier?

Thanks for input!
#affiliate #post #pro #rap #software
  • Profile picture of the author unitminer
    Post Affiliate Pro is not just about unlimited number of tiers, you can setup easily multiple performance rewards for affiliates use private campaigns, split commissions between more affiliates, offer a lot of different types of banners, offer replicated websites for your affiliates or datafeeds, etc.

    I recommend you to compare PAP with RAP e.g. on website called affiliate software review (search in google)
    Also there are other affiliate software comparison websites if you want to be sure, which one of those two is the best option for you.

    In case you will decide for PAP, we can help you with installation for free. Also our live chat support agents are able to help you any time you will need help.
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3077932].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author MLamano
      untimer, can you please contact me personally concerning Post Affiliate Pro question? 505-639-5939, Mark
      Originally Posted by unitminer View Post

      Post Affiliate Pro is not just about unlimited number of tiers, you can setup easily multiple performance rewards for affiliates use private campaigns, split commissions between more affiliates, offer a lot of different types of banners, offer replicated websites for your affiliates or datafeeds, etc.

      I recommend you to compare PAP with RAP e.g. on website called affiliate software review (search in google)
      Also there are other affiliate software comparison websites if you want to be sure, which one of those two is the best option for you.

      In case you will decide for PAP, we can help you with installation for free. Also our live chat support agents are able to help you any time you will need help.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9377507].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author MLamano
        Thanks for getting back to me, I cannot PM as I haven't the required number of posts.

        Have question about functionality of PAP. Wife has gotten involved with a company that uses your software, but have some concerns.

        1. Their terms state if customer does not type her name in a filed "Rep Name" the will not be paid. Does PAP not automatically track each and every sale via cookies, easily providing the company the required info to appropriately credit the sale without a rep name?

        2. The company has the rep notifications in the back office under Profile disabled, can you provide ANY reason why they might do that other than to not report sales that indeed the buyer failed to enter the "required" Rep Name (but PAP tracked anyway) and then not pay the rep?

        Thanks very much, pretty new to IM and any insight you can provide is appreciated, just don't want my wife scammed!
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9387111].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author unitminer
          Originally Posted by MLamano View Post

          1. Their terms state if customer does not type her name in a filed "Rep Name" the will not be paid. Does PAP not automatically track each and every sale via cookies, easily providing the company the required info to appropriately credit the sale without a rep name?
          My Answer: PAP tracks it automatically even if the name of affiliate is not entered. I have never heard about integration, when affiliate name is required ... in such case you don't need affiliate software :-)

          Originally Posted by MLamano View Post

          2. The company has the rep notifications in the back office under Profile disabled, can you provide ANY reason why they might do that other than to not report sales that indeed the buyer failed to enter the "required" Rep Name (but PAP tracked anyway) and then not pay the rep?
          My Answer: I don't know why they disabled notifications. Normally affiliates get notification in real time as sales happen (with max delay about 15 minutes)

          But in general, we can not force the merchant to use our software in specific way. It is up to merchant how will be set terms and conditions of their affiliate program. The only way how you can change it is to stop promote their products. If enough affiliate will do it, I'm sure they will update their conditions.
          Signature
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9389365].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author DannyDarwin
    Thx, I found that review site!

    Couple of questions about Post Affiliate Pro.

    Affplanet.com is the hosted version of PAP, so if I get the hosted Professional plan ($39/month) I get pretty much what I need. But what is the "Full Integration" option for $199?

    Also, is it possible to run a multi-tier affiliate program and use Paypal as the payment processor? Some people say yes, some say no... If not, which payment processor do you recommend for multi-tier programs?

    And, final question... If I run the mass payments file from the software on a daily basis, it would be close to "instant commision". I'm asking, since I can't find anything about instant commission in the feature list of Post Affiliate Pro or Affplanet. Any plans to add instant commisions?

    Thx a lot!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3078745].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author unitminer
    Full Integration service means, that we will connect your site with Post Affiliate Pro for you.
    You will not need to care about click integration or sale integration, you will just tell us what you want to have in your affiliate program (e.g. structure of commissions, etc) and we will do it.

    Multitier affiliate program you can run with any edition of post affiliate pro - it doesn't matter if it is hosted or installed on your server.

    multi-tier commissions are independent on Payment processor, Paypal is fine.

    Instant commissions we don't have yet, it is not common feature, because it waste the money of affiliates. It is better to pay affiliates e.g. once a month, than affiliate doesn't loose money on transfer fees.
    During last 6 years, we had just 2 or 3 customers requesting this feature, therefore we didn't implement it yet (we have more than 15 000 installations).
    If you will want to pay development of this feature as custom development, we can give you a quote of such feature in January, when our developers will be back from holidays.
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3078822].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Sid Hale
      I beg to differ....

      Originally Posted by unitminer View Post

      multi-tier commissions are independent on Payment processor, Paypal is fine.
      Directly from the Paypal Acceptable Use Policy

      You may not use the PayPal service for activities that:
      <snip>
      3. relate to transactions that (a) show the personal information of third parties in violation of applicable law, (b) support pyramid or ponzi schemes, matrix programs, other "get rich quick" schemes or certain multi-level marketing programs,
      The last time I checked, MLM stands for multi-level marketing, and my personal experience backs up the fact that Paypal will, indeed, freeze your account if they find you promoting ANY MLM using their payment processing service.
      Signature

      Sid Hale
      Coming Soon... Rapid Action Profits (Pro)

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3078941].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author SageSound
      Originally Posted by unitminer View Post

      Instant commissions we don't have yet, it is not common feature, because it waste the money of affiliates. It is better to pay affiliates e.g. once a month, than affiliate doesn't loose money on transfer fees.
      RAP allows affiliates to be paid directly by customers. You do not touch their funds. Therefore, there is no "waste" to the affiliates. The PayPal fee is only paid once.

      But it goes further than that...

      If you live or have a business in America, starting today, 1/1/11, our dear "get the Government out of our lives" Republicans in Congress have refused (three times now) to repeal a crazy tax revenue measure THEY snuck into the HCRA that requires EVERYBODY to collect SSNs/TINs from everybody they pay commissions to AND file 1099's for them at the end of the year -- not just those who were paid $600 or more, but ANY commissions!

      So dear friends, if you're collecting 100% of your sales receipts from customers and then paying them out to affiliates later on, you'd better get your affiliates to send you W9 forms before you send them any more payments. Otherwise, you're setting yourself up for a very costly audit.

      If you think THAT is not wasting your time, money, and effort, over just having customers pay affiliates directly then by all means, have at it.

      Originally Posted by unitminer View Post

      In case there will be higher demand for such feature, we will be first, who will implement it.
      There's not more demand for it, IMO, because there is a widespread myth that refund requests are unmanageable using this model. This is a MYTH because it flies in the face of the experience hundreds of people who've been using this model since RAP was introduced 3+ years ago. In fact, RAP vendors tend to have FEWER refund requests overall than average Clickbank merchants, for example. RAP vendors I've asked typically see 2%-5% refund rates, whereas Clickbank is 8%-12%. With RAP, the customer needs to contact the seller directly. That in itself tends to discourage people from requesting refunds.

      BTW, the best way to reduce refund requests is do dial back the HYPE and OVER-ZEALOUS CLAIMS that are made on your sales page!

      Originally Posted by unitminer View Post

      Also in case commissions for single sale are low (or minimum payout limit is low), instant payments have no sense, because quite high percentage is going to transfer fees
      This statement is complete nonsense.

      PayPal charges about 3% commissions on all transactions. If you get paid by a customer, you're charged 3%. If you then pay your affiliates, THEY are charged 3% again, unless possibly if you use PayPal's Bulk Pay facility. (I've never used it, but I hear it may not charge fees.)

      Three percent is three percent. I doesn't matter if the payment is ten cents or $10,000. PayPal will take about 3% as their vig.

      -David
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3105994].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author DannyDarwin
    Well, would be interesting to get the facts from Paypal themself, thx for the input. I'll verify with Paypal directly.

    I could just use Alertpay or the merchant account at my offshore bank, it's just so much easier to manage it all in Paypal.

    Well, I thought affiliates liked instant commisions, but I get the point about losing money (transaction fee). Have to think about that...

    Great feedback, thx!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3079193].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Sid Hale
      Danny,

      Maybe I wasn't clear.
      Originally Posted by DannyDarwin View Post

      Well, would be interesting to get the facts from Paypal themself, thx for the input. I'll verify with Paypal directly.
      That was a quote pasted directly from the Paypal Acceptable Use Policy. It's available from the links at the bottom of the page when you are logged into your Paypal account.

      Well, I thought affiliates liked instant commisions, but I get the point about losing money (transaction fee). Have to think about that...
      Affiliates DO like instant commissions!

      ...and an affiliate pays fees anytime he/she is paid via Paypal, whether that payment occurs at the time of sale, or if it is delayed to arrive according to a merchant's payment schedule.

      Obviously, the real reason it isn't available in Post Affiliate Pro, is that they just haven't developed the ability to do it.
      Signature

      Sid Hale
      Coming Soon... Rapid Action Profits (Pro)

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3079778].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author unitminer
    Sid, we implement features, which is requesting a lot of customers, but this feature was not requested often - I know just very few affiliate programs, which have instant payments.

    In case there will be higher demand for such feature, we will be first, who will implement it.

    Also in case commissions for single sale are low (or minimum payout limit is low), instant payments have no sense, because quite high percentage is going to transfer fees


    BTW: you had good notice about limitation of Paypal for MLM - maybe it would be interesting to ask them, if forced matrix limited to specified size will not be accepted.
    I know, that a lot of merchants, which use multi tier commissions are using Paypal too.
    Maybe Paypal just don't check it in detail for each merchant or they accept any specific size of affiliate tree limited by forced matrix.
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3082959].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Sid Hale
      Hi,

      I know that there are very few that offer instant commissions

      Originally Posted by unitminer View Post

      Sid, we implement features, which is requesting a lot of customers, but this feature was not requested often - I know just very few affiliate programs, which have instant payments.

      In case there will be higher demand for such feature, we will be first, who will implement it.
      That doesn't mean that there is little demand - just less competition for those that DO offer it.

      Also in case commissions for single sale are low (or minimum payout limit is low), instant payments have no sense, because quite high percentage is going to transfer fees
      The way that instant commissions have been implemented with Rapid Action Profits and with most of the other popular affiliate management systems that offer this, the sales are rotated, so that the affiliate gets paid the full sale price on his/her second sale, regardless of the commission rate that has been set.

      For instance, if the selling price is $197, and the commission rate is 25% - the merchant gets the first sale, the affiliate gets the full $197 on his/her second sale, and then the merchant will get the 3rd and 4th sales. At that point, it's the affiliate's turn again.

      With the same example, but with a commission rate of 50%, the merchant still gets the first sale, and the affiliate gets the full $197 on his/her second sale. At that point, the affiliate has received their 50%, so the rotation begins again - merchant -> affiliate, merchant -> affiliate, etc.


      BTW: you had good notice about limitation of Paypal for MLM - maybe it would be interesting to ask them, if forced matrix limited to specified size will not be accepted.
      I know, that a lot of merchants, which use multi tier commissions are using Paypal too.
      Maybe Paypal just don't check it in detail for each merchant or they accept any specific size of affiliate tree limited by forced matrix.
      I have discussed this with Paypal. Just advertising 2nd tier commissions is enough to get an account frozen, IF it is advertised on the same page as the Paypal button/link is displayed (i.e. the sales page). Of course, if Paypal doesn't know about it, they can't take action, but if their link is used on a page that advertises multi (2 or more) levels of compensation, and they confirm that (i.e. an unhappy customer or a competitor reports the page to Paypal), they WILL freeze the account that the payment link goes to.
      Signature

      Sid Hale
      Coming Soon... Rapid Action Profits (Pro)

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3085269].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author iSoftware
    Originally Posted by DannyDarwin View Post

    I have to admit, I'm a bit confused by all the different affiliate networks, softwares and shopping carts.

    Right now I'm looking at Rapid Action Profits and Post Affiliate Pro 4.

    From what I can see, RAP has instant commisions while Post Affiliate Pro has a more advanced system for multi-tier affiliate programs.

    Other than that... what is your experience from any of those, and which is preferred by affiliates? Instant commisions or multi-tier?

    Thanks for input!
    RAP also has a very powerful feature, "equity sharing" which is very god for joint ventures. Not alot of people understand it as well.

    The thing is that for alot of new affiliates, instant commissions allow them to quickly reinvest their earnings so they can afford to buy traffic (which alot of new affiliates can't), outsource, etc...basically, if you play your cards right, you can really use instant commissions as a motivating factor that helps you stand out from other product owners on networks like clickbank or larger cpa networks...

    There's something very psychologically powerful when you see those payments coming in (I'm speaking as both an affiliate and a product owner!)
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3091723].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Werdin
    Banned
    [DELETED]
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9097463].message }}

Trending Topics