SENuke vs Magic Submitter vs SEO Link Robot vs ???

by Keith Price

Posted: 11 years ago 21 replies

PRODUCT REVIEWS

I know there are a lot of threads on these tools, but I could not find anything recent.

So, I'm wondering what the opinions are of the current versions of these tools?

Let's PRETEND they all cost the same. Which one is better, faster, most accurate and effective at getting your pages ranked?

Thanks.

#link #magic #robot #senuke #seo #submitter

amuro 11 years ago

You might want to try Content Marketer by Ross Goldberg. It allows you to submit articles, bookmarks, classified ads, directories, PDFs, press releases and videos.

Due to Google Penguin updates, I tend not to use automatic but rather semi-automatic tools so that I can build my links slowly and gradually.

Unlike those tools you mentioned, you just have to pay one-time $67 on single PC or $97 on up to 5 PCs and you get to use it for life.

2 years, this tool was sold as part of $997 Niche Omega webinar package by Deep Walia.

You can go here for more details.
- Thanks
- 1 reply
Signature
Get My FREE Course On Affiliate Marketing
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189748].message }}
- webgenco 10 years ago
  
  I have to agree with @amuro - with the Google updates, autosubmitter and link building tools have really decreased in effectiveness. I have used SENuke over the years (via a VPN) and had some very nice results. I paid month to month. yes it is expensive but if you get results, the ROI is there. But about a year also I stopped because I had some of the sites blacklisted by Google and also I think because of the newer captcha technology, the messages and links weren't getting through. SE nuke is an amazing software with brilliant founders, coders & support behind it and is fairly intuitive to use. It isn't their fault the way search engines work, etc. has dramatically changed.
  
  Thanks
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8990677].message }}
boosters 11 years ago

Current market was full with Senuke, MS, GSA and UD. While GSA is for advance users and rest are all the same but in my opinion if you are considering about going with SEO Tiers building than Tier 1 is must use manually rather than any automated tools than 2-3-4 tier you can ahead with the Automated tools.

Before you buy those tools you must know the how you can run it, the way they designed you should know each and everything of those tools from basic to advance course training such types of videos can help you or you can join ZontSEO for the Senuke and MS already have their free useful training.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189768].message }}
azguru 11 years ago

In my opinion, SeNuke Xcr will be the best option of the ones you mentioned. You may also want to look at Ultimate Demon
- Thanks
- 1 reply
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8192323].message }}
- NetSensei 11 years ago
  
  Hey Keith. I have used Magic Submitter, Back link Beast and Rankbuilder. I now use Rank builder. Magic Submitter is very good and I like it`s features a lot. But it is a bit more complex to learn. It took me a few weeks to get use to it, but once I did, I liked it`s functionality a lot. Backlink Beast by Mike Callen is a decent tool, but the problem I had with it was that everytime it updated it wouldn`t work and I had to send in a support ticket. They always took care of it, but for me, waiting a day or two was a nuisance.
  
  Rank builder is very much like Back link Beast, but it has always worked from the start and with every update. It is a bit simpler tool than Magic Submitter, but it is so easy to use and works well. It has all the same functionality as M.S., but M.S. has visual aids for setting up your link campaigns that make it easier to see exactly how your campaign will run. But functionality is the same.
  
  I have never used SeNuke, but the top marketers like and continue to use it. Much of the functionality of SeNuke is found in the tools I mentioned above, but SeNuke does do more, such as the old school automated back linking like forum profile submissions and others that the tools I mention above don`t do.
  
  But SeNuke is $147 a month, but Rank Builder and Magic Submitter are $67 a month. For the money, I would go with RB or MS.
  
  [ 1 ] Thanks
  
  Signature
  Video Marketing Is The Future Of Internet Marketing. Learn To Battle With The Big Boys.
  Video Marketing Grunt
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8194288].message }}
TrafficMystic 11 years ago

1) see what software will meet the needs of your seo startegy
2) see what software will meet your financial needs (seo link robot is the cheapest at $37)
- Thanks
Signature
[Link Alchemist] YOU ARE WASTING 80% Of Your SEO Efforts.. And you don't realise it!!!!
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8202369].message }}
Cassano 10 11 years ago

Article kevo is the best for me.
thy have free 7 day's trial.
- Thanks
Signature
DOWNLOAD YOUR FREE RESUME TEMPLATE
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8202560].message }}
TomBuck 11 years ago

I've tried magic submitter and think it was pretty good and was going to go back to it this week as I was away for a while and didn't want to pay the fees, from what you guys are saying its still one of the best SEO softwares.

I had heard of rank builder about a year ago but haven't heard anything since, is it still worth me researching? Or is the difference between RB and MS not worth using new software and the time needed to get use to it?
- [ 1 ] Thanks
- 1 reply
Signature
The Seo Oasis

SEO Company? - 8 Great ways to get new SEO Clients

High DA Links for sale
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8223519].message }}
- harivney 11 years ago
  
  Don't buy seo link robot. Web 2.0 properties are constantly changing their interface to disrupt robots and seo link robot has not been updated in months. Your lucky if you get a 15% success rate with seolr even when using good private proxies.
  
  I now use fcsnetworker and get a 90%+ success rate and they update their sw almost daily to fix and account reg issues due to web2.0 changes.
  
  [ 1 ] Thanks
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8251182].message }}
FlamingWolf 11 years ago

I used both Senuke and Magic Submitter.

Both of them are pretty good and constantly updated. They are very similar ( even if MS has a worse interface and it takes more time to learn ).

However, right now, I'm not using them anymore. The links you create with these tools have a lower quality and are very predictable by the search engine ( after all, if a lot of people do the same thing, search engine will catch up ).

In my experience, even without those links I can rank well.

What matters more are Social Media signal ( and that's what I'm focusing on now ).

One other thing: don't consider only the cost of the software: also consider that you'll have at least another cost ( the anti captcha services ), which doesn't seem much, but when you start creating hundreds of backlinks a day, you'll start spending more for the anti captcha than for the software.
- [ 1 ] Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8252040].message }}
stargazinc 11 years ago

hands down senuke, constant updates. The trick is to use your own templates or buy premade templates
- [ 1 ] Thanks
- 1 reply
Signature

"If you don't quit, you can't fail"

Success will follow.
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8253730].message }}
- BillyPilgrim 11 years ago
  
  GSA and FCS. Crushes the others. End of story.
  
  Thanks
  
  1 reply
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8261641].message }}
  
  Keith Price 11 years ago
  
  Originally Posted by BillyPilgrim
  
  GSA and FCS. Crushes the others. End of story.
  
  End or story?? Hah! It's not even the end of the movie trailer. Care to back up your claim?
  
  Thanks
  
  1 reply
  
  Signature
  
  Keith Price
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8261668].message }}
  
  fmolina2010 10 years ago
  
  Good informative discussion right here. It would be great if we can get more responses.
  
  I just bought Magic Submitter today and I can't wait to maximize its use. Really the main reason why I didn't get SEnuke XCR is the huge price difference BUT looking at it now the platform importer plus the designer where you can "teach" the software to post to other sites, this looks like a great deal for half the price of SEnuke XCR.
  
  Here's my take on the rest
  GSA - I haven't used this but from what I've read it's great for building subtier links and not for tier 1s? Someone out there would like to confirm this?
  
  Ultimate Demon - the word "demon" reminds me of my sleepless nights back then regretting the fact that I spent money on Bookmarking Demon
  
  Article Kevo - pretty decent considering its only a one-time payment. On the other hand, once you've used powerful softwares you would feel a bit "toned down" with what you can do with this.
  
  For now I'll try MS. That extra money for SEnuke is hurting my budget. We'll see what happens after a month.
  
  [ 1 ] Thanks
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8743908].message }}
vladinla 10 years ago

They are pretty cool.
SEnuke is quite easy to learn and very visual.
I do most of my campaigns on GSA though. That's a beast with very extensive set of options. Takes time to learn but it's worth it.
But make sure to use your own sites lists.
Good luck!
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8987178].message }}
Arian Surya 10 years ago

Magic Submitter actually is a GREAT software, We just need LITTLE BIT time to learn, and... Voila! MAGIC Happens!
- Thanks
- 1 reply
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9199549].message }}
- PuraVidaProfits 10 years ago
  
  GSA Search Engine Ranker + GSA Captcha Breaker + common sense link building structure= Complete Niche/Keyword Domination! Nuff said...
  
  Thanks
  
  Signature
  
  Chris...PuraVidaProfits
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9200336].message }}
ns17 9 years ago

Do these still work in 2015 and if yes please let me know which is the best as I have a MMO website and would like to build backlinks for it. thanks
- Thanks
Signature
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10097051].message }}
winnermarketing 9 years ago

After Google Penguin updates may be danger use a robot.

Magic submitter is a bit complicated but when you learn to manage it you have a lot of great features to use!
Senuke is easier to be used and the features are almost the same!
- [ 1 ] Thanks
Signature

Free Guide to Make Money Online [Now!]
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10097075].message }}
cypherslock 9 years ago

Yes it works. It depends on the user not the tool. If you have a solid strategy and don't blast the crap out of your site, AND use quality content, you can still use tools like MS.
- [ 1 ] Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10098197].message }}
tyronne78 9 years ago

Was a big fan of Magic Submitter back in the day. Can't go wrong with either MS or Senuke XCR though. Never used SEO Link Robot. Right now I'm using GSA Search Engine Ranker + GSA Captcha Breaker and have them both installed on a Virtual Private Server.
- Thanks
Signature
Visit my blog for FREE direct response marketing tips & tricks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10106920].message }}