Why you will always find it difficult to outsource your articles?

61 replies
Hi everybody,

After ghostwriting more than 2000 articles on more than 70 different topics, I think that I am best person to post some bitter home truths.
1] The attitude of the webmasters:
Many people are convinced that getting free samples from the ghostwriter is their divine right. They will never provide sufficient info. They may not pay even after completing the articles. Can these people really complaint about the unprofessional behavior of ghostwriters? I personally know people who collect free samples. Get them rewritten at cheap price. And then sell their PLR packs. If you want to write one sample as per the order of the webmaster in his area of interest, it does mean investing half an hour of the ghostwriter's time. I personally know ghostwriters who have spent 100 or more hours in writing free "samples". These people are really talented. But they leave this internet world in sheer disgust. Everybody asking for free samples and nobody giving the real paying orders.
2] The plight of the ghostwriters.
The ghostwriter is never secure. He feels that there will be someone else taking away his orders at lesser price. The end result? All the ghostwriters always take more work than they can handle. Is it a wonder that they can not churn out quality work? Is it a wonder that they can not keep the delivery schedules? Add to this unscheduled power cuts, internet server failures, rampant in third world countries like India. No doubt you have a recipe for a disaster. All this applies to all those so called cheap third world country writers. Why do people from third world country want to become ghostwriter?

In India minimum wage act expects a laborer to be paid $60 per MONTH wages. This means getting $300 per MONTH is most respectable middle class income that you can get. Everybody feels that writing 10 articles per day and charging one dollar per article will do the trick. There are lot many ghostwriting coaches who teach you to take an article from some ezine magazine and turn it in to "unique" articles. There is a great exodus of Indian people trying to become ghostwriters. There are lot many software products promising unique articles, spinned articles, rewritten articles. All these software products impress upon the young Indian ghostwriters that article writing is a MECHANICAL process. All aspiring ghostwriters are damn sure that you do NOT need either human creativity or the research for writing good quality unique articles. Well, every Tom, Dick and Harry wants to become a ghostwriter! When they see all those recycled ezine articles, they are sure that they are on the right path.

To add to this confusion, there are all those non-writer bum marketers who feel that they can become successful by outsourcing their articles by hiring this one dollar per article ghostwriters. For every one unsuccessful non-writer bum marketer leaving this IM world in disgust, you will find ten more entering in this IM world. So demand for this one dollar per article ghostwriters is ever increasing fast. The supply of one dollar per article ghostwriters is also matching it all the time.

3] What happens to all those creative, research oriented ghostwriters?

The good ghostwriters do not remain in this insecure field for long. After all they can make five times the money by using same articles if they do the affiliate marketing on their own efforts. There are lots many ways they can monetize their writing skills. Some learn these ways faster. Some take more time. But the end result is same. A good, creative, research oriented ghostwriter will not remain ghostwriter for a long time.

There will be some people asking the questions like "what about those content service providers/ teams?" I have an interesting email from one such content provider. When I asked him more info about the topic, he wrote. "I do not bother about what you write. My only condition is it should be relevant to the key word provided to you."

I rest my case.
Pratibha.
#articles #difficult #find #ghostwriting services #outsource #unique aritcles
  • Profile picture of the author seriousmny
    Thank you for the interesting perspective you have in ghostwriting. Outsourcing has been an industry that has flourished and will continue to do so. You are correct when you say that those providers that figure out they can make money themselves will move on from writing. Why would they continue to make others rich off of their own efforts when they could be doing it themselves?

    I offer services at a much higher price and I don't get many requests for work because there are many that want to pay just 1 to 5 dollars for an article. I am sticking to my guns and believe in my ability to deliver quality work. My time is valuable and I refuse to work for less. Quality always wins in the end. All my articles are original works.

    I must also say that I have seen the light as well. If the people don't want to pay for quality articles, then I will just take my articles and use them for myself. While I am sitting and waiting for orders, I will just write for myself. I will still profit.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[996235].message }}
  • {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[996240].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author seriousmny
      Originally Posted by Emmanuel Betinis View Post

      I'm confused...

      I never have a problem outsourcing my articles.
      Great :-) Where did you find the person that is writing for you? It seems like you have gotten what you need. I am hearing here in the forum more frequently that customers are not getting well-written articles, and becoming frustrated with finding good writers. This article somewhat explains why the problem is increasing from an individual that has first-hand information in the foreign article writing workforce.

      It is still great to know that there are others out here who are getting good service and are satisfied with the final product.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[996307].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Karen Connell
    Hi Pratibha,

    I beg to differ regarding asking for a sample. How does the purchaser know if the style of writing is right for them?

    I can write in a humourous, businesslike or conversational way.

    I failed to ask for a sample when I made my first venture into the IM world

    When I first started in IM, I put up a website and to save time, outsourced some article writing.

    In my ignorance I assumed the articles would be readable with correct spelling and grammar.

    Boy, was I wrong.

    I had not asked for a sample and I didn't go for the cheapest offer either!

    However, I paid up as promised, binned the articles and started writing my own.

    For me, this was the natural thing to do because, in the real world, I wrote for several newspapers for a number of years.

    Now I know that whatever has my name on is good stuff and of a high standard.

    My advice to anyone who can write, is to try your hand at it yourself before outsourcing.

    (I know - I'm shooting myself in the foot here!)

    If you do decide to outsource because of time constraints or you just hate writing, buy one sample article or ask for a sample of an article that the writer has already done - only after you have seen the end result can you judge if the content is up to your required standard.

    Regards

    Karen

    P.S. I don't think anyone finds it difficult to outsource, there are plenty of article writers offering their services. It's just not that easy to find 'good' writers that don't cost the earth!
    Signature

    Never Mistake Activity for Accomplishment

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[996268].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Bev Clement
    Karen I would totally disagree with you regarding writing samples.

    I will not normally write samples for anybody. I have samples available which is all they see.

    I have seen too many IMers asking for samples who have said this. "Post on elance, and ask the writers to give you a sample, then when you have all the free ones you need close the project and never hire anyone." That I believe is what the OP was referring to.

    If someone really wants a sample, then I would consider writing it, but never give it to them in txt format. I wouldn't pass on copyright to them, but add it to my samples.

    The advice about taking articles from EZA and other directories is being given now as a standard, and that I believe it bad advice. Using an article directory for your research material isn't the place to look, and then just rewriting it so it looks different isn't professional. I know too many people who are telling people to do this, I tell them to do other things.

    As far as whether a person will remain a ghostwriter, I disagree, because there are many of us who earn far more outside the IM niche.

    When you consider there are people who pay betwen $1 and $5 a word for an article you will see there are always places to write for higher rates.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[996381].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Karen Connell
      Originally Posted by Bev Clement View Post

      Karen I would totally disagree with you regarding writing samples.

      I will not normally write samples for anybody. I have samples available which is all they see.

      I have seen too many IMers asking for samples who have said this. "Post on elance, and ask the writers to give you a sample, then when you have all the free ones you need close the project and never hire anyone." That I believe is what the OP was referring to.

      If someone really wants a sample, then I would consider writing it, but never give it to them in txt format. I wouldn't pass on copyright to them, but add it to my samples.

      The advice about taking articles from EZA and other directories is being given now as a standard, and that I believe it bad advice. Using an article directory for your research material isn't the place to look, and then just rewriting it so it looks different isn't professional. I know too many people who are telling people to do this, I tell them to do other things.

      As far as whether a person will remain a ghostwriter, I disagree, because there are many of us who earn far more outside the IM niche.

      When you consider there are people who pay betwen $1 and $5 a word for an article you will see there are always places to write for higher rates.
      Hi Bev,

      Firstly, thanks for the PM - sorted!

      I absolutely agree when you say not to write a sample for a particular niche.

      As I said in the last paragraph of my post - buy a sample or ask to see something that the writer has already done.

      I think, perhaps, I didn't word that too well. I did mean something the writer already has in a PLR pack.

      Regards

      Karen
      Signature

      Never Mistake Activity for Accomplishment

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[996509].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author pratibha
        Hi, everybody
        I will post my detailed comments today night. I will like to clarify only one point. There are many freelance jobs websites where webmasters routinely ask for new samples in their area of interest. I have no objection in sending already written sample. Nor do I have issues about buying a sample article. The fact remains that many talented ghostwriters leave this IM world in frustration after doling out lot many free samples and investing lot of their time.
        Pratibha.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[997388].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Sandi Valentine
    I don't think that there's any inherent problem with wanting to see samples - a portfolio comes in quite handy for cases like this. However, I don't think that webmasters should expect each ghostwriter they interview to write a free original article on their specific niche as a a sample, and I'm seeing this more and more. I personally don't apply to jobs any longer that ask for a new original article - I've built up enough of a portfolio online that I can provide more than enough material for a potential client to evaluate my writing style.
    Signature
    http://sandililly.contently.com
    High Quality Content for .03/word. Order by PM.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[996397].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author billionareHuman
    Thanks for the info about the payment per month $300 per month is considered respectable there and that's really cheap to hire a full time writer then for the Western world.

    For ghostwriters I say forget about free sample articles. Any employer with money and who is willing to pay for good work will pay for samples, only employers with little money or are very tight (stingy) with their pay regardless of quality is not someone you want to be working for anyway.

    if you are a good writer why worry about other people stealing your jobs? As an employer of writers I found it so hard to find reliable quality people, if your consistent and your work is good that's all you need to do to be better than 70% (perhaps more) of the freelance writers out there. Consistent good work is rewarded with a reasonable employer
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[997397].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author parker3773
      Originally Posted by billionareHuman View Post

      Thanks for the info about the payment per month $300 per month is considered respectable there and that's really cheap to hire a full time writer then for the Western world.

      For ghostwriters I say forget about free sample articles. Any employer with money and who is willing to pay for good work will pay for samples, only employers with little money or are very tight (stingy) with their pay regardless of quality is not someone you want to be working for anyway.

      if you are a good writer why worry about other people stealing your jobs? As an employer of writers I found it so hard to find reliable quality people, if your consistent and your work is good that's all you need to do to be better than 70% (perhaps more) of the freelance writers out there. Consistent good work is rewarded with a reasonable employer
      I have never written a free article. I have enough of a portfolio that my work can be viewed there. I must be missing something but I have never even been asked and I write a lot of articles.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[997493].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author pratibha
        Hi Everybody,
        My sincere thanks to all the warriors posting their comments. Let me make some comments.
        billionareHuman,
        Just as there are 70% below average writers, there are more than 90% webmasters who are simply not trustworhty for remaining 30% above average writers in this part of world. The fact that $300 pm is respectable in this part of the world, was recognized by westerners more than 10 years ago. This is precisely the reason why Obamas can never stop outsourcing. But this very same grim economic reality has given birth to rampant exploitation of Indians by westerners at all levels.
        Will you be able to hire a full time writer for $300pm?
        Most certainly not!
        The below average 70% you will not hire. and above average 30% will never trust you!
        Lot many writers were promised $300pm & were promptly cheated at the end of the month. The above average writer learns quickly, that it is better to contact 5 webmasters and get cheated by 3 in whole month, rather than depend only on one and get cheated completely.
        If he is a really above average writer, he learns many other monetization methods within month or two and will no more require your
        monthly job at all !
        You will have to go on searching new monthly job seekers every month !
        RanD, You are perfectly right when you say that quality writers should not be afraid of stealing. But there can not be repeat orders as the webmasters are simply not trustworthy. If you contact 10 webmasters,7 will never pay you. Out of 3, 2 will promise you repeat orders in NEXT month. There will be only one providing you real repeat order! Under these circumstances writers feel extremely insecure. They simply overload themselves with lot of work which it is humanly not possible to complete.
        As far as so called best writers are concerned, they simply outsource their work to third world country writers. The quality checks will be avilable for a few reputed webmasters. They are not bothered if there is no repeat order from the small guy. The net result is you may not get good quality articles from so called best authors even after paying their fancy rates. These are the reasons you will always find it difficult to outsource your articles.
        Pratibha.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[997723].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author RanD
          Originally Posted by pratibha View Post


          RanD, You are perfectly right when you say that quality writers should not be afraid of stealing. But there can not be repeat orders as the webmasters are simply not trustworthy. If you contact 10 webmasters,7 will never pay you. Out of 3, 2 will promise you repeat orders in NEXT month. There will be only one providing you real repeat order! Under these circumstances writers feel extremely insecure. They simply overload themselves with lot of work which it is humanly not possible to complete.
          As far as so called best writers are concerned, they simply outsource their work to third world country writers. The quality checks will be avilable for a few reputed webmasters. They are not bothered if there is no repeat order from the small guy. The net result is you may not get good quality articles from so called best authors even after paying their fancy rates. These are the reasons you will always find it difficult to outsource your articles.
          Pratibha.
          I'm sorry, but you are just pulling those stats out of thin air, not to mention that you have just said that most of us here are not trustworthy. If you are having trouble getting paid, then maybe you should be working through sites like Elance or Rentacoder. I have to put the money into an escrow account before the writer even begins writing. I use these sites, and despite the title of your thread, I do not have a problem outsourcing articles.

          You may not get repeat orders from everyone that says they will give them. The reality is that many new webmasters don't succeed and give up. Those that do succeed can't necessarily afford to have regular monthly articles done until the money starts rolling in for them. You act like webmasters are rolling in cash, but most spend more than they ever take in. Life is as tough for webmasters as it is for writers. Good ones will succeed, bad ones will fail.

          The bottom line is that if you are a good writer and create a good rapport with the customer you will get repeat business.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[997948].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author pratibha
            hi RanD,
            " If you are a good writer and create good rapport with your customer, you will get repeat business." This is the point that I had stressed in my " The thrilling success story of an Indian ghostwriter"
            thread. I agree with your point of view. I know perfectly well, that webmasters are not rolling in cash. I also understand that any investment in articles should generate sufficient money. The statistics is certainly not out of thin air. But I was NOT writing about elance crowd at all. There are many freelance jobs websites where these things do take place. As far as elance and others are concerned, the third world countries writer find it very difficult to get the bids. The simple fact is there are lot many talented writers who find it difficult to reach good webmasters inspite of elance. Can we find some way out of this situation? You can read ben clements post in this thread. There is trend of getting free samples for nothing and then closing the bids. I can very well agree that 90% writers can be of below average level calibre. But I do not understand why you are shy to admit that there do exist lot many bad webmasters also.Thanks for posting your comment
            Pratibha
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998129].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author RanD
              Originally Posted by pratibha View Post

              ...But I do not understand why you are shy to admit that there do exist lot many bad webmasters also.
              Maybe you should read my post again. I never denied that there were bad webmasters. in fact, I said, like writers, "Good ones will succeed, bad ones will fail" . You made the blanket statement that "webmasters are simply not trustworthy", when the fact is, most are. If 7 out of 10 of your customers do not pay you, then you are doing something wrong, and you need to correct it. If you aren't using reputable sites that protect you like Elance and rentacoder (I'm sure that there are others) then you you only have yourself to blame if you are getting ripped off. It doesn't matter that there are other websites where bad things happen. You have the choice not to use them. If you are consistently putting yourself in a position where you are getting ripped off 7 out of 10 times, it's you that needs to do something differently, not us. Your numbers are out of thin air, because you are clearly not talking about the major sites, and they are not based on any real data.

              If people from third world countries are having trouble winning bids, there is a reason for it. Most likely, because they are not as talented as they or you think. I don't even see what that has to do with the title of this post. How does these writers not winning bids make it difficult for me to outsource my articles. Somebody is winning the bids. Likewise, writers getting screwed over because they are using some inferior site to do business does not affect my ability to outsource articles. I don't use those sites. I'm sure that if they don't protect the writer, then they probably they don't protect the buyer either. I wouldn't go near those sites.
              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998393].message }}
              • Profile picture of the author pratibha
                Hi RanD,
                Thanks for your detailed post. There are lot many threads complaining about not geting quality articles at affordable prices. I should have given a title as " Why you will always find it difficult to outsource your articles at affordable price inspite of existing large pool of talented writers ?".

                From my point of view, there are lot many good writers in third world countries who can offer their services at affordable price. Unfortunately they are forced to face bad webmasters. The existing so called good websites do have a prejudice regarding third world country writers.
                Out of 100 good writers trying to make it good, only one like me can survive. 99 are left behind. What is their problem? If we can solve it,then
                total number of good writers will increase dramatically and even non writer bum marketers will also be able to get quality articles at affordable rate.

                I started this thread with the hope that there will be some intelligent discussion on " how to define quality of the article". When I write for
                British people, they do use lot many phrases and terms differently as compared to Americans. So what is good english for British people, becomes grammatically in correct, bad english for Americans.

                From a person like Bev Clement, I expected some sort of standardization procedures. I have emails of clients telling me to improve my bad english.
                Every person had different idea and every person gave different advice.
                I dutifully obeyed each one as per his ideas for his articles. Same thing about writing style. I enjoy writing complex sentences. Some clients liked that style very much. Some told me to write simple sentences. I obeyed all of them.

                Unfortunately the warriors thought that I am calling them all as cheats and frauds. So there were personal attacks on me. What is the intention of this thread?

                There is lot of talent avilable. If they write in bad english, then let us define what is good english. Let there be some sorts of exams and certifications. If a writer has passed certain profeciency tests, then he
                should be taken seriously. May be these people need some polishing. May be these people need some orientation courses. It is not really difficult
                to write in passable english.

                Please remember that BPO industry flourished in India. Indians were taught to speak with american accents. They did learn it fast. But then there were courses where these accents were taught. You could get job
                once you have acquired american way of speaking.

                Indians understand english very well. There is only a question of providing them with necessary skills. I thought that there will be intelligent discussion on how to improve bad Indian english in to good englishand bring in a large force of writers in this industry. Ultimately this will bring in
                affordable quality writing in this industry.

                Mike thought I am promoting my article services! I have enough orders in my hand. I wrote that blog with only one intention. I wanted everybody to see the vast range of topics that I have covered. No comments on that by Mike! I wanted all new writers to understand what sorts of research they need to do, if at all they want to be successful. If I had not written that blog, then many warrior friends like Mike would have asked the question" If you have nothing to do with article writing, then why do you post this thread?" I am happy and well settled in forex and affiliate marketing. I do not need to market article writing services.

                But yes, if there are some good webmasters interested in getting affordable articles, I can help one of my writer friends. Initially there can be some problems of bad english, but eventually a long lasting relationship can be built using this medium. I am a small guy. Many warriors have helped me to reach here. Now it's my turn to do whatever I can. I am not in this for money. I need to help lot many non writer bum marketers and
                good at research and bad in english writer friends.

                Hope there will not be any more personal attacks on me.
                Pratibha.
                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998613].message }}
                • Profile picture of the author pratibha
                  Hi Mike, I read your latest post only after posting my comments. I agree with you completely that the article on the blog is of inferior quality. I was categorically told by the webmaster to stuff the article with keywords. I should have removed it, but forgot to do so. As my aim is certainly not that of promoting my article services, I did not pay attention to this aspect. As already clarified, my aim was to show the vast range of topics covered by me. As far as your personal attacks on me are concerned, that is your problem! If you are sure that I am a bad writer,then let it be. I have my testmonials and more than that my paypal accounts to prove the fact that I am successful ghostwriter. As already explained I do not do ghostwriting anymore for money. I do have my forex and affiliate marketing business.
                  Pratibha.
                  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998673].message }}
                • Profile picture of the author Bev Clement
                  [quote=pratibha;998613

                  I started this thread with the hope that there will be some intelligent discussion on " how to define quality of the article". When I write for
                  British people, they do use lot many phrases and terms differently as compared to Americans. So what is good english for British people, becomes grammatically in correct, bad english for Americans.

                  From a person like Bev Clement, I expected some sort of standardization procedures. I have emails of clients telling me to improve my bad english.

                  Pratibha.[/quote]

                  I have a lot to say about this, I have snipped the post to focus on a couple of points.

                  What do you mean from a person like me? You expected what? Since when did I write the standards for ghostwriters, and sorry, you were disappointed that I didn't read your mind and perform and give you what you thought was your right.

                  All the Indians we know learnt British English.

                  If you started this thread with a pre-determined idea then you didn't make it clear at all. Sorry, that we are not into reading peoples' minds.

                  This is why you have a problem writing if you can't decide what is good for the British and American market. We always ask clients which voice they want, and we have no problem moving from one language to another.

                  I have written for Big Mike, and I know he won't mind me saying this, as he is in the thread. The situation with Mike was exactly the same as with any client we had. Mike asked us to write on various topics, his brief was simple, he told us what he planned to do with the writing, and told us what keywords he was aiming for, and actually there was nothing else.... you see he didn't ask if we would research the niche, he expected and knew we would research the niche.

                  It doesn't matter whether we are writing a cheap article or a manuscript for a book, research is a given. Research is always a given, and we don't have any clients who ask will you research this topic and then write on it. It is assumed we would do that.

                  It is because of that, we were given the title from a well known person of being the best researcher online.

                  Finally, why should I give a standardised procedure? The simple truth is this, there isn't one. Each business is responsible for their own procedures and how I write isn't the same as you write.

                  My writing came as being a ghostwriter for a publishing house in London, and I wrote the complete manuscript for a book which is still available both online and offline.
                  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[999552].message }}
                  • Profile picture of the author Marhelper
                    Nothing personal but your grammar and sentence structure are left wanting. I don't even bother outsourcing to non-English speaking writers because I have to basically write the articles all over again. This of course defeats the purpose.
                    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[999579].message }}
                  • Profile picture of the author DeePower
                    You wrote: "When I write for British people, they do use lot many phrases and terms differently as compared to Americans. So what is good english for British people, becomes grammatically in correct, bad english for Americans."

                    If you had written that for me, I wouldn't pay for it.

                    Here is the corrected version, not rewritten, just corrected.

                    When I write for British people, they use many phrases and terms differently, as compared to Americans. So what is good English for British people becomes grammatically incorrect, bad English for Americans.

                    Do you see the improvement? Oh, and your statement isn't true. There are some differences in spelling. For example: The Brits use an "s" where we Yankees use a "z" in some words. But overall what is well written in the King's English would be considered well written by Americans.

                    For the record I do occasionally hire ghostwriters to write for my own websites but never for clients. I am the author of 3 commercially published books. I write for a living.

                    Dee
                    Signature
                    FREE Pump Up Your Profits With PLR
                    Are You a Writer? Then you need this FREE guide Convert Your Words to Ca$H Make Money Writing Online
                    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[999618].message }}
                    • Profile picture of the author drmani
                      So you're saying that web masters should pay for and train your so-called
                      writer friends? Why on earth would they do that? If they promote themselves
                      as writers, then they should be competent to begin with. Then they can focus
                      on developing a long-lasting relationship.
                      I *think* the point of the OP (from the perspective of representing a group
                      of writers from India) is that IF reasonably skilled writers can count
                      on the 'long-lasting relationship' happening, then they may more effectively
                      train themselves to improve their writing skills.

                      But when ghostwriters get scammed out of pay, or aren't hired to write repeat
                      articles, they get disillusioned and insecure, forcing themselves to take on
                      more work from multiple clients (to diversify risk) that they then cannot
                      complete on time, and thus dig themselves deeper into a hole.

                      There is room for debate and discussion on best practices for
                      non-English-as-native-language writers to learn and improve their skills.
                      Maybe that's what Bev was called upon to help derive (I'm guessing again!)

                      The Indian writing community that's being referred to will gladly write
                      for relatively low monthly income - as long as it can be guaranteed and
                      secure
                      (that's a cultural thing, btw!).

                      The audience is quick to learn, as the BPO industry proved recently in
                      great numbers.

                      Over 7 years or longer, I have toyed with the idea of setting up some
                      kind of training/coaching program to help writers like this - but haven't
                      come up with a way to access the right audience easily (or justify that
                      effort in contrast with others I'm engaged in, especially in light of
                      the price-competitiveness at this beginner/intermediate level work).

                      I've admired folks like Daniel Turner and Marc Lindsay of PLRpro who not
                      only planned something like it, but executed it brilliantly to create PLR
                      services that are thriving. By all accounts, it should be a good business
                      model for someone based in India to mimic - and maybe Pratibha (or someone
                      with similar skills and interests and committment) can try it.

                      All success
                      Dr.Mani
                      Signature
                      The Heart Bookstore | Buy a Book, Help a Child Live!
                      Email Marketing Tips | How To Focus Better | Time Management
                      GET YOUR FREE GUIDE: The 33:33 System
                      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[999642].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Bev Clement
          Originally Posted by pratibha View Post


          RanD, You are perfectly right when you say that quality writers should not be afraid of stealing. But there can not be repeat orders as the webmasters are simply not trustworthy. If you contact 10 webmasters,7 will never pay you. Out of 3, 2 will promise you repeat orders in NEXT month. There will be only one providing you real repeat order! Under these circumstances writers feel extremely insecure. They simply overload themselves with lot of work which it is humanly not possible to complete.
          As far as so called best writers are concerned, they simply outsource their work to third world country writers. The quality checks will be avilable for a few reputed webmasters. They are not bothered if there is no repeat order from the small guy. The net result is you may not get good quality articles from so called best authors even after paying their fancy rates. These are the reasons you will always find it difficult to outsource your articles.
          Pratibha.
          I would also disagree with you on these figures. In all my time writing, I have only had 2 people who didn't want to pay, and when I told them I was selling the work, they suddenly decided to pay.

          I have never outsourced my writing to a third world country writer. I have in the past weeks hired writers, and our clients know which writer is doing their work. But, none of our writers are in Third World Countries.

          The main reason people find it hard to outsource their articles, is many good writers know there are better ways to earn an income than being paid $10 or less for an article.

          I'm about to write an article which is 2,000 words, and no it isn't a report but an article, very short story, and the pay is $2,000 for that one article.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998207].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RanD
    I can understand your frustration, but there are always two sides to the story.

    I understand asking for sample articles, even to the point of asking for a specific sample. I have hire writers who's writing did not remotely resemble the sample I had been given. I have also paid top dollar to an author, only to find that they could not follow instructions, meet deadlines, and were extremely difficult to work with.

    I understand the frustration of some people expecting great articles for just a few dollars each. I think they will eventually understand that you get what you pay for.....to a point, anyway. Face it, some writer think far more highly of their own abilities (and charge more) than they should. I have found some of the best writers to have more reasonable prices, and believe me, they will get repeat business. If you are a good writer with reasonable prices, there should be no concern about other writers stealing your jobs.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[997444].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JayXtreme
    I have two girls that I use all the time for my outsourced content. University level writing..

    Can't be bad. Sure, I pay them a good English profit, no third world rates here.... but it's more than worth it.

    Treat your writers like GOLD people..

    Peace

    Jay
    Signature

    Bare Murkage.........

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998216].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
      Banned
      [DELETED]
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998513].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author JayXtreme
        Originally Posted by alexa_s View Post

        People will talk!
        Typical... :rolleyes:
        Signature

        Bare Murkage.........

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1000239].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Damien Roche
    Guess it's the good businessmen and women who keep the *actual* ghost writers alive

    Fact is, if you're selling shitty articles for $1 then you deserve the company of some wannabe entrepreneur. By the same token, if you are some wannabe entrepreneur and are only willing to pay $1 for an article, you deserve the company of a shitty article writer.

    I wouldn't even think about paying someone a $1 for an article, that's ridiculous. I expect quality, researched content, with optimum keyword density. You get what you pay for, and it's never been clearer than when you hire someone to write an article, or batch of articles.
    Signature
    >> Seasoned Web Developer (CSS, JavaScript, PHP, Ruby) <<
    Available for Fixed Fee Projects and Hourly ($40/hr)
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998240].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author pratibha
      Hi Big Mike,
      Thanks for your comments.
      I request everybody to read my thread" The thrilling success story of an Indian ghostwriter"

      I am not interested in promoting my article writing service. I am not interested in making money in article writing services. I am trying to use my article writing skill to build new and lasting relationships. For me it is simply a means of networking with like minded people.

      As far as quality of my writing is concerned, there are no definite parameters of quality in article writing world. This is totally subjective issue. There is no standardization of quality. Some of my clients had insisted that I must use simple sentences. Some had insisted that I should use complex sentences. I do have testimoinials of my clients. But then I am not here to promote my writing services. I know from my experience of writing more than 2000 articles, that perceptions of quality do change a lot from person to person. If you feel that I am a bad writer, then it does not make any difference to me.

      Whatever statistics I have given is not applicable to my article writing career. I have lot many writer friends. It is based on their experiences.
      I have never said that there is a world wide conspiracy of stealing my work. I was only trying to give the mind set of a ghostwriter and was trying to analyse why he takes on the sorts of jobs, he can not complete.

      There was absolutely nothing personal in all this thread. I was trying to analyse mind set of the general Indian ghostwriter. It seems lot many people do not want to see the reality in this world.
      I am thankful to you, Mike, for taking time to visit my blog and commenting on the quality of my bad english. The strange fact is NO body wants to comment on my research ability! It seems that in this part of the world only good english is all that matters and research has absolutely no value! If your idea of a good article is nicely written article without any research, then be it! My clients always felt that well researched articles written in passable english are infinitely better than nicely written articles without research. This is the reason why I have become successful as a ghostwriter and have diversified in different streams of income on net.

      Finally I will request all the warriors not to take this thread as my personal problem.

      There is a good talent of pool in third world countries. There are good webmasters in western world. Can there be some way of matching these two groups? I feel that If there is solution ,then there will not be any more problem of finding good writers at affordable prices.
      Pratibha.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998381].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Hamish Jones
        Originally Posted by pratibha View Post

        As far as quality of my writing is concerned, there are no definite parameters of quality in article writing world. This is totally subjective issue. There is no standardization of quality. Some of my clients had insisted that I must use simple sentences. Some had insisted that I should use complex sentences. I do have testimoinials of my clients. But then I am not here to promote my writing services. I know from my experience of writing more than 2000 articles, that perceptions of quality do change a lot from person to person. If you feel that I am a bad writer, then it does not make any difference to me.

        "There is no standardization of quality."

        I would have thought correct grammar and syntax would be a part of what most purchasers would consider a 'quality' article.
        Signature
        Best Business Deals - The World's Most Customer Focused Telecommunications Company. Servicing Customers in Australia, Canada and the USA.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998534].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Droopy Dawg
    My only problem has been turn-around time... but the quality of the articles that have been written for me has been excellent... so I just suck it up and deal with it... for now.
    Signature


    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[998688].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Paul Hancox
    Hi Pratibha

    I'm just putting the finishing touches to a report that is going to help writers (and ghostwriters) to earn more money from their writing. (I'm just trying to figure out a name for the report right now.)

    One of the things I've found is that many writers (especially "500 word article" writers) do not know how to distinguish themselves from other writers in the first place, and then they don't know how to SELL THEMSELVES.

    Your article makes clear that there will always be $1 article writers around, for as long as people in India and other countries think that is a good wage (which I guess it is, relative to others in their country).

    But it's a shame, because if the $1 article writer actually bothered to develop specific SKILLS (beyond the basic writing skills such as grammar and spelling) that could help their clients get more of what they really wanted (i.e. money, traffic, sales, subscribers), they could easily be charging $10 or more per article and still have more than enough work!

    What's also a shame is that many good writers here think that these $1 writers are actually competition. Well, if they were really good at what they did, they wouldn't be charging $1 an article... regardless of their cost of living.

    After all, why charge $1, when $2 for the same amount of work will double their income? And why charge $2, when $4 will double it again?

    The key for them is about securing and keeping clients. But if they're good, they will have clients regardless of whether they're charging $1, or $10 or $30... as long as they "sell the difference" to their clients, and demonstrate why their writing delivers value for money.

    So the GOOD writer will quickly discover they can put their prices up and still have more than enough clients.

    While the AVERAGE or POOR writer will always need to rely on keeping prices low.

    That's why I won't be using $1 writers any time soon. Regardless of whether it's actually true or not, if they're pricing themselves at $1, it implies to me they do not feel they are good enough to charge $5 or $10... which means they probably aren't good enough.

    OR... and this is just as likely... they are good, but just don't know how to sell themselves and their writing service... which is why I'm writing my report ... to help the good ones earn more and be able to sell themselves, so their clients are happy to use them at $2, $5, or $10 an article and beyond.



    Signature
    PresellContent.com - How to sell without "selling"
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[999738].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BeauFla
    As many have already said there are good and bad GWs and WMs. it is very hard to find the good ones. IMHO when you find a good writer you should treat them well.

    I have three writers I work with and loath the day when one leaves. Fisnding a GOOD writer can be very time consuming.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[999902].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Phil
    Thanks for opening an interesting discussion, Pratibha.

    I used to do quite a lot of articles, ghostwriting and PLR; but haven't for
    some time now. I was fortunate to work with some good Warriors who paid
    decent prices for decent work (Mike included). And I never had to compete
    on price.

    But there are a lot of people out there only prepared to pay the bare minimum,
    and there will always be others ready to answer that need. And in answering that
    need, tactics such that you descibe have become so commonplace that there appears
    to be a whole swathe of writers and 'marketers' who have no idea how to research
    and write their own material. Or who do not understand that good quality work
    takes longer than 30 mins to create.

    The fact is that the Warrior forum must take some time to reflect on that too -
    since the very ebooks, reports and software that promote 'cribbing', 'rehashing' and
    virtual copyright theft continue to appear with dull regularity in the WSO forum.
    Often by reputable names which seem to help make such tactics acceptable.
    How many times do we see new software and ebooks promoted there which tell
    us to search Ezine Articles as research and tell us "it's not copying because we are
    going to change it..."?

    The truth here is that no matter how many times a mistake is repeated, it never
    ceases to be a mistake. And no matter how glossy those reports and rewriting
    applications appear, they are still repeating that basic mistake: trash in, trash out
    - or, just because you changed a few words, it doesn't mean you've created
    something original (or good).

    If a writer's sole aim, and test of ability, is to pass a copyscape test, then they
    are writing only in the sparest of senses. Yet so often this is declared as the
    test of uniqueness.

    Phil
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1000031].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author lakshaybehl
    Pratibha,

    Some of your points are good, some not. Simple as that. Most of what I was about to say has been said by Michelis. And he has mainly put things into perspective here. Many thanks, Big Boy.

    But keep on the hard work... You shall be rewarded.

    -Lakshay
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1000259].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Bev Clement
    Dr. Mani, I have no idea what the OP really expected, because he didn't make it clear at all.

    What I don't understand is why there is a problem about getting or not getting repeat work?

    We don't do a huge amount of repeat work, but that doesn't mean we get depressed because of it.

    By nature some projects are always going to be one-offs.

    We have also worked with some Indians who want to be writers, and it is possible to teach them, but, and this is a big but, their ego has to be removed from the package. We have travelled and worked in India, so have first hand experience, and you will find that many do what the OP did, tell us about his achievements. When starting out writing it doesn't matter what you did or didn't do in the past because you are starting on a level playing field with other writers.

    I could say I worked for one of the top firm of accountants, KPMG but what is the relevance of that to me writing? None. It is totally irrelevant.

    The problem is the same regardless of where a person lives, many have got into writing cheap articles, they know they can't earn enough putting in hours and hours of research, so they make it a basic article. Then they complain it is the buyers fault, which isn't the truth. The buyer might at times be at fault, but the reality is, if a person can't decide how to make a profit from their work, they need to take a fresh look at their business model.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1000330].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Kael41
    Good points Bev, and on the opposite side of the coin our most lucrative contracts are those that come by way of referral AND by repeat work. Funny enough, one of my larger contracted clients wants nothing BUT U.K based writers.

    It all comes down to giving the client what they want and want they expect. Undersell and overproduce, while under deadline
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1000367].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RanD
    But when ghostwriters get scammed out of pay, or aren't hired to write repeat
    articles, they get disillusioned and insecure, forcing themselves to take on
    more work from multiple clients (to diversify risk) that they then cannot
    complete on time, and thus dig themselves deeper into a hole.
    But what is the real problem there? If they get scammed, they should be using sites that offer them more protection. That is a simple solution....by itself, anyway. If the real problem is that they aren't winning bids or getting repeat business, you have to explore why that is. My guess is that, for whatever reason, their writing is not high enough quality. Is it being suggested that we accept poorer quality articles so that writers in India feel better about themselves?

    Unfortunately they are forced to face bad webmasters. The existing so called good websites do have a prejudice regarding third world country writers.
    That is just nonsense. The sites do not have a prejudice, but the buyer has the option to not use writers from anywhere they choose. It is sounding more and more like we are dealing with mediocre writers that can't win good bids and therefore resort to having to deal with bad webmasters. That is not our problem.

    The strange fact is NO body wants to comment on my research ability! It seems that in this part of the world only good english is all that matters and research has absolutely no value! If your idea of a good article is nicely written article without any research, then be it! My clients always felt that well researched articles written in passable english are infinitely better than nicely written articles without research
    And there is part of the problem. You feel that your great research ability should outweigh the problems with your writing. It doesn't. I can do research, and am very good at it. What I can't do is write eloquently. That is why I hire a writer. If you can't write eloquently, then I can't use you. "Passable English" is not acceptable. I can write "passable English" myself. Ultimately, a good writer should be a good researcher AND a good writer. That is what the better webmasters are looking for. If you feel that it is OK to sit back and rely on research alone, then you will always lose out on bids from those who can do it better.

    What is the solution to your/their problem? I don't know. I can only say that if the problem is a lack of good English writing skills, then something needs to be done to improve that skill. That is not our responsibility to figure out. If someone really wants to write articles for the English speaking market then they will need to do whatever it takes to improve their English writing skills. It's as simple as that.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1000605].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author drmani
      The simple fact is that those who do not focus on developing their writing
      skills first will find it a difficult market to work in and rightfully so.
      Absolutely agree with you, Mike.

      Yet there's a reason I put cultural thing in my post. As a community,
      as far as it's possible to generalize a group that spans 1 billion people,
      Indians lack the entrepreneurial streak I've noticed in certain other cultures/
      countries. It's changing - but not very fast. It's why there's so much
      competition for coding/programming JOBS at software companies, but relatively
      few start-ups in the same space.

      And as 'risk-taking/managing' is inherent to being an entrepreneur, there's a
      mismatch between "what we want" and "what we find"!

      would you advertise for OB/GYN clients to test the market and then go get
      trained/board certified if it proved worthwhile?
      You can DO that????!!!

      If yes, absolutely yes! But I can't - and that's why I took a chance.

      If only you knew how big a risk it was going after a specialty like mine
      that did not exist in India at the time I chose to take it!

      (Hmm... If only *I* had known, maybe I wouldn't have )

      All success
      Dr.Mani

      P.S. - Bev, nice points
      Signature
      The Heart Bookstore | Buy a Book, Help a Child Live!
      Email Marketing Tips | How To Focus Better | Time Management
      GET YOUR FREE GUIDE: The 33:33 System
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1001132].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author pratibha
        hi everybody,

        Thanks for your contributions here. Dr Mani has made everything pretty clear here. I agree with Dr Mani completely. Well, I should have written that way.

        I have already made it clear that I never had problems of getting business as ghostwriter myself. I was writing for the group of Indian writer community. I am sorry that I did not make it clear from the start. I told Mike not to attack me personally for the simple reason that I was representing a group of writers from India. My stats were never from the thin air. They were based on the experiences of this group. I wanted all the contributors to concentrate on the community, but failed to express myself very well. It was my mistake.
        I apologize to you all.

        Is it the duty of the webmasters to provide the training? Of course, if it is going to make economic sense! Whether it is BPO/software or any other industry, Americans did provide training to Indians and both the Indians and Americans prospered a lot. Same thing is possible here.

        Indians were always ridiculed and made fun of in those initial days of BPO/software. It is natural that many Americans felt that Indians will not be able to give quality service. But in the end both parties prospered.

        As there were some personal attacks on my bad English, I will like to clarify some points.

        When I started my ghostwriting career I was fully aware of the fact that my English is bad. I always told the webmasters that research is my strong point. On that basis I was selected. May be Mike would have rejected me. But it would not have mattered. For every 7 Mikes rejecting me on the basis of my bad English, there were three other Toms ready to give me a chance on the basis of my strong research background

        In the next step, I myself took some grammar lessons. But as that was insufficient, I hired an Indian editor. In the next step I hired British editor. Of course there would be some webmasters making fun of my Indian bad English. I REJECTED THEM.

        For all the webmasters out there I will tell only one point. It is possible to get affordable good articles from Indians. In future there would be lot many webmasters providing training to Indians to get affordable quality content. There would be lot many Bev Clements providing coaching exclusively designed for Indians writers.

        After nearly 16 months of ghostwriting, I had decided to stop it completely, as I had two different streams of income providing me lot of economic stability. The ghostwriting business was taking more time.

        I had understood that for Indian people, ghostwriting was a good way of getting economically well settled. I had first hand experience of all the problems involved. I wanted to bridge the gap between webmasters who need good articles at affordable rates and Indians who could provide that service. Building lasting relationships through ghostwriting was an idea born out of this thinking.



        First point, I am not doing this for money. I want to help all those small guys struggling to make both ends. There are lot many webmasters with shoe string budgets; they will get good articles at affordable rate by the Indians writers who are also struggling to make both ends meet. I am trying to make it possible for the small webmaster to communicate with small ghostwriter. They will help each other and grow a long term relationship. This is my way of saying thanks to warriors like DR Mani who had helped me selflessly in my initial days.

        In one of the proposed models of co operation, writer will be involved in the project as a whole. The quality of the articles will be determined by the economic results it produces. If the average Joe feels comfortable with good content written in passable English and buys the product itself, then it's OK.

        This is an experiment and not a business venture. Of course I will be investing some money and TIME in this venture. Dr Mani is perfectly right when he says that Indians lack entrepreneurial spirit. If an Indian writer sees what sorts of economic results his writing is producing, then he will become an entrepreneur himself, just like me. In affiliate marketing, it was clearly proved to me that my articles [whatever their quality was] produced nearly eight times what I would have got by ghostwriting them. Naturally I left ghostwriting and moved into affiliate marketing. I have been emphasizing on the fact that good ghostwriters find different means of monetizing their content and then naturally stop writing for others.

        Coming back to my experiment, I will say that there are few like minded persons like me. We have all come together. We are discussing and evolving different models. The main idea is that a small webmaster and a small ghostwriter should help each other. My blog will be meeting place for these guys. There are bound to be lot many difficulties. But my ghostwriting experience has taught me how to overcome them. I will clarify only the term" long lasting relationship" This is not necessarily in the monetary sense. If the small guys helping each other decide to stay together for monetary reasons, they are most welcome. But basic idea is to provide help until they become self sufficient. If the small guy feels now he is in a position of affording highly paid writers, it's OK! If the writer feels that he has become an entrepreneur and does not want to ghostwrite anymore, it's OK. Both of them can tread their individual paths.

        Dr Mani had sent me his e-books free of charge in my initial days. He had encouraged me tremendously by sending PMs. We had never contacted each other after that incident. He had forgotten me completely. When I wrote my thread "The thrilling success story of an Indian ghostwriter", he congratulated me. Then I reminded him of the past incident.

        Even if Dr Mani had forgotten me completely, for me that was and is "long lasting relationship". He had touched my life and changed it profoundly. The aim of blog is simple. I hope to change lives of a few small guys. I have decided that ghostwriting is the best medium to do so.

        My first thread in warrior forum was way back in 2007 introducing me as a new member.

        My second thread was in 2009 after I had become successful as a ghostwriter, aptly titled as "The thrilling success story of an Indian ghostwriter"

        My third thread was this one. I had lot many ideas, concepts, going through my mind when I started this thread. There was lot of confusion in my mind also. All these things reflect very well in this thread. I never expected the tremendous response and the diverse opinions expressed in these comments. I never thought that so many people will take notice of this thread. I am thankful to you all.


        My fourth thread will be about the results of experiment called as "Building relationships through ghostwriting "in 2011. I will try my level best to make this experiment successful.

        Thank you everybody.

        Pratibha.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1001576].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Bev Clement
          Originally Posted by pratibha View Post


          Is it the duty of the webmasters to provide the training? Of course, if it is going to make economic sense! Whether it is BPO/software or any other industry, Americans did provide training to Indians and both the Indians and Americans prospered a lot. Same thing is possible here.
          No it doesn't make economic sense, why do you think it is the duty of the webmaster to pay for your or your friends' training. It is one thing to say something is possible, totally different to say it is their duty. Webmasters use ghostwriters because of time saved, because they are not writers and lots of other reasons. Why should a non-writer have to train a writer.


          For all the webmasters out there I will tell only one point. It is possible to get affordable good articles from Indians. In future there would be lot many webmasters providing training to Indians to get affordable quality content. There would be lot many Bev Clements providing coaching exclusively designed for Indians writers.
          If you are going to quote me, or use me as an example to prove a point, then please get your facts correct. You say research is your strong point. You spell my name incorrectly, you say I provide coaching exclusively designed for Indian writers. Where do you get that information from? I wasn't aware I have coaching exclusively designed for Indian writers. Yes, I have and do coach some Indians, but the program you have no idea about, so research is a strong point, then research, don't make wild claims which you can't back up.


          I had understood that for Indian people, ghostwriting was a good way of getting economically well settled. I had first hand experience of all the problems involved. I wanted to bridge the gap between webmasters who need good articles at affordable rates and Indians who could provide that service. Building lasting relationships through ghostwriting was an idea born out of this thinking.
          So your basis of all this is for Indians to use webmasters to get their finances sorted. Once they have done that, then chuck the webmaster because you can make more in affiliate marketing. Long term relationships don't get built that way.

          If you want to teach Indians, then why not affiliate marketing which is what you are saying you now do.

          In one of the proposed models of co operation, writer will be involved in the project as a whole. The quality of the articles will be determined by the economic results it produces. If the average Joe feels comfortable with good content written in passable English and buys the product itself, then it's OK.


          And this is why you will never move from being a cheap article writer into a ghostwriter. If you were able to do that, then you would make more writing than affiliate market. Passable English isn't wanted, even by webmaster on a low budget.


          Ghostwriters can make a lot of money writing for others. You say you make 8 x what you could for writing an article. As you charge $6 per article that means $48 for every article written. I get that for a single ghostwritten article.

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1001852].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author drmani
            Ghostwriters can make a lot of money writing for others.
            You say you make 8 x what you could for writing an article. As
            you charge $6 per article that means $48 for every article
            written. I get that for a single ghostwritten article.
            GREAT point, Bev.

            One I made the central theme of a report I wrote in 2007, with
            the cliched title "The Death of $5 Article Writing".

            It's a free direct download here. It has one affiliate link (but
            that's for a domain that's no longer active, so I guess it won't
            come across as self-promotional in any way - it is not meant to!)

            Writer alert: If you charge $5 per article or less, you'll find
            some of the sentiments I express in it harsh, even cruel!

            All success
            Dr.Mani
            Signature
            The Heart Bookstore | Buy a Book, Help a Child Live!
            Email Marketing Tips | How To Focus Better | Time Management
            GET YOUR FREE GUIDE: The 33:33 System
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002101].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author pratibha
              Hi Bev,
              I am really sorry that there is so much confusion about what I want to clarify.

              I have never said that it is the duty of the webmaster to provide training for
              Indians. I personally feel that there is lot of profit for businessmen if they decide to do so.
              I gave the example of BPO/software industry. When first ever time these industries started, many Americans were saying that this is not going to be profitable. But few Americans, who dared to think opposite, proved them all wrong. If you personally feel that this idea is unprofitable, it is OK.

              I have never said that you take coaching classes exclusively for Indians. I was just describing future scenario. If in future webmasters decide to train Indians, then you will see lot many reputed coaches like Bev Clement [The reason why I spelled it Bev Clements] taking exclusive coaching classes for Indians. What does it mean? It means that in future the training will be a profitable business, if webmasters decide to enter in this field. I personally know one company which is training Indians.

              I have already made it clear that I am not interested in becoming a ghostwriter at all.
              I will NEVER be able to make the kind of money that you can make in ghostwriting at this age. If somebody wants to remain a ghostwriter for all of his life, who am I to say no to him? My idea is to help a small guy free of charge only initially. Once he has established himself it is up to him/her, what to do in future. If a person wants to continue his ghost writing there after, he should do it on his own. If the person is interested in affiliate marketing, then I will help him initially only. There after it is his choice. I will never FORCE a person to remain with me forever. If the person feels that he wants to continue with me, it is alright

              I feel that small guys need help only initially. Once they have achieved particular turnover, they want to move on their own. I never had any monetary transaction with Dr Mani. But I do feel that I have long lasting relationship with him. The reason is simple. He changed my life. That gives me infinite moral support and courage. In Indian culture it is easy to understand this type of long lasting relationship.

              I must add one more point to this thread.

              I am 60 years old man. In our culture and religion, you are supposed to take "sanyas" at this stage. This means you are supposed to concentrate on spiritual matters and should not get involved in materialistic world. I have fulfilled all my family responsibilities.
              My needs are few. I get more money than I need. I am happy and content.

              For me, helping small guys is way of serving god. In next few months I will be attending seminars with a warrior friend all over India. The topic is "how IM can help charities" This will be possible only if my health allows me to do so. And yes, that warrior is NOT Dr Mani. If all the people here feel that I am cheap ghostwriter, it is OK. I have testimonials and paypal accounts to prove otherwise. But this thread is not about me. It is about third world community writers and in what ways I can help them to get stabilized in their IM journey.
              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002228].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author johnpaulgrant
    I think writing is one of the hardest areas to please people with .. as people have different writing styles and expect their ghost writer to adapt to their style immediately!

    Always best to get sample work
    Signature

    I am an expert in outsourcing to The Philippines and have been working with Filipino virtual assistants for more than 5 years. I am the co-founder of RemoteWorkMate (VA management service) and RemoteStaffRecruit (VA recruitment service) Check out my blog >>>LifeStyleBusinessDesign<<<!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1001507].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Paul Hancox
    Hi Dr.Mani

    "The Death Of $5 Article Writing". I think I will make that REQUIRED READING for readers of my new report on how to earning more from their writing, that was superb!

    I'd like to put that report on my domain... just in case it disappears from yours ... is this OK? The permission was a bit vague, I can "share it with a friend", but can I do so from my own domain?

    Either way, I say again... that should be REQUIRED READING both for every article marketer, and for anyone thinking of buying articles.
    Signature
    PresellContent.com - How to sell without "selling"
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002178].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Allurre
    Actually, most ghostwriters WRITE because that's their strength.

    When it comes to marketing, that's where they struggle. Internet marketing is not just about fueling content; it requires high involvement in various field to start with.

    Most flounder, quit, and return back to ghostwritng solely.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002245].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author pratibha
      Hi Allurre,
      You are perfectly right in observing that ghostwriters can not market well.
      If you are a good marketer, then it is easy to become an entrepreneur. There is MORE money if you become an entrepreneur after ghostwriting for sometime. Ghostwriting teaches you lot many things about keyword research, market trends, importance of good content in your IM business. It helps a lot when you buy content as IM businessman. Those who do not have marketing skills will have ghostwriting "jobs". Those who will fail as marketers will be forced to remain ghostwriters for ever. Of course there will be exceptionally talented few entrepreneurs who can rightly become great entrepreneurs in ghostwriting business itself.
      Pratibha
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002278].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author pratibha
        .
        Hi Dr Mani,
        A highly creative person like you is capable of producing one single article worth $350. But how many writers will be able to do same? Very few indeed!
        The majority of ghostwriters can produce $5 a piece articles only.

        What can they do?

        They can repeat $6x8=48 formula for 8 times and can make $384

        The most important fact here is even a cheap ghostwriter can make $350, just as highly creative writer can, in IM. If the highly creative writer has his high creativity to help him make money, the cheap ghostwriter has wonderful leverage of IM to help him.

        As I am branded by great people like BEV as a cheap ghostwriter, let us see what dumb cheap ghostwriters like me can do.

        Step1 Learn $6x8=48 formula first. Start making more money.

        Step no 2. Now repeat this formula and achieve economic stability.

        Step3 Stop writing yourself. Get $5 articles written by other ghostwriters.

        Why will anybody remain ghostwriter for ever?

        An IMer will like to hire many more ghostwriters and increase his income, rather than invest time and energy in writing $350 a piece articles.

        When ghostwriters are afraid of entering this IM world, they will remain $5 a piece for ever.

        I always tell people that you need not be highly talented to be successful. There are people making $1000 per website adsense income. But there are also people making only one dollar per day per website and have 35 websites to reach that target of $1000PM.

        Once you have understood how to leverage, you automatically learn different money making methods.

        It is great that DR Mani had made $350 per article.

        Ask him a simple question. Is he still writing articles for others? If not, why not?

        The simple answer will be he has diversified in so many internet marketing methods that he will no more find time to do so.

        Whether you are a great writer like Dr Mani or a dumb writer like me, you stop writing for others once you have understood the leverage of internet marketing.

        Is there any hope for all those $5 a piece writers who can not understand the leverage of internet marketing?

        It seems that there is lot many coaches in internet marketing field who can make a dumb cheap ghostwriter, a highly creative writer like DR Mani. I have never attended any such coaching. I can not comment on effectiveness of these coaching. But it seems to be the only solution for these writers. If as a writer you can not leverage internet marketing, then go out of this field. There might be more ways of monetizing your dumb cheap ghostwriting skills.

        Pratibha
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002737].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author pratibha
    Hi Mike, thank you for your latest post. It is most informative. I was all the time expecting something like this from you. The 5 points that you have posted were exactly the same that I had recieved from my first client. The floods etc are certianly not webmasters problems. I was just saying that Indian writer community NEVER takes in to account all these factors and thereby loose lot many customers.
    My most heart felt sincere thanks to you. pratibha.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002778].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JMarno
    It occurs to me that a free sample that is not in or related to their niche can show them all they need to know -- your writing skills, grammar, etc.

    If they're honestly looking for good writing for their articles, great. If they're just looking for freebies, well it won't be much use to them.

    Jaye Marno
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002932].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author DeePower
      Whether you are a great writer like Dr Mani or a dumb writer like me, you stop writing for others once you have understood the leverage of internet marketing.

      No. I still write for others. I'm getting ready to pitch offline hard copy magazines several articles on IM, book publishing, and finding great gifts. I'm working on a new book proposal that has nothing to do with IM.

      I also ghostwrite but I'm not cheap.

      Dee

      Signature
      FREE Pump Up Your Profits With PLR
      Are You a Writer? Then you need this FREE guide Convert Your Words to Ca$H Make Money Writing Online
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002967].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dsmpublishing
    I was extremely lucky in regards to outsourcing my articles i found a really cool guy pretty much as soon as i started looking.

    However we are all different take outsourcing of design work it was third time lucky for me to find someone that did a decent job and that i trusted.

    kind regards


    sam
    X
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1002984].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author maestro2010
    Awesome! I really found some interesting things to learn from this thread. The main factor is that the outsourced person should be quite known or have references. It is really difficult where you can get quality intertwined with contents.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1003166].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Kael41
    "The majority of ghostwriters can produce $5 a piece articles only"

    And what do you base this factual statement on? I know of many content producers who make a lot of money online not writing for the $1/500 word article segment. There may be a gluttony of third world/overseas writers who will write for pennies on the dollar, but professional organizations (and their webmasters) who count their ledger balances in the millions rarely even cast a glance at that market space. There are many qualified writers in the U.K and U.S who have a client base built up around producing profressional quality content pieces fit for trade publications and journals.

    I've held and serviced several contracts for online content GIANTS that have no problem being invoiced and paying thousands and thousands of dollars...monthly.

    I think your perception is a skewed one, or, primarily focused only on INDIAN writers. If so, then i retract everything in my post and agree with you. Rare is it that I find an Indian writer who can create content for the U.S/U.K market in a stylized grammatical format that doesn't require a ton of rework. And I take writing samples all the time from prospective writers who want to join AA.

    The best advice that I can give any writer who wants to write in American/British stylized formats is to read the classics. And by that I mean (for American) Hemingway, London, Steinbeck, etc and read for analysis. Paragraph construction, word usage, flow. Then move on to the contemporary authors of today as well. Do the same sort of analysis. That's my fast track to getting someone on pace with a certain of style of writing.

    The other thing to watch out for, and I was instructed on this in law school, is that people generally write like they talk. Just be aware of it when you or your students, or your writers, create content. Whenever one of my copy editors brings to me a writer who is having content issues, I always sit that writer down after a session and say "great piece, now read it ALOUD to me". Sometimes the flow doesn't work, sometimes it does. But great writers always take the time to find out.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1003265].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author D.K. Magnus
      Jack London is one of my favorite American authors.

      I have always been a good reader, and now my clients tell me I am a good writer.

      I find that the more I read, the better I become.


      Originally Posted by Kael41 View Post

      "The majority of ghostwriters can produce $5 a piece articles only"

      And what do you base this factual statement on? I know of many content producers who make a lot of money online not writing for the $1/500 word article segment. There may be a gluttony of third world/overseas writers who will write for pennies on the dollar, but professional organizations (and their webmasters) who count their ledger balances in the millions rarely even cast a glance at that market space. There are many qualified writers in the U.K and U.S who have a client base built up around producing profressional quality content pieces fit for trade publications and journals.

      I've held and serviced several contracts for online content GIANTS that have no problem being invoiced and paying thousands and thousands of dollars...monthly.

      I think your perception is a skewed one, or, primarily focused only on INDIAN writers. If so, then i retract everything in my post and agree with you. Rare is it that I find an Indian writer who can create content for the U.S/U.K market in a stylized grammatical format that doesn't require a ton of rework. And I take writing samples all the time from prospective writers who want to join AA.

      The best advice that I can give any writer who wants to write in American/British stylized formats is to read the classics. And by that I mean (for American) Hemingway, London, Steinbeck, etc and read for analysis. Paragraph construction, word usage, flow. Then move on to the contemporary authors of today as well. Do the same sort of analysis. That's my fast track to getting someone on pace with a certain of style of writing.

      The other thing to watch out for, and I was instructed on this in law school, is that people generally write like they talk. Just be aware of it when you or your students, or your writers, create content. Whenever one of my copy editors brings to me a writer who is having content issues, I always sit that writer down after a session and say "great piece, now read it ALOUD to me". Sometimes the flow doesn't work, sometimes it does. But great writers always take the time to find out.
      Signature
      For unique, high quality articles go to http://www.warriorforum.com/warriors...ent-great.html
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1003370].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Bev Clement
    The only person who called you a dumb ghostwriter is yourself.

    I have always said I have no problem with whatever rate a person choses to charge. Are McD's dumb because they don't run a 5 star restaurant. No they are cheap, plain and simple.

    I have no idea where you get your facts and figures from but it isn't from the real world of ghostwriting.

    I could give you at least 20 sites who have over 50 writers working for them. They pay their writers $1,000 for a 400 word article. Now think of that for a moment, they pay the writers $1,000 for a 400 word article so you have to guess what they charge the clients for those articles.

    Dr Mani I remember the report the first time around
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1003890].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author pratibha
      Hi Kael41.
      First of all I thank you very much. I do not have sufficient words to express my gratitude. My perception is of course skewed. I have limited experience of Indian community writers. All my thread has this reference frame. May be I should have written
      "Majority of Indian $5 a piece writers remain $5 a piece writers if they fail in IM."
      This is of course the reality in this part of the world.

      This is precisely the reason why your post is the best post in this thread so far. I was seeking exactly this type of info for my Indian writer community. I feel this might be useful for all other third world country writers also. The reality in this part of the world is making $300 per month is supposed to be respectable. If you get $1000 per month, you automatically enter into high middle class level. If a writer is going to get $1000 for one article, then he will do practically anything to achieve that target. Nobody will mind taking coaching for months at the cost of $1000. They will take loans from the bank for getting this sort of education and training. All they need is proper direction. I am extremely happy about this post.

      Now this community of Indian writers will rather like to take training at their own expenses, if they can see some sorts of promise at the end of it. If you take loan for your education from the bank and if you are sure that you will be able to repay in a year or two, then that does make sound economic sense.

      As far as reading is concerned, majority of educated people in India read English books only. They might need some direction regarding which authors they need to concentrate on and why. But this is not much of a problem at all. Personally I have read all the authors mentioned by you. But I will need to read all of them again from a different perspective as described by you.

      I want to help all the struggling Indian writers. Your post has given me an altogether different direction, regarding how I can do it. This is certainly going to open doors for new opportunities and many different methods of getting financial freedom for this community of Indian writers. You are certainly an important turning point in my IM journey. This post is certainly going to change lives of lot many Indian writers. They are eager to work hard. They are ready to study. They are interested in applying their skills. All that they needed was proper direction and relevant info. For me, like Dr Mani, there will be long lasting relationship with you. Thanks again.

      Hi Bev, My figures are based on my limited experience of Indian writer community only. This is the only frame of reference that I am using. I do not know anything about western authors and will never comment anything about them. Thanks for the info that there are websites offering $1000 per article. Indian writers will never mind taking coaching from you if it is that cost effective. After all they will be able to write one good piece investing time of one whole month, reading, studying, and improving that article! For them getting $1000 per month will be their first target.

      Pratibha.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1004626].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RanD
    Pratibha,

    I have been thinking about this over the course of this thread (honestly, it took us a while to get to the heart of the matter). I think your time would be better spent elsewhere. By that, I mean taking this topic somewhere where it would do more good. I think you could get more help in this area on a forum dedicated to writers and writing. They would be the best people to ask on how to build skills and improve in certain areas. As I said before, I can not train anyone to write. It is not my area of expertise. My advice is to take this problem to the experts....other writers. I'm sure there are many good forums for writers out there.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1004663].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Bev Clement
    I think the problem with this thread is the absolutes that Pratibha has been giving, whereas he was talking only about the Indian community.

    Pratibha, if you read your posts, you will see that you make absolute statements, whereas you are not making them in your mind. Some have been projecting into the future, but what do you think the biggest problem has been with your posts?

    You have not communicated clearly what you were thinking. Now before you talk about how good, bad or indifferent your English is, I am talking about making a point and making it clearly.

    I have lived and worked with people from Third World Countries, and I am used to taking what they say and getting the ideas of what they want to say, removing any bad English.

    This hasn't been easy to do here, because of the absolutes you have been making.

    You started by saying, "you were the best, because of the number of articles you have written." The reality is you might be one of the best voices in the Indian market, because this is the market you know about.

    Do you see the difference, one is stating an absolute, that you were the best, and that didn't include just the Indian market but the ghostwriting community.

    If a person wants to be a writer and make a decent income from it, communication is the biggest thing they need to learn and understand. If you can't get your point over then why would people hire you again.

    You say you have written thousands of articles, but you also talk about being ripped off. Where do you get your work from?

    If the rates are an issue, then that comes down to you and the way you price your business. Different people put different prices on their work, and the price you put will get different types of clients who are looking for different things.

    If you want to help the Indian writers then can I suggest you learn how to communicate clearly what you intend to do, because you have so many thoughts which when put for the Indian writers, but you are not saying that until now.

    You make the absolute comment about a ghostwriter won't remain a ghostwriter. Again, is this based on the Indian community or the whole world of ghostwriting?

    Actually, it doesn't matter, because if you believe a person can't make good money as a ghostwriter, you have already decided and nobody will change your mind.

    You talk about it as if there is no other options, but that isn't true. The problem as far as I can see, is your experience of ghostwriting doesn't exist. Now, before you say you are a ghostwriter, let me explain why I say that.

    Your experience is only for writing articles, a ghostwriter does far more. Your limited knowledge of writing, is what stops you from making a decent income online.

    Writing articles is always the low end of a writer's income.

    Press Releases will always make you more money.

    Writing report or ebooks are another way to make more money.

    Writing reviews again will earn more money. Now reviews come in all shapes and sizes and we have written reviews on copy.

    There are research projects which pay high rates.

    PLR can make you a lot of money if done correctly.

    You might be discouraged because you can't get repeat clients or nobody wants to pay more than $6 an article, but the question is have you asked people why this is, and more importantly learnt from the replies.

    Before making these absolutes, you really should look deep into your subject and see if there is anything else you are missing or could be doing. You say you like to research, but you have failed to do much research in this niche, yet you want to teach others.

    You can only teach what you already know, and yes an Indian teaching an Indian is a great business model, but your negative stance about ghostwriting will be passed to any students. You would be a better teacher if you learnt more about the niche and then passed on those lessons.

    I have spoken to a lot of webmasters as you call them, but they are not necessarily the webmaster, who want to hire writers and pay decent rates for the work. These are people outside the IM niche, and one thing they do is look through the search engines for companies who offer writing. They disregard people who don't have their own site, (a site hosted by themselves and not on blogger or wordpress) and those whose rates are below a certain level, because they don't want cheap writers. Now, if you read what I have written, and take the information to heart you will find lots of tips in there.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1005249].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author MSGeek
    pratibha:

    Thanks for a very interesting insight into an Indian ghostwriter life. Frankly, I was postponing an outsource order for a series of cooking mini-articles for autoreponder because I thought it may be more expensive, may be I should check those sites (Goober, elance, etc) again...

    I agree with a lot of people on this thread: if you write _original_ artcile as a free sample, you are giving too much power to webmasters. You need customers, but they need the content. If all they need is just something to throw into PLR pack, they don't really need you, but you also don't really need them. It's likely they are penniless and just cannot pay.

    Send them to portfolio for style. If the whole project is one article for $5, what free samples are they talking about? That $5 is their cost of the sample. Or, just don't take orders for just 1 article for $5, only consider series and put a delivery and payment schedule. Say, they want 50 articles, deliver one, get paid the first installment, deliver 10, get paid the next installment. I know it's pain in the ... well, you know, but once you get through this, you will be getting repeat orders (provided, you are as good as you think) from a person you already tested and who is genuine. And he will come to you again for the same reason. And if it does not work, fine, nobody's got cheated.

    In essence, you have to be more picky about whom you work with. I know it's not easy, and many people get desperate (not to mention, may just need money for food, it happens here in US too), but that will only bring you into the hamster wheel of free samples. Maybe you should spend less time writing free samples and more time into marketing yourself, so that quality customers like myself will find you. For reference, I have 100% payment rate on Goober as an employer. I've met Indian providers who claim a lot, but who, frankly, suck. So what?

    I just always start with a small project with the new provider. If he cannot deliver, I pay agreed small amount and leave the honest feedback. That's it. Yes, they may retaliate, but once customers see my 100% payment rate and good feed back I gave to other providers, they understand. And those, who don't, are probably not that good to do the work anyway...

    Market yourself, be reasonable for both sides (including not giving up too much), build repeat customer base -- yes, that's very hard in any part of the world. Do you think it's easy for me to get people stick to my websites?

    Anyway, good luck.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1009975].message }}

Trending Topics