Is Google punishing Affiliate Review Sites?

17 replies
I am in the process of setting up some review sites for my affiliates and was wondering if this is anything that I need to be concerned about.
Google Slap for Product Review Sites
Is Google really going to punish those with affiliate links and if so what is the best way to get around it?
#affiliate #google #punishing #review #sites
  • Profile picture of the author tryinhere
    ? that has been out for a while and i put it into the sky i falling basket and probably more a knee jerk.

    that being said G are enforcing more of the policies that are currently in place more so than re inventing the wheel, and what that report does not show or link to are the sites? are they reviewing what topic ? make money / snake oil ? and the like ? i highly suspect they would be along those lines.

    So with that it probably is an unbalanced view of what is happening, never let the truth stand in the way of a good story as it is often said.

    a reply from google states to have good customer experience to do this with a review page

    Option 2: Redesign your web page to offer multiple, competing offers from
    different companies for related services. For example, a web page
    promoting a specific book could have links to four on-line bookshops from
    which one could purchase the book.
    /\ sounds like a review page to me,

    All of that said, there is another side to the coin where if you peddle a review page that runs products that G does not like and this is where people are confused when people ask can you do this and can you do that, often the answer varies Dependant on what it is you are peddling.

    I can say that if you peddle make money / gazillions on-line in any form just about be it review or not it will be slammed with little or no mercy from G and will probably get a account suspended for life / bang

    other border line topics seem to be getting a warning.

    One thing i am seeing right now with no answers is some people offering a guide for sale that involves setting a up a review sites for G and those accounts are then slammed with the person setting them up being banned for life.

    This is on the surface but looks strongly that way from what i have seen and to my knowledge this is still being peddled, so people need to use some common sense when reading some touted information especially in this area.

    * note this is in no way related to anyone here or any product here on warrior forum and is information from other sources that is available.

    If unsure simply do not go there and be safe until you can have clarity on the outcome, if you juggle knives and you are a beginner odds are one will slip and cut deep.
    Signature
    | > Choosing to go off the grid for a while to focus on family, work and life in general. Have a great 2020 < |
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450354].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author deloriagod
    I hear link cloaking can help a lot. I have an affiliate site ranking on the 2nd page of Google for it's main keyword and I haven't done much of anything to it besides put some products on there, got a few backlinks, wrote an article or two. If you're using WP like me, I use Link Cloaking Plugin.
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450356].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author kursat
      Originally Posted by deloriagod View Post

      I hear link cloaking can help a lot. I have an affiliate site ranking on the 2nd page of Google for it's main keyword and I haven't done much of anything to it besides put some products on there, got a few backlinks, wrote an article or two. If you're using WP like me, I use Link Cloaking Plugin.
      Just read this and I have been waiting to learn this for a while. So, when I add my affiliate link on my posts on WP, it doesnt show as an affiliate link. But when someone click on this, than they can see the affiliate link on the URL address bar.

      So, how does the cloaking work? Can you explain please. Is it that when someone click on an affiliate link, the address bar just hides the link?

      Also, is the above plugin free. Thanks
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450387].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author deloriagod
        Originally Posted by kidsniper21 View Post

        Does using a HTm Cloaker Buzz as your cloaking software against the big G's TOS?
        I have actually never read any of G's TOS aside from the Adsense TOS.

        Originally Posted by kursat View Post

        Just read this and I have been waiting to learn this for a while. So, when I add my affiliate link on my posts on WP, it doesnt show as an affiliate link. But when someone click on this, than they can see the affiliate link on the URL address bar.

        So, how does the cloaking work? Can you explain please. Is it that when someone click on an affiliate link, the address bar just hides the link?

        Also, is the above plugin free. Thanks
        Yes, the plugin is free. Honestly I have no idea how link cloaking works (I bought a WSO from Rob Fore and was told to use link cloaking so I did). I'm looking at one of my affiliate sites right now and it appears that instead of showing where the link is directing to, it instead shows it directing to the anchor text. So my anchor text is "xxx - click here" and instead of showing domain.com/goto/site-i'm-linking-to it shows it shows domain.com/goto/xxx-click-here. I get a feeling Google might not be the most fond of this but according to my Statpress plugin Google hits my site fairly often and they don't seem to have found anything worthy of a manual review.
        Signature
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450438].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author tri
    this is not proven anywhere but I would imagine if 90% of the links in your site is linking out to other site that sell products and your links are not cloaked, it would be easy for Google to figure out your site is an affiliate site and might not give your site as much "credit"

    there are plugins out there for cloaking content as well as cloaking links, just be careful using them
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450407].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author kursat
      Originally Posted by tri View Post

      this is not proven anywhere but I would imagine if 90% of the links in your site is linking out to other site that sell products and your links are not cloaked, it would be easy for Google to figure out your site is an affiliate site and might not give your site as much "credit"

      there are plugins out there for cloaking content as well as cloaking links, just be careful using them
      What if there is a way that I can link to the payment page, sort of bypassing the sales page? Do you think that avoids the google problem?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450434].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Mayo
    Hi Jagger,

    Just wanted to let you know that using excessive asterisks in your thread title could
    cause this post to be deleted.

    Don't take my post the wrong way. I'm just trying to help you knowing that
    you've just recently registered an account here.

    If you look at the main forum right now you will notice that your thread is the only
    one sporting special characters.

    I know you did it to draw attention to the thread but this isn't allowed here for the
    fact that if everyone did it then the forum would be visually hard to read.

    I'm not complaining but rather trying to tell you that if you remove them(the asterisks)
    from your thread title, your post will have a better chance of remaining active without being
    deleted.

    Hope that Helps,
    Have a Great Day!
    Michael
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450502].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author jaggerbabwin
      Thanks, no offense taken. I am still a Warrior newbie and as such am not yet entirely versed in the ways of the Warrior World (and here I thought that I was being slick)
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450538].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Mayo
    Hi Jagger,
    Thanks for understanding.

    While viewing your Original post in the thread, you can edit your original post
    by clicking on edit post button and then clicking on the Go Advanced button
    under the edit post box.

    Have a Great Day!
    Michael

    PS. It won't change all the post titles in this thread although it will change it in the Main forum listing.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450585].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author John Alves
    Google isn't going to punish for affiliate review sites. I don't think they care about affiliates as long as it's not a thin affiliate page. The page must offer a lot of value for the reader. Google does not like wordpress mini sites that are mainly focused on getting affiliate sales or adsense clicks. I still don't think they penalize them, but I know of other marketers getting emails about "thin affiliate sites" when they were using adsense on them. I'm assuming that it will eventually be a problem for affiliates promoting products.

    The reality is that you should provide a lot of value on a website whether it's for non profit or for profit. The value of the content attracts visitors and keeps repeat visitors coming to the site. Content is the number one thing to focus on if you want to have a successful, money making website. Google realizes that content is important, so they want to rank sites higher that provide unique content that helps the visitor.

    I don't think that Google is out to penalize affiliate review sites, however, I do think your main goal should be to make a quality review site. Offer some pros and minor cons about a product, and provide as much knowledge as you can about a product. You will be able to gain more customers that way, and you will be able to build trust. After building trust and having word of mouth build traffic for you, you will be able to get email subscribers if you set up an opt in widget. Then you can promote more products and continue to build growth for your website.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450618].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author tryinhere
      Originally Posted by John Alves View Post

      I don't think that Google is out to penalize affiliate review sites, however, I do think your main goal should be to make a quality review site. Offer some pros and minor cons about a product, and provide as much knowledge as you can about a product. You will be able to gain more customers that way, and you will be able to build trust. After building trust and having word of mouth build traffic for you, you will be able to get email subscribers if you set up an opt in widget. Then you can promote more products and continue to build growth for your website.
      rather than think, i will put it black and white for you, if you build a review site regardless of amount or quality or perceived quality on any non G approved topic you will have your account slammed or suspended for life. period especially if your in the make gazzilions , spin doctor depts, the only thinking you will do after that is to wonder why you were suspended.
      Signature
      | > Choosing to go off the grid for a while to focus on family, work and life in general. Have a great 2020 < |
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2451102].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author MichaelBenz
        Originally Posted by tryinhere View Post

        if you build a review site regardless of amount or quality or perceived quality on any non G approved topic you will have your account slammed or suspended for life.
        This is a little dramatic bro. First off, what account are you talking about? We are talking about SEO here.

        If you run one on Adwords yea - your adwords account will 99% of the time be suspended.

        But what account can Google suspend if you're not running PPC?

        Sure they can tank your site and not rank it, but not ONE of our affiliate review sites (we have over 120 of them) have moved significantly since this happened.

        Just cover your links. If you use Wordpress, use the "Pretty Link Plugin"
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2451134].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author davidjames42973
          Yes I have been noticing a couple of my websites that have been bringing me good money on a monthly basis turn up in the Google sandbox.

          I can't blame a "thin wordpress site" because one of the websites had 27 posts with backlinks from websites that were authority sites from the same niche.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2451232].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author tpw
          Originally Posted by MichaelBenz View Post

          This is a little dramatic bro. First off, what account are you talking about? We are talking about SEO here.
          And besides that, if your site gets banned from google, there is one absolute sure way to get unbanned... I tipped a friend, and he got unbanned in two weeks... LOL
          Signature
          Bill Platt, Oklahoma USA, PlattPublishing.com
          Publish Coloring Books for Profit (WSOTD 7-30-2015)
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2458793].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author tryinhere
          Originally Posted by MichaelBenz View Post

          This is a little dramatic bro. First off, what account are you talking about? We are talking about SEO here."
          the op post was in regards adwords / in ref to the link provided and i will stand by what i said in relation to the topic as intended. in regards SEO i would leave that with more informed people on that subject to reply, I am sorry if my post was seen as anything other than as intended and as indicated by the op.
          Signature
          | > Choosing to go off the grid for a while to focus on family, work and life in general. Have a great 2020 < |
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2576172].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author tpw
    Originally Posted by jaggerbabwin View Post

    I am in the process of setting up some review sites for my affiliates and was wondering if this is anything that I need to be concerned about.
    Google Slap for Product Review Sites
    Is Google really going to punish those with affiliate links and if so what is the best way to get around it?
    LOL... The easiest way around it is to NEVER EVER let Google dictate how you build your websites!!

    While Google could be a major source of traffic for you, many people find that they can drive a ton of traffic from other sources as well...

    My primary website gets 10,000 clicks from Google every month, but Google only accounts for 40% of my global traffic...

    Whenever Google tries to dictate to me how I should build my websites, I respond by introducing them to my favorite bird... ;-)

    I will make money without Google if I need to, but I am not going to turn away any bread crumbs they would like to throw my way...

    Do they need me? No... Certainly not.... But I do not need them either, to be successful with my businesses...
    Signature
    Bill Platt, Oklahoma USA, PlattPublishing.com
    Publish Coloring Books for Profit (WSOTD 7-30-2015)
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2450639].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author xiaoayuan
    I am not sure if Google is punishing Affiliate Review Sites? But I do notice that most of the time, the pages without affiliate links rank better than the pages with affiliate links in Google search results (I mean they are using the same keywords).
    Has anybody noticed this?
    Signature

    Submit articles to article directories using Magic Article Submitter or blogs by Free Traffic System--It is Free
    Article Architect simplifies my article marketing process
    Article Marketing Lifeline answers all my article marketing quesitons

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2576020].message }}

Trending Topics