News & Solutions To The Recent Gmail Spam Folder Issues

by Zeus66
7 replies
As you may or may not know, Google recently became much more aggressive in putting emails into the spam folder. This is affecting many permission-based email marketers. If you're on any marketing lists and you are signed up with your gmail account, go check your spam folder right now and you'll likely find some surprises in there.

If you use email marketing, this is likely costing you money now or will in the future, if you don't adapt to the new reality...

OK, so my researcher and I have spent the better part of today digging around at Google and I have some solutions if you do find this to be a problem.


Google is trying to help in a way that might be a little overbearing.

Let's say that:
I delete your emails while they are still unread (I would NEVER do that, of course – I love your emails)
I don't rescue your emails from my spam folder (it looks like google assumes that we all go through our spam folders every day)
Someone clicks on the “Report Spam” button with your email open
You are promoting something that has been associated with spam....

It all goes into your permanent record

Google will start tossing your emails into spam folders. It doesn't seem to be ALL messages. I found messages in my spam folder from the same sender that made it into my inbox today.

There are only THREE ways that google gives to avoid this, and they ALL must be done by your email recipients.

1. Add you to their contacts list – BUT be warned – they explicitly say that even an added contact's email can go to your spam filter:
“”””Some messages sent from contacts which are very clearly spam can be sent directly to your Spam label. More importantly, in some cases messages from contacts will not be sent to Spam but will be marked with a red warning banner if the content is suspicious - for example, your friend's or contact's account has been compromised and used to send phishing messages.””””

2. Your recipients can sort through the crap in their spam folder, find your messages, and mark them as “Not Spam.” This, too, apparently goes into your permanent record... If not yours, at least your recipients'. Here's what google says:

“”””users have the option of clicking a 'Not spam' button for each message flagged by our spam filters. We listen to users' reports, and correct problems in order to provide them with the best user experience. As long as our users don't consider your mail as spam, you shouldn't have inbox delivery problems.””””

In the old days, if there were spam complaints, the ISP would contact the user or the sender and get the opt-in proof. Google doesn't wait for the complaints it seems, and you know how they like automation – they see the “Not Spam” button as the user confirming that the email is solicited.

3. Your recipients can create a filter to ensure that your emails NEVER go into their spam folders... Getting them to do something simple like adding you to contacts is hard enough – teaching and getting them to set up filters would be um... ambitious. Here's how to set up filters:

Using filters - Gmail Help

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here are my tips for you:

1. Google wants to help people unsubscribe beyond the normal means. They like little sort of pop-up unsubscribe headers in email (I've seen these a few times, but not often):

"Because Gmail can help users automatically unsubscribe from your email, we strongly recommend the following: Provide a 'List-Unsubscribe' header which points to an email address where the user can unsubscribe easily from future mailings (Note: This is not a substitute method for unsubscribing)."

2. Put the email that the user used to subscribe IN the email. Again, from google:

"It's possible that your users forward mail from other accounts, so we recommend that you: Explicitly indicate the email address subscribed to your list."

3. They encourage you to use the same from address with all of your bulk messages, but they THEN go on to tell you to maybe use different email addresses for promotion vs. transaction. I'll leave conclusions and loopholes implied there up to you.

4. It could just be your offer. It seems that when an affiliate marketer is tagged as a spammer, everyone associated with the offer suffers:

"Affiliate marketing programs reward third-parties for bringing visitors to your site. Unfortunately, these programs are attractive to hard-core spammers and can potentially do more harm than good. Please note the following: If your brand becomes associated with affiliate marketing spam, it can affect the mail sent by you and your other affiliates." YIKES!

A very telling change Google just implemented yesterday (May 4) I think points to them trying to push Gmail users into adding more Contacts...

Store up to 25,000 contacts - Official Gmail Blog

Google just increased the maximum number of Contacts you can add from 10,000 to 25,000 yesterday. It can't be a coincidence that this happened just after the problems with inaccurate spam filtering.


That's about it.

Just wanted to put this out there as many of you may not even be aware this was going on with gmail.

Thanks,
John

#folder #gmail #google #issues #news #recent #solutions #spam
  • Profile picture of the author Coby
    Great Post John!

    I was wondering about this and your post helped shed some light - as usual!

    I had never had a problem with my emails hitting the spam folder before this...

    Hard to believe that Gmail is now more restrictive than yahoo :p
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3833979].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Zeus66
    Thanks, Coby. Yeah, I'm hearing from my own subscribers and I'm seeing it in my Gmail spam folder where other marketers whose lists I am on are ending up in my spam folder. It's out of control. It's looking like we'll have to train our own list members to "unspam" us and add us to their contact list in Gmail to avoid this. For a whole host of reasons that sucks, but it is what it is.

    Adapt or die.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3834145].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Vanessa Reece
      Thanks John, that was a great post and ties in nicely with something I'm teaching right now. I went through my gmail and found various emails from places/people I'd subscribed to. Not good. I use gmail for everything because I had a bad incident with one of my .com addys. Long story...but its one battle after the other huh?

      I'll be sure to address this with my lists so they don't miss my emails - well that's if they get through.:rolleyes: My lists aren't huge and the click throughs are quite good but if I think they could be better I'll definitely take action.


      V
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3834195].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Zeus66
        Originally Posted by ITS-V View Post

        Thanks John, that was a great post and ties in nicely with something I'm teaching right now. I went through my gmail and found various emails from places/people I'd subscribed to. Not good. I use gmail for everything because I had a bad incident with one of my .com addys. Long story...but its one battle after the other huh?

        I'll be sure to address this with my lists so they don't miss my emails - well that's if they get through.:rolleyes: My lists aren't huge and the click throughs are quite good but if I think they could be better I'll definitely take action.


        V
        I'm strongly considering emailing all the people on my list with a gmail address on an individual basis and asking them to add me to their contacts (I mail using a gmail account as the 'From' and 'Reply To'). If even 30% of them do it, at least that gives me some insurance against these false positive spam filterings.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3834345].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Converting Copy
    Thanks for bringing this to my attention. Great post and very sneaky about them promoting their "add more contacts" feature around the time of this spam issue update.

    So would it logically make sense that if I email all of my Gmail subscribers as you said and asked them to add me, obviously that would lead to less of my emails being labeled as spam... BUT would that reflect positively on my emails as a whole in Google's eyes so that my emails would less frequently be labeled as spam even to those who did NOT add me to their contacts?

    In other words by getting more people to give me and my content the green light, Google says hey let's stop calling this guy's content spam for EVERYONE?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3837154].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Zeus66
      Originally Posted by Converting Copy View Post

      Thanks for bringing this to my attention. Great post and very sneaky about them promoting their "add more contacts" feature around the time of this spam issue update.

      So would it logically make sense that if I email all of my Gmail subscribers as you said and asked them to add me, obviously that would lead to less of my emails being labeled as spam... BUT would that reflect positively on my emails as a whole in Google's eyes so that my emails would less frequently be labeled as spam even to those who did NOT add me to their contacts?

      In other words by getting more people to give me and my content the green light, Google says hey let's stop calling this guy's content spam for EVERYONE?
      In my opinion, yes I think if Google "sees" an uptick in Gmail users adding your email address to their contacts, it will have a positive effect and reduce the false positive spam filterings. But it's just my opinion ok? I have nothing to go on that's more substantial.

      At the very least and according to Google's own words as I quoted in the OP, it will give you a lot more defense for those particular users and prevent your emails to them from going into their spam folders. It's not a total assurance, but it gives you a lot more of a shield.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3837175].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author telewarrior
        John, thanks for the posts about gmail that made me discover what I was missing out on. While it may be necessary to filter out spam generally, having an automagic 30 day cliff that had to be discovered once cognitive dissonance had set in is a bit disconcerting. I appreciate your pointing this out and as a result of acting on your post above I was able to rescue some missing email before it went over the falls.

        Since you appear to have been so prolific, informative, and to the point in WF I thought that I'd sign up for your weekly videos, but my verified gmail account doesn't seem to pass your screening code. Having been a developer in my past, I can appreciate how difficult it is to parse text so I clobbered the pre-existing text in the text box, copied and pasted directly from my account, and even made sure some spaces didn't sneak in at the ends. No dice. Here is the input:



        and here is the result:



        I suppose NoScript may be preventing the transaction as seen in the second image so perhaps some development to avoid loosing out on others that aren't as stubborn as I may be worth some rework time.

        Perhaps you could IM me through WF if that channel is available for a noob like me.

        Thanks,

        Brett
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3884577].message }}

Trending Topics