Is sending Newsletter still a good strategy?

27 replies
Dear Warriors

As we all know money is in the list and we are very eager to capture the subscribers by putting an opt in form in our sites.

Whether this was a good idea in the first place or not, I think most of the email applications offer anti spam filters and most newsletters only end up in the junk mail folders.

Frankly the open rate of my last news letter was 12.5%. What is your experience and open rate?
#newsletters #send
  • Profile picture of the author Richard Van
    Am I reading this correctly? You are advising people not to create a mailing list?

    If you are that is the worst advice I've seen given out here.

    Just because you appear to be making assumptions on spam filters and failing to get people to open emails, certainly doesn't mean it doesn't work. Incidentally are you talking about the site in your signature? If so are you basing this advice just on the IM niche?

    Hardly a comprehensive test on whether or not peoople should build lists.

    Seriously, maybe you need to write better subject lines and copy so more people open it and buy things from you, instead of blaming it on spam filters.
    Signature

    Wibble, bark, my old man's a mushroom etc...

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4964993].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author cardine
      Originally Posted by Richard Van View Post

      Am I reading this correctly? You are advising people not to create a mailing list?

      If you are that is the worst advice I've seen given out here.

      Just because you appear to be making assumptions on spam filters and failing to get people to open emails, certainly doesn't mean it doesn't work. Incidentally are you talking about the site in your signature? If so are you basing this advice just on the IM niche?

      Hardly a comprehensive test on whether or not peoople should build lists.

      Seriously, maybe you need to write better subject lines and copy so more people open it and buy things from you, instead of blaming it on spam filters.
      Completely agree with this. List building and sending out newsletters is still one of the best ways to reach out to people who are interested in what you have to say. It is usually very hard to get a list of targeted members who are interested in what you have to say and it would be short sided to toss that promotional method aside because your newsletters are getting marked as spam.

      OP, maybe you should start writing less spammy newsletters and higher quality content so that most email services don't think what your writing is spam.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965407].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Will Edwards
    I agree with Richard and in addition to what he said, I would point out that if your newsletters are truly good quality, you will benefit from a viral effect when people start referring their friends.

    Will
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965006].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Richard Van
      Originally Posted by Will Edwards View Post

      I agree with Richard and in addition to what he said, I would point out that if your newsletters are truly good quality, you will benefit from a viral effect when people start referring their friends.

      Will
      The other thing Will, looking at the persons signature, is he/she appears to be targeting the "I want to retire next week" mob. The very same type of product that CB has millions of, including this one. Those people are likely on tons and tons of other similar marketers lists.

      There's also very little information to work on. The OP says his last email had a 12.5% open rate. Well is that going up or down? How often are you sending them out? Do you just hit them with several affiliate offers a day or do you actually interact with the list? Etc. Etc. Etc.

      It's just not enough info....and Will, I haven't forgotten you chap, it is getting closer to being done!
      Signature

      Wibble, bark, my old man's a mushroom etc...

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965027].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Shaun OReilly
    Originally Posted by onlinebizgiant View Post

    Dear Warriors

    As we all know money is in the list and we are very eager to capture the subscribers by putting an opt in form in our sites.

    Whether this was a good idea in the first place or not, it really is a waste of time nowadays. Most email applications offer anti spam filters and most newsletters only end up in the junk mail folders.

    Frankly the open rate of my last news letter was 12.5%. What is your experience and open rate?
    My experience is based on 8 years of list building.

    Based on that experience, your advice is BAD, BAD, BAD.

    If you're going to give out bad advice, then keep it to
    yourself and don't get spreading it here.

    For the record, my open rates vary between 15-40%
    typically but for some segmented lists with highly relevant
    offers I can get to 70% opens or more.

    Dedicated to mutual success,

    Shaun
    Signature

    .

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965038].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author FergusM
    Are your newsletters going to the same people as before? May be it's a case of been there, done that, on thousands of other similar format sites. Maybe you could post a copy of your email you sent out.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965045].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Chris Webb
    A 12.5% open rate on the most targetted communication you can send (bar a phone call) is better than 2000 visitors to a webpage that do nothing.
    Signature

    Hi I'm Chris and I run compelling.tv, a site dedicated to helping you to sell more with online video
    Get Free Video Marketing Tutorials on YouTube!
    Free Video Stuff: - Join for access!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965074].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author gilbertm
    Wow. I've been building lists for three years now and that's a first. I've been taught to build email lists since I started marketing online. It's been the best thing I have ever done. Despite spam filters, Social networks are still growing by the thousands through email. Just look at facebook!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965104].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author theemperor
    Originally Posted by onlinebizgiant View Post

    Dear Warriors

    As we all know money is in the list and we are very eager to capture the subscribers by putting an opt in form in our sites.

    Whether this was a good idea in the first place or not, it really is a waste of time nowadays. Most email applications offer anti spam filters and most newsletters only end up in the junk mail folders.

    Frankly the open rate of my last news letter was 12.5%. What is your experience and open rate?
    The trick is to send them stuff they want to open. They will hint through the spam folder to find your email if it is valuable. Also use aweber or get response for a better delivery rate than possible with the free alternatives.
    Signature
    Learn to code faster, and remove the roadblocks. Get stuff done and shipped! PM me and I can help you with programming tutoring, specialising in Web and the following languages: Javascript ~ HTML ~ CSS ~ React ~ JQuery ~ Typescript ~ NodeJS ~ C#.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965137].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Richard Van
      Hi Onlinebizgiant,

      I think with respect, looking at the other comments, that building email lists is still a very good practise.

      The problem I feel is that you may not be doing it in an effective manner for your list.
      Signature

      Wibble, bark, my old man's a mushroom etc...

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965363].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author onlinebizgiant
    I do apologize for making such a post, sorry warriors. I just modified the post little bit so that it may not be misleading. Once again my apologies.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965575].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Richard Van
      Originally Posted by onlinebizgiant View Post

      I do apologize for making such a post, sorry warriors. I just modified the post little bit so that it may not be misleading. Once again my apologies.
      Oh no my friend. No one was annoyed with you or anything like that. There's certainly no need to apologise, I just didn't want people new to this bypassing building a list.

      It's a discussion forum and when you say something that people disagree with, you'll invariably get people saying they disagree.

      I certainly don't think you mean't any harm and it was very noble of you to come back and apologise, though I don't think you needed to.
      Signature

      Wibble, bark, my old man's a mushroom etc...

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4965667].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JohnMcCabe
    One thing to keep in mind is the way "open rate" is usually calculated.

    Most of the time, a 1x1 pixel graphic is included with the email, and the open rate is based on the number of server requests for that tracking graphic. At best, that number will give you a minimum number due to a number of other factors.

    Some readers use a preview pane in their email programs. Even though they read your message, they do not 'open' it.

    As a security measure many email clients (including Gmail) do not download graphics. If the reader opens the email, but does not download the graphic, they are not counted as an open.

    I'm going to swim upstream here, but I do believe their are some niches in which a traditional, ongoing newsletter type list is a waste of time for most folks.

    Mostly, I'm thinking a of very tiny, very specific micromarkets in the 'desperate buyer' topics. They have a problem they urgently want to solve, but once they solve that problem, they have no further interest. Many people would tell you that you can always start pitching related products, but in my eyes, that leads to spray and pray marketing. Which leads to endless threads ranting about email marketers marketing.

    Even in those markets, I do believe that you should capture email addresses from people who don't buy immediately. Use a defined email follow-up sequence to help some of them decide to purchase your product. But generating an ongoing newsletter with any relevance will be difficult.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4966050].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author art72
      Originally Posted by JohnMcCabe View Post

      Most of the time, a 1x1 pixel graphic is included with the email, and the open rate is based on the number of server requests for that tracking graphic. At best, that number will give you a minimum number due to a number of other factors.

      Some readers use a preview pane in their email programs. Even though they read your message, they do not 'open' it.

      As a security measure many email clients (including Gmail) do not download graphics. If the reader opens the email, but does not download the graphic, they are not counted as an open.
      It never ceases to amaze me what one can learn on this forum. I had no clue about the 'pixel graphic' and being I heavily use Gmail, that's something to reconsider in the near future.

      Thanks for pointing that out!

      All the Best,

      Art
      Signature
      Atop a tree with Buddha ain't a bad place to take rest!
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4966191].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author stong
      Originally Posted by JohnMcCabe View Post

      I'm going to swim upstream here, but I do believe their are some niches in which a traditional, ongoing newsletter type list is a waste of time for most folks.

      Mostly, I'm thinking a of very tiny, very specific micromarkets in the 'desperate buyer' topics. They have a problem they urgently want to solve, but once they solve that problem, they have no further interest. Many people would tell you that you can always start pitching related products, but in my eyes, that leads to spray and pray marketing. Which leads to endless threads ranting about email marketers marketing.
      This is pretty interesting to me, because I'm actually trying to serve one of those desperate buyer markets (aka people who need a problem solved ASAP). I thought about doing a series of ongoing email followups for a while, but ultimately decided that once their problems are taken care of, they would no longer require my services.

      What I'm doing now is to formulate a series of emails designed specifically to tackle that problem, kind of like a mini course with instructional articles on how to solve it. When that's done, they'll still be in my list - but I'll be terminating my fixed followup emails.

      The selling part will be done in those emails, where I recommend products that will help. But I think that giving my customers what they want (i.e. information they need) is more important than me pushing my goods on them.

      I think I should state that I haven't actually had success with this model yet. But if I were a customer with a specific problem, I would probably want to know how I can make it go away, rather than hang around for months reading about something that could be of benefit to me if I squint my eyes a little.

      That's just my opinion of how to adapt the email marketing strategy to desperate buyers, anyway. Anyone care to offer their insights? I like to learn new things everyday.
      Signature
      Need a writer? Click here to get content that you'd be proud to have...
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4968798].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author supershoesclub
    of course, we always use newsletters to get the new orders from old customers.I think if you send the newsletter to the real subscribers with your store.thus, they will open your email mostly.Even though they don't have the intention to buy.But a clinking will happen for the actual subscribers.if you spam the non-subscribers,sure, the emails will arrive into the junk mail inbox mostly.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4966281].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Dracilla Dalton
    Yes but keep them short and concise. People don;t want to have to read a lot. Also make sure you have a dynamic subject line--something that makes opening your newsletter irresistible.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4967752].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author packerfan
      Originally Posted by Dracilla Dalton View Post

      Yes but keep them short and concise. People don;t want to have to read a lot. Also make sure you have a dynamic subject line--something that makes opening your newsletter irresistible.
      Really? People will read as long as it's interesting, helpful, funny, controversial, etc. Length is of little importance.

      Personal example. I don't really like to read, never have. But I've become really fascinated with copywriting lately. So I've been reading the Gary Halbert newsletter archives, I've bought 10 books on the subject, etc.

      Over the past month I bet I've read 350,000 words on the subject of copywriting, advertising, and direct response marketing.

      The subject just really has my interest peaked.

      If you can do the same in your newsletter, it can be 25 pages long and it will get read.
      Signature

      Nothing to see here

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4968870].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Adnimated
        Originally Posted by packerfan View Post

        Over the past month I bet I've read 350,000 words on the subject of copywriting, advertising, and direct response marketing.
        Rookie!

        But yeah... I agree on the length doesn't matter part. It doesn't till a certain extend. It's more about readability.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4968924].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author jbsmith
          The key is to maintain contact with your list, here are some of the mailouts we use:

          1. A weekly FAQ from various polls, surveys and reader email I get
          2. A product review of the week related to the interests of my list
          3. A bi-weekly newsletter, which today is really an article plus a summary of my top blog posts over that 2-week period
          4. Periodic audio or email interviews, Youtube videos and/or special reports - giving value to my list
          5. Single updates for certain blog posts

          The key is to keep contact with them, keep feeding them relevant and useful information and keep the lines of communication open so you can promote additional products and services to them over time.

          I wouldn't get wrapped up specifically in the "newsletter" format - do what makes sense to communicate with your subscribers.

          Jeff
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4969009].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author packerfan
          Originally Posted by jkhunter View Post

          Rookie!

          But yeah... I agree on the length doesn't matter part. It doesn't till a certain extend. It's more about readability.
          We all have to start somewhere...

          I don't even have any intention of becoming a copywriter perse, but man the more I read the more I want to read...

          I mean I had a basic understanding before, but all the nuance is fascinating to me.

          I'm at the point where I'm about to start writing famous sales letters out by hand. Never mind the fact that my handwriting is completely unreadable, and I haven't written anything other than scribbling notes for about the last 20 years...
          Signature

          Nothing to see here

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4969178].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Adnimated
            Originally Posted by packerfan View Post

            We all have to start somewhere...

            I don't even have any intention of becoming a copywriter perse, but man the more I read the more I want to read...

            I mean I had a basic understanding before, but all the nuance is fascinating to me.

            I'm at the point where I'm about to start writing famous sales letters out by hand. Never mind the fact that my handwriting is completely unreadable, and I haven't written anything other than scribbling notes for about the last 20 years...
            I was just kidding around.

            That is a great way to go. When I started writing copy, I wrote maybe 200 pieces out by hand. Day and night.

            Now I got to the point where I just try my own things.

            What really fascinates me now is the designing aspect. So not only how pictures impact the copy... but also how the structure of words, sentences and even paragraphs make the copy look better.

            The most exciting feeling is when you put together a winning ad. It never bores in my opinion.

            If I may recommend someone, read and listen to stuff from Gary Bencivenga. That guy is absolutely genius.

            If you need some more tips on the flow of your copy, I'd read stuff by Joe Vitale. A lot of hypnotic writing is about the proper flow of things. So the way you structure your stories, the words you choose, etc.

            And to become good at short but high impact stories... you are reading stuff from the right guy. Gary Halbert is definitely your man.
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4969216].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Dennis Gaskill
      Originally Posted by Dracilla Dalton View Post

      Yes but keep them short and concise. People don;t want to have to read a lot. Also make sure you have a dynamic subject line--something that makes opening your newsletter irresistible.
      My newsletter typically prints out to about 12-14 page or so. No one every tells me they're too long, but people do say they wish I'd send more.

      Paul Myers is another person who writes long newsletters. I read every word of them most of the time.

      Short is necessary if you can't hold your audiences interest. Length doesn't matter if you can.
      Signature

      Just when you think you've got it all figured out, someone changes the rules.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4969090].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Dennis Gaskill
      Originally Posted by Dracilla Dalton View Post

      Yes but keep them short and concise. People don;t want to have to read a lot. Also make sure you have a dynamic subject line--something that makes opening your newsletter irresistible.
      My newsletter typically prints out to about 12-14 pages or so. No one ever tells me they're too long, but people do say they wish I'd send more.

      Paul Myers is another person who writes long newsletters. I read every word of them most of the time.

      Short is necessary if you can't hold your audience's interest. Length matters little if you can. Still, your advice would be well-suited for a lot of people. I just wanted others considering your advice to know that it isn't as black and white as you presented it.
      Signature

      Just when you think you've got it all figured out, someone changes the rules.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4969092].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author StevenJones
    My weekly newsletters did not convert that well either. So I bundled 2 week in on letter, basically bi-weekly newsletters. Conversion raised with 8% after doing that. Worth looking into!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4967795].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Adnimated
    I send emails out every single day. And I make a lot of money on my lists.

    I honestly don't care about openrates, CTR, etc. The only thing I care about is cold-hard cash in my pocket. And I tested many things. The most profitable thing is still mailing something every single day.

    When you do it right, you won't get that many spam complaints. In fact, I saw less spam complaints after I started doing that.

    Please note:

    I am not talking about sending short, spammy messages.

    If we have to talk openrates and all that funky jazz:

    Last time I tracked, mine were between 10% and 50%. CTR as high as 70%.

    Is email dead? I do not agree. In fact, I think it's more alive then ever. And the really savvy marketers will only thrive during these tough times. As they'll be the ones standing out from the rest.

    Just my 2 cents.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4968855].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author nicholasb
    I still send newsletters, don't call them that, I prefer to call them reports, but yes as long as the content is solid and promotes good offers it is still a very effective strategy.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4969047].message }}

Trending Topics