Write original article or rewrite PLR?

34 replies
Reading the PLR post is dead thread got me thinking - Would I rather rewrite PLR or write an original article?

The lazy side of me instantly answered - Rewrite PLR. It is easier to take the ideas from an article, and put them into your own words. This is simple to do provided the seed article has a certain level of quality. If it is filled with syntax errors and a mess, then writing from scratch is easier.

The more I thought about it, the more I realized writing an original article is easier. I like to research a topic, give it some thought, and then see if I can put a unique spin on the subject. It might take a longer to finish an article, but it I like writing this way.

So, my vote goes to writing an original article.

What about everyone else?

Keith
#article #original #plr #rewrite #write
  • Profile picture of the author Sheryl Polomka
    I voted 'it makes no difference' but I would rather the option have just been 'both'.

    I do both and it really depends on my mood at the time or whether I have come across some good quality PLR that I decide would be good to use, then I would rewrite it.

    If Tiffany has one of her great specials then I will buy any PLR that is in any of my niches and rewrite them - you can't pass her deals up and they are good quality so I know they are worth using. Same thing goes if I see a good PLR deal in the WSO section or something.

    Any other time though I will usually just write my own new articles. So I won't choose either, it really depends on the situation as to whether I'll rewrite or write from scratch. They are both good options if done correctly
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5164596].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Ruth P
    I agree with Sheryl - definitely both.

    The problems you mentioned about poorly written PLR don't really apply to me as I only buy my PLR from select sources that are always high quality. So rewriting is really fast for me, even if I choose to add in a few unique ideas.

    Original content does take longer, but if it's a topic or an angle where no PLR is yet available then that's the only choice I have. And, sometimes, if it's a topic I enjoy then I will just choose to write my own content for it instead of rewriting PLR anyway.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5166259].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dadamson
    It depends on what you are using the article for.

    Articles are used in a variety of different ways and no two ways are the same, this means that either option can attract a different answer.

    For example:

    Website content: Original Content
    SEO purposes: Either
    Press Releases: Original Content.

    etc.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5166295].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author fxstay
    original content is the best way always
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5166777].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author andy moore
    Original always.

    Make bullet points of main information in the article

    Write your own stuff round those points.

    Always better.
    Signature
    http://videotubestation.com How To Get Top Ranking Videos In Google and YouTube - In Days!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167355].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author sbucciarel
    Banned
    I'd just as soon rewrite high quality PLR. Saves me time.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167433].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Barefoot Warrior
      Keith,

      I agree with your view.

      I've tried rewriting existing material and setting up an article for spinning. I don't enjoy doing either and can't imagine ever doing so again.

      I much prefer writing original material, even though it probably involves more time - I haven't yet mastered the Jason Fladlien 7-minute article

      The closest I'd come is to read through some existing articles and structure my article from them, making notes as I read for the different topics to cover. It also requires some work to actually find PLR that is worth rewriting, could be quicker to write your own, than spend the time finding good original material.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167506].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Tricerra
    As a writer I enjoy selling PLR that I have developed. It is easy, quick and is a recurring stream of income from work I have already done.

    However, as I a writer I enjoy creating new content for individual clients as well. It is a part of the creative process, I guess.

    Good PLR that has been rewritten well is good content and usually provides basic info about a subject while original content is usually covers a subject more completely.
    Signature

    The number of ideas to use in content is odd--and 3 is too many.--Timo Everi

    Content to Copy--AdWords to E-Books www.tricerra.com

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167476].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Daniel Wilson
    If PLR is used by 10k other IM'ers I'd rather write original article. But what exactly is original article? There is no way you can be completely original nowadays on the "evergreen" niches - niches that have the highest value.
    Signature


    -25% WF PROMO CODE: "WFPROMO911" (expires on 1.1.2012)
    - High search volume keywords , high CPC keywords, easy to rank keywords
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167496].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author John Coutts
      Originally Posted by Daniel Wilson View Post

      If PLR is used by 10k other IM'ers I'd rather write original article. But what exactly is original article? There is no way you can be completely original nowadays on the "evergreen" niches - niches that have the highest value.
      Yes you can, in the ways that matter. Being original through finding a topic that has never been written about before may be difficult, but finding a new angle on an old topic is still originality.

      You could say it's impossible to write an original song, for example, but fresh songs keep being produced, and we keep listening to them. Articles are really no different as far as originality is concerned.

      John.
      Signature
      Write System - superior web content
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5168486].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author CheapTrafficDude
    I'd say, pick a niche that you know a lot about and could write about for hours or days on end. Nothing is more unique than individual human minds and its "organically" acquired knowledge. You can always amplify on one aspect that you might think is "not useful" but someone, somewhere, might not think the same way.

    For example, I'm a HUGE fanatic of snowmobiling, so I could write articles/content on something as "useless" as choosing the proper lug depth of a track for trail riding. Heck, I could write a couple 500 word articles on something as simple (to me) as lug depth... Lug depth for trail riding, for boondocking, both trail AND deep snow and so forth, the best aftermarket tracks etc. It might sound useles but hey, it's unique content and the almighty G LOVES it!!

    I find PLR to be rehashed articles anyway from the get go; PLR = Posting (my) Lame Research. I find asking someone who knows a lot about your subject to have some great value to it. Make a call, talk to someone who knows tons about the subject or offer to pay them for a 500 word article or an interview, which is well worth it. Many will be happy to help and do it for free! Some just get the gratification that they are helping out and could benefit society. Pay it forward so to say.

    Hope this helps
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167508].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author joekoffi
    Why lots of people go in for PLR is because they are either not good writers or are lazy or don't just have the time. Writing your articles will be the best choice ever given that your articles will be original and unique.
    Signature
    Affiliate Marketing For Bloggers, Revealing unknown killer Affiliate Marketing tricks for Bloggers. Special Discount: WF17
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167538].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Keith Goodrum
    It really depends on whether you come across some quality PLR. When you do find a quality source, it makes rewriting a breeze. I have tried to rewrite some of the free stuff you find around, and it was impossible... Lesson learned the hard way.

    This just goes to show you need to buy PLR from a writer with a solid reputation.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167832].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author nicheblogger75
    I often rewrite PLR, and in the process I get a really good idea of just how bad some of these PLR articles are. That being said, PLR articles are great because they give you an idea of what to write about. I think if you choose to rewrite a PLR artcle, you need to work it out so that the article is at least 75% changed.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5167893].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jhangora
    I voted for writing original articles. I do purchase PLR sometimes, however, they are no match for quality original content. As you pointed out - PLR saves time. Many sides to the equation.
    Signature
    The Real Voyage of Discovery Consists not In Seeking New Landscapes but In Having New Eyes ~ Marcel Proust
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5168160].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Kris79
    It depends of purpose:
    - main money site: original content
    - SEO: depands where will you submit it to: Press release - original, 2nd tier article submission - PLR
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5172870].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author JohnMcCabe
      Originally Posted by CheapTrafficDude View Post

      For example, I'm a HUGE fanatic of snowmobiling, so I could write articles/content on something as "useless" as choosing the proper lug depth of a track for trail riding. Heck, I could write a couple 500 word articles on something as simple (to me) as lug depth... Lug depth for trail riding, for boondocking, both trail AND deep snow and so forth, the best aftermarket tracks etc. It might sound useles but hey, it's unique content and the almighty G LOVES it!!

      Hope this helps
      Even more important, other snowmobile fanatics will love it. I know just enough about the machines from using them to fish in the winter growing up that your example made perfect sense to me.

      It's the same with any truly passionate group. I've spent hours discussing hook sizes, styles and colors with other anglers, and heard golf nuts talking about the shape and depth of grooves on a sand wedge.

      This is the kind of depth that separates the truly expert from the average PLR writer, who would tell potential anglers that they need to tie on one of those curved, sharp things on the end of their string. [PLR writers, if this doesn't apply to you, you are above average. So don't take offense to any of this, please... ]

      Maybe it's my inner control freak talking, but by the time I've done some fact checking on PLR in subjects I'm not knowledgable in, I've done the research to write my own entry level article. And I'm not trying to shoehorn my style into a pre-exissting structure.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5173092].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author angela99
    Keith, I noticed that you're promoting your ghostwriting services in your sig. So why worry about PLR? (Unless you're selling it.)

    "Rewriting" services don't pay well, judging by what you see on the outsourcing sites.

    To my mind, rewriting is editing, and I only enjoy it when I edit my own work. Editing others' work is too stressful for me. You couldn't pay me enough. :-)

    You can make writing original content EASY.

    Here's how:

    1. Keyword research

    Choose keywords which are appropriate for your market and client (when writing for others. Make a list of keywords you're targeting. Focus on ONE primary keyword per article);

    2. Article research

    Always fun. Use Google Books and Amazon, as well as forums. If you're writing for a high-paying market -- $1 a word, you'll use primary research. That is, you'll interview people, make observations, etc. The big difference between low-paying articles and articles which pay more is primary research.

    More on primary research: Purdue OWL: Conducting Primary Research

    Set a time limit on your research, otherwise it can get out of hand. Make notes as you research, this helps you to remember and gets your brain digesting what you've read. You'll find that you're more relaxed if you make notes. I make notes on index cards; I think better with a pen and paper, but that might just be me...

    3. Outline and write in BATCHES

    That is, outline ten or more articles at a time, then draft those ten articles.

    Tomorrow, start writing. You'll find that if you clearly separate left-brain tasks like outlining and the right-brained task of writing, you'll be more creative, and you'll write faster too.

    The day after tomorrow, edit your articles for clarity and flow.

    In a nutshell: forget rewriting. Write original content based on primary research. You'll increase your income, and you'll have a lot more fun too. :-)

    Angela
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5173587].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Keith Goodrum
      Originally Posted by angela99 View Post

      You can make writing original content EASY.

      Here's how:

      1. Keyword research

      Choose keywords which are appropriate for your market and client (when writing for others. Make a list of keywords you're targeting. Focus on ONE primary keyword per article);

      2. Article research

      Always fun. Use Google Books and Amazon, as well as forums. If you're writing for a high-paying market -- $1 a word, you'll use primary research. That is, you'll interview people, make observations, etc. The big difference between low-paying articles and articles which pay more is primary research.

      More on primary research: Purdue OWL: Conducting Primary Research

      Set a time limit on your research, otherwise it can get out of hand. Make notes as you research, this helps you to remember and gets your brain digesting what you've read. You'll find that you're more relaxed if you make notes. I make notes on index cards; I think better with a pen and paper, but that might just be me...

      3. Outline and write in BATCHES

      That is, outline ten or more articles at a time, then draft those ten articles.

      Tomorrow, start writing. You'll find that if you clearly separate left-brain tasks like outlining and the right-brained task of writing, you'll be more creative, and you'll write faster too.

      The day after tomorrow, edit your articles for clarity and flow.

      In a nutshell: forget rewriting. Write original content based on primary research. You'll increase your income, and you'll have a lot more fun too. :-)

      Angela
      Thank you Angela for this 3-step process. I copied and saved it as a reference. This is one of the clearest outlines for writing articles I've come across.

      Outlining and writing in batches is something I have done before, but never as a deliberate strategy. Most of the time, I would approach each article as an individual task. Even if I had several articles centered around related keywords.

      In your experience what is the shortest amount of time you would allow yourself between researching, writing, and editing? Can you run though all three without a break? Or do you feel some time away is needed between each step?

      Keith
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5178730].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author JohnMcCabe
        Originally Posted by Keith Goodrum View Post

        In your experience what is the shortest amount of time you would allow yourself between researching, writing, and editing? Can you run though all three without a break? Or do you feel some time away is needed between each step?

        Keith
        Keith, I'm obviously not Angela, but here's what generally works for me...

        From research to writing, I want at least a couple of hours (if possible) to let the material marinate in my subconscious. Overnight is better.

        From writing to editing requires a minimum of overnight, with two or three days being better. Without the break, I tend to see what I think should be there, rather than what actually appears. And the editing is usually done in two passes, one for style and flow and one for spelling and grammar.

        This is the process for 'serious' articles. For a blog post of a few hundred words, the time can be compressed a lot.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5180616].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author MaryK
    Prefer original content. Research I really enjoy, so no drama with that, don't like editing even my own articles, so that rather rules out PLR. Plus originality always counts as the best.
    Signature
    Mary K Gill Latest book: The Twelve Natural Laws of the Universe - achieve all your desires for less than the price of coffee and cake. P.S. It only fattens your mind, not your thighs.
    Mindset Power Site
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5175932].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Anthony
    I use both. But original content is the way to go
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5176522].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Trivium
    When I go about writing articles, I typically pick a topic that is relevent, and then have a look at several articles that have already been written on that topic - these provide ideas on how to approach the article, and also can often broaden your knowledge on the topic, and introduce new things to think about. I then take the best and most interesting bits from the articles, and try to integrate those into the article that I write. Of course, the actual write up is completely in my own words, but I use the other articles as a scaffold of sorts, and as research material.

    A lot of it comes down to how you approach it. If you write new material based on what you've read, or just edit and reword what's already there, the end results will differ, but its all using the same material and information. It just comes down to how you present it.
    Signature
    Wired Up - Computer guides and software reviews
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5176833].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BlackRob
    To be honest, you could rewrite the PLR article to make it an original article from you, or you could use it as a base to write a 100% original article.

    I guess it just depends on the person who is writing at the time. A lot of PLR articles can have spelling and grammatical errors, but I have found that the content is normally ok, and just needs to be re-written, in other cases, the PLR articles have been of a very low standard as to be unusable.

    So my advice is just get PLR articles from people you trust, and go with your instinct.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5177091].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author PaulSolid
    Banned
    I will vote for writing original articles. if you can't write, then outsource it.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5177141].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Lee Murray
    If it's a topic I am highly familiar with and have an absolute passion for, then I'll write fresh, unique stuff all day.

    If I don't know the topic, then I will use plr AS my research... WHILE I'm rewriting it.

    Buying 10 good-quality articles, provided they don't all cover the exact same aspect of the niche, can really fill up one's own mind with enough knowledge to then take over and write the next 10 or 20 articles "from heart" with little trouble.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5177355].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bajakan
    Every situation is different; for some people, sourcing original articles will make sense, for instance I don't write press releases myself, or at least get a second editor. Otherwise I could compare article writing to writing software and say I can bill way more as a contractor, so I would source any article writing I wanted done. Then again if I'm free on the weekend I might write a couple original articles. So I'd say it is situational
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5181321].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author beckey
    Originally Posted by Keith Goodrum View Post

    Reading the PLR post is dead thread got me thinking - Would I rather rewrite PLR or write an original article?

    The lazy side of me instantly answered - Rewrite PLR. It is easier to take the ideas from an article, and put them into your own words. This is simple to do provided the seed article has a certain level of quality. If it is filled with syntax errors and a mess, then writing from scratch is easier.

    The more I thought about it, the more I realized writing an original article is easier. I like to research a topic, give it some thought, and then see if I can put a unique spin on the subject. It might take a longer to finish an article, but it I like writing this way.

    So, my vote goes to writing an original article.

    What about everyone else?

    Keith
    original article is the best,but it takes too much time.
    So using tools to rewrite articles is another way,which can save much time.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5181996].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author KrisOlin
    Original beats PLR hands down. Always.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5182677].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JCorp
    in my biased opinion I say original content...because that's all we provide
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5183376].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author WebsiteContentSEO
    Depends on time, skill and motivation that you have at your disposal.
    Time: If you are in a hurry to put something up, then use a plr and make some edits to it.
    Skill: If you're not familiar with the subject matter, then use plr to guide you to develop the content.
    Motivation: Some subjects or topics can be boring to one if one is not accustomed to it. So you can grab a plr and start to rewrite it.
    But the best way in my opinion is to do research on the topic and gather all necessary data and then start writing. You'll be amazed at how much quality articles you'll come up with.
    Cheers!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5183426].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author JohnMcCabe
      Originally Posted by WebsiteContentSEO View Post

      Skill: If you're not familiar with the subject matter, then use plr to guide you to develop the content.

      Cheers!
      I keep hearing people say this, usually with the bland surety that the PLR content is actually well researched. While some writers definitely deliver, many more don't. Especially at the lower price points.

      Too many times the "research" consists of scanning a few articles in a directory and assuming that those writers know their stuff.

      If you go charging into a new niche trumpeting your exertise with facts anyone remotely familiar with the subject knows are wrong, you might as well hang it up and look for a new niche.

      If you are going to use PLR as a base, spend a little time doing some fact checking before you end up with egg (or worse) on your face...
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5187719].message }}

Trending Topics