A New Way Some Sneaky Article Writers Use To SCAM You Which Is Almost Impossible To Catch.

30 replies
I would never have come to know about this but it actually happened by accident. I hired an article writer to write me a few articles. I ran a plagiarism test on copyscape and other sites. It passed easily.

But then I started to check the article for any grammar mistakes and it seemed something familiar. In fact very familiar. I thought wait a minute...This is something I wrote.

As I read further I realized that the article writer had copied a few paragraphs from my ebook written by me which is being sold on clickbank. I said wow. So I cancelled the project.

But here is the big issue...How can one catch something like this? I mean we are dealing with paid ebooks here which aren't available freely. I don't know how many article writers are actually doing this and getting away with it right as I type this post but I am not sure if there is a way to track this.

So how does one catch this? Any ideas here?
#article #catch #impossible #scam #sneaky #writers
  • Profile picture of the author MeTellYou
    very interesting. I don't think there is a way to actually catch this unless the person doing it, or people, will go crazy with it and the market just becomes aware of it.

    Thanks,
    Sebastian
    Signature
    [UPDATED] FREE 1-ON-1 MENTORSHIP: Student Makes $12,000 His First Week Of Running Ads
    Skype Me! Skype: yourebookwriter
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[657853].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author mmurtha
    Hey ryanman,

    This isn't something new at all, especially in the IM arena. Matter of fact, it's been going on for some time now. This is why I use the same article writers I've had for some time.

    The best prevention is to write content yourself, and if you absolutely have to outsource, get writers you know and trust to write for you.

    If you catch someone copying other people's work, and trying to pass it off as thier own, expose them for who and what they are.

    That's all you can do.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[657854].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Shakul
    Was on GAF or Elance?

    I think it is very difficult to catch such people...You can only catch them if you have read the ebook from where articles were taken.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[657865].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author ryanman
      Originally Posted by Shakul View Post

      Was on GAF or Elance?

      I think it is very difficult to catch such people...You can only catch them if you have read the ebook from where articles were taken.
      Elance and it's good that I use escrow. And yes you are right! But how can one read every ebook out there? Just not possible. I guess at the moment it is some what impossible.
      Signature


      ^^^Click The "UGLY BANNER" to "MAKE MONEY"^^^
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[657947].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Dan C. Rinnert
        Perhaps Copyscape could offer a service where eBook authors could upload their books (free) and then Copyscape could check submitted content against those eBooks?

        The actual eBooks would not be shown publicly, but, if someone were to submit an article that copied from an eBook, Copyscape would show a message like, "This article contains content copied from _____ by _____."

        If it were free for eBook authors, that might encourage them to upload their eBooks. It also gives them an extra layer of protection, as it would help guard against people copying their content and reselling them as original work, where it could end up even passed around as PLR or whatnot, reducing the value of the eBook.

        And, of course, the benefit to article buyers is that they have a greater opportunity of catching plagiarizers whose work could damage their credibility, or worse.
        Signature

        Dan's content is irregularly read by handfuls of people. Join the elite few by reading his blog: dcrBlogs.com, following him on Twitter: dcrTweets.com or reading his fiction: dcrWrites.com but NOT by Clicking Here!

        Dan also writes content for hire, but you can't afford him anyway.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[657988].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Floyd Fisher
          Originally Posted by Dan C. Rinnert View Post

          Perhaps Copyscape could offer a service where eBook authors could upload their books (free) and then Copyscape could check submitted content against those eBooks?

          The actual eBooks would not be shown publicly, but, if someone were to submit an article that copied from an eBook, Copyscape would show a message like, "This article contains content copied from _____ by _____."

          If it were free for eBook authors, that might encourage them to upload their eBooks. It also gives them an extra layer of protection, as it would help guard against people copying their content and reselling them as original work, where it could end up even passed around as PLR or whatnot, reducing the value of the eBook.

          And, of course, the benefit to article buyers is that they have a greater opportunity of catching plagiarizers whose work could damage their credibility, or worse.
          Yeah, but who would trust copyscape to keep their ebooks out of the wild?

          All it takes is one malicious hack and poof! Millions of ebooks are now compromised.

          See the problem?
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658255].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author sylviad
            Actually, that sounds familiar - submitting your book to be scanned like that. Wish I could remember what situation that was - don't know if it was anything to do with checking plagiarism. The thing is, if that service is doing it, then you make a good point - your books could be in jeopardy of unlawful distribution. Although, it seems to me that particular service was perhaps Amazon? Yeah. That could be it, because they will provide chapters of your book for people to preview before buying.

            So did you nail that guy who plagiarized from your book? I hope you took some action, like reporting them to Elance. If he's doing it to you, he'll do it to others.

            Interesting how you caught it though. It reminds me of the day I was researching info for articles and came across an article that had some good ideas. It was on some guy's site. As I read, I was thinking how good it was and then I saw my own name at the bottom.

            Sylvia
            Signature
            :: Got a dog? Visit my blog. Dog Talk Weekly
            :: Writing, Audio Transcription Services? - Award-winning Journalist is taking new projects. Warrior Discounts!
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658299].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Dan C. Rinnert
            Originally Posted by Floyd Fisher View Post

            Yeah, but who would trust copyscape to keep their ebooks out of the wild?

            All it takes is one malicious hack and poof! Millions of ebooks are now compromised.

            See the problem?
            Good point. Maybe Copyscape should just scan the file sharing sites that already have copies of those eBooks...
            Signature

            Dan's content is irregularly read by handfuls of people. Join the elite few by reading his blog: dcrBlogs.com, following him on Twitter: dcrTweets.com or reading his fiction: dcrWrites.com but NOT by Clicking Here!

            Dan also writes content for hire, but you can't afford him anyway.
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658339].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Steve Sanchez
        That's pretty good, selling you your own stuff. How long had you been buying your own work?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[657991].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author ryanman
          Originally Posted by Steve Sanchez View Post

          That's pretty good, selling you your own stuff. How long had you been buying your own work?
          Lol. This is the first time and hopefully the last time.
          Signature


          ^^^Click The "UGLY BANNER" to "MAKE MONEY"^^^
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658631].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author TheRichJerksNet
    I think your title needs edited as it is directed toward article writers which is not fair to those honest article writers. This person must not be an article writer if he has to copy your own work to create an article, thus why the title of this thread should be changed..

    Would hate to give people the wrong idea about "real" article writers.

    Then again I will never understand why people run to a freelance site full of scams when it is obvious that the warrior forum is full of very talented people.

    James
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658080].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Raydal
    That's a tough one to manage. But quite sneaky on the article writer's
    part though. At least copyscape cannot read paid publications.

    The pittance that most article writers sell their wares for must lead
    to things like these in order to survive. When you think you are
    getting a 'deal' you are getting scammed.

    This is no way justifies dishonesty but at least explains it IMNSHO.

    -Ray Edwards
    Signature
    The most powerful and concentrated copywriting training online today bar none! Autoresponder Writing Email SECRETS
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658336].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author topher
    All I can say is that you were really smart to spot that one, especially as it passed copyscape. I also agree with the point that copyscape could do something about it. However, how about if hackers manage to break into the database and have free access to every book on copyscape? Paid uploaded book ofcourse. Just my thoughts.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658354].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author IMChick
      Well, I guess there's always a way to be dishonest if you have that goal in mind. I don't think there's any way to prevent this. But there are a few things that I would do.

      Number 1: make a big stink on the site you got the writing freelancer from. Post poor feedback and your experience in their profile. If there is a forum for that site, "out" them on it. Not vindictive revenge stuff, but make others aware of your experience.

      Number 2: figure out how to write your own stuff from now on. No more freelancers or outsourcing workers that weren't referred by people you know and trust.

      • Seems like a lot of work? Just think how expensive and time-consuming a lawsuit is going to be when the rightful copyright owner discovers THEIR material on YOUR website.
      • Don't put yourself back in the situation where your business is in jepardy because you (read, your freelancer) scraped articles, ebooks or website content from a copywritten source.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658393].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author mormel
    Hi,

    When everybody would indeed load up their ebooks to Copyscape, a whole range of new problems could arise. What if (some of) these ebooks would be sold as PLR products later? The makers shouldn't forget to mention that to Copyscape, then. Or else some people who would - totaly legitamately - use that PLR content for the creation of a series of articles, would get in serious troubles because they're accused of plagiarism.

    It's more complex than one might think.

    Yours, warriorly, Ed
    Signature

    Get my WSO: The PPC Horizon Report (http://www.warriorforum.com/warrior-...ney-table.html)
    Read Why You PPC'ers Are Leaving Money on the Table!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658770].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author ryanman
      Originally Posted by mormel View Post

      Hi,

      When everybody would indeed load up their ebooks to Copyscape, a whole range of new problems could arise. What if (some of) these ebooks would be sold as PLR products later? The makers shouldn't forget to mention that to Copyscape, then. Or else some people who would - totaly legitamately - use that PLR content for the creation of a series of articles, would get in serious troubles because they're accused of plagiarism.

      It's more complex than one might think.

      Yours, warriorly, Ed
      I completely agree with this...If they started having a database of paid ebooks then it might kill the industry.
      Signature


      ^^^Click The "UGLY BANNER" to "MAKE MONEY"^^^
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658808].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Bob Crawford
        It comes down to a question of whether you want to focus on the people stealing from you or on creating great content.

        The reality is that people steal. They always have and they always will. I believe that your original quality content will win out in the end - especially as you build a recognizable 'voice' that your readers identify with.

        Stay focused on those things that you can control, take the preventative measures that you can, and keep moving forward!

        Peace,
        Bob
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[658888].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author webcopywritersblog
    Banned
    [DELETED]
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660361].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author ryanman
      Originally Posted by webcopywritersblog View Post

      Look, you have to find a writer who believes in creating original content rather than copy from somewhere exactly what has been written! Copying is NOT Creativity! Creativity is an idea that comes into existence in the NOW which had been completely non-existent before!

      I really think if you wanted an article writer who could original content, you require to hire an expert writer! How do you know whether the writer is an expert? ask for past samples, portfolio and check whether the writer has enough experience not re-writing content but writing content that is new, something the reader would find mind blowing and may have never heard of what has been written..

      As deeper you go, you will find that you have to look for people who are creatively versatile, have a flair for making their name and reputation within their target audience, would love to help people genuinely and make BEST USE OF people's most valuable asset(s): their time and space.

      To find an original writer is a big deal and when you find one it will be hard for you to afford one who will be willing to be creative in his/her efforts to provide you with content that is completely new from start to finish! A writer who could write appealing content, capture the reader's imagination, inspire them to act upon the information and post a comment consequently about your article on your website/blog which is what makes him/her as an article writer successfull! Need A Writer, PM me!
      Here is the strange thing. The one I hired had 5 star ratings from several people and has a good history.

      You see the thing is that not all writers write themselves. They further outsource the task and get work done by someone else. So you never know where it's coming from.
      Signature


      ^^^Click The "UGLY BANNER" to "MAKE MONEY"^^^
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660563].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Sandor Verebi
        Said simply: you may not make a lot against the thieves. We have to live together with this, unfortunately. Expedient to devote the time and energy translated to them to writing a new product rather. Causes a less headache at least, I say this from my experience.

        Disappointing?

        It may possible, but it is necessary to decide it, which is the more useful for us. As Bob wrote: "Stay focused on those things that you can control, take the preventative measures that you can, and keep moving forward!"

        Good luck,

        Sandor
        ____________
        ... coming.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660665].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author vistad
    Any one with experience of say 15 years plus in editing will be able to detect changes in style within a document.
    Further, writers have distinctive styles which are almost like signatures. Doing the writing yourself is not a solution, you may need to handle managerial functions.
    You have to put newcomers under the microscope and watch them.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660662].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Hamish Jones
    Originally Posted by Kingpin123 View Post

    try copyscape it detects duplicate content
    I think you may need to read the posts above a little more carefully!

    Signature
    Best Business Deals - The World's Most Customer Focused Telecommunications Company. Servicing Customers in Australia, Canada and the USA.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660711].message }}
  • I used to work for a top level marketer, and I managed his content publishing division. I dealt with the writers under his employ, most of whom were freelancers. The scenerio you provided is one which happened to us a few years ago.

    It taught us a very valuable and expensive lesson.

    Since that event, we have included an indemnity clause in our standard contract for freelance writers (and programmers as well). The indemnity clause binded the freelancers to any liability that would arise from the works they will submit. Such liability may be a consequence of damages caused by plagiarism, delivery of false information, or untruthful remarks that bismirch the reputation of another party.

    Our intention was not to absolve ourselves from all liability arising from the aforementioned possibilities, for such was impossible as we knew that as content publishers, we are responsible for the content we circulate and we should do our own due diligence.

    Our intention was to strongly send a message to the freelancers we hired that unethical and irregular activities will be treated with corresponding severity, so that they would - as they should - extend the professionalism and the honesty demanded by their noble work.

    I am happy to report that it worked.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660721].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author IGotTheNews
    I think that it is hard to tell if someone is plagiarizing something. The best thing to do is have a good memory of what you write. I am new at this and have yet to really get into the whole thing, but in my schooling I have seen many plagiarized papers. If they use quotes and reference, then there is no issue. I think that if one is using your work, it is good to quote it. But I recommend that you have a percentage on what should be original work. I like to write 80% original and 20% reference for my school papers.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660742].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author urbt
    Banned
    As a content writer myself, this puts a bad name to all the honest writers trying to make a living.

    I guess there is no real way to tell until the author of that paid ebook is complaining that you're publishing their content for free.

    Ed
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[660807].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author CmdrStidd
    With all due respect, as an article writer (and a damn good one at that if I do say so myself) I can say that there is a way that you can guarantee that you are getting original stuff from the writer. Ask to see a copy of their research notes that they used to create the article. I always keep my research notes on my articles so if my contractee wants to see them, he or she can. I also use direct quotes from the people I interview or from articles I read in the research phase. Insist on direct quotes as well. This way you are able to see who all they are getting their information from.

    I know I should be able to get as much as 5 cents a word for my work but because of under bidding by cheats like you have had to deal with, I am stuck only getting 2 cents a word, however, I do not lower my standards one bit because of the lower price I have to settle on because I know that sooner or later, the cream rises to the top and the dregs will settle to the bottom and I will start getting paid what I am worth.

    That is my 2 cents worth, well maybe more than that since it is more than one word I wrote here.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[661044].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author ryanman
      Originally Posted by CmdrStidd View Post

      With all due respect, as an article writer (and a damn good one at that if I do say so myself) I can say that there is a way that you can guarantee that you are getting original stuff from the writer. Ask to see a copy of their research notes that they used to create the article. I always keep my research notes on my articles so if my contractee wants to see them, he or she can. I also use direct quotes from the people I interview or from articles I read in the research phase. Insist on direct quotes as well. This way you are able to see who all they are getting their information from.

      I know I should be able to get as much as 5 cents a word for my work but because of under bidding by cheats like you have had to deal with, I am stuck only getting 2 cents a word, however, I do not lower my standards one bit because of the lower price I have to settle on because I know that sooner or later, the cream rises to the top and the dregs will settle to the bottom and I will start getting paid what I am worth.

      That is my 2 cents worth, well maybe more than that since it is more than one word I wrote here.
      Majority of article writers are never willing to share it but this seems like a good idea.
      Signature


      ^^^Click The "UGLY BANNER" to "MAKE MONEY"^^^
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[661083].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Greg Cooksley
      Originally Posted by CmdrStidd View Post

      With all due respect, as an article writer (and a damn good one at that if I do say so myself) I can say that there is a way that you can guarantee that you are getting original stuff from the writer. Ask to see a copy of their research notes that they used to create the article. I always keep my research notes on my articles so if my contractee wants to see them, he or she can. I also use direct quotes from the people I interview or from articles I read in the research phase. Insist on direct quotes as well. This way you are able to see who all they are getting their information from.

      I know I should be able to get as much as 5 cents a word for my work but because of under bidding by cheats like you have had to deal with, I am stuck only getting 2 cents a word, however, I do not lower my standards one bit because of the lower price I have to settle on because I know that sooner or later, the cream rises to the top and the dregs will settle to the bottom and I will start getting paid what I am worth.

      That is my 2 cents worth, well maybe more than that since it is more than one word I wrote here.

      I agree, it's such a pity that real article writers are under seige from these unscrupulous fiends!!!!

      But - you're right about one thing - cream rises to the top - if you're dealing with milk that is!! Scum or dross also rises to the top.....so you better make sure you know if you're in a cesspool or not.....

      Regards

      Greg
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[661942].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author vistad
    You need an idemnity clause in the contract with the writer. Ask for the input documents for the article, usually this will be in soft copy and hard copy. The hard copy will obviously have to be returned.
    Get four or five articles read for consistency in style. If you pay very little some writers are going to squeeze quality, even if they don't blatantly plagiarize. So unless you are facing a crunch...
    Stay with writers whom you know but keep more than you need. This way if one or two drop out you will still have a fallback. Look around for new writers even if you can't give them work you can recommend them to others.

    As for the comment that earlier writers were getting 5 cents a word and now we are getting 2 cents, this plunge began in 2008. A lot of people have moved into writing since then. There are good writers who are getting much less than earlier. Every person who is undercutting is not necessarily a plagiarist.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[663630].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author artwebster
    Very strange that nobody asked how much was paid for these articles.

    The simple fact is that far too many people expect quality articles for a few cents.

    My own writing style and the amount of research I do for my articles means that nobody is prepared to pay a fair rate for the work involved. When I do get a commission to write articles, they are delivered with details of all research sources, (acknowledgements to Authors and Publication). The last articles I wrote were about stoma care and a comparison between internal and external pouches. There were three articles to be used in news letters for the general public and (in 1984) earned me the equivalent of $4700 in today's terms.

    In a generalised topic like Internet Marketing where there is really nothing new to say, all research will tend to produce look-alike copy but if you are only paying $1 to $4 an article, what more could you reasonably expect?
    Signature

    You might not like what I say - but I believe it.
    Build it, make money, then build some more
    Some old school smarts would help - and here's to Rob Toth for his help. Bloody good stuff, even the freebies!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[663658].message }}

Trending Topics