Direct(ish) Marketing Question
I am in a specialized athletic equipment niche. I am currently marketing it through a couple of the tried-and-true IM tactics: forum marketing, guest posting, and some Facebook advertising.
These methods are proving profitable. I am getting a couple sales per day, but when a coach contacted me and ordered 100+ in one fell swoop, I realized that there was an additional avenue of promotion that I had overlooked.
In addition to going after individual sales, I should be devoting energy to procuring team and group orders. It was one of those "d'oh!" moments that are both humbling and confidence-inducing.
How to do this? Contact the coaches and organization heads directly. Being proactive, right?
Over the next few weeks I built up a list of 4,000+ prospects in a spreadsheet. They are mostly coaches, and the principals in the organizations with which they are involved in. In other words, they are the people who control the purse strings.
After crafting a query email, as well as 2 follow-ups (to be scheduled 1 and 2 weeks following the initial query), I wrote personalized emails to 120 of the individuals on the list over the course of a weekend.
I went to bed on Sunday night full of glee and anticipation. While I didn't expect a flood of responses, I found it reasonable to get at least 10-15 responses.
Instead, over the next week, I got one with UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line, and another to explain that the team had recently folded.
I am flirting with the idea of going old school and writing actual letters. Like, with stamps and everything.
Figure that can only improve the open rate, and I suspect that receiving a letter versus an email would imply a tad more seriousness. After all, anybody with a forehead and a keyboard can send an email.
So here is the question(s)....
What would you do? Say f*** it and email the rest of the list? Or go the direct mail approach? Or get all crazy and do both?
Boom.