by mcerny
34 replies
Anyone here using hubpages ? I just discovered it this week, lol.

Is it any good to help get traffic to my websites ? Can you make good money off it ?
#hubpages
  • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
    Banned
    Originally Posted by mcerny View Post

    Is it any good to help get traffic to my websites ?
    Only traffic that you first get to HubPages instead of getting it directly to your website in the first place.

    It's all a big fallacy, really. You're far better off using a page which you yourself own and control. It's easy to imagine that you're getting traffic "from" HubPages when in fact all you're doing is diverting some of your potential traffic "to" HubPages rather than directly to your own site, and eventually getting some of it at your own site. Unless and until your click-through rate from HubPages to your own site is 100%, you'd actually be making a net loss on it.

    The mistake that people make, doing this, is the same as the mistake that people make when they put their articles in Ezine Articles instead of on their own site and imagine that they're generating traffic "from" Ezine Articles. Their "logic" is exactly the same, too. :rolleyes: :p

    I think you're not going to fall for anyone telling you that "your" HubPages page can rank more easily than a page on a site that you yourself own and control and that this confers some advantage, are you? You already know this is nonsense, right? And you don't imagine that the high PR of HubPages own home page is going to help "your" page(s) there to get traffic? We don't need to go all over this nonsense, do we?

    It's exactly the same argument as all the stuff about Squidoo, Blogger, and all the other places where you don't own and control your own pages but are just unnecessarily dependent on a third-party service. I mean, there are a dozen threads here which explain the whole thing and all the fallacious reasoning and misattributed causation arguments involved in these things. I can dig some of them up for you, if you really want. But I think you know better than this, really?

    The short answer is that using HubPages to try to get traffic is better for your business than going out for breakfast and spending the rest of the morning trying on shoes (and in that sense, the people who comment that they did a HubPages site and got some traffic from it may technically be correct!), but it's still "just silly" and based only on fundamental misunderstandings and confusions, when you look at the easier/better/safer ways of doing exactly the same thing.

    The reality is that people do it because they like it, because it's easy, because it's fun, and so on. And you can, technically, make very small amounts of money from it (just not nearly as much as you can make without it!!), so they like to convince themselves that it's a "proper business activity". (Or some are maybe gullible enough never even to question that in the first place). I just hope that all my direct niche competitors will use HubPages as "part of their businesses' traffic-generation/income strategies".
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7941601].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author MP80
      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      Only traffic that you first get to HubPages instead of getting it directly to your website in the first place.
      Um.. You don't need to get traffic to Hubpages.. It's already there, in droves!
      That's kind of like saying you first have to get traffic to WarriorForum, before anyone will click on your signature.

      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      It's all a big fallacy, really. You're far better off using a page which you yourself own and control.
      This is an opinion.. Not a fact; different horses for different courses.

      There is no harm using pages that you don't own/control (eg. Ezine Articles :p, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, WF, whatever..) Just backup your content, and maybe don't put all of your eggs in one basket.

      P.S. It's far easier to get banned from here than it is from Hubpages (imo, and my experience.)

      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      It's easy to imagine that you're getting traffic "from" HubPages when in fact all you're doing is diverting some of your potential traffic "to" HubPages rather than directly to your own site, and eventually getting some of it at your own site. Unless and until your click-through rate from HubPages to your own site is 100%, you'd actually be making a net loss on it.

      The mistake that people make, doing this, is the same as the mistake that people make when they put their articles in Ezine Articles instead of on their own site and imagine that they're generating traffic "from" Ezine Articles. Their "logic" is exactly the same, too. :rolleyes: :p
      This is nonsense.. If you have a website in the IM niche, and then write a post at warriorforum, are you 'diverting some of your potential traffic' to WarriorForum? Of course not. The traffic was already here (not searching for your site in google, lol) and they get to your site by reading something you wrote, and/or getting to 'know' you, before clicking on your signature.

      Likewise.. there are heaps of people already interacting at hubpages, much like there are here at warriorforum (and unlike Ezinearticles.)

      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      I think you're not going to fall for anyone telling you that "your" HubPages page can rank more easily than a page on a site that you yourself own and control and that this confers some advantage, are you? You already know this is nonsense, right?
      At the moment, this appears to be true.. but hasn't always been, until recently.

      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      And you don't imagine that the high PR of HubPages own home page is going to help "your" page(s) there to get traffic? We don't need to go all over this nonsense, do we?
      Apparently we do, as I've noticed your logic regarding PR (especially) and SEO is flawed. But I will save that discussion for another day!

      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      The reality is that people do it because they like it, because it's easy, because it's fun, and so on.
      BINGO! I agree.

      Alexa,

      You know how frustrated you feel when someone gets article directory marketing vs article syndication confused? Lol, that's about how I feel every time I see you give an opinion, presented as a fact, regarding Hubpages (or pr/seo! :p) ..something which you have obviously had little to no experience with.

      I know that you realize Hubpages is not an article directory (..right??) but you seem to think that it is webhosting or something, which it's not!

      It's a community of real, live people.. similar in some ways to facebook, twitter, or warriorforum. For the most part these people aren't typing keywords into google or whatever, they are hanging out at hubpages.com Realizing this fact is the key to making it 'work'.

      What is HubPages?
      HubPages is an open community of passionate people--writers, explorers, knowledge seekers, conversation starters. Interacting and informing. Sharing words, pictures and videos. Asking questions. Finding answers. It's a rich and rewarding experience with a unique set of tools and resources to help Hubbers find and build an audience, easily create articles, and earn all sorts of rewards, from accolades to ad revenue. Over 38 million people explore HubPages every month
      Signature
      Before you do ANYTHING else in your day - do at least ONE thing that brings money into your business.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7942077].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Kay King
        Hubpages can be useful but only if you use them in the way they are meant to be used. If you try to use hubs as only satellites to point to your links, you'll have a problem.

        Hubs requires original content - not copy/past stuff - and you need to severely limit any links you add to other sites.

        You have to focus on building hubs that get good attention from the hub community and most people don't bother to do that when they try hubpages.

        I haven't done any hubs for some time but one of the ones I built was ranked very high by hubpages and that one day of work paid the hosting bills for the site (I had one link to that related site on the hub) for almost two years. Not a lot of money - but quite good when you consider it was for a few hours time on one day.

        kay
        Signature
        Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
        ***
        One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
        what it is instead of what you think it should be.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7942101].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
        Banned
        Originally Posted by MP80 View Post

        Um.. You don't need to get traffic to Hubpages.. It's already there, in droves!
        Not on your pages, it isn't. (Well, I'm using the word "your" too loosely: maybe on yours, if you've attracted it - I mean not on the OP's putative pages, unless he attracts it to those pages).

        That's like saying "you don't need to get traffic to Squidoo because it's already there in droves". Which, indeed, is exactly what you used to say when you and I discussed at some length the same aspect of Squidoo - so you're certainly very consistent.

        It's actually not even very different from saying "you don't need to get traffic to Hostgator because it's already there in droves." The commonality is that there are also a million other pages there, and collectively they have some enormous amount of traffic. So what? How does it help you? Hostgator doesn't pretend to be a "community" like HubPages does? You and I have discussed this at some length before (with regard to Squidoo - but basically the same discussion) and disagreed about that, too. I regret the reality that we're not suddenly going to agree about what's a sensible and reasonable way to run a business just because this thread's labelled "HubPages" instead of "Squidoo".

        Other people's traffic is not your traffic. Yes, you can make some of it your traffic at HubPages if you put effort/energy into doing that. I'd rather attract them to my own site.

        Originally Posted by MP80 View Post

        That's kind of like saying you first have to get traffic to WarriorForum, before anyone will click on your signature.
        No - it really isn't. That's totally different, because people reading the forum get your signature in front of them, on their screens. They don't get your page at HubPages in front of them. The difference is self-evident. For this reason, I think it's mistaken and misleading to compare a forum signature with a page on a hosted Web 2.0 site.

        Originally Posted by MP80 View Post

        There is no harm using pages that you don't own/control
        I didn't say there was.

        I even said it's more help to your business than going out for breakfast is.

        I also said that it makes more sense, in the long run, to use instead a page which you do own/control. And I'm still saying that, because it still does. :p

        Originally Posted by MP80 View Post

        I know that you realize Hubpages is not an article directory (..right??)
        "Realize" it? I'm the person here who regularly and reliably points it out, about 5 times per week, to others who post every day of the week offering advice about article marketing, without themselves understanding what an article directory is.

        Originally Posted by MP80 View Post

        It's a community of real, live people.. similar in some ways to facebook, twitter, or warriorforum.
        That's stretching "in some ways" beyond recognition or significant meaning, IMO.

        I've stopped using HubPages, myself. (I never used it as much as I used Squidoo, to be honest). And like many who do that, I do better without it than I did with it. I'm happy for you if you're making it work, but I'd suggest that anyone thinking of starting to use it should think very carefully, especially about the potential alternatives which cost no more (i.e. they're equally "free of charge") and can work out so much better, and so much more securely, in the long run. I appreciate, sadly, that you probably don't agree with this perspective.

        By the way, how long before HubPages does this, for exactly the same reason that Squidoo has just done it: http://www.warriorforum.com/adsense-...-nofollow.html ? Maybe better, wiser and safer to use pages you own and control, where you get to decide whether the links are no-follow?

        But I have to agree with you that there isn't necessarily any intrinsic harm in using pages you don't own and control, though I think (to put it very politely) that it's a disinctly sub-optimal approach and an entirely unnecessary thing to do, and that it's highly foreseeable that other options would be a far better use of one's time/effort/energy. Where are we going for breakfast?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7942268].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author MP80
          Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

          I've stopped using HubPages, myself. (I never used it as much as I used Squidoo, to be honest). And like many who do that, I do better without it than I did with it. I'm happy for you if you're making it work, but I'd suggest that anyone thinking of starting to use it should think very carefully, especially about the potential alternatives which cost no more (i.e. they're equally "free of charge") and can work out so much better, and so much more securely, in the long run. I appreciate, sadly, that you probably don't agree with this perspective.
          I do agree, actually, that anyone thinking of starting to use it should think very carefully and weigh up their options (my profile doesn't say Devil's Advocate for nothing. ) Fwiw, I was always the opposite.. Never could get excited about Squidoo really, but found Hubpages easy and intuitive to use.

          As with anything though, people need to consider what they want to get out of it first, and whether or not it is the right vehicle for them. Personally, I am more focused on Kindle and Crowdfunding, because I believe that these offer greater potential and are more suited to my interests and personality. But, for many people, Hubpages will provide what they are looking for and/or can be used as part of a larger strategy.

          Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

          By the way, how long before HubPages does this, for exactly the same reason that Squidoo has just done it: http://www.warriorforum.com/adsense-...-nofollow.html ? Maybe better, wiser and safer to use pages you own and control, where you get to decide whether the links are no-follow?
          This was probably a great move on their part, imho.. and most users at Hubpages probably wouldn't care about such things (other than for the possible benefits that it provides their hubs) because they are more interested in building relationships.

          I agree with you anyway, that using Hubpages, or any other site, purely for seo has its minuses.

          Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

          Where are we going for breakfast?
          I know a great place.
          Signature
          Before you do ANYTHING else in your day - do at least ONE thing that brings money into your business.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7944041].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
            Banned
            Originally Posted by MP80 View Post

            This was probably a great move on their part, imho..
            Yes, I agree.

            I was just slightly annoyed with Ezine Articles, who had a really good opportunity to do the same thing in 2011 (when they were making other changes anyway), and even discussed it with their authors ... only to decide, after all, not to make all their links "no-follow". :p :rolleyes:

            Still, it goes to show: anyone can make a mistake.
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7944799].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author YellowGreenMedia
    Originally Posted by mcerny View Post

    Anyone here using hubpages ? I just discovered it this week, lol.

    Is it any good to help get traffic to my websites ? Can you make good money off it ?
    Yes it is, but they are getting tougher on the hubs you publish, also the link is no follow until your account has gained reputation.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7941675].message }}
  • {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7941917].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author MakeMoneyKid
      I agree. Even I wasted a whole lot of time. HP is not recommended for the effort you need to put in.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9986149].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author anshukr06
    I have used hubpages for getting good traffic and natural search engine ranking of keywords for website.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7941935].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author MP80
    Originally Posted by mcerny View Post

    Anyone here using hubpages ? I just discovered it this week, lol.

    Is it any good to help get traffic to my websites ? Can you make good money off it ?
    If you are looking for traffic from google.. Then [at the moment] I have to :p agree with Alexa, in that hubpages probably won't provide you with much benefit over your own site.

    However, if you are looking for traffic from hubpages, then it's easy, and doable. As with everything, you first need to look at what people using the site want.

    For the most part, people at Hubpages are interested in:

    Writing
    Sharing experiences/knowledge
    Forming relationships with other users.
    Getting advice
    Making a few $$$ on the side.
    Getting paid for their writing.
    Reading/Being entertained
    etc...

    As a general rule, they are not usually interested in running and maintaining their own site. They are, however, interested in getting more vistors to their pages, and learning how to monetize them.

    So, based on the above, you could promote:

    Anything to do with publishing on kindle
    Writing courses/advice
    Coaching
    SEO tips (whitehat, of course)
    Various traffic methods
    Sites that pay you to write
    Great books that you have read
    etc...

    Since hubpages users are looking for authentic connections, there is no use spamming, hard selling, and/or making stuff up. In short, be genuine, and know your subject matter.. preferably speak from experience.

    It also goes without saying that you need to write entertaining and informative hubs, aka quality content.

    HOW TO GET TRAFFIC AT HUBPAGES:

    Ask and Answer a lot of questions
    Publish new hubs
    Participate in the forums
    Read and learn from advice
    Read and follow Hubpages TOS

    The more that you interact, the more people will visit and read your stuff.
    For example.. When you answer or ask a question, a lot of people will click through to see who you are, and what you write about. If you target the questions/answers in your niche, you will get targeted traffic; people who are interested in that area.

    Make sure that you 'Follow' people that you find interesting. When you follow someone, maybe two thirds of the time they will follow you back. Then, every time you publish a new hub, your followers willl recieve an email to notify them. This is instant traffic, without the need for your own mailing list.

    Your hubs will also be featured/promoted internally, throughout the site.

    These are just my opinions and thoughts on the subject.. Hope it helps steer you in the right direction (for you.) If I think of anything else I will add it later.
    Signature
    Before you do ANYTHING else in your day - do at least ONE thing that brings money into your business.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7944077].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author beaddve
    Seriously, I am so satisfied with Hubpages. I have been using it for over a year. The website is not for people building links. "HubPages is your online space to share your advice, reviews, useful tips, opinions and insights with hundreds of other authors. " I make lots of grammar mistake in writing but users and contributors of Hubpages still approve and feature my writing. I think it is one of the most friendly websites.

    If you write articles and have one or two anchor text link back to your site, that is fine to Hubpages. But you need to have quality content and consistently write some articles.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8374521].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Randall Magwood
    Hubpages frowns on squeeze pages and landing pages that links to sales pages and squeeze pages. If you want to make money with Adsense, Ebay, or Amazon.... it can be a lucrative proposition - assuming if you promote your hubs, attract followers, and provide excellent content.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8374563].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author AaronBurton
    I made like $15 on that site so far. Been like 6 months lol. I stopped making hubs tho. If you make 10 hubs a day you can make decent money. Its a lot of work tho. You can make more money doing other things which is why I stopped.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9849352].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author art72
    Arrrrghhh... typed out a deep and powerful message as to 'why' I only have one Hub Page published (*which remains in top 3 on page 1 of Google...

    But the short version is Lexy (Alexa Smith) amongst several other well-informed writers steered me clear of wasting time with most of my SEO efforts after the person whom I was taking advice from suggested spinning articles and I asked a question about article spinning software...that was 4 years ago!!!

    My one hub was used as a buffer... I wrote a unique and informative article around an SEO based affiliate product, created a link to my .com site with an even more compelling review, and sent the traffic to the product owners landing page... Naturally, a lead capture (squeeze) page.

    There to a wrote 3 more unique reviews on the same product on weebly, blogger, a d webs...never did get around to creating a lens on Squidoo tho.

    Long story short, each review I wrote rests on page 1 of Google, and for most keywords regarding this product... I hold 3-5 slots all on page one til this day...again 4 years later.

    I've since had these articles ripped off by idiots, blog scrapers, spun versions, etc... And have actually been outranked on page one by my own stolen and spun up version of one or more of these reviews.

    Hours spent issuing DMCA's having the stolen materials removed ( fearing they were stealing my affiliate commissions and cause it pissed me off!!!)

    Then, my Hub vanished from Google altogether...all of a sudden the 3 links (1 in the opening sentence, one in a banner image, and 1 in the closing sentence was suddenly deemed 'overpromotional' by HubPages and un-Published (after holding firm on page 1 of Google for 3 years!.. whereby, I reduced it to 1 link at the end of my Hub, and 10 days later back on page one it was!

    Now for the clincher... I was a noob with no clue how to make money online. Obviously, for a first attempt this might seem a homerun considering I've made roughly $270 to date in aff commissions for my reviews/articles which took maybe 5 hours to write.

    But, the product landing page determined my referrals... Which totaled 1000+ people who opted-in to the product creators list (not my list....his!!!)

    My aff commission is $27.

    In total my Hub on page 1 of google generated 14 sales (in 4 years) of which 4 people refunded!

    I spent hours building a WP site with a .com name centered around the product..., yes, it paid for itself... But there to I built a free blogger page, a free webs page, and a free weebly page...almost all of which are also someone on page 1 for their specific keyword included in the 1 unique article I wrote for each free web property...like Hub Pages.

    I was being told by a so-called SEO guru these were 'buffer' sites and would drive traffic to my website, and build quality backlinks...that was only partially true.

    Yes, i got some traffic, made a few sales, even made a little bit of money...but if you look at the time I spent writing, building free web properties, chasing down thieves who scraped, stole, or used my articles (*some of which even landed page 1 rankings along with the original work it was stolen from) hours srnding DCMA's and the fact I gave a vendor 1000+ email subscribers to market to in the future... And Hub Pages removing my published works after 3 years due to 'over-promotional' linking

    Take Lexy's advice...there are much better ways to utilize your time and writing efforts than trying to build a rep or trickles of traffic from Hub Pages, Blogger, or sites that do little by way of serving themselves for your writing efforts.

    Heck, save time, energy, and money and either buy traffic or step in front of targeted traffic, and make sure your readers optin to your list...not someone elses.

    Prob got a bit off the topic with my rant, but I'd hate to see anyone put in the time and effort I did only to have page one articles produce such minuscule results over a four year span.

    Thanks to Alexa and others here... I learned NOT to listen to SEO guru's who think gaming google is a winning proposition. In my personal experience, its a big waste of time and there are much more reliable forms of traffic than using HubPages or any SEO outside of obtaining quality/relevant backlinks and some basic on-page SEO.
    Signature
    Atop a tree with Buddha ain't a bad place to take rest!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9849714].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author DWolfe
      Originally Posted by art72 View Post

      Then, my Hub vanished from Google altogether... (after holding firm on page 1 of Google for 3 years!.

      Thanks to Alexa and others here... I learned NOT to listen to SEO guru's who think gaming google is a winning proposition. .

      First off no Surprise here, and would caution others who put a lot of time and effort into something and watch it vanish. I use to like hubpages and Squidoo, but learned the hard way. Spent 1/2 a day on a Saturday building a hub about fuel mileage. Took pictures with a camera of tire pressures on my own vehicle. Used the tire information from the owners manual about air proper inflation. I than took photos of the inside tire guide pressure label on the door post. Went to the EPA website and used the information from there. Made sure information was quoted and rewritten. It was up for two years. Than one day out of the blue, hubpages sent a letter saying the hub had been removed for duplicate content ??? My camera, my time and efforts vanished !


      I would never waste time trying to game google it is not worth the effort, at least one person here lost his entire business depending on Google. It's not worth the effort to see a business gone in an instant. Thanks for Sharing above.


      On another note: The last post was 2 years ago on this thread was two years ago.Untill the poster above you gave his .50 of information.
      Signature


      You can earn 10% average annual returns on your investments - https://app.groundfloor.us/r/m2aa7b
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9851649].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author FreedomBlogger
    Hubpages are a great site for real writers online.

    You can definitely build something good by following exactly what the trainings and tutorials you find teaching you how to do it.

    It will take a lot of time and effort but the results are the ones you read about.

    I would recommend you to do more research on how others are doing it. I have seen a lot of good information out there. You should also invest in some good trainings about this and just do it!!

    You can earn from the revenue you generate using their platform!!

    I hope this helps!

    cheers!
    Signature
    At the beginning, I thought making money online with a blog was super super hard. Not anymore. Learn the art of making money online blogging - step by step - HERE.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9849870].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
      Banned
      Originally Posted by FreedomBlogger View Post

      Hubpages are a great site for real writers online.
      No - this is just wrong: it's actually a terrible site for "real writers" online.

      Just read post #15 above, carefully, and think about it!

      Originally Posted by FreedomBlogger View Post

      You can earn from the revenue you generate using their platform!!
      But not nearly as much as you can earn from the revenue you generate using your own platform, and you get no real advantage at all from using theirs. (You only imagine you do.)

      It depends what you compare it with, arguably. It's true that you can earn more revenue there than you can earn by painting your toenails, but less revenue (and far less securely!) than you can earn by doing something sensible instead.

      All the points made in this post apply to Hubpages just like they apply to other Web 2.0 sites.


      .
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850226].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Lightlysalted
    I've used hubpages in the past for many years. In my opinion you get paid a fraction of what you would have earned if you had set up your own site/blog and posted your high quality unique content there. That's not to say that there is no benefit but ust it for shorter articles that then feed back to your main site with high quality content.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9849883].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author PriyankaMehta
    Well, according to me, Hub page is one of the best ways to get the a lot more traffic on your website. I have used it many times. At the initial stage, it generates the no follow link, but after sometime, it generates the do follow links and attract the visitors towards your website.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850250].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
      Banned
      Originally Posted by PriyankaMehta View Post

      Well, according to me, Hub page is one of the best ways to get the a lot more traffic on your website.
      It really isn't, I'm afraid, Priyanka. It's rather a confusing and deceptive appearance, I know. It's all too easy to see that you're collecting traffic on your website from your HubPages page, and not quite to appreciate that what you're actually seeing there is the residue of traffic that you've generated and sent to the wrong place, and some of it has been lost there: the visitors you successfully get from it are part of a group all of whom could have been visitors directly to your own site, instead, if you had gone about things a little differently.

      So the traffic you are generating, in that way, actually has quite some "opportunity cost" attached.

      Not the easiest of things to understand, and it's misled a lot of people, but it's exactly the same mistake that people make when they try to generate traffic "from" article directories (as they see it). Most of that traffic doesn't really come "from" article directories or Web 2.0 sites at all: it actually comes via article directories and/or Web 2.0 sites (and some of it is lost en route, because nobody has a 100% CTR).

      Unfortunately, this is one of the things that makes it so difficult to explain to people why what looks like "gaining something" really isn't at all, when you compare it with other, better alternatives, and different ways of doing the same thing.

      Again, this post will perhaps help you, if you read through it (and all its links) mentally substituting the word "Hubpages" wherever it (and they) say "Squidoo": the principles and realities are exactly the same.

      (Post 15 of this thread, just above, may also help you.)

      Good luck, good wishes and welcome to the Warrior Forum.


      .
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850265].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author art72
    While HubPages might be a good platform for writers to gauge their abilities, it reminds me of how a similar site (Helium) worked. Writer's there submitted articles to chosen titles (usually co taining a keyword or subject matter concentrated on a specific niche audience). Anyway, Helium clearly stated in their TOS that You (the writer) held no ownership over the articles once submitted to their website.

    The 'concept' was simple; the more articles you write a d have approved for submission... The more money you could make. They paid a percentage of the adsense revenue generated in each article, and if you properly jumped through all their rings of fire (like You had to rate other peoples articles to get paid or You'd essentially forfiet your portion of the adsense revenues generated from your work!)

    Naturally, you were allowed to have a short 'bio' on your profile page, so you could have an external link to your website or social profile pages and (if done properly) get a trickle of traffic from people who liked/respected your writings or message. SoYes, there was a payoff for using their platform.

    But... I think what matters here is getting your writing/information in front of targeted buyers, and exposure to your efforts...not Helium's or HubPages, etc.

    I simply didn't know any better...and I had written roughly 200+ articles on Helium and earned a whopping $5.73 from my portion of the adsense revenues.

    However, (and I am not sure if HubPages works in similar context) - I realised exactly what Helium and similar sites were doing...they had aspiring (and some well rounded hobbyists) filling their website with content...so they could mass promote those written materials through 'other' media portals and in essence - get rich off the unsuspecting souls who just didn't know any better.

    Imagine if you had a web property that invited writers to submit articles...they release their ownership rights over to you in exchange for a tenth of your adsense revenues...and if you were savvy (as Captain Jack would say) - you could syndicate, sell, publish, or use those written materials in any manner You deemed fit...You'd better bet you'd be banking some serious 'booty'... Booty you looted and pirated from the efforts of unknowing 'wannabe' authors or even those who just wanna get recognized and gauge their works.

    To answer the OP's question...no, Hubpages and the likes is not profitable. I don't think it's wrong to use these resources as a place to get your bearings and learn to be a better writer or internet marketer. I'm not saying they don't offer a great free service or wonderful community of writers...what I am saying (as is Alexa) is you are 'giving away too much' in respect to your efforts. Certainly don't make it a primary source
    to wit your income derives.

    Clearly, you must appreciate that 'giving your work away' never pays well, and most people here are looking for full-time income to quit their job(s) not merely create another one.
    Signature
    Atop a tree with Buddha ain't a bad place to take rest!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850531].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Randall Magwood
    They wont let me link to a squeeze page or sales letter. So the only thing that's left is to write content and try to make money from Adsense or Amazon (or whoever else they have)... and cross-link to other hubs that you have, and have interactive conversations with the commenters that you attract. Worthless to me if you're trying to use it for your website... for traffic.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850576].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author schttrj
    Okay, here's someone who has been talking with HubPages account users for a long time.

    And after all these years, I can tell you a few things from my experience.

    Pros of HubPages

    1. Traffic - Getting organic traffic to your HubPages was easier a few years ago. But now, it might not be that easy. Having said that, it might still be easier to optimize it with a couple of links, since thought the page authority might be low, the domain authority is still high. So, it can be expected that it will garner organic traffic faster than your newborn website might.

    2. Hub Users - If you engage in HubPages forum activity and provide value, you can gain lot of support and links from the other users. What that means is, you will gain exposure through your Hub Network. So, if you get popular and another HubPages writer links to your article, the viewers of that article will come to your article as well.

    3. Side Income - Although very small, it might still lead to passive income over time. I am not saying you will be earning in three digits right away. But after maybe 10-20 solid in-depth hubs, you will gain traction from HubPages promotional service only. At least, that's what data says. Now, it might take even shorter or longer than that.

    Cons of HubPages

    1. Brand Development - You will not have any significant brand development of your business. You are just another HubPages content creator. And if you want to build your website alongside writing for HubPages, it's way too much work. Good luck to you on that. It's been seen that social media users will promote your website with a brand, rather than a HubPages article.

    2. Traffic - When you are building traffic for HubPages, you are not building any for your site. Moreover, when you are SEO'ing the HubPages article, you are eating into the organic traffic that might have landed on your website.

    3. Blogging - Now, to add to the above points, it's way much work blogging in itself. Don't go searching "Highest Earning Bloggers" on Google and think that you will rake in $1500/day just like they do. It's too much work. I run a blog myself, so I know. Yes, although a blog can be a good way to showcase your expertise in a particular niche, it is highly likely that you will not be earning big from it anytime soon. (Unfortunately!)

    Now the decision is on you, my friend.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850704].message }}
  • Yes, it can be good, however don't overcrowd it with links.

    And add value..
    Signature

    [CENTER][B]==> Do you want to make money online? [/B]
    Free video: How regular people are making 6-figures per month on the internet! [URL="http://www.clkmg.com/fc27/UDCL-IN2WF"][B]Watch this free video now![/B][/URL] <==[/CENTER]

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850873].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
      Banned
      Originally Posted by selfdisciplineacademy View Post

      Yes, it can be good, however don't overcrowd it with links.

      And add value..
      Heaven forbid that you should ever take the trouble actually to read a thread before putting in your fatuous, nonsensical, misguided, one-line reply to it. But no, of course not: you wouldn't be able to reach your signature-exposure target of making 20 nonsense-posts in 20 minutes, if you ever actually paused to read anything here, would you?


      .
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850876].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author DABK
        Let's do it this way:

        You have a bakery store.

        Do you put an ad in the paper and give the address of your store?

        or

        You put an ad in the paper and put the address of a restaurant nearby that sells dinners and bakery items and arrange with the owner that every bill he gives should have your address at the bottom?

        Think it through and tell me: which method would get more visitors to the bakery assuming the ad was seen by the same number of people?

        In other words,

        People, people, people: get people to your goddamn store, if you want to sell them something.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850979].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author TheProductReviewGuy
    Banned
    Hubpages is a god send. I use it for many purposes. I use it to rank my micro niche sites on Google and also earn decent money from it using Amazon and Adsense. From all my hub articles, I'm earning $400 a month on autopilot doing absolutely nothing but trying to rank my sites.

    I use it only for web 2.0 link building but you can make money from it too. $400 a month may not be a lot but since you don't have to do anything except publish an article, it's golden.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9850997].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author art72
      Originally Posted by TheProductReviewGuy View Post

      Hubpages is a god send. I use it for many purposes. I use it to rank my micro niche sites on Google and also earn decent money from it using Amazon and Adsense. From all my hub articles, I'm earning $400 a month on autopilot doing absolutely nothing but trying to rank my sites.

      I use it only for web 2.0 link building but you can make money from it too. $400 a month may not be a lot but since you don't have to do anything except publish an article, it's golden.
      So which is it...

      You ARE making $400 per month on autopilot from your hubs? -Or- you believe you can make money from HubPages exclusively?

      Seems a bit of a contradition rests within your claims.

      And from the humoring nature of protecting warriors for a whole 31 days... ( via your signature) I'd be inclined to believe the latter of your claims...despite several testimonies here that suggest your not building viable links or making money!

      If anything, you might get some organic search traffic.
      Signature
      Atop a tree with Buddha ain't a bad place to take rest!
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9851496].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author schttrj
      Originally Posted by TheProductReviewGuy View Post

      Hubpages is a god send. I use it for many purposes. I use it to rank my micro niche sites on Google and also earn decent money from it using Amazon and Adsense. From all my hub articles, I'm earning $400 a month on autopilot doing absolutely nothing but trying to rank my sites.

      I use it only for web 2.0 link building but you can make money from it too. $400 a month may not be a lot but since you don't have to do anything except publish an article, it's golden.
      Well, I would like to see your hubs.

      Can we see it?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9851654].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author katherineolga
    I think the real harm in using Hubpages for either traffic or making money is when it's the ONLY thing that someone has going on.

    Yes, for a long term plan, relying on sites like this, can get us into trouble.

    Using it for a short term plan, such as using it to learn how to perform effective keyword research, getting some traffic to your site, or making some extra cash, is fine.

    With that being said, I've not had that much luck with it on all three counts, but I know people who have.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9851048].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Walter Parrish
    all I can do is LOL

    Signature
    Use Feeder Sites, Articles, And Social Media Sites To Generate Unstoppable Traffic, FREE! Click Here Now To Get It For FREE
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9851767].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author turboshandy
    Making money or gaining traffic from hubpages is not impossible, but it's not easy either.
    If you have the time and the will, you could try it out and see how it goes, but don't expect too much from them too soon
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9851980].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author srp0987
    I only tried to use them briefly, but did not care for my experiences with them. In terms of content, it seems that you're frequently subjected to the collective idea of what "good" content is instead of just being able to put out what you want. I love the idea of being able to write about whatever you want, but the rating system puts a damper on that.

    Plus, they recently took down my most popular post for a few weeks, claiming it was plagiarized, which it certainly was not. Recently I got an e-mail saying that it was their mistake and a lot of pages were falsely flagged as plagiarized, including mine, and now these pages were put back up. It's good that they realized their mistake, but that kind of thing can be avoided when you control your own content publication. In the meantime, I lost out on traffic while that post was sort of hot on a social media site I posted it to. I'm not impressed with them, generally.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9986513].message }}

Trending Topics