It's All Over for Minnesota Amazon Affiliates

by Tom Ryan 62 replies
Just got the email from Amazon this morning that because of the recent tax legislation that just passed MN amazon associate accounts will be terminated as of June 30th.

Yup, that pretty much stinks. I have a number of sites that use amazon. My one main site that I build a list in also using Amazon quite extensively because they have all the products that my subscribers use.

I guess I'm going to have to figure out what my option are from here.
#main internet marketing discussion forum #affiliates #amazon #minnesota
  • Profile picture of the author flipfire
    Could you not create a LLC or a company based in a city that accepts amazon affiliates and then paid through the company?

    I'm not actually sure how it works over in the US, i'm sure some other warriors will give a bit more of an explanation on setting up a company.

    Regards,

    Lee
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187108].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Marc Rodill
    Without knowing more, I see two options. You could sell digital products to them. That depends on your market of course. If they don't buy those types of products, you can try pitching them and see what happens and how they respond. Will require salesmanship.

    Also, while you may not be able to be an affiliate, you could acquire the products yourself and sell them as a vendor from Amazon. The good news is you'll make more money. The bad news is you'll have to manage inventory and acquisition costs, returns, etc. Depends on your budget and desire to go down that path obviously but it can be scaled. But I'm pretty sure Amazon will do a lot of the legwork on fulfillment for you.

    There are other options out there of course, but those come to mind.

    Marc

    PS. Like flipfire said, you could create a Nevada corporation that holds your LLC then you and Amazon will be taxed according to that state. There are several other states too that will give you a level of privacy similar to Nevada too. Leave it up to the government and taxes to ruin a good thing.
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187117].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Daniel Elss
      "We are writing from the Amazon Associates Program to notify you that your Associates account will be closed and your Amazon Services LLC Associates Program Operating Agreement will be terminated effective June 30, 2013. This is a direct result of the unconstitutional Minnesota state tax collection legislation passed by the state legislature and signed by Governor Dayton on May 23, 2013, with an effective date of July 1, 2013. As a result, we will no longer pay any advertising fees for customers referred to an Amazon Site after June 30 nor will we accept new applications for the Associates Program from Minnesota residents"
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187455].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author CurtisSWN
        Dayton is a rich liberal idiot, of course, buying his way into office with Dayton-Hudson-Target wealth. But it's just another way for the middle class to pay for the super-rich lifestyles.
        Signature
        Simple Two Step Formula
        Earns Me Over $146.72 in 12 Hours. This is Weird, But it Works!
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187717].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author chow
          Just got the email too. I have so many sites that are running on the amazon associates program. This sucks!
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187800].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author NewParadigm
          Originally Posted by CurtisSWN View Post

          Dayton is a rich liberal idiot, of course, buying his way into office with Dayton-Hudson-Target wealth. But it's just another way for the middle class to pay for the super-rich lifestyles.

          and the bipolar libiot Dayton just raised MN taxes RETROACTIVE back to Jan 1 up to 9.85%. Nearly 10% state tax!!! 4th highest taxed state in the country.
          Signature

          In a moment of decision the best thing you can do is the right thing. The worst thing you can do is nothing. ~ Theodore Roosevelt "Trust, BUT VERIFY" ~ Ronald Reagan

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8315300].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JSProjects
    Seems to be happening fairly frequently. I agree with flipfire and would look at creating a LLC somewhere.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187814].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Mandi
    You could try finding sponsors through Commission Junction advertising your niche products as an alternative and push your traffic to their store instead. A lot of CJ sponsors pay a higher commission rate than Amazon, and if your content is good enough to convert browsers to buyers, you won't need the power of Amazon to help you finish the sale.

    Another alternative is skimlinks.com - I haven't used them before, but from what I understand, you can convert your Amazon links to skimlinks and get a flat 6% commission on your Amazon product sales without having to change too much on your site. This is a bonus for small sellers who don't reach the 7-30 products shipped tiered Amazon commission structure in the first place to boost commissions, but it'd be a bit of a reduction in your profits otherwise. However IMO, 6% is better than 0%. So the benefit here is sending your traffic to the same place as before, but getting your commission check from another source for the same sales.

    Regards,
    Amanda
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187854].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author wesawu
    No need to worry. Set up a single member LLC in a state that is Amazon friendly and open a bank account in that state. You will also need an office address in that state also. You can open a PO Box in that state and then use the USPS forwarding service for a few months, at least until you get the Amazon Key in the mail. You can then notify Amazon of the new LLC and address and have them reinstate your account. All payments will go to your out state bank account. You can then write yourself a check from that account! Of course you will have to file state tax returns in whichever state you start the LLC. As long as you are the only member in the LLC, you don't have to file a separate federal tax return for the LLC since all income/expense flows thru to your ss#.
    Signature
    Get 50% Off on High Quality PLR - Use Coupon Code: WSO50
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187884].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Lori Kelly
    Wow that stinks.

    Nevada is a good state to set up an LLC. There's no state income tax in that state so no state tax return is filed. A tax return for the LLC is filed on the federal level and then your personal return filed, you will claim any earnings from your LLC on your personal return.

    I don't know about forming LLCs or corporations in other states, but I was registered agent in Nevada for over a decade. You can do the filing on your own (online) and that will save you money.

    You will need a registered agent in Nevada, find one that also offers the business address and mail forwarding. There are many agents who will also help you set up a bank account so you won't even have to leave the comfort of your own home.

    It will take a while, but at least you can get back in the game.

    Good luck and again, sorry to hear about this. It's like someone punches you in the gut.
    Signature
    Learn Website Tips, How to Do Keyword Research, & How to Write Killer Content.
    Stop Wasting Time.
    Start Living Your Dream.
    Click Here NOW to Get Your Hands on
    One of the Most Valuable Ebooks Ever!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187905].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RogueOne
    Just to be fair, there is more to this email:

    While we oppose this unconstitutional state legislation, we strongly support the federal Marketplace Fairness Act now pending before Congress. Congressional legislation is the only way to create a simplified, constitutional framework to resolve interstate sales tax issues and it would allow us to re-open our Associates program to Minnesota residents.


    We thank you for being part of the Amazon Associates Program, and look forward to re-opening our program when Congress passes the Marketplace Fairness Act.
    Signature
    How To Make $10,000 Per Month, "Working" Only 2 Hours Per Day! Download The 2017 "Profit Blueprint"
    For Free (Over 150,000 People Have Already Downloaded It!) Get The Blueprint Now! >>>
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187912].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Tom Ryan
    While I'm not absolutely killing it with Amazon, I am still contemplating forming an llc in another state. I might wait to see how sales ramp up as my sites grow before I do that, which leads me to the other option...

    In the meantime I may very well use a site like skimlinks or viglink, which will share the commissions.

    So, all is not lost, there are options.
    Signature


    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8187950].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Kay Elliott
      Just received my email from Amazon. I saw a previous comment in this thread about selling digital products instead. Good suggestion, but that won't work either. MN's new sales tax law includes digital products. See Star Tribune article: Ringtones, digital books, business repairs will soon be taxed in Minn. _ with a few catches | StarTribune.com

      They also just passed a gift tax law (second state to have one). The law excludes spouses giving gifts to each other. (Wasn't that thoughtful?) The gift tax also excluded political contributions. (Even more thoughtful.)

      I love Minnesota, but it may be time to move.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188137].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author GforceSage
    Any friends or relatives in other states that could help get you set up there?

    Once it appears that you are operating from a different locale, you can keep rolling.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188181].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author teresarothaar
    If you want to set up a corporation, look to set it up in Delaware. This state is very corporate-friendly. Additionally, there is no sales tax here.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188189].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author schnisz
    Yep, same thing happened to us in California. I had myself all set up with an out of state relative when the state came to an agreement and everything was restored. for now. Hope that happens for you guys. Mobilize!!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188203].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author midwestmedia
      Originally Posted by schnisz View Post

      Yep, same thing happened to us in California. I had myself all set up with an out of state relative when the state came to an agreement and everything was restored. for now. Hope that happens for you guys. Mobilize!!
      How exactly did that all shake out? What was used as the reason to restore everything?

      I'm in Minnesota and can probably expect to be dropped from other programs too now, correct? I've been checking for emails from other companies/networks but so far, I think Amazon is the first to officially drop me.
      Signature

      Jen Knox

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188791].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Kay Elliott
        Here's another issue. A few weeks ago I called MN Dept. of Revenue to ask about the new sales tax laws and if online sales would be MN 6.875% sales tax or if local taxes would be included. If local taxes were included, how was the location to be determined if digital (address of credit cards, etc.). The person at the Dept. of Revenue said she didn't know. I said the deadline was the end of the month and businesses would need time to set up the systems to collect the correct tax. She said the Dept. of Revenue hadn't heard from the MN Legislature yet and a statement from them was to be issued June 13th. I said that only allows 17 days for a business to figure out how to be compliant. She said it was a problem for them also. It is now June 18th and no word yet from the MN Legislature. It makes it very difficult for a business (including Amazon) to be compliant with MN laws when no one knows exactly what the laws are and within an impossible timeframe.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188875].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author OnlineStoreHelp
          Unfortunately this is just Amazon.com posturing. They want the marketplace fairness act passed as it gives them a huge competitive advantage over just about any other seller, regardless of what their PR pieces are telling you. Now they will use this to lobby congress of, "oh look how this hurts stay at home moms trying to make a little money". Bunk.

          As for setting up a Nevada LLC and trying to run it through there... don't. While there is no "corporate income tax" starting an LLC or corp in Nevada is cost prohibitive now, with a $350 a year business license you need to file now, as well as your typical $99 registered agent fee. Your bank will not allow you to use a PO Box as your address (Patriot Act and KYC rules) which means you will need to use your home address (which Amazon will pick up) or your registered agent which will charge you for every forwarded mail you want to send.

          Add on top of this, even if your business is "based" in Nevada, you still have nexus in Minnesota and your corporation or LLC will still have to file income tax filings in Minnesota. You don't want to run afoul of the state revenue department and guess what happens when Amazon finds out. Back at square 1.

          When it is all said and done, many online businesses are starting to register in Wyoming or South Dakota which also has lax filing requirements and no "corporate income taxes".

          Your best bet, is to move away from Amazon and find affiliates that you can point people towards from networks such as CJ, Linkshare, Avantlink and Share-a-sale, etc. You might find it is better for you income wise since most tend to pay out better than Amazon with much longer cookies. This could be a blessing in disguise. The other thing to check out is if Skimlinks will let you open an account to use Amazon in your state.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188904].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author seasoned
          Originally Posted by Kay Elliott View Post

          Here's another issue. A few weeks ago I called MN Dept. of Revenue to ask about the new sales tax laws and if online sales would be MN 6.875% sales tax or if local taxes would be included. If local taxes were included, how was the location to be determined if digital (address of credit cards, etc.). The person at the Dept. of Revenue said she didn't know. I said the deadline was the end of the month and businesses would need time to set up the systems to collect the correct tax. She said the Dept. of Revenue hadn't heard from the MN Legislature yet and a statement from them was to be issued June 13th. I said that only allows 17 days for a business to figure out how to be compliant. She said it was a problem for them also. It is now June 18th and no word yet from the MN Legislature. It makes it very difficult for a business (including Amazon) to be compliant with MN laws when no one knows exactly what the laws are and within an impossible timeframe.
          TRADITION dictates it is by the SHIP TO ADDRESS! I'm surprised they couldn't tell you that. Then again, they ARE the "government".

          Steve
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190909].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Kay Elliott
            Just called the MN Dept. of Revenue again this morning and they person couldn't give me an answer, but gave me an email address to send my questions. My question to her wasn't about physical products, but digital products.

            The rep at Paypal told me their stance is the sales tax applied is the address of the seller. I agree with you Steve, I thought the tax was applied to the "ship to address". But what happens when there isn't a "ship to address", because it's digital?

            All of this is just going to add costs (time and money) for compliance. I sent in my email to the MN Dept. of Revenue, we'll see what happens.

            I could set up my digital products and on the website state they are unavailable for sale in MN. (Just kidding!)
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8191204].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author seobro
    Well, move from Minneapolis to Indianapolis as houses are inexpensive. Also, it is warmer. Indiana is a right to work pro business state that is not going away. This is one solution for you. Frankly, I do like amazon. However, I do not like their affiliates program.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188627].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ratracegrad
    Well another option would be to sell your Amazon affiliate websites that are making money to others - like me. Just PM me your website and what price you are asking and what revenue you have earned in the past year and let's talk.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8188977].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Randall Magwood
    Take your skills and migrate over to Ebay. Set up shop, forget about Amazon, and start over again. If you need to chill and re-collect your thoughts because of this new policy... take 1 or 2 days off, then get back on your grind on Ebay - or even your own website. Sorry about your situation though. Trust me, i know how you feel.
    Signature

    <a href="https://www.fiverr.com/articlesucces...ting-in-72-hrs" style="color: #0000ff; font-size: 11px;" target="_blank">I will write 10, 500-word articles on Internet Marketing in 72 hours</a>

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189036].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Marc Rodill
    Originally Posted by Daniel Elss View Post

    This is a direct result of the unconstitutional Minnesota state tax collection legislation passed by the state legislature ...
    What's unconstitutional about it anyway? I'm not saying it's not, I just want more details.

    Originally Posted by Kay Elliott View Post

    Just received my email from Amazon. I saw a previous comment in this thread about selling digital products instead. Good suggestion, but that won't work either. MN's new sales tax law includes digital products.
    I'm not sure I see how that matters, unless digital websites close down their affiliate programs. And if you're selling your own product, just charge sales tax? Problem solved?

    I love Minnesota, but it may be time to move.
    This seems silly. You can't just move every time they change the tax law. If anything this is probably just a sign of more to come. You'll be moving a lot!

    Originally Posted by Kay Elliott View Post

    Here's another issue. A few weeks ago I called MN Dept. of Revenue to ask about the new sales tax laws and if online sales would be MN 6.875% sales tax or if local taxes would be included.
    Every other brick and mortar business pays sales tax already. Why can't Amazon just charge tax? But I agree with you about the time frame and the vagueness of the law. Meet government!

    Originally Posted by OnlineStoreHelp View Post

    Unfortunately this is just Amazon.com posturing. They want the marketplace fairness act passed as it gives them a huge competitive advantage over just about any other seller, regardless of what their PR pieces are telling you. Now they will use this to lobby congress of, "oh look how this hurts stay at home moms trying to make a little money". Bunk.
    Do you have a source, or are you speculating?

    As for setting up a Nevada LLC and trying to run it through there... don't. While there is no "corporate income tax" starting an LLC or corp in Nevada is cost prohibitive now, with a $350 a year business license you need to file now, as well as your typical $99 registered agent fee. Your bank will not allow you to use a PO Box as your address (Patriot Act and KYC rules) which means you will need to use your home address (which Amazon will pick up) or your registered agent which will charge you for every forwarded mail you want to send.

    Add on top of this, even if your business is "based" in Nevada, you still have nexus in Minnesota and your corporation or LLC will still have to file income tax filings in Minnesota. You don't want to run afoul of the state revenue department and guess what happens when Amazon finds out. Back at square 1.

    When it is all said and done, many online businesses are starting to register in Wyoming or South Dakota which also has lax filing requirements and no "corporate income taxes".
    Like you said. Wyoming, Delaware, South Dakota.

    Originally Posted by socialsignals View Post

    wow the US really has become a police state.
    We did revolt from England for less, which a lot of people like to remind us of. The only problem is, there's not a lot of land to take from Indians these days.

    Regardless of what anyone thinks, it's the customers who are going to absorb most of the consequences when smart business owners relocate and or pass the cost down to them.

    Marc
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189136].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author OnlineStoreHelp
      Originally Posted by Marc Rodill View Post

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by Daniel Elss
      This is a direct result of the unconstitutional Minnesota state tax collection legislation passed by the state legislature ...
      What's unconstitutional about it anyway? I'm not saying it's not, I just want more details.
      Essentially Minnesota State Legislature is finding nexus where there really isn't any. You are not required to collect sales tax where you have no physical presense. What they are saying is if you use affiliates those third party seller act as your agent and you have nexus. The next route will be for any manufacturer that also sells online to pay taxes since, selling in a retail store gives them nexus.

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by OnlineStoreHelp
      Unfortunately this is just Amazon.com posturing. They want the marketplace fairness act passed as it gives them a huge competitive advantage over just about any other seller, regardless of what their PR pieces are telling you. Now they will use this to lobby congress of, "oh look how this hurts stay at home moms trying to make a little money". Bunk.
      Do you have a source, or are you speculating?
      Speculating of course since I have not been in the board room but ask yourself why the entities such as Amazon.com, Sears, Walmart and National Retail Federation would be pushing for this? All of these companies have fully staffed tax departments whose only job is to file taxes, inside for sales and tax, outside for federal and others. I don't have a full time tax department and find it cost prohibitive and time prohibitive to file taxes in 48 tax jurisdictions.

      Add on top of this, while Amazon, Walmart and Sears are complaining about level playing fields, they are all negotiating property and sales tax exemptions plus "retraining" funds for their company owned warehouses and facilities. No small seller, whether retail or online has these advantages, so yes, maybe I am speculating but history tells us if a large Fortune 500 company is pushing for something, someone is going to be hurt, most likely their competitors.
      Like you said. Wyoming, Delaware, South Dakota.
      Regardless of where you domicile the entity, it doesn't get away from the fact you will still have nexus in the state you live and work. The only possible route is an offshore entity theoretically but even companies like ADP that are domiciled offshore still have nexus in the states they work in.

      I'm not sure I see how that matters, unless digital websites close down their affiliate programs. And if you're selling your own product, just charge sales tax? Problem solved?
      Sure, because its the charging of the sales tax that is the issue. Wait a minute, that's an easy change, its the filing and payment of those taxes that takes time. Remember you still have to collect data from every one of your sales channels, parse out what state they belong to then go about figuring out the non-sense of a government form, file and pay. For my Hawaii Excise taxes it takes me a full day once a month to collect and file. If I have to add in 47 more states, I will either spend all my profits on accountants or all my time filing taxes.

      And before anyone starts popping off about there being software available, what software there is, is limited and is integrated only with a few shopping carts. So no, it sounds great on paper but real life tends to be quite different.

      Most news releases that tends to give Amazon lots of kudos will even admit, the only reason Amazon supports online sales tax is not only do they not need it anymore, but it gives them a competitive advantage since they will be building warehouses in most states anyway to provide 1 and 2 day delivery.

      Here is just one story on Amazon today about the incentives states throw at them. Florida alone, not any tax break, could lure Amazon to Hillsborough | Tampa Bay Times

      And another one: Behold: How Amazon wins the sales tax wars even when it loses &mdash; Tech News and Analysis

      I am all for paying my fair share of taxes but when I ship to a state that I don't have nexus in, they are still getting money from me. Whether it be federal excise gas taxes, state specific gas taxes, Federal Highway and DOT transfers or tolls, I am not getting a free lunch.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189188].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Kay Elliott
      I really don't have a problem with sales tax (a little off the topic of Amazon). The problem is knowing the correct sales tax to charge. Brick and mortar stores know exactly what to charge for sales tax at the location of their stores (state and local taxes).

      If the sales tax applied is where the buyer is located, then it gets really messy.

      MN taxes aren't even by zip code. There are multiple tax codes within a zip code. If You need to know the exact address of the buyer in order to charge the correct tax.

      If it's a digital product, it makes it even more difficult since there isn't anything to ship. Maybe use the billing address of the credit card to figure out the location/tax?

      Setting up a product with the correct tax with a payment processor like Paypal might be challenging since in some areas the taxes rates vary street by street and block by block, so it makes it really hard to charge sales tax upfront or to pre-program the tax rates.

      It would probably be easier for the seller not charge tax to the customer upfront, then figure out and pay the total sales tax due from monthly sales reports. If a person uses multiple sales channels, then the workload increases.

      There are other MN oddities that programs like Amazon would have to deal with. For example, some states charge sales tax on clothing, MN doesn't tax clothing (well, some clothing). If a person in MN buys a shirt it wouldn't be taxed, but if it had a sports logo on it, then it would be taxed.

      I'll say it again. This tax stuff gets messy. There are services out there that receive quarterly updates from all the states and they will help with sales tax records. I'm not sure what they charge. Whatever happens, I'm guessing it will cost time and money to be compliant.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189623].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Marc Rodill
    I see what you're saying. I think. I'll summarize.

    So according to the constitution, you are not required to collect sales tax in a state where you do not reside. But Minnesota is telling Amazon, hey these people are your affiliates, and they reside in Minnesota, so you have physical presence there. So we're going to require you to collect it.

    So Amazon said, okay good bye affiliates. So they won't have to deal with it. But shouldn't Amazon be supporting what Minnesota just did, if they want the Marketplace Fairness Act passed?

    Or are you saying, they won't do it because some companies are selling online in Minnesota right now, who don't have affiliates, and Amazon can't compete on price, right now?

    I think that makes sense since Amazon wants to dominate. So now they're posturing to get it passed ASAP. But I'm not sure if I got your point of view yet. I think I do.

    As for it being unconstitutional, I can see how that can be argued both ways. So, not sure if I agree with the other posters opinion of it being unconstitutional, but it's an emotionally interesting word that may or may not be true.

    Then the thing about it being a pain in the ass to file your taxes. Why not just get a tax guy? Wouldn't you save more in the long run? Not only on your time, but if you get a guy who actually knows the tax law, you would probably save a bundle, wouldn't you?
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189228].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Farish
      Originally Posted by Marc Rodill View Post

      I see what you're saying. I think. I'll summarize.

      So according to the constitution, you are not required to collect sales tax in a state where you do not reside. But Minnesota is telling Amazon, hey these people are your affiliates, and they reside in Minnesota, so you have physical presence there. So we're going to require you to collect it.

      So Amazon said, okay good bye affiliates. So they won't have to deal with it. But shouldn't Amazon be supporting what Minnesota just did, if they want the Marketplace Fairness Act passed?

      Or are you saying, they won't do it because some companies are selling online in Minnesota right now, who don't have affiliates, and Amazon can't compete on price, right now?

      I think that makes sense since Amazon wants to dominate. So now they're posturing to get it passed ASAP. But I'm not sure if I got your point of view yet. I think I do.

      As for it being unconstitutional, I can see how that can be argued both ways. So, not sure if I agree with the other posters opinion of it being unconstitutional, but it's an emotionally interesting word that may or may not be true.

      Then the thing about it being a pain in the ass to file your taxes. Why not just get a tax guy? Wouldn't you save more in the long run? Not only on your time, but if you get a guy who actually knows the tax law, you would probably save a bundle, wouldn't you?


      In 1992 Quill Corp. v. North Dakota, the Supreme Court ruled that a business must have a physical presence in a state for that state to require it to collect sales taxes.

      However, the court explicitly stated that Congress can overrule the decision through legislation

      Until the bill is passed by Congress or signed by the president, these bills are technically unconstitutional. The Supreme Court is the final decider in all these test cases.

      The reason why Amazon compromised with California, is because the state is such a large market that Amazon wanted to build distribution centers there. They wanted to delay the start of the sales tax collection for a couple years once they build their centers there, but the compromise was a one year reprieve.

      A bill will probably be passed by Congress by the end of the year ending this and changing how the system works. Until then, these bills really won't stand in Court, as Amazon has already won in other states over this.

      The other thing Amazon has stated is they don't want to have to fight all 50 states over this so they rather a uniformed law that all states must follow versus each individual state.

      For example, California has several counties, and each county has its own sales tax. I can drive 20 miles away in two different directions and pay different tax rates because of that.

      Also expect somebody to sue the federal version of this law once it passes, either the Court will reaffirm there previous decision or overrule it. Unless it is a great injustice, rarely does the Supreme Court overrule its past rulings.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189464].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Joni D
        Originally Posted by Farish View Post

        A bill will probably be passed by Congress by the end of the year ending this and changing how the system works. Until then, these bills really won't stand in Court, as Amazon has already won in other states over this.
        .
        So what are the chances this is overturned, does Amazon fight for each state as quoted above before and or after the fact. Since it is already passed what are the chances Congress will reverse this? Maybe use skimlinks or viglinks until the end of the year and see what happens? Does anyone know what other states were turned back if any after the fact?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8189648].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author midwestmedia
          Well, since it appears this is out of our hands for the time being, let's talk solutions.

          Until now, I never had to worry about a network like Skimlinks so what can those who have used it say about it? Good? Better options available?

          Are there similar networks that include Amazon that someone can suggest?
          Signature

          Jen Knox

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190243].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Tom Ryan
            Originally Posted by midwestmedia View Post

            Well, since it appears this is out of our hands for the time being, let's talk solutions.

            Until now, I never had to worry about a network like Skimlinks so what can those who have used it say about it? Good? Better options available?

            Are there similar networks that include Amazon that someone can suggest?
            Skimlinks main competitor is VigLink, so they are another network you may want to check out. They both appear to be similar, but as of now if I were to pick one over the other it would be VigLink.
            Signature


            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190301].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author midwestmedia
              Originally Posted by Tom Ryan View Post

              Skimlinks main competitor is VigLink, so they are another network you may want to check out. They both appear to be similar, but as of now if I were to pick one over the other it would be VigLink.
              Thanks Tom! I'll check it out!

              Just out of curiosity, is there a reason you prefer Viglinks to Skimlinks?
              Signature

              Jen Knox

              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190377].message }}
              • Profile picture of the author Tom Ryan
                Originally Posted by midwestmedia View Post

                Thanks Tom! I'll check it out!

                Just out of curiosity, is there a reason you prefer Viglinks to Skimlinks?
                For several reasons I would more than likely test out Viglink. First setup is instantaneous whereas Skimlinks there is an application process. Viglink pays net 60 whereas Skimlinks it could be up to 90 days. And I guess Viglink has really good analytics.
                Signature


                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8192498].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Farish
          Originally Posted by Joni D View Post

          So what are the chances this is overturned, does Amazon fight for each state as quoted above before and or after the fact. Since it is already passed what are the chances Congress will reverse this? Maybe use skimlinks or viglinks until the end of the year and see what happens? Does anyone know what other states were turned back if any after the fact?
          Amazon is avoiding litigation unless necessary because of the costs.

          Amazon's most recent victory was in Colorado.

          Judge spares Amazon from Colorado sales tax reporting scheme | Ars Technica


          Amazon in some states has offered to build distribution centers and create jobs in return for either tax forgiveness or a delay in implementation of the law. They have already done this in Texas and South Carolina.

          Also Congress will probably pass a online tax bill. I believe the one that has passed through one of the houses, requires that retailers making over a million dollars had to collect sales tax for all states they ship to.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190402].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author ronrule
        The irony of Minnesota's sales tax is that it will produce less revenue than the income tax they're about to lose currently does.

        Amazon paid over $500 million to affiliates in MN in 2012 - residents who paid income tax on those earnings to the tune of about $35 million. That $35 million is more than the state would have earned on sales tax for the same sales, and now they will receive neither. I say good... that's what happens when you unconstitutionally tax outside of your jurisdiction. I hope more retailers follow suit.

        For those of you in MN, just incorporate in Nevada, Delaware, or Florida and sign up as a new affiliate under your company.

        Amazon Drops Minnesota-Based Affiliates
        Signature
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8192354].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Joni D
          Originally Posted by ronrule View Post

          For those of you in MN, just incorporate in Nevada, Delaware, or Florida and sign up as a new affiliate under your company.
          ISsthere a reason to incorporate vs LLC? I go to FL every year for 10 days so could this be set up online or do I have to be there? any ebook you know that explains how to do this? Is a PO address acceptable? would I "forward" the mail to me here in MN, just wondering how it works so I can set it up easily.
          Thanks
          Joni
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8202992].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Joni D
            Just spoke with Skimlinks and they are still working with Amazon Affiliates unlike Viglinks. The details for the tax law is still being worked on and hoping that affiliate's in MN will be reinstated like CA, there is hope yet.
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8248312].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author NewParadigm
    Elections have consequences Minnesota. I live here and don't drink the city water, there's got to be an extra dose of stupid put into it by the Dayton government. Or perhaps Dayton's bipolar psychotic medications. Driving business out of state is not smart.
    Signature

    In a moment of decision the best thing you can do is the right thing. The worst thing you can do is nothing. ~ Theodore Roosevelt "Trust, BUT VERIFY" ~ Ronald Reagan

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190407].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author northernbird
    Hi Tom,

    I, too, got the shocking email yesterday from Amazon. I was in the process of having 6 Amazon sites built. Guess that plan is out the window. I hate living in such a liberal state, but my spouse won't consider leaving. Minnesota is NOT business friendly!

    JR
    Signature
    Aut viam inveniam aut faciam
    ~ I'll either find a way or make one
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190409].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author elmo033057
    What can you expect from a state that elects a SNL flunky comedian for a senate office?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190687].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author northernbird
      Yes, an SNL wannabe comedian, and a former wrestler for a governor. C'mon Minnesotans, we can do better than this!!!

      Elections have consequences; pay attention!
      Signature
      Aut viam inveniam aut faciam
      ~ I'll either find a way or make one
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190817].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author elmo033057
        Originally Posted by northernbird View Post

        Yes, an SNL wannabe comedian, and a former wrestler for a governor. C'mon Minnesotans, we can do better than this!!!

        Elections have consequences; pay attention!
        Yeah, and now Ben Afleck and Ashley Judd wants to run too. I'm glad Holly-weird is so in tuned with the people.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8191518].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author bengirwb
          Buyers PAY the sales tax (taxes).
          What the merchant does is pass the taxes on to the state.
          The expensive problem is taking the time to do the damn paperwork correctly.
          But we're dealing with Government. And Government never seems to be able to find simple solutions to problems Government put in place.

          Simple solution?

          Make a sale with a separate space for the tax amount.
          Immediately use PayPal to send that tax to the proper state.
          The state gets its tax money quickly and without all the paperwork.

          But, we're dealing with Government.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8191574].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author NewParadigm
    I was going to relocate a biz to st paul and met w/ the city planners etc.. 10 of them showed up across from me at the table, from a different department, EACH with a regulation book from 2-8" thick. They interrogated me basically. Then at the end had the audacity to say they look forward to me bringing my 50 jobs to their city!!!! My eyes rolled back, i bit my tongue hard to hold back telling them to effff offf.
    Signature

    In a moment of decision the best thing you can do is the right thing. The worst thing you can do is nothing. ~ Theodore Roosevelt "Trust, BUT VERIFY" ~ Ronald Reagan

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8190833].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author NewParadigm
    You don't need an ID to vote in MN, just a neighbor to vouch for you or show a utility bill. But God forbid you try and sell something!!! They'll be up your ass to collect a tax!!!
    Signature

    In a moment of decision the best thing you can do is the right thing. The worst thing you can do is nothing. ~ Theodore Roosevelt "Trust, BUT VERIFY" ~ Ronald Reagan

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8191382].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Shane12
    The change in Minnesota's state law affects about 1,000 online retailers -- not just Amazon.com -- Madigan said. The 5,200 affiliates in Minnesota generated a total of about $500 million worth of business in 2012 and paid about $35 million in state income tax, she said.

    Because of the new online sales tax law, "the state is actually going to lose money" from the affiliates, Madigan said, "because they'll lose that income tax revenue." About three-quarters of the businesses have fewer than four employees.

    Amazon affiliates such as Maple Grove-based Carrie Rocha, who blogs about consumer bargains at Pocketyourdollars.com, direct shoppers to Amazon and are paid a commission on purchases made by those they refer.

    Although Rocha has affiliate relationships with hundreds of retail websites, Amazon is the largest, making up more than 10 percent of her affiliate revenue. Other retail websites have ended their affiliations with Rocha, too, including Overstock.com, because of the new law.

    "Amazon is the big dog," Rocha said. "But I've been fired by other online retailers already. ... I've been getting these emails since this was signed into law."
    Amazon dumps Minnesota affiliates to avoid collecting online state sales tax - TwinCities.com
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8192252].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Kurt
    You can use a site like GoldenCan for Amazon. I think they take 1 out of every 4 "clickc", but it's an option for Amazon until you figure something else out.

    GoldenCAN, Affiliate Data Feed, Coupon & Search Integration Solution
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8193169].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author thedog
      For those looking at the likes of Viglink. I have experience with them. It's not all that bad, yes, they take a 25% cut, but, as they have so many sales on amazon, it's 25% of an 8 - 8.5% Amazon commission, so, just a little less than what most affiliates get, around 6%.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8201939].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Paintball Guns
    I have affiliate links and represent Minnesota affiliates as a Minnesota attorney. Here is a summary I wrote regarding the Minnesota law and FAQs: http://thompsonhall.com/minnesota-af...ate-nexus-tax/
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8314547].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author kingrook
    I live in MN and was talking to SkimLinks and it looks like they are dropping Amazon nexus states in the coming weeks:

    I should also mention that in the coming weeks we will have to start enforcing Amazon's new affiliate terms so if possible, I would start switching those links over to other merchants.
    I then asked them to be more specific, and they responded with:

    Yes I'm afraid that's the case. We won't bar you from using Skimlinks -
    just from affiliating Amazon links through Skimlinks. We have to honor the
    specifications given to us by the merchants with regards to who can use
    their programs.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8314748].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author serryjw
    This appears to be the trend. I just received this in a newsletter.
    Three More States Add Affiliate Nexus Tax
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8315372].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author serryjw
    This appear to be the trend. Just received this article in a newsletter.
    Three More States Add Affiliate Nexus Tax
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8315377].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author mysterrio
    This is a great reason why we should never put all our eggs in one basket. Having said that, I must admit...I have been guilty in the past.
    Signature

    The Gurus Have Lied To You: Learn Internet Marketing For FREE. Don't Spend Another Penny Before You Read My FREE REPORT. Go here: http://internetmarketingdude.xyz

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8315478].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author serryjw
    Smith33122 One of the funniest posts in a long time. I just forwarded to my email list. Barbara Walters did a special tonight in honor of the birth of your future King. MY YOU do pay the Queen well. What a lifestyle.
    It was kick to learn Kate has a look-a-like....so will the baby.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8317066].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dml8131
    That is too bad as Amazon can be a good income source from many Internet marketers. Perhaps look at a business address outside of your state?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8317214].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author CrossCreations
    If Viglinks, Skimlinks, etc. ARE an alternative to being an Amazon affiliate in a Nexus state, then wouldn't the seller need to establish business in another state first - BEFORE doing so?

    Otherwise seems risky business in that the affiliate is still earning from amazon in a Nexus state. Comments above suggest using Viglinks etc. meanwhile... as this is sorted out. Not so sure that is wise or even legal. Think?

    Looking for other alternatives & solutions. Amazon Nexus laws recently hit Missouri as well, killing a lot of affiliate income for me. Amazon was the largest source of affiliate income, but not the only one. CJ, Clickbank, Share-a-Sale, etc. appear safer for now.
    Signature
    SoloSpark Helping Solopreneurs SHINE Online!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8609845].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Tom Ryan
      Originally Posted by CrossCreations View Post

      If Viglinks, Skimlinks, etc. ARE an alternative to being an Amazon affiliate in a Nexus state, then wouldn't the seller need to establish business in another state first - BEFORE doing so?

      Otherwise seems risky business in that the affiliate is still earning from amazon in a Nexus state. Comments above suggest using Viglinks etc. meanwhile... as this is sorted out. Not so sure that is wise or even legal. Think?

      Looking for other alternatives & solutions. Amazon Nexus laws recently hit Missouri as well, killing a lot of affiliate income for me. Amazon was the largest source of affiliate income, but not the only one. CJ, Clickbank, Share-a-Sale, etc. appear safer for now.
      Viglinks is no longer an option, they dropped the nexus states as well.
      Signature


      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8609908].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author 19rl75
    Are there any updates on this? I saw that in October the Illinois supreme court overruled the initial decision. Time to move to South Dakota like many other businesses have done.

    Amazon Associates back in business in Illinois thanks to Supreme Court decision
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8787490].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author LeadGenie
    >>North Dakota will become the New Amazon Affiliate Mecca..
    Either that or the Cayman Islands...

    Fortunately with situations like these there are always new opportunities and businesses that can tend to open up.. Unfortunately if its all based on robbing more jobs and money out of peoples pockets it doesn't really end up good for anyone.

    Go Go Gadget Bureaucrats!!
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8787969].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jen Eick
    Sorry to hear this, Tom Ryan (and others in Minnesota).

    Welcome to the dung heap. They did this in Missouri already along with several other states, and I've been trying to warn people abut Amazon.com ever since.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8788547].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BradVert2013
    Don't lose hope! Illinois passed the same stupid law, then the Illinois Supreme Court struck it down. Amazon recently reinstated all affiliates in Illinois! The court decision here will set a good precedent for other courts around the country. I predict these laws won't hold muster for very long.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8788622].message }}

Trending Topics

  • 1 {{ upvoteCount | shortNum }}

    Difference between google analytics aquisition and audience

    param in Internet Marketing

    I am new in Google Analytics, Please guide me the difference between google analytics acquisition and audience.

  • 1 {{ upvoteCount | shortNum }}

    Need recommendations for a good inbound appointment scheduler

    Delta223 in Offline Marketing

    Hi, I plan to do some voice drops to drum up business for customer reactivation campaigns, but beling called out of the blue is a bit hard for me. I ... [read more]

  • 6 {{ upvoteCount | shortNum }}

    How to deal with pain from sitting all day?

    ish1231231 in Off Topic

    Recently I left my job and started working full time online. I spend an average of 10 hours at the computer working currently and I've come to realize that my ... [read more]

  • 7 {{ upvoteCount | shortNum }}
  • 3 {{ upvoteCount | shortNum }}

    How do I find a mentor?

    erealmz in Personal Development

    I've bought Bruce A Berman's secrets to success way back when. I was totally new to internet marketing and the many promises it offered in what I considered the Golden ... [read more]