Starting and advancing my career - advice needed

by a_dude
35 replies
  • OFF TOPIC
  • |
My goal is to get into some sort of management position. Mainly because I'm good at noticing inefficient procedures/situations/etc. and correct them, and I enjoy doing so. I also enjoy mending a situation into something better and something new. And I enjoy theory significantly more than small technical details (for example, my manager made me to waste a day making a list of what I do day-to-day in very small detail, so that an idiot (his words) could understand it, because I used my methods to do my job more efficiently, rather than his. However I prefer to be the guy creating the methods rather than the one following them or the one having freedom over how I do things).

Since there's literally hundreds of different positions, I can't name a position I want to be in, so take the concept above to understand it.

I have only 12 grade education and I'm an IT specialist right now. I do a lot more than that, including a low-level management of the whole department, but since the company is small (like all IT-based companies where I live), my position is not prospective, unless somebody else quits.

I'm not up for doing technical work for the next 15 years - I do it well and even better than the guy before me who was working there for 2 years or so. Most of what I do was new to me, so experience is not an issue. I'm a fast learner.

So since you don't get right into a management position, what are my options? I wouldn't mind doing something remotely related to management, something that could lead there too. I can't stand the current environment because it is incredibly disorganized and inefficient, and I can't do anything about it.

OPTIONAL: a bit about my personality:

I'm ambitious, driven, goal-oriented, fast-learner, direct, realistic, future-oriented, articulate, sometimes a bit blunt guy in my early 20s.
  • Find opportunities to lead people. Volunteer to take over a project or start your own. Get the project done on time and under budget. Take that experience to your management and use it show your leadership and management skills.

    Tell them what you learned, what you did right, challenges you overcame, what you learned about yourself. Above all, show what you learned about people. Not just the "up with people" stuff. For example, maybe you had to take someone off the project because they weren't following through on their commitments. This shows decisiveness and determination.

    It doesn't have to be at work. Offer to lead a new initiative or project for one of your clubs or organizations. Try to make it bigger than a dart league at the pub.

    This will go a lot farther than saying, "I'm ready," or "I need to make more money."

    Show them you are ready to lead and manage by getting some experience doing just that, and then leverage it into the position you want.

    Then when you really become a manager the real challenge starts. More pressure, more reward. Make sure you want the responsibility.
    Signature
    Marketing is not a battle of products. It is a battle of perceptions.
    - Jack Trout
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7946461].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bizgrower
    You may not want to do this with your current employer because boat rocking can get one fired.

    But, you could do this: study your company, or other company's that you target and want to work for and write a report showcasing how they could make more money and/or save more money. Perhaps in one specific department. Then, use this report instead of a resume to get hired in some capacity. Perhaps a higher level management position than you think you could get now. And, you submit this well written report to someone pretty high up in the company: VP, CEO, President, Owner, Department manager....(not the person you might be replacing.)

    Dan
    Signature

    "If you think you're the smartest person in the room, then you're probably in the wrong room."

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7947968].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author a_dude
      Originally Posted by joe golfer View Post

      Find opportunities to lead people. Volunteer to take over a project or start your own. Get the project done on time and under budget. Take that experience to your management and use it show your leadership and management skills.

      Tell them what you learned, what you did right, challenges you overcame, what you learned about yourself. Above all, show what you learned about people. Not just the "up with people" stuff. For example, maybe you had to take someone off the project because they weren't following through on their commitments. This shows decisiveness and determination.

      It doesn't have to be at work. Offer to lead a new initiative or project for one of your clubs or organizations. Try to make it bigger than a dart league at the pub.

      This will go a lot farther than saying, "I'm ready," or "I need to make more money."

      Show them you are ready to lead and manage by getting some experience doing just that, and then leverage it into the position you want.

      Then when you really become a manager the real challenge starts. More pressure, more reward. Make sure you want the responsibility.
      We don't have any volunteer projects other than handing out food, cleaning out the streets under the supervision of some city-official who looks nice on a camera and caring for the elderly. No management positions. I'd like to start some of my own projects, but I'm not sure what I could do that would bring profit - it's either not profitable because of the extremely poor economy in my country, it's been done or it requires a lot of budget to begin with. Would appreciate some examples or something like that, if you don't mind. Or you could ask for more information if that'd help you.

      Uhm. I don't have/belong to any clubs or organizations, most of them are either artistic or sports, I have zero interest in both. And I mean zero - at least I listen to music and watch movies. Unless you had something different in mind.

      Originally Posted by bizgrower View Post

      You may not want to do this with your current employer because boat rocking can get one fired.

      But, you could do this: study your company, or other company's that you target and want to work for and write a report showcasing how they could make more money and/or save more money. Perhaps in one specific department. Then, use this report instead of a resume to get hired in some capacity. Perhaps a higher level management position than you think you could get now. And, you submit this well written report to someone pretty high up in the company: VP, CEO, President, Owner, Department manager....(not the person you might be replacing.)

      Dan
      That's a good idea, but I have a question that I hope you have an answer to:

      Since I'd be an outsider, someone who only sees the end-result of the management, someone who doesn't get to see the profit/expenses/etc. only say the prices of their hardware or services and maybe a few "best" customers. How can I write a decent report with a small amount of information like that? I mean, I can write a report, but it may contain serious inconsistencies with what's really happening, not to mention that I can't write a full report, I can only use maybe 20% of the information available. Other than that, I don't know the manager and his viewpoint on such things, he may just take my ideas and use them without hiring me. But that's not as important as the first part, as it's crucial for the actual quality of the report.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7950407].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author bizgrower
        Originally Posted by a_dude View Post

        .



        That's a good idea, but I have a question that I hope you have an answer to:

        Since I'd be an outsider, someone who only sees the end-result of the management, someone who doesn't get to see the profit/expenses/etc. only say the prices of their hardware or services and maybe a few "best" customers. How can I write a decent report with a small amount of information like that? I mean, I can write a report, but it may contain serious inconsistencies with what's really happening, not to mention that I can't write a full report, I can only use maybe 20% of the information available. Other than that, I don't know the manager and his viewpoint on such things, he may just take my ideas and use them without hiring me. But that's not as important as the first part, as it's crucial for the actual quality of the report.
        1) It's a different way to apply for a job as opposed to a resume.
        It should show your thinking towards operations, marketing, increasing income,
        reducing expenses...

        2) You would preface it with the fact that you are an outsider, which is a given
        and they will understand.

        3) Because you are not an insider you could only give examples from
        your experience and give them your take on market and customer service
        opportunities for more revenue and repeat and referral business. Perhaps
        research their sales and marketing processes by pretending to be a
        prospective customer, or interviewing existing customers...

        4) So what if they take your ideas. One company might. Another
        company might respect you and your motivation and take you on to
        help implement. They could also say they already thought of most
        of your ideas...

        5) Regarding your education, tell them more about how you learn
        what you need to learn, and do take steps to show them what you
        do to be self-taught as well as any training, workshops, seminars you
        attend. Include or add tech, people, sales, management, skills or trainings...

        Hope this helps.

        Dan

        PS -"example, my manager made me to waste a day making a list of what I do day-to-day in very small detail, so that an idiot (his words) could understand it, because I used my methods to do my job more efficiently, rather than his. However I prefer to be the guy creating the methods rather than the one following them or the one having freedom over how I do things)."

        Yes. You were recognized in really a positive way, so maybe you are with a company
        that is open for more. A place you could stay and get more experience, skills, and formal or
        informal education and knowledge. Perhaps eventually create a position for your self that you would be interested in and would make and/or save them many times more than your salary.
        Signature

        "If you think you're the smartest person in the room, then you're probably in the wrong room."

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7959941].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Michael Ten
    You can go into management if you start your own business and hire employees. Do you really want to have a boss to report to?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7951029].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author a_dude
      Originally Posted by Michael Ten View Post

      You can go into management if you start your own business and hire employees. Do you really want to have a boss to report to?
      That's my goal. Before then, however, I gotta get some money to have some capital, and I'd like to get some management experience on a bigger scale.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7951867].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author HeySal
    I'm good at noticing inefficient procedures/situations/etc. and correct them,
    You do see the irony of posting that statement in the WF bar where we come to blow off business, right?
    Signature

    Sal
    When the Roads and Paths end, learn to guide yourself through the wilderness
    Beyond the Path

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7952343].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author socialentry
    Banned
    One easy way to show your pro-active is to train the new guys.

    I don't know how IT orgs in the private sector works, but wherever I went, usually no one really wanted to take care of the trainees.

    Since your senior, they will do whatever you want, so you have some freedom to implement your ideas.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7952903].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Kay King
      including a low-level management of the whole department, but since the company is small
      Here's how it's done in the real world. You have a low-level management position - do a good job and earn the respect of the company you work for...

      Then you make a lateral move to another low level or slightly higher management position in a larger company and you start working your way up the ladder.

      I enjoy theory significantly more than small technical details
      Unless you are a theoretical physicist or work for google you probably won't find a position where your time is spent theorizing rather than attending to details.

      You complain about your boss who made you write out procedures you were using. The plus side is he recognized you were doing the job well. What you didn't get is that your boss was MANAGING by noticing your methods and wanting to share them with other workers.

      Managers ARE about details and reports and meeting quotas/deadlines - they are about implementing new procedures and to do that you have to be willing to document and train.

      To move up into management means doing a good job where you are. But it also means sharing your methods or risking being that employee who "owns" his job and is kept in the job because no one else knows how to do it.
      Signature
      Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
      ***
      One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
      what it is instead of what you think it should be.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7953595].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author a_dude
        Originally Posted by HeySal View Post

        You do see the irony of posting that statement in the WF bar where we come to blow off business, right?
        Forum's focused on internet business, no great category. May have been a better one, but if so, a moderator may move it there, as I am not aware of that.

        Originally Posted by socialentry View Post

        One easy way to show your pro-active is to train the new guys.

        I don't know how IT orgs in the private sector works, but wherever I went, usually no one really wanted to take care of the trainees.

        Since your senior, they will do whatever you want, so you have some freedom to implement your ideas.
        I'm not a senior, I'm a guy in a minor position who's just started. Technically, I'm the trainee, though I did help some other old-timers. But anyway, I can't advance in the current company, so it doesn't matter.

        Originally Posted by Kay King View Post

        Here's how it's done in the real world. You have a low-level management position - do a good job and earn the respect of the company you work for...
        Then you make a lateral move to another low level or slightly higher management position in a larger company and you start working your way up the ladder.

        Yea, that's what I'd like to do. However, the problem is that my position technically doesn't include management. Technically I should only be fixing software-related issues. In short, it won't be in my resume. I'd like to get a reply to this.

        Unless you are a theoretical physicist or work for google you probably won't find a position where your time is spent theorizing rather than attending to details.

        You complain about your boss who made you write out procedures you were using. The plus side is he recognized you were doing the job well. What you didn't get is that your boss was MANAGING by noticing your methods and wanting to share them with other workers.

        Managers ARE about details and reports and meeting quotas/deadlines - they are about implementing new procedures and to do that you have to be willing to document and train.

        To move up into management means doing a good job where you are. But it also means sharing your methods or risking being that employee who "owns" his job and is kept in the job because no one else knows how to do it.
        There are no other workers who do my job. I'm the only one, and they are not planning to hire anybody else. In short, there's nobody to share them with. And at the time he didn't know my thinking yet, not to mention that he asks me to follow his methods, even though mine are more efficient.

        Deadlines/quotas aren't details, details is "click here, here and here" instead of "click here and be done with it." I'm willing to train others, as long as it pays off for me financially/career-wise, by the way.

        Being the guy who does the job because nobody else can can't be management, at least I don't think so. Although, I wouldn't mind that, that'd mean that I'm needed and that I'm more capable in that section that anybody else at the workplace.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7953841].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Kay King
          Yea, that's what I'd like to do. However, the problem is that my position technically doesn't include management. Technically I should only be fixing software-related issues. In short, it won't be in my resume. I'd like to get a reply to this.
          YOU said "low level management". I think perhaps your goals are getting in the way of reality.

          I'm a guy in a minor position who's just started. Technically, I'm the trainee, though I did help some other old-timers.
          Would not have known that from your initial post. If you are a trainee in a minor position - you have a long way to go before you are management material. Doesn't matter how many kudos you give yourself, you still have to prove your worth to employers. You know that. You have to build your work rep - and be able to interact with co-workers in a positive way.

          I can't tell you how many new, bright people I've seen come into businesses in beginner jobs thinking they know more than the owner about how the company should be organized. They usually don't last long.

          Before thinking your ways are superior to seasoned workers - make sure you know the company inside and out, the history, etc. Otherwise you risk being seen as a know-it-all rather than a good new employee.

          If you are newly hired to fix software-related issues - spend your work time fixing software-related issues. Be the best and most productive at what you do and people will notice. You can't tell employers how great you are - you have to show them.
          Signature
          Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
          ***
          One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
          what it is instead of what you think it should be.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7954154].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Don Schenk
    My goal is to get into some sort of management position. Mainly because I'm good at noticing inefficient procedures/situations/etc. and correct them, and I enjoy doing so. I also enjoy mending a situation into something better and something new.
    After more than 40 years self-employed with employees, I can say there is a lot more to management than these. Management includes understanding how the business works, a working knowledge knowledge of HR, and the people skills to motivate employees. And it is a learned skill.

    ... sometimes a bit blunt guy in my early 20s.
    Blunt is different than direct. Direct is good, however to positively motivate others, blunt doesn't work.

    Businesses that promote from within, often provide management training.

    A fellow I've been friends with for more than 20 years was working as a server in a large hotel chain's restaurant when I first met him. He spoke with management about ways he could move into management, and the hotel (a Westin) agreed to put him through management training.

    The hotel sent him to classes over the course of the next year, and he moved into management, because they taught him specifically how to work people effectively. A few years later he moved into an upper management position at another business.

    :-Don
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7954276].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author a_dude
      Originally Posted by Kay King View Post

      YOU said "low level management". I think perhaps your goals are getting in the way of reality.
      Huh? I do a lot more than my job title says I should be doing, which includes management. Basically I without pointing out that it's somebody else's responsibility because a) I want some experience and, which is the main reason b) because it's really hard to get a job.

      Would not have known that from your initial post. If you are a trainee in a minor position - you have a long way to go before you are management material. Doesn't matter how many kudos you give yourself, you still have to prove your worth to employers. You know that. You have to build your work rep - and be able to interact with co-workers in a positive way.

      I can't tell you how many new, bright people I've seen come into businesses in beginner jobs thinking they know more than the owner about how the company should be organized. They usually don't last long.

      Before thinking your ways are superior to seasoned workers - make sure you know the company inside and out, the history, etc. Otherwise you risk being seen as a know-it-all rather than a good new employee.

      If you are newly hired to fix software-related issues - spend your work time fixing software-related issues. Be the best and most productive at what you do and people will notice. You can't tell employers how great you are - you have to show them.
      Doesn't matter, as I've already said - won't get promoted in this company. Although I still am productive, if I get to use "my" methods, I am more productive than the guy before me, and as far as I know, he had to do some things tens of times before he got how to do them, took me once to learn instead.

      But yea, I'm trying to "show off" to the management as little as possible, purely because if anybody will get any kudos, it'll be the manager, and I couldn't care less about him, not to mention that it's my ideas. As far as other workers told me, including the guy before me, he doesn't give any raises either.

      Originally Posted by Don Schenk View Post

      After more than 40 years self-employed with employees, I can say there is a lot more to management than these. Management includes understanding how the business works, a working knowledge knowledge of HR, and the people skills to motivate employees. And it is a learned skill.
      I can definitely motivate people to do things, even change their negative attitude towards it by "energizing" them about the matter. Done that many times back when I owned a game-related project with a team who at first didn't agree with my controversial management style.

      Blunt is different than direct. Direct is good, however to positively motivate others, blunt doesn't work.

      Businesses that promote from within, often provide management training.

      A fellow I've been friends with for more than 20 years was working as a server in a large hotel chain's restaurant when I first met him. He spoke with management about ways he could move into management, and the hotel (a Westin) agreed to put him through management training.

      The hotel sent him to classes over the course of the next year, and he moved into management, because they taught him specifically how to work people effectively. A few years later he moved into an upper management position at another business.

      :-Don
      That's very nice, sounds exciting actually. That would actually interest me a lot, I wonder where I can get management training. Companies here don't provide any kind of training, even now there wasn't any training, I can only ask questions if I have any. Good thing is - it's efficient. Bad thing - some workers assume that I know something I don't, because they assume that someone else has told me that already. But knowing the in-and-outs of a company isn't similar to management (or any other position) training of course.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7954342].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Don Schenk
    Done that many times back when I owned a game-related project with a team who at first didn't agree with my controversial management style.
    Good. You have had some experience at doing management. That is half the battle.

    ...I wonder where I can get management training.
    You're motivated, which means you can learn on your own. Books, books, and more books. Start at your local library. Any books you get from the library, books which you realize will be beneficial to your career moves, go purchase at a book store or online.

    Grab a highlighter and start marking up your copy of the book. Treat it as if it were a school textbook, and write out the most helpful points from those you have underlined. Doing so will start putting the information more solidly into your brain.

    If you were to take any college course on management, this is exactly what you would be doing with the course textbook. You can do this on your own, without taking classes.

    Search Amazon to find books you might want to read at the library. Buy Kindle books about management. Begin to acquire your own personal library of management material.

    Look at
    AMA - American Management Association Management Training ...

    There is a wealth of information on their website! And they also promote local seminars held in large cities. You may even want to travel to some of these. Think of it the way we think of going to an Internet Marketing seminar, except there won't be much, if any, selling at an AMA event.

    I was a member of the AMA, some years ago, and went to a couple of their seminars.

    This is a good start.

    :-Don
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7957484].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author a_dude
      Originally Posted by Don Schenk View Post

      Good. You have had some experience at doing management. That is half the battle.

      You're motivated, which means you can learn on your own. Books, books, and more books. Start at your local library. Any books you get from the library, books which you realize will be beneficial to your career moves, go purchase at a book store or online.

      Grab a highlighter and start marking up your copy of the book. Treat it as if it were a school textbook, and write out the most helpful points from those you have underlined. Doing so will start putting the information more solidly into your brain.

      If you were to take any college course on management, this is exactly what you would be doing with the course textbook. You can do this on your own, without taking classes.

      Search Amazon to find books you might want to read at the library. Buy Kindle books about management. Begin to acquire your own personal library of management material.

      Look at
      AMA - American Management Association Management Training ...

      There is a wealth of information on their website! And they also promote local seminars held in large cities. You may even want to travel to some of these. Think of it the way we think of going to an Internet Marketing seminar, except there won't be much, if any, selling at an AMA event.

      I was a member of the AMA, some years ago, and went to a couple of their seminars.

      This is a good start.

      :-Don
      I've read quite a bit on most topics, including management. Reading a book is nothing compared to real experience. I can read an article on how to restore lost data from a physically damaged HDD, but I still won't know how to do it until I do it. Even if it's 1 time done vs. 20 times read. Literally. I'm the kind of guy who learns by doing - saying that from experience.

      However, I already have about 15 tabs open that I'm going to read and which are going to refer me to the right direction for more management-related things. Mainly I'm doing that to satisfy my curiosity, because I know that I won't learn much until I actually do it.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7958626].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Kay King
        You have an answer for everything and discount most of the advice given.

        Above all - managers are detail and results oriented with good people skills. Your reluctance to share glory with your supervisor, to document your "better" methods so others can learn, and pride in "controversial management" (does that mean confrontational?) style aren't likely to be positives for you as a manager.

        I know that I won't learn much until I actually do it
        But perhaps you won't have an opportunity to actually do it until you learn much more. Don't know what country you are in and it may be different there but the way you are approaching the idea of "being a manager" wouldn't work here very well in most companies.

        Just saying - be ambitious and have goals but be realistic, too, about your own potential and what you need to do to reach your goals.
        Signature
        Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
        ***
        One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
        what it is instead of what you think it should be.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7958824].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author a_dude
          Originally Posted by Kay King View Post

          You have an answer for everything and discount most of the advice given.

          Above all - managers are detail and results oriented with good people skills. Your reluctance to share glory with your supervisor, to document your "better" methods so others can learn, and pride in "controversial management" (does that mean confrontational?) style aren't likely to be positives for you as a manager.
          Not trying to be that way, can explain some things if that would help to understand the situation(s). Just ask a question.

          I am quality and goal-oriented, and I do have good people skills, as long as it doesn't mean being the fluffy type with 2 hours of small-talk before getting to the point. I think quality/goal is what you meant, isn't it?

          As for sharing, here's what I think, and it'd be interesting to get an answer about it in relation to your quote and the rest of the information provided earlier:

          I know that I cannot get a promotion in my company because it's too small. I know that I won't get an extra raise. I know that I won't get any useful contacts due to my supervisor. I know that our methods of approaching problems are completely opposite (I'm future-oriented, he's past-oriented). That said, I see absolutely no reason to share my thoughts about management with him or anybody else at my workplace - I have no motivation to do so.

          As for "controversial management," I meant non-traditional ways of managing it, which lead to its success in a short period of time, by the way.

          But perhaps you won't have an opportunity to actually do it until you learn much more. Don't know what country you are in and it may be different there but the way you are approaching the idea of "being a manager" wouldn't work here very well in most companies.

          Just saying - be ambitious and have goals but be realistic, too, about your own potential and what you need to do to reach your goals.
          Just saying that writing that I've read 23 books about management in my resume wouldn't do much good, but saying that I've had successful experience doing it would.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7959032].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Kay King
            I know that I cannot get a promotion in my company because it's too small. I know that I won't get an extra raise. I know that I won't get any useful contacts due to my supervisor. I know that our methods of approaching problems are completely opposite (I'm future-oriented, he's past-oriented). That said, I see absolutely no reason to share my thoughts about management with him or anybody else at my workplace - I have no motivation to do so.
            In 81 words - you used "I" ten times and "my" four times. You have decided (though you say you are new there) no benefits are likely to result from this job. If nothing else you should have some motivation to do well in your current job to keep a paycheck coming. Keep in mind your next employer will ask for a recommendation from the company you work for now.

            You are theorizing management but the people you work for are keeping a business going through a rough economy. That's not easy so maybe the management is better than you realize.

            I remember an employee evaluation meeting I attended years ago. The employee worked under me (I was the manager) and though his work was good his attitude and tendency to gossip and complain caused trouble.

            When problems were pointed out - the guy was angry and started telling us everything he thought was wrong in the company. We heard him out and then my boss (the company owner) had a simple question.

            "If you are so smart and superior to everyone else here - why is it I own the company and you work for me?"
            Signature
            Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
            ***
            One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
            what it is instead of what you think it should be.
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7959213].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author a_dude
              Originally Posted by Kay King View Post

              In 81 words - you used "I" ten times and "my" four times. You have decided (though you say you are new there) no benefits are likely to result from this job. If nothing else you should have some motivation to do well in your current job to keep a paycheck coming. Keep in mind your next employer will ask for a recommendation from the company you work for now.

              You are theorizing management but the people you work for are keeping a business going through a rough economy. That's not easy so maybe the management is better than you realize.

              I remember an employee evaluation meeting I attended years ago. The employee worked under me (I was the manager) and though his work was good his attitude and tendency to gossip and complain caused trouble.

              When problems were pointed out - the guy was angry and started telling us everything he thought was wrong in the company. We heard him out and then my boss (the company owner) had a simple question.

              "If you are so smart and superior to everyone else here - why is it I own the company and you work for me?"
              I do my job to meet the basic requirements (not always capable, need to get used to not trying to improve everything) and to get some experience, that's my motivation - to get a paycheck and to get a positive recommendation letter.

              Okay... So 3 workers talking half a day in front of the manager instead of doing their job (they should be calling clients) is good management? And that's been going on for since I'm employed, colleagues said that it's always been like this. What about cheap tech given to the workers or poor network configuration that causes 1) slow workflow when actually talking to a customer and having to ask him to wait a couple minutes until a program launches, or telling that the internet's gone and asking to wait a few minutes until it's restored? And those are just a few things out of MANY. If you disagree that it's not efficient, please explain your logic because I don't get it, at all.

              Originally Posted by Dan Riffle View Post

              After reading your responses to some excellent advice, I really feel like laying into you, but I remember what I was like in my early twenties and doing so would be hypocritical.

              Kay noted a very important point: you are way too into your needs and wants and, unfortunately, you don't have the education and experience to call your own shots yet.

              Spin your perspective around and your company will not only promote you, but they'll pay you accordingly, as well. If you make it a goal to improve your company, specifically by finding ways to improve revenue and decrease expenses, your employer would be astronomically stupid not to attempt to keep you. If not, you move on to the highest bidder.

              Right now, worry about developing a track record of success. It's that track record that will get you what you want.

              Or start your own business. You can start a side business for very low or no capital. Saying you can't is a cop out -- unless there's a clause in your employment agreement dictating no moonlighting. If so, find another job.

              Look, I get where you're coming from ideologically. Unfortunately, ideology and the real world can be mortal enemies.
              Depends on the shots. But I don't have the position either though.

              I already said that there is nowhere to be promoted to management in this company. Literally nowhere, there's no position available, I didn't mean it figuratively. If that wasn't the case, that is the BEST advice there is actually.

              I'm actually thinking of a decent idea that requires little capital to start a business, can't think of a decent one. Mostly the competition's too high with little capital. If you can help me with that, that'd be great by the way.

              Originally Posted by bizgrower View Post

              1) It's a different way to apply for a job as opposed to a resume.
              It should show your thinking towards operations, marketing, increasing income,
              reducing expenses...

              2) You would preface it with the fact that you are an outsider, which is a given
              and they will understand.

              3) Because you are not an insider you could only give examples from
              your experience and give them your take on market and customer service
              opportunities for more revenue and repeat and referral business. Perhaps
              research their sales and marketing processes by pretending to be a
              prospective customer, or interviewing existing customers...

              4) So what if they take your ideas. One company might. Another
              company might respect you and your motivation and take you on to
              help implement. They could also say they already thought of most
              of your ideas...

              5) Regarding your education, tell them more about how you learn
              what you need to learn, and do take steps to show them what you
              do to be self-taught as well as any training, workshops, seminars you
              attend. Include or add tech, people, sales, management, skills or trainings...

              Hope this helps.

              Dan

              PS -"example, my manager made me to waste a day making a list of what I do day-to-day in very small detail, so that an idiot (his words) could understand it, because I used my methods to do my job more efficiently, rather than his. However I prefer to be the guy creating the methods rather than the one following them or the one having freedom over how I do things)."

              Yes. You were recognized in really a positive way, so maybe you are with a company
              that is open for more. A place you could stay and get more experience, skills, and formal or
              informal education and knowledge. Perhaps eventually create a position for your self that you would be interested in and would make and/or save them many times more than your salary.
              1-3: Great ideas, but wouldn't pretending be an a***olish thing to do? After all, I'd waste the company's time. And interviewing customers would be odd too, I think it'd be something like an investigation rather than research, which isn't very nice to hear when you're a manager. (not arguing, asking for opinion)

              4: Need to be careful about such things, I suppose... Question's how. Stalk the managers? Hehe.

              5. Not much "real" stuff to show, most of it is at least remotely related to gaming (even managing a team, or the workflow of a web/graphics designer/etc.). But I think I could manage to keep some more detailed information from coming out of my mouth. So yea, that's a good idea.

              It does help indeed.

              P.S. He made me made a list of his methodology, not mine. That's the thing - he wants me to use his methods. For example, if he finds out that I use a different way of doing something, he makes me re-tell everything I've done to arrive there and open all related files and/or documents. If I tell him, he asks me "now, how you SHOULD have done it?" I find that very annoying and time-wasteful, my main focus becomes the fact that I have to not let him know how I do things and arrive at the same goal but in less time. I'm trying to not do that if it wouldn't save me more than 5 minutes, otherwise I'm trying to hide my steps so he wouldn't know that I didn't use his inefficient method to do the same thing. Probably funny.
              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7963072].message }}
              • Profile picture of the author Dan Riffle
                Originally Posted by a_dude View Post

                I already said that there is nowhere to be promoted to management in this company. Literally nowhere, there's no position available, I didn't mean it figuratively.
                So you're telling me that if you came up with ideas that reduced expenses by 20% and increased revenue by 25%, they wouldn't create a position for you or, at the very least, give you a shiny new title and a sizeable raise? I honestly highly doubt that.
                Signature

                Raising a child is akin to knowing you're getting fired in 18 years and having to train your replacement without actively sabotaging them.

                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7963137].message }}
                • Profile picture of the author a_dude
                  Originally Posted by Dan Riffle View Post

                  So you're telling me that if you came up with ideas that reduced expenses by 20% and increased revenue by 25%, they wouldn't create a position for you or, at the very least, give you a shiny new title and a sizeable raise? I honestly highly doubt that.
                  I'll answer shortly this time: the manager's moto's "if it works - why change it?"
                  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7963188].message }}
                  • Profile picture of the author Kay King
                    I do my job to meet the basic requirements (not always capable, need to get used to not trying to improve everything) and to get some experience, that's my motivation - to get a paycheck and to get a positive recommendation letter.
                    You were doing really good there...for a minute. But then you went right back to complaining about how the company is run, how other workers do their jobs and criticizing the manager.

                    He made me made a list of his methodology, not mine. That's the thing - he wants me to use his methods. For example, if he finds out that I use a different way of doing something, he makes me re-tell everything I've done to arrive there and open all related files and/or documents. If I tell him, he asks me "now, how you SHOULD have done it?"
                    That tells me you aren't as good as you seem to think. Your manager has given you a protocol - a procedure to follow. You aren't following the procedure.

                    It is not unusual for a company to require a job done in a certain way using specifically designed procedures. You may not think this is the best way but there are valid reasons for defined procedures in any company.

                    otherwise I'm trying to hide my steps so he wouldn't know that I didn't use his inefficient method to do the same thing.
                    People are giving you advice based on what you've said about yourself - and I think you are way off base. You are trying to hide what you do - don't want to follow instructions from your manager. Those are not traits of a good worker or someone on his way "up".

                    There are times when innovation helps you move ahead - and times when refusing to follow policy or respect management gets you fired.
                    Signature
                    Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
                    ***
                    One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
                    what it is instead of what you think it should be.
                    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7964007].message }}
                    • Profile picture of the author a_dude
                      Originally Posted by Kay King View Post

                      You were doing really good there...for a minute. But then you went right back to complaining about how the company is run, how other workers do their jobs and criticizing the manager.
                      So I say the truth now? What's up with that? And yes, this is a serious question, because that's what you've discarded - the truth. Have you even read it?

                      That tells me you aren't as good as you seem to think. Your manager has given you a protocol - a procedure to follow. You aren't following the procedure.

                      It is not unusual for a company to require a job done in a certain way using specifically designed procedures. You may not think this is the best way but there are valid reasons for defined procedures in any company.
                      How do you know how good I am? Not saying that I'm good, but you can't, nor can you know his procedure. Your motivate, however, seems to be to reverse whatever I say.

                      Yes, he has given me a protocol, however the steps are not recorded anywhere, and the goal is reached in half the time it would be if I followed his protocol. The only way he can discover that I didn't follow it is by coming by and peeking from behind my shoulder, which is when I stop working and just wait for him to leave or talk to him with hopes that he leaves faster. Hate it when somebody's standing behind me. In short - no point in following his protocol.

                      I've covered this already, but as I said, there's no reasons because it is not recorded, only the result is.

                      People are giving you advice based on what you've said about yourself - and I think you are way off base. You are trying to hide what you do - don't want to follow instructions from your manager. Those are not traits of a good worker or someone on his way "up".

                      There are times when innovation helps you move ahead - and times when refusing to follow policy or respect management gets you fired.
                      If the procedure is recorded and needed for something, which I haven't mentioned previously. Now I have, so I think you'll rethink this part.

                      Unless you meant moving up in the same company, which, as I've repeated multiple times, will not happen.

                      Originally Posted by Dan Riffle View Post

                      So will I: Good luck. You're going to need it.
                      Sounded like sarcasm. If so, why was it sarcasm?
                      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7967303].message }}
                      • Profile picture of the author Kay King
                        Not saying that I'm good
                        Yes, I've read everything you wrote here - and that's exactly what you've been saying.

                        Still don't know where you are located - maybe that kind of approach works where you are. Whatever - it's your job. Good luck with it.
                        Signature
                        Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
                        ***
                        One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
                        what it is instead of what you think it should be.
                        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7967358].message }}
                        • Profile picture of the author a_dude
                          Originally Posted by Kay King View Post

                          Yes, I've read everything you wrote here - and that's exactly what you've been saying.

                          Still don't know where you are located - maybe that kind of approach works where you are. Whatever - it's your job. Good luck with it.
                          I like how you ignore my whole posts and just say that you're right, without discussing anything or paying attention to what I say.
                          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7968240].message }}
                          • Profile picture of the author Kay King
                            ignore my whole posts
                            Are you serious? You want to be in management and that's your level of understanding and discussion?

                            Good luck with that - I'm done here.
                            Signature
                            Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world changes forever for that one dog
                            ***
                            One secret to happiness is to let every situation be
                            what it is instead of what you think it should be.
                            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7968884].message }}
                            • Profile picture of the author a_dude
                              Originally Posted by Kay King View Post

                              Are you serious? You want to be in management and that's your level of understanding and discussion?

                              Good luck with that - I'm done here.
                              Thought you were done with the previous post - you've ignored my previous post even then.
                              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7968941].message }}
                              • Profile picture of the author Big Rob
                                Dud,

                                You seem to have all the answers, why did you come here in the first place?

                                As, Riffle already said, You have had some very thoughtful and sound advice given to you, yet you choose to be combative and arrogant.

                                Not a good way to make friends.

                                You are a subversive at your workplace, and I can only hope for the companys sake, you quit or get fired.

                                Congratulations, Know it all.

                                You have successfully alienated people here that were genuinely trying to help.

                                Now, think about your actions here, and the end result.

                                Don't go away mad, just go away.
                                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7969026].message }}
                                • Profile picture of the author a_dude
                                  Originally Posted by Big Rob View Post

                                  Dud,

                                  You seem to have all the answers, why did you come here in the first place?

                                  As, Riffle already said, You have had some very thoughtful and sound advice given to you, yet you choose to be combative and arrogant.
                                  I've explained why I can't do X or Y, yet I received no answers to that. That's not being arrogant, that's a discussion. I've even said that some advice IS great however I can't use it *....* <-- explained why in detail. That was ignored.

                                  Not a good way to make friends.

                                  You are a subversive at your workplace, and I can only hope for the companys sake, you quit or get fired.
                                  Yea... Now I get it why you've posted what you've posted. Not going to even reply the the rest of your post. You just don't like that I don't recognize the concept of authority, and you refuse to go into detail...
                                  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7969058].message }}
                  • Profile picture of the author Dan Riffle
                    Originally Posted by a_dude;7963188>

                    I'll answer shortly this time<snip>
                    So will I: Good luck. You're going to need it.
                    Signature

                    Raising a child is akin to knowing you're getting fired in 18 years and having to train your replacement without actively sabotaging them.

                    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7964041].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Dan Riffle
    After reading your responses to some excellent advice, I really feel like laying into you, but I remember what I was like in my early twenties and doing so would be hypocritical.

    Kay noted a very important point: you are way too into your needs and wants and, unfortunately, you don't have the education and experience to call your own shots yet.

    Spin your perspective around and your company will not only promote you, but they'll pay you accordingly, as well. If you make it a goal to improve your company, specifically by finding ways to improve revenue and decrease expenses, your employer would be astronomically stupid not to attempt to keep you. If not, you move on to the highest bidder.

    Right now, worry about developing a track record of success. It's that track record that will get you what you want.

    Or start your own business. You can start a side business for very low or no capital. Saying you can't is a cop out -- unless there's a clause in your employment agreement dictating no moonlighting. If so, find another job.

    Look, I get where you're coming from ideologically. Unfortunately, ideology and the real world can be mortal enemies.
    Signature

    Raising a child is akin to knowing you're getting fired in 18 years and having to train your replacement without actively sabotaging them.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7959318].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author williambrown
    Base on what I read you could do what you wanted to do, you have the right skills and attitude you just have to hone it so that you could be efficient
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7960223].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Big Rob
    Consider this,Troll.

    You will never manage anyone until you mature.

    Recognition of the "concept" of authority?

    Like actually earning your pay and contributing to the betterment of the company you work for?

    Nah, not your style.

    You would rather sabotage your superiors, that way, you suppress your own insecurity.

    Keep believing you have all the answers, thinking you can achieve everything without any effort,feigning humility and cooperation, only to deceive.

    And ,therein lies the sad reality.

    Perhaps my original post did not register with you, let me try again.

    Congratulations, Know it all.

    You have successfully alienated people here that were genuinely trying to help.

    Now, think about your actions here, and the end result.

    Don't go away mad, just go away.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7969641].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author a_dude
      Originally Posted by Big Rob View Post

      Consider this,Troll.

      You will never manage anyone until you mature.

      Recognition of the "concept" of authority?

      Like actually earning your pay and contributing to the betterment of the company you work for?

      Nah, not your style.

      You would rather sabotage your superiors, that way, you suppress your own insecurity.

      Keep believing you have all the answers, thinking you can achieve everything without any effort,feigning humility and cooperation, only to deceive.

      And ,therein lies the sad reality.

      Perhaps my original post did not register with you, let me try again.

      Congratulations, Know it all.

      You have successfully alienated people here that were genuinely trying to help.

      Now, think about your actions here, and the end result.

      Don't go away mad, just go away.
      Maturity is a relative term. For most mature means being married for 40 years and eating at the same diner for 25 at exactly 7:46AM. Not my style.

      Earning my pay means doing my job, which is what I do. There wasn't a line saying "do more than you're asked for" in my contract, was there? And you don't have to care about the company you work for only because you work for it. You don't even have to respect it or anybody working in it. Especially when getting a job is hard and you can't choose who to work for, and even if you could - I don't do the "respect blindly" nonsense, that's just utterly stupid and mindless.

      Uhm. Do you think that my insecurity is refusing to follow inefficient procedures to achieve the goal while doing a specifically goal-oriented task? Yea, I'm insecure about that and I'd rather sabotage the superiors by doing my job more efficiently.

      When have I said that I believe that one can achieve something without any effort? Little do you care that you haven't read most of my posts here, now you're also making them up. Great going.

      As for your "re-post," I'm going to re-post as well, maybe it didn't register with you well either:

      Read my posts before replying to them. Read them whole, not 2 words. Tie my answers with the quotes above the text you read.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7970548].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ronrule
    Back in the 1990's, IBM was on the brink of bankruptcy and their future was uncertain. They had lost their grip on the software industry after the sale of DOS, and lost their grip on the hardware industry due to the emergence of lower cost hardware manufacturers like HP, Packard Bell, Compaq, etc. Management couldn't figure out where they went wrong.

    It wasn't until a shareholder meeting that one of the shareholders voiced an observation. IBM had a habit of promoting their best employees up the chain, it was one of the reasons they attracted the top talent in their earlier years - people knew they would be able to move up in the company. But this came with a side effect... when you promote your best programmers to management positions, you're leaving the programmers who WEREN'T as good doing the programming. Likewise when you promote your best engineers and marketing strategists, you're leaving the ones who aren't as good doing the engineering and marketing. Product quality suffered, and that gap created the opportunity for competitors to move in and capitalize on their temporary weakness.

    IBM learned from their mistake and was able to turn it around, and it's a case that's been studied by every successful CEO I've ever met. Ever wonder why people always scratch their heads wondering why companies that used to promote from within don't anymore? This is why. Because the higher-ups don't want to promote the best people ... they want the people who are best at their jobs to continue to do them, and are more apt to hire someone outside with an established management track record than promote the best and brightest within a department.

    So - now that you have some insight into how your managers (and their superiors) are viewing their workforce, you can use this knowledge to your advantage by executing the following strategy:

    1. Stop being a rockstar at your job - it's keeping you exactly where you are. Do the job you're being paid to do, following the procedures laid out by your management team - nothing less, nothing more.

    2. Stop trying to impress your CURRENT employer - statistically speaking, if you want to move up you have no future there. Whether you agree or disagree with me on this, PRETEND it's the case.

    3. Take LEADERSHIP initiative at every opportunity and don't wait for it to be offered to you. Offer to head up projects, even though you know it won't advance your career. Offer strategies, even if you know someone higher up will get the credit for them. Take EVERY opportunity, inside and outside of the company, to be a leader in everything you do even if no one notices.

    4. TALK about these things - share your best strategies through social media and LinkedIn. It doesn't matter if no one is looking TODAY - they'll still be out there the day someone is.

    5. Understand that arrogance will get you nowhere. If you think a company's policy is stupid, there's a right and a wrong way to handle it. If you have a better idea, you should HUMBLY and PRIVATELY meet with your superior to discuss it. "I was thinking that we might be more efficient if we did it this way instead" will get you a lot further than "this policy is stupid, we should do it like this"

    Once you've done these things, seek employment elsewhere and put in for management positions. Reference THESE THINGS - not your day to day tasks - on your resume. Because when you're standing in MY office waiting for an interview, I don't care about your menial cubicle job and how great you were at it unless I need to hire someone great for a menial cubicle job. When I hire a manager, I want to hire a leader - and it's those examples of leadership, whether it was your "job" or not, that will impress me. And when my team does their due diligence and looks you up on Facebook and LinkedIn, discovering a "public persona" that matches the resume will further reinforce my opinion that you're the right guy for the job.

    And one more tip ... EVERY employer is looking at your Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn profiles before they hire you. Every single one. Am I going to see a profile that matches the LEADER your resume has made you out to be, or a kid holding a red cup? Don't think your privacy settings are protecting your jackass Facebook posts from being seen... you never know who I know. If you live in my city, chances are I know SOMEONE who knows you. Maybe they're a better friend to me or my HR director than they are to you. And when I ask them "So what do you know about a_dude" are they going to say "He's a slacker" or "he cheats on his girlfriend" or "Man, that dude can party!" ... or are they going to say he's a really smart guy?

    Think about it. Presentation is everything.

    To win at anything, you need a plan. This should be your plan.
    Signature

    -
    Ron Rule
    http://ronrule.com

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7970637].message }}

Trending Topics