Trading is good to learn to make money?

15 replies
  • OFF TOPIC
  • |
I'd like start learning trading and stocks, but are they good to learn to make some money in today economics?


I've read many books about maths, warren buffet books, entrepreneurs books in last months..

I'm a computer engineering student atm but I really like investments, finance, marketing etc

I tought I could go on basic MBA degree after I finish engineering, but I think I can learn more about finance and stocks myself
  • Profile picture of the author whateverpedia
    Originally Posted by msuper28 View Post

    but I think I can learn more about finance and stocks myself
    You most certainly can.

    I'd recommend investing over trading though. It's the same principle, but with a longer time frame.
    Signature
    Why do garden gnomes smell so bad?
    So that blind people can hate them as well.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9494515].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author socialentry
    Also, you don't pay commish for each transaction as in daytrading so there's more margin for error.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9494741].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author pppz
    sure you can make big money with trading... but statistics says that on market only 1-3% of all people succeed ...
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9501341].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
      Banned
      Originally Posted by pppz View Post

      statistics says that on market only 1-3% of all people succeed ...
      About the same as in internet marketing, then, probably?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9501826].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author msuper28
        Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

        About the same as in internet marketing, then, probably?
        Maybe you're right? Internet Marketing is not for all.. also many scammers out of there..
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9502115].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
          Banned
          Originally Posted by msuper28 View Post

          Internet Marketing is not for all.. also many scammers out of there..
          In some markets, yes. And trading is definitely one of them, by the way: in forex trading (which happens to be the aspect of trading I know about, though I suspect this is probably true "across the rest of the trading board", too), the proportion of misinformation to information out there is particularly high: http://www.warriorforum.com/main-int...ml#post9457503

          .
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9502165].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author msuper28
      Originally Posted by pppz View Post

      sure you can make big money with trading... but statistics says that on market only 1-3% of all people succeed ...
      Really!? I know trading is not easy but only people who work hard can succeed at trading..
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9502113].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Young Financier
    In the long-run, none of that stuff really matters. We can talk about being able to read balance sheets, assessing the economic situation, etc. That stuff sounds good but it all comes down to being able to gauge supply and demand. You can do that by reading the market itself via price action. Besides, a lot of that information shows up in the prices before the public knows about it anyways, so it's useless. Learn to read price and you'll be fine if you can apply a method and control risk.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9503100].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author yukon
    Banned
    Here's what I've learned about stocks, always look for businesses that have a monopoly on their niche.

    An example is Baidu (BIDU). The day I watched the local TV news report that Google had been kicked out of China I started researching who was the most popular search engine in China If Google didn't exist, the answer was Baidu. To date that same stock is up +1,750%. I have no doubts that stock will eventually reach $500 per share as long as China Gov. keeps Google out of the country (still looking good).

    Anyways, there's money in business monopolies. Look around, do some research, who has unfair advantages where other businesses can't do anything about the situation.

    While we're on the subject of stocks...

    Warren Buffett once said something interesting about his insurance business, Warren said his bet on insurance is that the world will never end, If he's wrong it doesn't matter because none of us will be around to collect on the policies.

    One thing Warren does to minimize his insurance risk in case of local disasters, he's also an insurance affiliate where all he does is collect payment for insurance leads & leaves other insurance businesses holding the policies so he doesn't have to pay out on a claim.

    In the end the money is in the detailed research.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9503180].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author yordanov
    Trading is not so easy to learn, but if you start from somewhere read technical analysis and learn how to win real money!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9504257].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Joe Benjamin
      Originally Posted by msuper28 View Post

      I'd like start learning trading and stocks, but are they good to learn to make some money in today economics?


      I've read many books about maths, warren buffet books, entrepreneurs books in last months..

      I'm a computer engineering student atm but I really like investments, finance, marketing etc

      I tought I could go on basic MBA degree after I finish engineering, but I think I can learn more about finance and stocks myself
      You won't be able to learn it yourself.

      Those who DO know were taught and trained
      by those who ALSO were taught and trained by
      those before them.

      If you *figure it out* on your own, which is highly
      unlikely, it will be into old age. But, most likely,
      if you want to get rich doing it, it will be *never*.

      Unless you seek mentorship from those who DO
      know who himself was trained by those who DO
      know.

      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      About the same as in internet marketing, then, probably?
      Depends on who you ask.

      Originally Posted by msuper28 View Post

      Really!? I know trading is not easy but only people who work hard can succeed at trading..
      It's not hard, actually.

      You do have to know the basics (Sell Order, Buy Order,
      Stop Limit, Buy Limit, basic charting and candle stick
      formations, etc).

      It's no more challenging then learning how to ride a bike
      or tie your shoe.

      The challenge comes from people who THINK they know
      but don't.

      The simplicity is enough to *anger* you, yet inspire you.

      Originally Posted by yordanov View Post

      Trading is not so easy to learn, but if you start from somewhere read technical analysis and learn how to win real money!
      The BEST way is mentorship.

      Problem is, few are willing to *share their secrets* with
      outsiders (so to speak). So, they hoard information,
      keeping it among themselves and a select *elite* few.

      The best way to learn to drive, for example, is from
      someone who knows how.

      The best way, therefore, to trade, is from someone who
      himself has been taught to trade SUCCESSFULLY.

      Sure, he can study technical analysis, but it will mean
      nothing in the end if you don't understand how it applies
      in the market.

      Market Makers rely on naive traders to use Fibonacci
      the way they've been *taught*, hitting stop-loss orders
      and such, but it get's much deeper than that.

      There's a highly spiritual aspect to generating great
      wealth...

      ...if one seeks it.
      Signature
      **How I FLIPPED $80 into $690 Pure Profit With ONE EASY Method...2 to 3x Per Week...Only 30 Minutes Per Day (and how YOU can COPY my RESULTS, too!) **CLICK HERE FOR VERIFIED VIDEO PROOF**
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9577135].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author HN
        Banned
        Originally Posted by Joe Benjamin View Post

        You won't be able to learn it yourself.

        Those who DO know were taught and trained
        by those who ALSO were taught and trained by
        those before them.

        If you *figure it out* on your own, which is highly
        unlikely, it will be into old age. But, most likely,
        if you want to get rich doing it, it will be *never*.

        Unless you seek mentorship from those who DO
        know who himself was trained by those who DO
        know.
        What exactly did you say?

        You won't be able to learn it yourself? What a crock of nonsense! I know, I wish there was another way to say it.

        This myth is told by people who run a coaching business. If they are that good, why teach instead of just trade? Some say they can do both, it's not a matter of choice. Yet, if you can make money doing nothing but trading, why waste time teaching others instead of traveling the world or spending time with family?

        I 've watched some courses, they are run my marketers, not traders, mostly rehashed stuff. Some never even tell about swap or roll over fees and expiry dates (commodities). And they mostly teach day trading which is, well, not much different than a day job. The only difference is that you are not working for a boss, but staring all day at charts.

        When is comes to investing, it's really simple, you buy a stock and when it goes up you sell. If it won't go up, don't buy. Never buy hot stocks trading at all time highs. Never use stop loss. If you thought price was good, you should buy more at better price, instead of selling. I know amateurs will argue this point. And it's not relevant to day trading or forex. No stops if you are investing in stocks or commodities for a long term.

        Never listen to so called experts or specialists. Buy instruments that are trading at multi-year lows. Today it would be Silver 2/5 lots at $17, buy limit order 3/5 lots below $16.
        Sell half of what you buy above $20 and hold the other half. Don't listen to me either.

        Just read Peter Lynch.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9577229].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Joe Benjamin
          Originally Posted by HN View Post

          What exactly did you say?

          Exactly what I said.
          You won't be able to learn it yourself? What a crock of nonsense! I know, I wish there was another way to say it.

          Well if doing it your way worked out financially
          for yourself, how many millions have you made
          so far?

          ...silence?
          This myth is told by people who run a coaching business. If they are that good, why teach instead of just trade?

          This might be hard to swallow but...

          ...not everyone is a selfish, greedy person.

          I don't *have* to be here. I don't *need* the
          money. And like most I could keep this to
          myself and you'd never know.

          ...but God WOULD know. And, ultimately, I
          am here to serve Christ by reaching out to
          turn around peoples financial lives forever.

          Some people ARE inspired by God to give.

          ...like myself.

          For example, I can not, in good conscious,
          keep the information I have to myself for my
          own gain...

          ...for it's not my gain to begin with...it's God's
          gain. It's HIS money and it was HIS blessing
          to me so I can live the life of my dreams...

          ...marry my wife-to-be...

          ...have many kids...

          ...live in a big, beautiful mansion to raise my
          family with all their needs taken care of.

          ...and I can be a Father to my kids without
          making the choice, "Should I go to my child's
          dance performance at church or my 9 to 5 job?"

          These are the decisions I will never have to
          make because the Lord blessed me with what
          YOU might deem impossible.

          But I'm here to tell you the Truth...

          ...through Christ, ANYTHING is possible!

          And I am living proof.

          This is my way of glorifying him by blessing
          others the way he's blessed me.

          He's given me the responsibility to wake up
          and enlighten unbelievers like yourself that
          through HIM and HIM ALONE...anything IS
          possible.

          ...even the *impossible*.
          Some say they can do both, it's not a matter of choice. Yet, if you can make money doing nothing but trading, why waste time teaching others instead of traveling the world or spending time with family?

          How do you figure it's a waste of time to reach
          out and *touch* another soul by showing them
          the way to financial abundance here on Earth?

          That's a waste of time?

          Who says you can't travel the world, spend time
          with family AND enlighten others by teaching
          them currency trading principles that are HIDDEN
          from public eyes?

          I am led in spirit by Christ to do what I'm doing.

          Perhaps as the selfish, godless man I once was
          your question would be valid.

          Why reach out to spread the light at all?
          I 've watched some courses, they are run my marketers, not traders, mostly rehashed stuff. Some never even tell about swap or roll over fees and expiry dates (commodities). And they mostly teach day trading which is, well, not much different than a day job. The only difference is that you are not working for a boss, but staring all day at charts.

          The Holy Spirit, if it's within you and you listen to
          it will NEVER lead you astray, into scams or harms
          way.

          He will make it plain and simple. It may not happen
          at the time YOU want it, but it will in the time that's
          right for you...as it was for myself.

          This is such a time for you...if you can read deeper
          into message and allow your eyes to be opened.

          Right now the Devil does NOT want you to know
          what I have to share with you...at no cost to you...

          ...when I speak of the free gift of salvation in Christ,
          people reject that, too (MUCH more harshly).

          The choice is yours.

          Humble yourself and ask, "Okay, fine. HOW is this
          possible.?" And I'll be happy to show you. You will
          see it with your own two eyes, but if you don't Believe
          then you will be forever blind to this great wealth
          waiting for you.
          When is comes to investing, it's really simple, you buy a stock and when it goes up you sell. If it won't go up, don't buy. Never buy hot stocks trading at all time highs. Never use stop loss. If you thought price was good, you should buy more at better price, instead of selling. I know amateurs will argue this point. And it's not relevant to day trading or forex. No stops if you are investing in stocks or commodities for a long term.

          Never listen to so called experts or specialists. Buy instruments that are trading at multi-year lows. Today it would be Silver 2/5 lots at $17, buy limit order 3/5 lots below $16.
          Sell half of what you buy above $20 and hold the other half. Don't listen to me either.
          No disrespect but, you are severely misinformed
          and uneducated on the matter as knowledgeable
          as you think you are.

          It get's deeper...much deeper than what you have
          read...

          ...which is why I said, "You can't TEACH yourself
          this stuff"...it has to be taught to you who's been
          taught themselves...

          ...or revealed to you by God through someone else
          who's convicted to teach what they know.
          Just read Peter Lynch.
          see the above text
          Signature
          **How I FLIPPED $80 into $690 Pure Profit With ONE EASY Method...2 to 3x Per Week...Only 30 Minutes Per Day (and how YOU can COPY my RESULTS, too!) **CLICK HERE FOR VERIFIED VIDEO PROOF**
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9577857].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author tagiscom
            Originally Posted by msuper28 View Post

            Maybe you're right? Internet Marketing is not for all.. also many scammers out of there..
            What, IM is easy, spend 5 to 7 years hitting your head against a virtual brick wall, then, after finally figuring out what works, work hard for a few more months then start seeing some actual money flow in!

            And, yes, get scammed a few times along the way! Unfortunately!

            But, in the end, unless you go nuts, you will succeed. Like anything really, if you want to succeed, you do not give up, or stop trying!

            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9578050].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author whateverpedia
        Originally Posted by Joe Benjamin View Post

        You won't be able to learn it yourself.

        Those who DO know were taught and trained
        by those who ALSO were taught and trained by
        those before them.

        If you *figure it out* on your own, which is highly
        unlikely, it will be into old age. But, most likely,
        if you want to get rich doing it, it will be *never*.
        With all due respect, what utter bollocks.
        Signature
        Why do garden gnomes smell so bad?
        So that blind people can hate them as well.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9577855].message }}

Trending Topics