Giving Back: a Craigslist posting guide

by tomleen 65 replies
Hello fellow members of WarriorForum,

For some time now, I've been posting on Craigslist.
I've been through many trials and tribulations, but thanks to the very helpful members of this amazing forum, I finally started figuring things out for my own.

Now, I'm posting 200+ ads/day consistently, and making a steady living.

So why this post?
I want to give back to the community that helped raise me up.
I believe in paying it forward. That's an important value to me. Call it karma, or whatever, but the many blessed dividends I've had in my life are really do to helping others.

I hope this guide will cut your learning curve in half. All of my advice stems from posting firsthand.

IP solution
- An IP address is the way that computers identify each other on the internet. I needed a good way for these IP addresses to be different in Craigslist's eyes. I've noticed there's a *LOT* of speculation about this on WarriorForum. People will recommend different things without ever trying what they recommend.

What didn't work:
I tried HideMyAss and free proxies found online (they are everywhere). Out of about 260 posts, about 248 of these were flagged and deleted immediately. That's a 95% flagging rate.
- Some Craigslist posting experts on this forum have talked in length about WHY this approach fails. The idea is that Craigslist has already found and blacklisted a lot of these IPs.
- Public proxies run into the same issue. Go ahead and try and you'll see what I mean.

What did work:
- using residential DSL lines (RDSL).
- This worked better than VPNs and public proxies but after about 1-2 weeks of posting (~55% success rate), they were blacklisted too (~10% success rate)
- I'm fairly certain that Craigslist is able to track these residential DSL lines across accounts.

Renting VPSes and mounting personal proxy there also works.
- Since I could never be sure that other people weren't sharing the proxies, I purchased a cheap VPS for $5/mo and setup a Squid Proxy with help from one of the members here. I am not technical by any means, but it was pretty easy to do.

Resetting your router for a new IP
- If you force your router to use a different MAC address, you will get a new IP address. So it's pretty simple to post, then go into your router and change the IP address, then post again. As you setup more computers, you will be able to post faster simultaneously!

Phone Verification
- Almost all sections of Craigslist require phone verification at one point or another. It's one of the hardest part about posting on Craigslist.
- VoIP numbers like Twilio/Google Voice/Callfire all don't work.
- Craigslist can detect whether a phone number is VoIP or not. They just never send you the phone verification code.
- Asking friends does work. This one is pretty obvious but you can ask any of your friends in US or Canada to help you phone verify. Leveraging my Facebook network, I phone-verified about 80 or so accounts. You should always start off with this.
- Some carriers (but not all) will lease you a line with refundable fees. I have friends now opening lines, phone verifying and then refunding.
- Purchasing prepaid SIM cards
- I started purchasing SIM cards and plugged them into old phones to phone verify. It worked great and is still working to this day. the troublesome part of it is that most online prepaid SIM cards don't actually work... you have to find ones that Craigslist has not already blacklisted already. Private message me if you want more tips here as I'm reluctant to post this information publicly.

- Adding the same URL to the posts caused a LOT of deletions. Craigslist can track your URLs across posts.
- Automated spinners would work for a little bit and then start flagging hard. I recommend AGAINST automated spinners like WordAI as they tend to cycle through the same permutations.
- Scraping is pulling content from another site. This almost always resulted in a bad live rate for me. Craigslist can track content on other sites. A lot of times Craigslist has deals with popular websites to "share" their content so they know if you are simply scraping off another site.
- Other users are scraping content too, so Craigslist starts to see the same content over and over, resulting in flagging or banning your account.
- Hiring content writers and manual spinners to create content at scale.
- You can find good ones on Upwork to write your content.

Do manual Craigslist posting teams work? -
You can find a ton of Craigslist posters on Upwork and internet marketing forums. The truth is that 90% of them claim to know how to post, until your ads get flagged after a few hours.
- There are too many horror stories about outsourcing Craigslist posting to Upwork freelancers outside of the US. Buyer beware.
- My experience: poor communication, hard-to-track live ads, high risk of being scammed

Do Craigslist posting services work?
- Difference between a "Craigslist posting service" and a "Craigslist posting team": these services generally have a website that show you all the live ads being posted in *real-time* instead of handing you a spreadsheet. You can usually specify that a live ad only counts after it's been live for 3 hours. Everything is automated and no risk of being scammed.
- As mentioned by many other Craigslist expert posters here, the best posting services are usually "private" Craigslist posting services and not on "Google". They usually require a minimum amount to post. These guys usually handle everything for you and work with you to formulate the best content.
- I've had good success with Craigslist posting services when I wanted to scale up for certain niches.

Do Craigslist bots work?
- Do-it-yourself bots like CLADGenius and other bots don't work.
- My experience: I have used almost all of them, and I can tell you from firsthand experience that all of them gave me terrible results. CLADGenius was the best of the worst but crashed so often and got my accounts banned. Not worth the $3000 price tag.

So after all this work, why post on Craigslist? After all, it seems like a mountain to climb.
Well, fellow Warrior members, the effort is certainly worth it - the payouts on Craigslist are amazing as there is high barrier to entry to post. It might seem hard at first, but if you can find your niche and find a way to post, you'll be making steady, monthly income for days.

Never give up.
#offline marketing #back #craigslist #giving #guide #posting
Avatar of Unregistered
  • Profile picture of the author austing hausbb
    Excellent work... I've been trying to post on Craigslist for a while and a lot of what you posted is new to me.
    The best way I've found to post on Craigslist that you've alluded to is to run multiple computers and switch between them.

    Have you had difficulties scaling your ads? I'm not talking about spamming Craigslist, but hitting multiple regions as your product goes nationwide.
  • Profile picture of the author tomleen
    When I started posting, it made sense to offer my product/services to as broad of a demographic as possible. Craigslist is the best way to do that.
    So these days, I've been focusing on scaling the ads via the system I outlined in my original post. I have not ran into scaling issues yet, as I've been outsourcing to a lot of different freelancers.
    My methodology is basically... run with the system manually until you can prove that it works, then outsource it.
  • Profile picture of the author beat ship
    Very interesting "what worked" experiences. A lot of posts seem to focus on what doesn't work, so it's refreshing to see what did work. I've also had success with prepaid numbers for phone verification.
    Craigslist makes it very difficult to actually use different numbers as they block VoIP as you know.
  • Profile picture of the author vpn port
    It's interesting to note that Callfire/Google Voice don't work. Any idea on how they do that? There must be some kind of 3rd party service, right?
    If so, how come asking your friends works and VoIP doesn't?
  • Profile picture of the author tomleen
    I'm not sure on the technical specifics of why VoIP doesn't work. All I know is that many of the big name providers i've tried get blocked automatically. There was another user on this forum who had posted an in-depth thread/guide on why phone verification with VoIP doesn't work. I believe it's in the Programming section.
  • Profile picture of the author Stfenhuse
    That was one of my posts. Feel free to sort through the posting history, there's a lot of misinformation out there, so I try to make sure everything is as accurate and up-to-date as possible.
    In short, the reason why VoIP doesn't work is because 3rd party databases keep track of what "type" of number the submitted number is. As a result, in the same way that Craigslist tracks IP, they also track phone number and blacklist the ones they don't like.
  • Profile picture of the author vpn port
    If VoIP doesn't work, then the only real ways I can think of verifying phone is through the methods outlined in the original post. But what do you do when you run out of friends to ask? Do you have to find one of these carriers like you said?
  • Profile picture of the author tomleen
    There are a few more techniques for phone verification that I didn't share in the thread because it would be difficult to explain it all and the thread is long enough.
  • Profile picture of the author beat ship
    Question for you Tom is, how far does this method get you in terms of scaling? You mention that you are posting 200+ ads/day, is that consistent or are you taking breaks in between?
  • Profile picture of the author pias15

Trending Topics