A Client A Day Keeps The Wolves At Bay (And Mamma In New Shoes!)

by Local Banned
41 replies
First, let me talk a bit, just a bit, about businesses like Groupon, LivingSocial and all of their evil spawn.

Groupon clones are popping up everywhere.

But the fact is that discounting DOES NOT build your business!

PERIOD!

I think everyone agrees, Groupon and LivingSocial are coupons on steroids.

And if your a Groupon/LivingSocial coupon user, it's a pretty cool deal huh?

But, if you are on the business side, oh boy!

For over a year now, I have been warning our clients of the perils of using Groupon/LivingSocial and educating them in the proper anatomy of creating a better Groupon/LivingSocial offer.

I am such a strong advocate for these business owners.

I did finally figure out why a nurse anesthetist would choose to build a business (now with 6 offices) that helps small business owners to be more successful, and it finally dawned on me while vacationing in Las Vegas and I was able to spend some time with my Mom and Dad, and a number of my aunts and uncles ( a sort of family reunion) and I realized all of my family members owned their own businesses.

I am sure it is why I am so enthusiastic.

But please, understand that I am not bashing Groupon/LivingSocial as much as I am sounding the siren for business owners to beware, be careful if you will, because the Groupon/LivingSocial math is skewed.

However, this post isn't about how dangerous a Groupon/LivingSocial deal can be to an average business, and how doing business with Groupon or LivingSocial is more like borrowing money from a loan shark, it is about finding these business, whom are already vested in doing business with Groupon or LivingSocial and have already pulled the trigger on their offer.

The idea is simple.

You find these deals and approach the business owners with an offer to help them capture each couponers contact information, in order to attempt to monetize them in the future with follow up offers.

A Rice University study showed that only 60% of the businesses surveyed would use Groupon again (compared to Groupon's claims of 97%) but what is most troubling is the chances of a Groupon or LivingSocial couponeer of returning to a businesses they used a coupon at, are slim to none.

This is where you come in like a knight in shining armor.

You see, the Groupon and LivingSocial programs do not provide the business owner with emails nor phone numbers of their newfound customers, and this is very strategic on Groupon and LivingSocial's part in an attempt to have the merchant continue to use Groupon or LivingSocial.

Groupon and LivingSocial want to remain the Kings and keep access to their list. I am sure you have heard before, the money is in the list? Well, there you go.

So, the idea is to contact these business owners as their offer goes live.

Time is of the essence and talk about having a sense of urgency built into an offer.

So, you simply optin to Groupon and LivingSocial offers (you can use a coupon aggregator like www.yipit.com) and each day, you call the businesses with new offers.

"Hi, my name is _____ with Maximize Groupon, may I speak to the person who is running the promotion today?"

This question gets you through the gatekeeper without having to answer any questions and puts the owner or at the very least, the general manager immediately on the phone.

"Hello, owner, my name is ______ with Maximize Groupon. Crazy exciting to see the number of Groupons sold so far isn't it? I see that you have sold X so far (you simply have the Groupon page open so the numbers are at your fingertips). Well, our company works with local merchants across the US that are currently running Groupon promotions and we offer an automated system for you to capture and connect with your customers at the exact point of sell, when they come to redeem the Groupons. You then have an effective way to contact them after the promotion. You know, to run your own offer, and keep all the money.

How does that sound?

I want to send you a quick one minute video that explains our program. What's a good email for you?"

Then you send them an email with a short video that explains it all.

Obviously, I am not going to give away exactly what we are using, but in doing our competitive research we did find a company that has a similar model and is using these videos, which are pretty good at explaining.

http://www.ingagemarketing.com/incapture-cms/capturegroupon/

http://www.ingagemarketing.com/incapture-cms/capturelivingsocial/

Please, do not COPY, but rather model.

What we are offer the businesses is a CMS system, that allows the owner to follow up via email and SMS (text messaging) and understand, you will not be selling, for example, text messages for .03 cents each, that is just NUTS!

95% of the clients we sign, join for a package that boasts 500 subscribers (they do not believe they would ever have more than 500 subscribers) with the ability to send one email and text message every two weeks for $147 a month. We do charge a $95 set up fee as well.

Currently, we only have one telemarketer/closer doing this, but he sells on average 5-8 of these per day.

You do the math!

Ciao,
Evie
#bay #client #day #mamma #shoes #wolves
  • Profile picture of the author Sky Writer
    Evie,

    This is both a great door opener and money maker. The new clients must then be receptive to buying more of your products/services, since this service should always make them future money, if enticing "come-back" offers are made.

    You are very generous with all the winning ideas you share.

    Thank you.

    With your double experience as a nurse anesthetist and helping small businesses make money, have you developed any products/services for the health care industry?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4628979].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Vagabond 007
    Funny you bring this up. I'm currently taking a few minutes break from working on this exact idea.

    Your thread gave me some additional tips I can use. Appreciate it!
    Signature
    The Ultimate Sales & Marketing Mind Map (Just updated - now twice as big!) - scott_krech - "Quite possibly one of the BEST WSO's ever."

    www.UltimateMindMap.com


    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4629013].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RRG
    Interesting. What system/program/software are you using to send out the emails and SMS messages? Do you control the sending of the messages or does the client?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4629301].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Vikuna2009+
      Re: A Client A Day Keeps The Wolves At Bay (And Mamma In New Shoes!)


      You don't happen to be Swedish, do you, lol? Great idea btw, thank you, Eva

      "Mamma vill ha nya skor".

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4629328].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author ryanpadilla
        So how exactly do you set up the system that captures new clients for the business
        Signature

        <a href="http://bestmobi.us">I build and sell mobile websites.</a> /
        <a href="http://drobelinc.net">I do internet Marketing.</a> /
        2-3 page mobile website for warriors for $45. If you want more we can talk. Just PM Me.

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4629655].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Local
        Banned
        Originally Posted by Vikuna2009+ View Post

        Re: A Client A Day Keeps The Wolves At Bay (And Mamma In New Shoes!)


        You don't happen to be Swedish, do you, lol? Great idea btw, thank you, Eva

        "Mamma vill ha nya skor".

        Ja, min familj svenska. Hur mår du?

        Farväl,
        Evie
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4630986].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by RRG View Post

      Interesting. What system/program/software are you using to send out the emails and SMS messages? Do you control the sending of the messages or does the client?
      Personally, we now have our own system with our own short codes, however, when we started, we had a private label version of Trumpia.

      I would not pay the set up fee, nor the monthly licensing fee. And you can also get a lower buy in, as low as $1,000 which equals about .03 cents each (30,000 texts) or buy in with $2,000 and get them for around .02 cents each. Once you are doing some real numbers, you can get text messages as low as .005 cents each. Your own email server will be an additional $150 per month, but once you have some clients in the bag, it is a no brainer, as I have stated before on the Warrior Forum, we also do simple restaurant walk ins and give them a free month to test and then $97 to $147 to start.

      Our closing ratio is at least 80% with all of our area restaurants.

      For someone that is just staring out with SMS, I'd probably use the simplest of services that actually work, like YepText and aweber.

      Don't mail it too complicated.

      Also, do not allow your text messages to roll over, the breakage is profit, and you don't want to be surprised by some dormant client, suddenly waking up and wanting to use all 2 MM of his messages.

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4630955].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author SirThomas
    Great post Evie! Thank you.

    1. Do you allow them to send email and SMS in alternate weeks like this:

    week one -SMS
    week two - email
    week three - SMS
    week four - email

    Or:

    week one - SMS + email
    week three - SMS + email

    2. Do you have a custom CMS system?
    3. Do they do their own text/email messaging or you do it for them?


    Thomas
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4629609].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by SirThomas View Post

      Great post Evie! Thank you.

      1. Do you allow them to send email and SMS in alternate weeks like this:

      week one -SMS
      week two - email
      week three - SMS
      week four - email

      Or:

      week one - SMS + email
      week three - SMS + email

      2. Do you have a custom CMS system?
      3. Do they do their own text/email messaging or you do it for them?


      Thomas
      Actually, that is just the way we explain it, what the package REALLY is, is 500 clients and 1,000 SMS and 1,000 emails, ie. 500 clients, messaging two times per month via email and text.

      Does that make sense?

      And I posted previously, we used to use a white label version of Trumpia (actually we are still using it for a number of clients) and if I was starting out, I'd use something like YepText and aweber.


      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4631019].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Warrior Ben
    WARNING TO ALL WARRIOR FORUM NEWBIES:

    Local/Evie has been exposed to not be who she says he/she is. While some advice given by "Evie" sounds good, (s)he is attempting to take advantage of newbies from an offer in his/her signature. Fair Warning -- Proceed at your own risk!!

    The thread where Local/Evie was outed is here (go to page 2): http://www.warriorforum.com/offline-...month-2-a.html

    For advice on how to avoid being scammed read this thread: http://www.warriorforum.com/offline-...-business.html


    (This post updated with the above information on 9/16/2011)

    ______________________

    Have you actually had much success with this?

    The reason I ask is because I've tried this approach too (contacting companies running Groupons to offer SMS services) and I have found that the day of their Groupon running, the businesses are so consumed with running their Groupon that the last thing they want to take is a sales call-- even when the sales call can actually boost their long term Groupon ROI.

    Additionally, I have a friend who ran a Groupon for his business and he said that Groupon is well aware that people use Groupon as a lead source and the sales rep cautioned him multiple times that salespeople will be calling him after his Groupon runs. Groupon requires businesses to sign a 90 day non-compete and in their standard welcome/what to expect e-mail to business owners, Groupon explicitly threatens legal action if the business owner signs up with another company during the 90 day period. Granted, the non-compete is for signing up with LivingSocial or another clone, but Groupon goes out of their way to scare business owners away from other services that they will be pitched as a result of running the offer. I've heard this from multiple business owners who have ran Groupons.

    Anyway, the whole point of me saying this is that in theory it sounds like a great pitch to business owners to capture the information of their Groupon clients, but in reality I've found it next to impossible to get them to buy anything. And Groupon does provide the e-mail addresses to the business of their customers, so although it isn't as effective as SMS marketing, the business owner still does have a way to follow up with their Groupon customers.

    So I guess Evie, my question for you, is when you say you have a telemarketer selling 5 - 8 of these a day, how many actual calls is he making? Are you calling all Groupon offers nationwide for that day and then closing 5 to 8 or just limiting yourself to a few markets? If you are in fact calling people nationwide and closing 5 to 8 deals, then why are you sharing this for free on WF? Seems like you'll just be hurting yourself by encouraging competition...

    -Ben
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4630088].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by Warrior Ben View Post

      Have you actually had much success with this?

      The reason I ask is because I've tried this approach too (contacting companies running Groupons to offer SMS services) and I have found that the day of their Groupon running, the businesses are so consumed with running their Groupon that the last thing they want to take is a sales call-- even when the sales call can actually boost their long term Groupon ROI.

      Additionally, I have a friend who ran a Groupon for his business and he said that Groupon is well aware that people use Groupon as a lead source and the sales rep cautioned him multiple times that salespeople will be calling him after his Groupon runs. Groupon requires businesses to sign a 90 day non-compete and in their standard welcome/what to expect e-mail to business owners, Groupon explicitly threatens legal action if the business owner signs up with another company during the 90 day period. Granted, the non-compete is for signing up with LivingSocial or another clone, but Groupon goes out of their way to scare business owners away from other services that they will be pitched as a result of running the offer. I've heard this from multiple business owners who have ran Groupons.

      Anyway, the whole point of me saying this is that in theory it sounds like a great pitch to business owners to capture the information of their Groupon clients, but in reality I've found it next to impossible to get them to buy anything. And Groupon does provide the e-mail addresses to the business of their customers, so although it isn't as effective as SMS marketing, the business owner still does have a way to follow up with their Groupon customers.

      So I guess Evie, my question for you, is when you say you have a telemarketer selling 5 - 8 of these a day, how many actual calls is he making? Are you calling all Groupon offers nationwide for that day and then closing 5 to 8 or just limiting yourself to a few markets? If you are in fact calling people nationwide and closing 5 to 8 deals, then why are you sharing this for free on WF? Seems like you'll just be hurting yourself by encouraging competition...

      -Ben
      Hi Ben!

      You are absolutely right, they are slammed with the running of their Groupon.

      And when we first started playing with this, it was really tough to even get through to them, let alone have a conversation.

      That initial script, once we started using that, made all the difference.

      And it was a grind to get our first few clients, but once we did, here is what we did.

      We sent two of our people down with Kodak Zi8 HD small flip-like cameras and wireless mics, and we were able to capture video of their business with a flood of people coming in their doors, how hectic the workers were, just basically capturing ciaos.

      We were able to interview each owner as they took breathes in between putting out fires, dealing with customers that did not want to follow the rules, running out of product, cash registers refusing to open, computer systems freezing, etc., etc., and we did that with 4 different businesses.

      We turned that into a sort of 3 1/2 minute documentary of being on the merchant end of a Groupon Deal.

      We even captured one of the owners calling Groupon to tell them to please STOP selling any additional deals as they hit their agreed upon ceiling 260 deals ago and their business could not handle the additional customers and Groupon refusing.

      We also did some simple Groupon math versus real math and have a quick interview with one merchant that did 4 different Groupon offers, each additional offer to help finance the losses from the previous.

      Once a prospect has finished watching that video, if they do not click call, and call us back, they must be out of their mind.

      We even explain integrating our solution into their Groupon campaign, will be seamless, but a week from now, when they want to generate another flood of business, and keep 100% of the money, they can, all at the push of a button.

      Now, getting them to watch our 3 1/2 minute video when they are at the beginning of all this ciaos, that is he trick that we had to figure out.

      But using the same wording in the script I posted, 4 of our telemarketers were able to each sell at least 1-2 per day.

      It was only after one of our closers began using wording that lite a fire under the business owners buns and encouraged them to go in their office, lock the door, turn the phones off, including your cell and spend the next 3 1/2 minutes watching a video each of the business owners, acknowledge they would have paid at least $1,000 to view, prior to D day. The video ends with a vacant business and a hand written note taped next to the "Closed" sign which reads "Thanks Groupon!"

      As for Groupon reps warning business owners of other people, I can't speak for the entire nation, but around here, that is NOT happening. The reps I have experienced will say most anything to get the owner to sign on the dotted line and can't get out of there fast enough once that has transpired.

      At last count, we do employ around 16 ex-Groupon reps (across 4 states) and we have one in our training right now (and 12 Yellow Book reps.)

      I'll survey them at some point this week and find out, but I have been present with over 20 business owners in the last 3 months as they negotiated and signed the agreement (isn't their agreement the most one sided agreement you've ever seen?).

      At the time, we were going to start a consulting service that helped our clients secure the very best Groupon agreement terms and we customized the offer and the backend/upsell.

      Just too much opportunity I guess, as that has been placed on the back burner.

      As for the non-compete, that is directly related to LivingSocial, Facebook and Google Deals, and look around at how many merchants are ignoring that and doing deals with any deal of the day rep with a breath.

      And Groupon itself is going to have their own legal issues as each state's attorney general begins cranking down on, for example, the expiration dates. The AGs contention is that these are really "gift certificates" and new "gift certificates" laws prevail.

      Sad for owners who might have to honor certificates for a year or forever depending on the state.

      Although, there isn't a lot of breakage as reps try to insinuate. Especially with all of the reminders Groupon sends the purchasers that their certificate is expiring.

      Our telemarketer that is closing 5-8 per day is calling 3 metro regions.

      In all honesty, he admits he is only looking for low hanging fruit, and the idea was like I said to create a Groupon Consulting Program and that has kind of fallen out of favor with myself and a couple of our managers.

      It could be my fault for ragging on Groupon so much, but lets face it, businesses are going to use Groupon/LivingSocial, etc., as long as the economy continues to suffer. This business owners are scared to death and they mistakenly look at Groupon as a zero cost of entry, not realizing that is smoke and mirrors and there IS a cost and it could potentially bankrupt their business.

      As for offering this here on Warrior Forum?

      I don't see it that way at all. In the last year especially, I have been very blessed and it seems like the more people I am able to help, the better my luck becomes.

      The first year of doing local consulting, I was selling videos, and I got sucked into believing everything that I learned from a certain course. I had to figure things out on my own, and once I did, that same course seemed to be fascinated with me and my success. I was very free with what was working even giving exact details, and soon, my clients were getting phone calls from people who knew a bit too much about me, my prices, technical aspects of my business, etc., etc. and they tried to steal my clients away.

      I grew paranoid and began guarding every single tactic and strategy I learned.

      But, over time, I realized, the hard way, that for most business owners, having 5 videos on page one of Google, even for great keywords, wasn't going to change their life.

      I then set out to discover what it was these business owners really wanted and you know what, as you already know, they don't care a lick about SEO, SMS, HTML, etc.

      They think they want customers... but what they really want is increased profits... that can mean new customers or making them more profitable from the customers they already have, or a combination of both.

      Next, however, I found that what these business owners were most impressed by was my customer service. how much I genuinely cared for them and their business. When I asked about their family, it wasn't some sales technique to warm them up. it was because I care. I truly wanted to hear about their kids soccer game or their daughter's college graduation.

      And I said what I meant and meant what I said. When I messed up, I told them so. I under promised and over delivered in every possible way. Each client, is added into a service which mails them a physical greeting card every 3-5 weeks.

      Even for the silliest of occasions or odd holiday's "Talk Like a Pirate Day!"

      Any reason to stay in touch, ask how they are doing, offer a tip or trick unrelated to our business, but something that might help their business.

      Being exposed to so many different businesses allows us to get one heck of an education and one tactic or strategy that is taken for granted in one industry, might be considered pure genius when presented to another.

      This business is high tech, but never forget it is also high touch.

      But to get back on track (I'm getting there, I promise) it was the help and guidance that I got from an old college friend, who invited me to come see his local consulting business in Florida, and how freely he shared his business model and gave me permission to "go back and try this," "see how this goes over in California."

      Even John Durham here on this board, who was an open book on all he had learned throughout the years. Well, I got excited again and I love to help people anyway, so I am sharing without given details that could directly hurt my business.

      The whole reason I became a nurse anesthetist.

      If you think about it though, it's still sort of selfish because I know it will come back to me exponentially.

      And right now, I'm about the luckiest girl I know.

      And the fact that there is so much opportunity out there that 100 Warrior Forums couldn't handle it all.

      There really is gold in them there hills!

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4631450].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author princewally
        Originally Posted by Local View Post


        And I said what I meant and meant what I said. When I messed up, I told them so. I under promised and over delivered in every possible way. Each client, is added into a service which mails them a physical greeting card every 3-5 weeks.

        Even for the silliest of occasions or odd holiday's "Talk Like a Pirate Day!"

        Any reason to stay in touch, ask how they are doing, offer a tip or trick unrelated to our business, but something that might help their business.
        What service do you use to send the cards?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4636621].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Local
          Banned
          Originally Posted by princewally View Post

          What service do you use to send the cards?
          We use a number of services as we found our way, and determined which worked best.

          We currently use a mailing program called MOM.

          And here are the services we had the most success with (none of these are my affiliate links):

          https://click2mail.com/ <-- full color postcards including postage for as low at .80 cents

          Photo Cards, Holiday Photo Cards, Personalized Photo Cards and Christmas Photo Cards <-- greeting cards as low as .99 cents

          PremiumPostcard - Home Page <-- also full color postcards and your first 10 are free!

          https://www.sendoutcards.com/ <-- which is actually an MLM (you get paid on those you recommend the service to and those they recommend as well) and we do recommend to clients for use with their own clients. You can even have cards printed in your own handwriting.

          I am not a huge fan of MLM, but sendoutcards does a great job. Personally, the money earned is then donated to charities that are close to our heart, so it is a huge win/win.

          Ciao,
          Evie
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4636950].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Entertize
            Evie could you email me a fmcfllc @ yahoo?
            I have a question to ask you that I don't want to post up here and I can't pm yet.

            Chriss
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4638212].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author oleskool
        Thanks for sharing. Your Help Enough People Get What They Want You Will Get What You Want attitude is a working well for you. More people need to live by your example.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4649604].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Local
          Banned
          Originally Posted by oleskool View Post

          Thanks for sharing. Your Help Enough People Get What They Want You Will Get What You Want attitude is a working well for you. More people need to live by your example.
          What I have found works best for me, and I have tried to distill this with everyone I have hired, and really, my success today, is 80% them and 20% me, is that when people sense that you're being your true self, they automatically feel comfortable revealing their true self, and that's the beginning of mutual trust.

          Imagine if every business owner trusted you 100%...

          How beneficial would that relationship be?

          So, you start off by letting go of thinking about making the sale at all and focus all your thoughts on helping business owners to solve their problems.

          And I am not talking about consultative sales, that was the biggest load of crap... prospects know all too well that underneath the questions and conversation lurked the usual buyer-seller confrontation.

          And unless you first change the "secret" intent behind your questions, beyond the notion of thinking about the sale, then that looming conflict will make it impossible for your potential clients to trust you at all.

          So, yes, if you help enough people get what they want, and do so without any sales pressure or ulterior motives, you will get what you want.

          Ciao,
          Evie
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4650756].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Entertize
    Thank you so much for this Evie!!!

    Chriss Stewart
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4636421].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Warrior Ben
    Hi Evie,

    Thanks for your response to my questions above! I completely agree that Groupon is very one sided and is not in the best interest of small businesses. I've been reading that they are delaying their IPO because of all the accounting gimmicks that they are using in their S-1, so it will be interesting to see if Groupon is even going to be around in 5 years!

    Your closer who is getting 5 - 8 deals in only 3 metro regions must be a SUPERSTAR! How many Groupons run a day in each region, 10 or so? Getting 8 appointments from 30 leads is really good, but closing that many?! WOW!! I think I'm starting to see your real talent-- hiring incredible people to sell for you!

    -Ben
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4639527].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by Warrior Ben View Post

      WOW!! I think I'm starting to see your real talent-- hiring incredible people to sell for you!
      Yes, he is a gem, but I am so proud of everyone.

      The funny part is he continued to play with following up with the Groupon/LivingSocial and a couple of other deal sites (our newspaper is now offering daily deals in multiple categories as is entertainment.com) on his own time as a sort of proof of concept.

      I just inquired of Sean and he said he calls about 40-50 deals each day and closes about 1:4 now.

      :-)

      But all along, he was determined to make it work, and as I said, the key was getting these business owners to watch that darn video. You'd think that would have been relativity easy.

      Like they say, you can lead a horse to water...

      But like all of my stars, he has a fire in the belly and success on the brain.

      Groupon should have taken the big payday from Google, as their S-1 is exposing their business model is a lot more "float" than substance...

      I have not heard recent numbers, but they are hemorrhaging big time.

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4639626].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author camilopez
    Thank you for this Evie. This is really great information. I love that you are willing to share this freely!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4639864].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author xichabodx
    Awesome stuff, Evie!

    How much, if you don't mind me asking, are you paying your sales reps?
    I've decided back & forth of either charging or not charging set-up fees for my SMS/coupon services. I've decided to lean more towards a free trial for xx days. However, if I were to hire sales reps, I'd have to implement some sort of set-up fee to pay my reps (paying them most, if not all, of the set-up fee as their compensation).

    All this being said, what are your thoughts of charging set-up fees (with a possible money back guarantee) vs. offering free trials? --having sales reps or not. Granted, this may be vague, seeing each business model and approach will be different.

    Thanks again!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4640596].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by xichabodx View Post

      Awesome stuff, Evie!

      How much, if you don't mind me asking, are you paying your sales reps?
      I've decided back & forth of either charging or not charging set-up fees for my SMS/coupon services. I've decided to lean more towards a free trial for xx days. However, if I were to hire sales reps, I'd have to implement some sort of set-up fee to pay my reps (paying them most, if not all, of the set-up fee as their compensation).

      All this being said, what are your thoughts of charging set-up fees (with a possible money back guarantee) vs. offering free trials? --having sales reps or not. Granted, this may be vague, seeing each business model and approach will be different.

      Thanks again!
      Personally, our experience with free trials, unless you have huge volume and can afford the breakage, is not the best idea.

      The free trial clients, that would not ante up to put some skin in the game, were where most of our headaches came from. Also, trials that converted to a paid subscription, we had refunds and chargebacks to deal with.

      With that said, we do have an SMS service that has one month for $1 and then it converts to a full boat, however, we disclose that fact numerous times and even send them a link to cancel, 5 days before their maturity date.

      That IS working quite well, but we are sending on average 600 people a day to that site.

      So the numbers work.

      For Sean, our Groupon/LivingSocial closer, Sean keeps 100% of the setup fee.

      He is making bank, that is for sure, but worth every penny.

      He does not receive any of the recurring, however, he does have an opportunity to upsell additional services and earn a percentage from those sales as well.

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4644994].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author NewParadigm
    Hey great topic and congrats on your success. A friend of mine has a medspa and does all kinds of these deals with many coupon companies, and still makes a profit. She has negotiated down the fees as well as the field is getting very competitive. She does get the client info(because they come in for an appt). She will market direct to the clients down the line with similar discounts/promos and not have to pay any fees.

    Trying to understand the value proposition here. Are you saying that businesses are not capturing customer information to market to them again?

    Or you are providing them new easy service to send messages to their clients?

    thanks!
    Signature

    In a moment of decision the best thing you can do is the right thing. The worst thing you can do is nothing. ~ Theodore Roosevelt

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4641253].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Vrs
      Hi Evie.

      When I open a thread and see that it's you I always read everything in it, and I'm never disappointed.

      Thanks for all the great information. I have a folder full of Groupon leads I've never contacted. What you've shared here looks really good. (Anything you'd like to add for someone like me who will be contacting owners about Groupon follow ups for the first time)?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4641798].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Local
        Banned
        Originally Posted by Vrs View Post

        Hi Evie.

        When I open a thread and see that it's you I always read everything in it, and I'm never disappointed.

        Thanks for all the great information. I have a folder full of Groupon leads I've never contacted. What you've shared here looks really good. (Anything you'd like to add for someone like me who will be contacting owners about Groupon follow ups for the first time)?
        In the beginning, we were quite discouraged from our results, but then, I think what made the difference was the video documenting 4 live Groupon campaigns from the merchants side.

        Those 4 merchants, we went to in person and we offered to set them up for free, as a proof of concept, if they allowed us to document their campaign and speak freely with their customers and employees.

        That was a turning point.

        It also gave Sean the confidence he needed when speaking with future prospects, as he KNEW without a doubt, what we were selling was worth way more than what we were charging.

        And I am so glad you are getting value from my posts.

        :-)

        Ciao,
        Evie
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4645168].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by NewParadigm View Post

      Hey great topic and congrats on your success. A friend of mine has a medspa and does all kinds of these deals with many coupon companies, and still makes a profit. She has negotiated down the fees as well as the field is getting very competitive. She does get the client info(because they come in for an appt). She will market direct to the clients down the line with similar discounts/promos and not have to pay any fees.

      Trying to understand the value proposition here. Are you saying that businesses are not capturing customer information to market to them again?

      Or you are providing them new easy service to send messages to their clients?

      thanks!
      It sounds like your friend is doing it right!

      For some reason personal services, like medspas, personal trainers, gyms, etc., have figured out that they need to not only capture their newfound customers information (which is easily done in these businesses, as they require each client to complete paperwork) but they also understand the importance of making a OTO or upsell.

      Most business owners are doing neither.

      Additionally, in our reputation management business, we have identified how the OTO/Upsell, if done improperly, can ruin a businesses reputation, which they might have built over a decade or more, in a one or two day Groupon/LivingSocial campaign.

      The public will smell a rat from a mile away and if you abuse them, by attempting a bait and switch, the same viral activity that made your campaign successful, will also work in reverse and destroy your business.

      Even large Fortune 500 companies do not quite get how important it is to make a sincere offer and not attempt to game the Groupon/LivingSocial system.

      For example, one only need look at the horrible FTD flowers, Valentine's Day fiasco. Groupon offered $40 to FTD.com for just $20, just in time for Valentine's Day. Unfortunately customers ended up feeling ripped off as the prices for Groupon customers was basically more than double that of their public website and to make matters worse, no delivery until a day AFTER Valentine's Day.

      Talk about bad press!

      So, businesses need to hire a consultant that can navigate the landmines and create an offer and OTO that is congruent and their new customers will find useful and are excited by.

      BTW - I thought this was an interesting fact. Groupon is spending $24.08 for every new customer, while the average revenue per customer is $17.55, or $6.53 less than the cost of acquisition. Similarly, the cost of adding a subscriber to their mailing list is $5.37, while the real revenue per subscriber is just $3.43. The more people they bring in, the more money they lose.

      Is that REALLY sustainable?

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4645103].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Amber Jalink
        Originally Posted by Local View Post

        ........


        BTW - I thought this was an interesting fact. Groupon is spending $24.08 for every new customer, while the average revenue per customer is $17.55, or $6.53 less than the cost of acquisition. Similarly, the cost of adding a subscriber to their mailing list is $5.37, while the real revenue per subscriber is just $3.43. The more people they bring in, the more money they lose.

        Is that REALLY sustainable?

        Ciao,
        Evie
        I read about that - I guess its just because of their investors LOL.

        Amber
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4645598].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Mark_Babcock
        Originally Posted by Local View Post

        BTW - I thought this was an interesting fact. Groupon is spending $24.08 for every new customer, while the average revenue per customer is $17.55, or $6.53 less than the cost of acquisition. Similarly, the cost of adding a subscriber to their mailing list is $5.37, while the real revenue per subscriber is just $3.43. The more people they bring in, the more money they lose.

        Is that REALLY sustainable?

        Ciao,
        Evie
        It doesn't look like it is....sustainable that is.

        In Q1 2010 they netted $8.5 million on $44.2 million in revenue - pretty strong at nearly a 20% net.

        Then they got greedy and decided to conquer the world in one fell swoop by going into Hyper-Growth mode and....

        In Q2 - Q4 2010 they LOST $398 million on $669 million in revenue, and

        In Q1 2011 they LOST $102 million on $664 million in revenue.

        But here's the scary part.....their BALANCE SHEET

        Total Current Assets: $290 million (of which $208 million is cash)
        Total Current Liabilities: $520 million (of which $230 million is money currently owed to merchants for payment on deals they have already fulfilled).

        THEY OWE MERCHANTS MORE THAN THEY CAN CURRENTLY PAY.

        So if they don't keep the cash coming in the front end (from somewhere), they can't pay the merchants that have already done deals (hmmm....I think there have been some people prosecuted by the FTC for that - it's called a "ponzi scheme").

        AND.....it get's better (NOT)

        In 2010 they raised $1.08 BILLION in Capital from investors.

        Of the funds raised, ONLY $150 million was used for operating capital.

        AND $930 MILLION WAS USED TO BUY BACK STOCK FROM THE FOUNDERS AND EARLY INVESTORS.

        In the last round...the founders took $120 million of the $130million raised and only put $10 million in the company.

        On top of that, in late March of 2010 both the COO and CTO resigned on no notice (did they know something then that nobody else did that caused them to run....?)

        But a writer for one of the major financial publications argues that they are sustainable and not a ponzi scheme.

        I beg to differ (unless there are DRASTIC changes).

        The financial writer argues that IF they were a ponzi, when they reduced their expenditure on marketing, which they have done - their revenues would have fallen off accordingly, which they have not....YET.

        What he points out that he is not factoring into the equation is that even though their revenues didn't decline when they reduced their marketing efforts - THEIR LIST DID.

        They have 85 million subscribers on their list (at last published count), and when they reduced their spending on marketing, subscriber acquisition declined in direct proportion.

        Hmmm...

        Add to that the growing competition in the group buy / daily deal market and attrition from subscribers who are tired of getting deals that don't interest them or are out of their market and I would bet we WILL see their revenues fall - probably almost in direct proportion to their reduction in marketing expenditures and decline in their list...just trailing behind a few months as the "novelty" wears off and the last big group of subscribers (when they were still spending $6.53 to make $0 as Evie pointed out) joined the list and said "wow this is pretty cool."

        There have been some companies in the past that burned though massive amounts of cash that did survive and go on to be great success stories - but they had sustainable business models (Amazon comes to mind).

        And here everybody was anticipating one of the best IPOs in history with with an anticipated valuation of $20 Billion+ even in a down market...

        But wait, that was BEFORE they filed their documents and Andrew Mason (CEO) proclaimed that "we don't measure ourselves in conventional ways" as he explained that they had previously "excluded certain operating expenses, such as marketing and the cost of acquiring new subscribers" because it's "not indicative of future operating expenses."

        Yeah...right. And that's why subscriber growth fell off when marketing expenses were cut - and with natural attrition revenues most likely won't be far behind. Then when attrition exceeds new subscribers...it will all come tumbling down.

        But really, I hope I'm wrong. If they go down...they could very well take some small local merchants out with them in the process. They currently owe merchants more money than they have - and I'm sure there are more than a few out there who were "betting" on their group buy to bring in the business to keep the lights on another month or so.

        The founders and shareholders who pocketed over $1 Billion over the last year while the company was strapped for cash, rode merchants 60 days plus and can't pay what they owe? That's a different story.

        So from my point of view - I'm not buying Groupons anymore (not that I bought many - they never really sent me anything worthwhile) and if a business hasn't done one that is thinking about it...I'm sharing why they might want to reconsider.

        As for those businesses who have done them or are scheduled to....this is a great way to get them more interested in building their own list

        And Evie - Thanks for contributing so much and being genuinely interested in the well being and success of others. It's refreshing, always informative and a pleasure to read and follow your posts.

        Mark
        Signature
        Mark Babcock
        The Prolific Profit Coach

        "Turning Passion, Purpose & Potential into Profit"
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4652587].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by NewParadigm View Post

      Or you are providing them new easy service to send messages to their clients?

      thanks!
      Sorry, I think I am so excited my electricity is back on, I missed that question.

      BOTH!

      Even for those that are capturing new customer information, very few have a reliable system in place to follow up on a regular basis.

      One personal trainer, her in La Jolla, had 90 some prospects, they were emailing each one individually.

      Individually!

      And this gal used to be an executive at Cox.

      She was blown away when I showed her how to personalize messages using email, text messages and then when i shared voice broadcast... :-)

      And we all know how many touches on average before a conversion, right?

      And using SMS marketing in creative ways, has the highest conversions I have ever seen.

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4645140].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author rideotm
    When Groupn goes belly up, the execs can move right into politics and government jobs...they unwittingly have experience in the procedures for failure down pat
    Signature

    Smoking cigarettes and watching Captain Kangaroo

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4645255].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by rideotm View Post

      When Groupn goes belly up, the execs can move right into politics and government jobs...they unwittingly have experience in the procedures for failure down pat
      Oh, but a REAL politician would have taken Google up on their offer. :-)

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4645276].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BradCarroll
    Evie, I've been doing local SEO for right at two years now. You just upped my game tremendously. Thanks for sharing here. Let me know if you ever need a favor.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4648132].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Local
      Banned
      Originally Posted by BradCarroll View Post

      Evie, I've been doing local SEO for right at two years now. You just upped my game tremendously. Thanks for sharing here. Let me know if you ever need a favor.
      Brad - thank you, that is awesome!

      Much appreciated.

      What would you say your biggest constraint is right now?

      Ciao,
      Evie
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4650695].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author TheLocalCoach
    Evie,
    What a refreshing and intelligent thread! Thank you. Not only have you articulated a success story using a model that many are working on (Chasing Groupon to provide customer capture), but you so "get it" regarding all the reasons that Groupon is bad for business and all the reasons you (your approach) are good for business! As a business owner and mobile marketer, I strive to deliver, in message and spirit, exactly what you are doing. Congrats on your success.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4652400].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Local
    Banned
    Thanks Mark -

    I too hope we are wrong, but no matter what, when the economy turns around, and it eventually will, all of the deal sites will be gone.

    Ciao,
    Evie
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4662694].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Amber Jalink
      Originally Posted by Local View Post

      Thanks Mark -

      I too hope we are wrong, but no matter what, when the economy turns around, and it eventually will, all of the deal sites will be gone.

      Ciao,
      Evie
      I really like what you've posted too, I've kept my eyes on the industry as a whole, from both aspects (mobile texting and the daily deals as they are). I think customers will always want it - its the businesses that probably won't. I did actually purchase some sms keywords to start working with this strategy but got sidetracked... this reaffirms I was right several months ago when I did buy them.

      Hopefully businesses aren't too dazzled by the $ that "appears" to be created with the daily deals sites to focus on what is most important, profits going into their pockets (not others).

      Amber
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4663029].message }}
    • Originally Posted by Local View Post

      Thanks Mark -

      I too hope we are wrong, but no matter what, when the economy turns around, and it eventually will, all of the deal sites will be gone.

      Ciao,
      Evie
      I think lots of people are rethinking deal sites. Check out what's happening in China.

      And this.
      Signature
      Marketing is not a battle of products. It is a battle of perceptions.
      - Jack Trout
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4671848].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Debbie T
        This is amazingly helpful information.

        Are your clients logging and executing the weekly email and text messages/campaigns themselves? Or does your monthly fee include your agency handling all of that for them?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4676791].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author kmids
    I think people who change how business is done (for the better) can have great success. You just gotta work out the kinks.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4663153].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Local
    Banned
    how are people using daily deals sites right now?

    Some of the answers might surprise you:

    What's the Deal With Daily Deals? [INFOGRAPHIC]

    Ciao,
    Evie
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4666385].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author toptones
    Awesome stuff! Thank you.
    Signature

    All Things Mobile
    VICTORIA MOBILE MARKETING
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4693249].message }}

Trending Topics