Commission only sales reps

20 replies
I am curious if anyone has had any success with hiring commission only sales reps to advertise their services.

If you did, what was your experience like?
#commission #reps #sales
  • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
    Very difficult to attract and keep qualified candidates. Those who can do the job are already being well paid to do it.

    I've set up an agency for a management consulting firm, and it took 3 rounds of advertising & interviewing before I found ONE candidate who would stick with it past an hour. The rest were lousy candidates: unemployed psychiatrists, stay-at-home moms...people with no skill and no stick-to-it-iveness. I even gave away my training to those who signed up (admittedly, this was well before my current programs...about 3 years ago now). They were looking for easy money, and telemarketing ain't it.

    I help companies that hire home-based telemarketers now and we concentrate most on the screening process. It's the reverse of what everyone else is doing (hire all the people who apply, and let them sort themselves out--it's paperwork nightmare and such a waste of time that way).

    I would not recommend you go forward this way. Instead, get $100 and spend $10/hr on someone you can monitor. That was John Durham's suggestion and after all the experience I've had I agree fully with it. You can't expect full commitment from someone who's on 100% commission with an unproven company.

    And screen, screen, screen your candidates. Don't waste your time with anyone who doesn't have proven experience succeeding with self-motivated phone sales. If they haven't done the work at home themselves before, even if they've been an inside salesperson, it's unlikely they'll have the discipline to stick with it now.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8448379].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author midasman09
      Banned
      Excuse me....I felt "compelled" to respond to "Commission Only Sales Reps";

      I have had mucho experienceo with these people.

      Now.....for starters, my guess for WHY you posted this question is because YOU....think you have a good money-making idea and...either;
      1) Don't know HOW to sell it
      or
      2) You've sold a few of your "thingees" and you'd like to expand

      My thinking is #1

      So....you truly believe YOU have something that someone will PAY for, BUT....you haven't sold any yourself and....you'd like to find a "sales"person who has the experience and know-how to...Sell....your thingee!

      Well....when I started my very first business....I found I could sell my thingee but....I wanted to "manage" my biz and HIRE OTHERS ON A COMMISSION BASIS....so I didn't have to come up with "Guaranteed Weekly Cash + an extra commission IF....they sold anything."

      Well....I soon learned that I could NOT afford to hire "commissioned" sales people! WHY? Because the GOOD ones will...."take your idea and either sell it to someone else or...start up their own biz in competition with you, after You've taught them everything!

      So....here's what I found....knowing that;
      1) The no-good sales people will waste your time
      2) The GOOD sales people will try to steal your program

      So.......I ran an ad looking for "Pro Sales people"...."CLOSERS WANTED!
      I'm looking for sales people who can close sales! If you can close sales, call me at 555-1212"

      And....wow, I got a BUNCH of calls from every type of "con" guy I could imagine....BUT, I got a few calls from people I had a "feeling"....could be "controlled"!

      Now....watch what I'm about to tell you; "Straight Commission Sales People will TRY....to Steal Your Deal! HEY! THEY are investing their Time and Expertise to help YOU....YOU who has NO investment in THEM....other than when and IF they make a Sale.....for YOU!

      It's Human Nature to "look out for yourself FIRST"...all others come later!

      So.....HOW do you get GOOD Sales People who KNOW how to sell and close deals for YOU.....without having to worry about them Stealing your program?

      One word; PROMISSORY NOTE

      One of my Frat Bros was a Lawyer and he told me; "Hey Donnie Boy, just have them sign a Promissory Note for $2,500"! (The max you could sue for in Small Claims Court)

      So....when a sales person USED TO go thru my Sales Training....I'd have them sign a "Commissioned Sales Agent" agreement which spelled out what their commission is on sales.

      They'd then....go out into the "field" and either sell or not! Hey! Didn't cost me anything. I'd try and give them all the advice and help I could

      Those who couldn't CLOSE .....I spent the most time on. And....when they discovered they couldn't sell my stuff.....they'd just leave, not tell me and go find something else....TAKING MY SALES MATERIALS WITH THEM!

      Same with the GOOD sales people. They'd sell a few thingees then.... disappear....taking MY Sales Material With Them.

      So.....after I got EVERY sales person to sign my "Promissory Note for $2,500" (This is a "Promise To Pay" document which means that I could go to my Small Claims Court and get the clerk to give me a Form that allowed me to.....Got to their Bank and....PUT A "BRICK" ON THEIR BANK ACCOUNT!....which meant they could NOT deduct any funds....until I was satisfied.

      Well.... a few of the "knowledgeable" ones....reluctantly signed my Note AND.....EVERY SINGLE SALES PERSON THEREAFTER....whether novice or pro... when they decided they didn't want to try and sell MY thingees any longer.....TOLD ME, INSTANTLY....RETURNED MY SALES MATERIALS AND....ASKED ME TO TEAR UP THE "PROMISSIORY NOTE"!

      So....hike on down to your local Office Supply store and pick up some copies of "Promissory Notes".....call your local Small Claims Court and find out the Max Amount you can file a Small Claims Suit for....and USE THEM when "hiring" sales people.

      They helped me build a few Good-Sized businesses!

      Don Alm....long time entroopeneer
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8448727].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
        Originally Posted by midasman09 View Post

        Excuse me....I felt "compelled" to respond to "Commission Only Sales Reps";

        I have had mucho experienceo with these people.

        Now.....for starters, my guess for WHY you posted this question is because YOU....think you have a good money-making idea and...either;
        1) Don't know HOW to sell it
        or
        2) You've sold a few of your "thingees" and you'd like to expand

        My thinking is #1

        So....you truly believe YOU have something that someone will PAY for, BUT....you haven't sold any yourself and....you'd like to find a "sales"person who has the experience and know-how to...Sell....your thingee!

        Well....when I started my very first business....I found I could sell my thingee but....I wanted to "manage" my biz and HIRE OTHERS ON A COMMISSION BASIS....so I didn't have to come up with "Guaranteed Weekly Cash + an extra commission IF....they sold anything."

        Well....I soon learned that I could NOT afford to hire "commissioned" sales people! WHY? Because the GOOD ones will...."take your idea and either sell it to someone else or...start up their own biz in competition with you, after You've taught them everything!

        So....here's what I found....knowing that;
        1) The no-good sales people will waste your time
        2) The GOOD sales people will try to steal your program

        So.......I ran an ad looking for "Pro Sales people"...."CLOSERS WANTED!
        I'm looking for sales people who can close sales! If you can close sales, call me at 555-1212"

        And....wow, I got a BUNCH of calls from every type of "con" guy I could imagine....BUT, I got a few calls from people I had a "feeling"....could be "controlled"!

        Now....watch what I'm about to tell you; "Straight Commission Sales People will TRY....to Steal Your Deal! HEY! THEY are investing their Time and Expertise to help YOU....YOU who has NO investment in THEM....other than when and IF they make a Sale.....for YOU!

        It's Human Nature to "look out for yourself FIRST"...all others come later!

        So.....HOW do you get GOOD Sales People who KNOW how to sell and close deals for YOU.....without having to worry about them Stealing your program?

        One word; PROMISSORY NOTE

        One of my Frat Bros was a Lawyer and he told me; "Hey Donnie Boy, just have them sign a Promissory Note for $2,500"! (The max you could sue for in Small Claims Court)

        So....when a sales person USED TO go thru my Sales Training....I'd have them sign a "Commissioned Sales Agent" agreement which spelled out what their commission is on sales.

        They'd then....go out into the "field" and either sell or not! Hey! Didn't cost me anything. I'd try and give them all the advice and help I could

        Those who couldn't CLOSE .....I spent the most time on. And....when they discovered they couldn't sell my stuff.....they'd just leave, not tell me and go find something else....TAKING MY SALES MATERIALS WITH THEM!

        Same with the GOOD sales people. They'd sell a few thingees then.... disappear....taking MY Sales Material With Them.

        So.....after I got EVERY sales person to sign my "Promissory Note for $2,500" (This is a "Promise To Pay" document which means that I could go to my Small Claims Court and get the clerk to give me a Form that allowed me to.....Got to their Bank and....PUT A "BRICK" ON THEIR BANK ACCOUNT!....which meant they could NOT deduct any funds....until I was satisfied.

        Well.... a few of the "knowledgeable" ones....reluctantly signed my Note AND.....EVERY SINGLE SALES PERSON THEREAFTER....whether novice or pro... when they decided they didn't want to try and sell MY thingees any longer.....TOLD ME, INSTANTLY....RETURNED MY SALES MATERIALS AND....ASKED ME TO TEAR UP THE "PROMISSIORY NOTE"!

        So....hike on down to your local Office Supply store and pick up some copies of "Promissory Notes".....call your local Small Claims Court and find out the Max Amount you can file a Small Claims Suit for....and USE THEM when "hiring" sales people.

        They helped me build a few Good-Sized businesses!

        Don Alm....long time entroopeneer
        I hope you were getting them to sign W2 forms too, because since you're telling them how to do the work, following your training, they become an employee. (Hence my paperwork comment above.)

        Eventually that sort of thing is going to catch up with you. Someone will get injured, or file for unemployment.

        The promissory note is an interesting idea. However, I personally would stay out of this approach entirely because of the risk.

        As Midas said, it quickly becomes apparent that you can't afford to hire commissioned salespeople. As a product creator/business owner, it is best to learn yourself how to sell.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8448774].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author socialentry
          Yeah, I've seen how a (offline) commission only organization can operate. I never ran one myself and I'm not sure I would want to.

          If I had to condense it in one phrase, it would be: Sell them the dream.

          They had someone that is close to the rookies, like an immediate superior or a peer that succeeded using their system. The party line was that it was some kind of exclusive privilege to join them and everyone was an up and comer.

          Admitting not making money was kind of a hush-hush thing.
          One thing to keep in mind. You might not legally be allowed to have a lot of control on commissioned sales people .You can`t tell them things like be there at 8 am sharp everyday.

          The thing is you're not their boss or anything. It's not at all the same atmosphere as in a regular office. Most of the time, people try to sell the idea that the salesmen are in their own business and leadership is a lot more er.... "liberal".

          You can't have dicipline, or rather you can but you run a risk. Someone can always turn you in. Some people were definetely aware of what the boss was doing but kept quiet.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8449413].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Talltom1
    Hey Jason,

    Just a quick observation - sincere question - why are stay-at-home moms lousy job candidates?

    Tom
    Signature

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8449259].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
      Originally Posted by Talltom1 View Post

      Hey Jason,

      Just a quick observation - sincere question - why are stay-at-home moms lousy job candidates?

      Tom
      Because it takes skill and a quiet location to make calls, and they usually don't have either available. In my first round, I had many sign up; they all said they could do it, but when it came time to work they were nowhere to be found. Even when they took the time to fill out the W2 and mail it back in.

      Not picking on anyone...that's just a big category of people who applied. They're just looking for a job...any job.

      I've put advertisements up on CL for callers with clear instructions, and literally gotten one-liners, no resumes, for applications.

      BTW if you find a stay-at-home mom who can and will call, please send her my way.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8449273].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author midasman09
        Banned
        Ya know.....ya kin research and think and study and check every Ordinance and Regulation and STILL not find all the rules & regs so.... back in 1975 I took the attitude of.....

        "Screw It!" I'm just going out and see what I can do....regs or rules or whatever. If' something happens or....if I'm doing something wrong....I'm sure some bureaucrat will tell me what it is.

        And....one of my "Straight Commission" sales people gets "hurt" on the "job"....I'll work on that IF or WHEN it happens!

        My goodness people....you're either an Entroopeneer or you ain't.

        I always remember the saying my daddy had; "NOTHING HAPPENS UNTIL SOMETHING IS SOLD!"

        And I added to it with...."DO IT, until someone tells you ya can't!"

        In my days of entroopeneership I saw many people who had some great ideas for a busness.....had the money and the talent to get orders and....were stopped by their FEAR of what "Could Happen"!

        Don Alm.....give it a go, until someone tells you to stop
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8449343].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author CreekChub
          Originally Posted by midasman09 View Post

          Ya know.....ya kin research and think and study and check every Ordinance and Regulation and STILL not find all the rules & regs so.... back in 1975 I took the attitude of.....

          "Screw It!" I'm just going out and see what I can do....regs or rules or whatever. If' something happens or....if I'm doing something wrong....I'm sure some bureaucrat will tell me what it is.

          And....one of my "Straight Commission" sales people gets "hurt" on the "job"....I'll work on that IF or WHEN it happens!

          My goodness people....you're either an Entroopeneer or you ain't.

          I always remember the saying my daddy had; "NOTHING HAPPENS UNTIL SOMETHING IS SOLD!"

          And I added to it with...."DO IT, until someone tells you ya can't!"

          In my days of entroopeneership I saw many people who had some great ideas for a busness.....had the money and the talent to get orders and....were stopped by their FEAR of what "Could Happen"!

          Don Alm.....give it a go, until someone tells you to stop
          That, my good man, is why you're 176 years old and still selling placemat spots. Keep on keepin' on...
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8449705].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author iAmNameLess
    I run an office with commission only staff... YOU have to be able to sell very well if you expect people to stay... and you need to get people selling ASAP so others can see that it can be done.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8449803].message }}
  • Hi Imperetse,

    I'll throw my 2 cents in here and take it for what it's worth. To give you an idea of my perspective, I have been a sales rep for 20 years or so, it's been my career since college. I come to the Warrior Forum looking for ways to supplement or replace my current job. While I am no Claude Whitacre or Jason Kannigan, I have made a fairly good living in sales, being at or near six figures for the last 15 years. Most of my career I have been paid on straight commission, I prefer it that way.

    Jason is dead on about it being hard to find good commissioned sales people, most are already in a good job. So now you are in the position of trying to lure them away.

    So, if there is one piece of advice I can offer you and anyone reading this thread, it's this: If you are going to pay only on commission, then offer a healthy commission. If your margins are such that you can't offer a big upfront commission then you better offer volume potential or recurring commissions. The bottom line is the bottom line, everyone works for money. Good sales reps in particular work for money, that's why they are good and why they are in sales. We can talk about loyalty and good benefits, but ultimately it boils down to what the opportunity is.

    Now many of you are thinking, " thanks for stating the obvious". But the reason I felt compelled to post here is because I routinely see threads and posts from people who want to hire "good" reps but don't want to pay. You get what you pay for.

    I did some side work last year for a local guy who built mobile sites, hence my name here. He was tech savvy and using a mobile site builder along with some customization so it only took him an hour or so to build some nice looking sites. Originally, he wanted to pay me 10% of the total sale. I politely declined and asked him how much he wanted to make on each site based on the time it took to build the site. We agreed on my cost being essentially $200 for the first hour and $75 for every hour after. I was selling the sites for anywhere from $399 on up, usually up. He handled the payment (because all i want to do is sell) and he was frustrated that I was making more money than he was on most of the sites. We did an ecommerce site that "cost" $575 to build and I sold it for $1950. He only paid me $975 on the deal because he felt that half was fair on such a big deal. That was the end of our relationship. We had an agreement and he broke it.

    I had another guy want me to sell $700 monthly SEO packages for 10% commission. I counter offered but he refused. I knew he was reselling the SEO and his cost on the packages was about $200 so he had room to move. Regardless of his cost, I wasn't going to chase a $700 monthly SEO sale for $70 bucks, even recurring. I'm not trying to sound arrogant, my point is there were better sales opportunities available.

    I think some entrepreneurs come in to the WF ( and in the offline world) without much knowledge of sales and sales people. They think that 10% is enough and standard pay rate because they heard or saw it somewhere, without much thought to the whole context of what they are selling. I would be EXTACTIC to earn 10% from my current job, I earn nowhere near that. But I sell about $200,000 per month of product. I know that I am making the company good money but it is the agreement I made and I have yet to find something better ( that's why I am on here). But 5 or 10% on some products or niches just won't cut it.

    One other thing to remember. When you are trying to get good sales people, you are not just competing with other Internet marketers, you are competing with completely other industries, like manufacturing. So while you might pay the best commission in the world for selling a mobile app, it might not be as much as Claude Whitacre can make selling vacuums. Sales is a transient profession.

    Anyway, I hope I reinforced a point I have seen made on here before by sales reps who are better than I am. If you want good reps pay'em well.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8451695].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
      Originally Posted by mobilemarketer2012 View Post

      Hi Imperetse,

      I'll throw my 2 cents in here and take it for what it's worth. To give you an idea of my perspective, I have been a sales rep for 20 years or so, it's been my career since college. I come to the Warrior Forum looking for ways to supplement or replace my current job. While I am no Claude Whitacre or Jason Kannigan, I have made a fairly good living in sales, being at or near six figures for the last 15 years. Most of my career I have been paid on straight commission, I prefer it that way.

      Jason is dead on about it being hard to find good commissioned sales people, most are already in a good job. So now you are in the position of trying to lure them away.
      I appreciate the support. Can I clear something up? Something I selfishly find important and other people might find a bit interesting? There's only one 'n' in the middle of Kanigan. It's Russian, not Irish. The Ukrainian word for 'book' is very close, so it could mean 'scholar'. I have also found references that it could mean 'little horse' in a cutesy way ("Awwwwww").

      My great-grandfather was part of a group that wouldn't fight for the Czar, and accepted transit from Queen Victoria out of Cypress to Montreal around 1900. The boat that dropped them off picked up a load of cattle, then promptly sank on its way to the US east coast. (Nice.) He worked on the railway moving west across Canada, and finally settled in a farming community in the interior of BC. I met him several times when I was a kid before he died in 1986 at nearly 100.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8451939].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author staff123
      [DELETED]
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11017011].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author BigFrank
        Banned
        [DELETED]
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11017037].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Talltom1
    Jason,

    You're right - that is really interesting. If we were discussing this over a beer, I'd ask how you got from BC to NC...

    Tom
    Signature

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8452071].message }}
  • My apologies Jason. I am Irish so I must have done it subconsciously

    Nevertheless, it was an error my part. Had Jason been a potential client, my mistake may have been enough to turn him off. What's the old saying, "it's in the details...."
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8452215].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ATAC
    I have been one for many companies with success along with hired many to work for me some good and some bad .. You have to give a lot of incentives to make the relationship work ...
    What I would do is run contest amongst the salesmen every Friday one of them was a all round trip for the weekend to the Bahamas with a extra $500 to gamble with for whoever wrote the most deals all week ..

    Doing stuff like this was always a big hit for everyone involved ...
    Signature
    This all-in-one marketing platform saves me over $7,000 per year. See how:
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8571238].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author WAHL
      @ ATAC - sounds like a great incentive, especially the trip to the Bahamas, I'm actively looking for sales commission rep, primarily in online marketing services, are you able to send me a PM ?
      Cheers
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8571941].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author expresswriters
        Happened on all the WF commission only sales rep hiring threads today. This one and especially the one from 2011 were very useful.

        I am looking for a sales rep to join us, a fresh face. (I have a team of 60 copywriters and we provide stellar content services...at great rates. We're an EASY sell.) We have one on base pay who is stagnating pretty bad. I want to switch from base pay to commission to motivate her; well, this rep has been here almost a year and doesn't want the whole commission switch. She has made us significant sales, but the past month, not so much.

        Anyone have additional ideas on where to hire a sales rep or what to offer my current rep?

        I read a few things about "vanishing base pay" for new reps and liked it...

        Last, I looked into www.timetohire.com today and considering investing the $399 for their headhunting services...anyone use them before/have thoughts on them?
        Signature
        We are:
        E-commerce online content shop. 60 copywriters hand-picked from all over the globe, working together with a passion for the written word. Content strategists, social media managers, copyeditors. We brainstorm writing, create, produce.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9347276].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dgui123451
    I personally have not done this but I heard of many people who were successful by hiring commission only sales people
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9353934].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Defacto
    I hire commissioned based sales people all the time, mostly because I have to replace the ones who do not work... My best results come from the paid ads on CL. Never the free ones; they have been a waste for time for me.

    And yes you have to protect your business. I keep my resources secret as much as I can and so far as I can tell no one has run off and started my business model themselves. And if they have so what? I have thousands of competing businesses anyway.

    But when pressed by an aggressive sales rep about my main outsourcer I just said a "personal friend" that I have known since grade school in hopes they would not try locate them and start their own business.

    When negotiating commission pay it has helped me to disclose my costs and even my profit margin (I am not 100% upfront with my cut but generalize) to the potential sales rep. Then I tell them that they will get the lion's share of the profits for sales. I don't do SEO, etc so my margins are much smaller. This way they don't feel they are being taken advantage of and understand what you are trying to accomplish.

    Also, I give lifetime/recurring commissions as long as they are an active sales rep for me and as long as they are making at least one sale a month. If they fail at either then they forfeit their recurring commissions from past sales.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9354563].message }}

Trending Topics