Freelancer.com

Go Back   Warrior Forum - The #1 Internet Marketing Forum & Marketplace > The Warrior Forum > Search Engine Optimization
Register Blogs Social Groups Advertise with usHelp Desk

Closed Thread
LinkBack Thread Tools
Unread 10th July 2010, 05:04 PM   #1
Phil B
War Room Member
 
Join Date: 2005
Location: , , .
Posts: 81
Thanks: 30
Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts
Default New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

I have noticed the new Google AdWords: Keyword Tool returns dramatically different results depending on whether I'm logged in or logged out of my AdWords account.

The logged in results are much lower then results when I'm logged out. I have seen others here on Warrior Forum make the same observation, but I have yet to find an explanation.

For example:

Keyword - canon camera bag - Exact result:
Logged In - Global 1,300 Local 590
Logged Out - Global 14,800 Local 8,100

I am new to AdWords and this confusion makes me hesitant to start a campaign until I understand what I'm seeing as far as search volumes.

Almost all the Keyword advice from folks seems to refer to the Logged Out numbers, but that distinction is never made, maybe because the new interface has not been around long, or maybe because not too many folks have noticed this yet.

I am starting to wonder if the logged in numbers are really closer to accurate than the logged out numbers.

Can anyone share their own observations and thoughts?

Thank You
bluefoot is offline  
Unread 10th July 2010, 06:02 PM   #2
HyperActive Warrior
War Room Member
 
Join Date: 2006
Location: GTA,Canada
Posts: 157
Thanks: 13
Thanked 13 Times in 11 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Get the same results. That is a big discrepancy. This is the first time I noticed actually. I just assumed they would be the same. Interested in hearing what some of the other forum members have to say about this..
sarafina is offline  
Unread 10th July 2010, 06:12 PM   #3
Senior Warrior Member
War Room Member
 
timpears's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2008
Location: Vancouver, WA, USA.
Posts: 4,590
Thanks: 828
Thanked 966 Times in 701 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

I wonder what Google's reason is for feeding people bogus data is? Obviously they have the intent to deceive, but for what reason would they do that. The correct data is obviously available from their server logs.

We have always known that the data given was not exactly right, but this basically proves it.

Inquiring minds want to know. But I don't think Google is going to give us an answer any time soon.

Tim Pears

Jason Kanigan is putting on a fund raiser for my kidney transplant. See here.

KIDNEY Transplant Fundraising WSO: $2000 In Marketing Products!.
timpears is offline  
Unread 10th July 2010, 06:34 PM   #4
HyperActive Warrior
War Room Member
 
Join Date: 2006
Location: GTA,Canada
Posts: 157
Thanks: 13
Thanked 13 Times in 11 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Hmm..I don't think its intentionally bogus really. As an adwords user, the data they provide is very detailed and obviously meant to help.

My theory on this discrepancy is such:

When you are logged in, the information you see is based on impressions within the adwords system. So when somebody searches and ads are displayed. The external tool is for whenever somebody searches. The logged in version is lower because every search does not yield an ad to be displayed (due to advertiser budget constraints, negative keyword or simply not bidding on that keyword).

Look at the keyword "canon camera bag" for example. There are only 5 ads. If their budgets are depleted on other keywords or they pause then it is possible some searches will not yield ads and thus google adwords logged in tool will show less results for that term.
sarafina is offline  
Unread 11th July 2010, 12:23 AM   #5
Senior Warrior Member
War Room Member
 
timpears's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2008
Location: Vancouver, WA, USA.
Posts: 4,590
Thanks: 828
Thanked 966 Times in 701 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

sarafina, the numbers are bogus. The OP stated that he got one number when logged in and another when not logged in. The ads didn't display differently when he was logged in and when he wasn't. If you use the Search Based Keyword Tool, you will get a different number than when you use the AdWords tool. So are these tools showning the search volume or not? Three different sets of numbers from two different keyword tools, all pulling from the same company data base. If these numbers aren't bogus, then you mist be smoking something or you work for Google. Sorry, I am not buying your story.

Tim Pears

Jason Kanigan is putting on a fund raiser for my kidney transplant. See here.

KIDNEY Transplant Fundraising WSO: $2000 In Marketing Products!.
timpears is offline  
Unread 11th July 2010, 07:35 AM   #6
HyperActive Warrior
War Room Member
 
Join Date: 2006
Location: GTA,Canada
Posts: 157
Thanks: 13
Thanked 13 Times in 11 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

You clearly didn't understand my post.

I am suggesting the data google shows when you are logged in to your adwords account is based on the searches THAT DISPLAY ADWORD ADS. Whereas the logged out external tool is ANY SEARCHES PERIOD. If you understand that every search does not display an ad, then naturally the logged in number would be different & lower which is what I observed in the few tests I did.

Again its not a story that I'm trying to sell to you or anybody. Its a hypothesis (google it).

Do you even use adwords? I do and google provides a TON of information to their users that help them so I find it unlikely that google would intentionally make this search tool misleading. I like to think of reasons behind something rather than just sitting down and calling everything I don't understand "bogus".
sarafina is offline  
Unread 24th July 2010, 01:58 PM   #7
Warrior Member
War Room Member
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 24
Thanks: 12
Thanked 5 Times in 5 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

I just noticed this too with great shock. I see very opposite and drastic results though. For the keyword phrase "inducing lucid dreams", when logged in I see 110,000 global and logged out I see 460 global.

This is very disturbing! I am going to try to find out what is going on and will come back here to share my findings.
marketwarlord is offline  
Unread 15th August 2010, 05:16 AM   #8
Advanced Warrior
War Room Member
 
Bryan V's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2010
Location: USA
Posts: 536
Thanks: 39
Thanked 69 Times in 65 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

I made a post about this a few weeks/months back and still don't really know the answer to this.

However... my traffic stats seems to be more in line with the data when logged in. Search results when logged in show between about 10% to 25% of the search volume compared to when NOT logged in.

This is with the adwords tool, exact match only. My page impressions make WAY more sense compared to these lower search results for all my sites ranked in positions 1-4 for the keyword.

So uh.. this sucks. A lot! I guess I will play it safe from now on and only go by search volume when logged in...

Perhaps an attic I shall seek.
Bryan V is offline  
Unread 15th August 2010, 09:22 AM   #9
Warrior of the Warriors
War Room Member
 
Shaun Lee's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2009
Location: Malaysia
Posts: 793
Thanks: 67
Thanked 105 Times in 48 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Logged Out Stats

Broad - 9900
Phrase - 9900
Exact - 2900

Logged In Stats

Broad - 9900
Phrase - 9900
Exact - 2900

I'm getting the same results.

By the way, these numbers are "Global Monthly Searches".

-Shaun

Shaun Lee is offline  
Unread 25th August 2010, 05:31 AM   #10
Warrior Member
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 4
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Ok, i've just opened this profile to reply to the threat.

Today morning was really shockin! Until today, i didn't really care to login to see the stats. My search term had global monthly: 74 000 and seemed no serious competitor. I began a project based on the number and soon it will be launched. But today morning, by a chance, i logged in to the adword tool and searched my term.....................it's 2200. almost 30 times lower than the result without login. Well, i feel so dumb! I put $$$$+11 months to develop my complex website with many modules and apis. Now, i really feel something.......bad!

I really believe logged in result is the closest one to actual number. My other website's keyword impression ranged between 500-700 but logged out result used to show 3000-3500. I used to always wonder why there's such discrepancy. Now i'm logged in to the Adword tool and checked the keyword and it shows me 700. Exactly my keyword's impression number.

My hypothesis:
Logged Out result: repeated, not unique searches
Logged In result: absolute unique searches (from visitor point of view)

But Shaun's post is disturbing to my hypthesis. He's same result to the both cases.

Sorry my bad english though! I'm lost! I go and listen Beatle's Yesterday.
JustToWriteThis is offline  
Unread 25th August 2010, 11:10 AM   #11
Warrior Member
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 1
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

I'm new to google keyword tool but I noticed that for the same keywords the old interface and the new one are displaying different results for global monthly searches and for competition as well. Does somebody know why?
fastman is offline  
Unread 26th August 2010, 02:08 AM   #12
Norms Buster
War Room Member
 
Join Date: 2010
Location: India
Posts: 369
Thanks: 16
Thanked 9 Times in 9 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

See:

Why you shouldn't use Google's keyword tool for SEO malcolm coles

Mithun on the Web
SledgeHammer is offline  
Unread 26th August 2010, 03:53 AM   #13
Active Warrior
War Room Member
 
Therlos's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2009
Location: Germany, Aachen
Posts: 84
Thanks: 11
Thanked 658 Times in 9 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

See here : Keyword Tool Displaying Different Data When Logged In To Adwords - AdWords Help

This explains the difference when you're logged in and logged out. They're using your accounts performance data to estimate the amount of impressions you could possibly get.

Best regards,
Daniel

A Warriors Armory - Titanic List of IM Tools and Services + Newbie Bonus

A wise saying: Don't follow the exact footprints of the gurus - search for what they searched for once.
Therlos is offline  
Unread 26th August 2010, 12:58 PM   #14
Warrior Member
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 4
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Hi Daniel,
Thank you very much for the link. I think it explains the reason of the stat discrepancy.

One question, i don't have any Ad group. How would estimate it if i don't have any ads to track? My niche is so ''uninteresting'' and literally no one wants to put money for this. No ad groups as yet. The logged in result shows 2200 far less from stand alone traffic estimator's number 70K.

Any idea?
Thank you again
Marvin
JustToWriteThis is offline  
Unread 26th August 2010, 03:41 PM   #15
Freeman
War Room Member
 
JackPowers's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2009
Posts: 753
Thanks: 86
Thanked 104 Times in 78 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

What's the point?

To confuse internet marketers and SEO's, while making it seem like there is more volume for Adwords than there is.

JackPowers is offline  
Unread 1st September 2010, 09:00 AM   #16
Active Warrior
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 33
Thanks: 13
Thanked 6 Times in 5 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Quote:
Originally Posted by JackPowers View Post
What's the point?

To confuse internet marketers and SEO's, while making it seem like there is more volume for Adwords than there is.
The point is that this is the Google AdWords Keyword Tool, not the Internet Marketers and SEO's keyword tool. It was created to give AdWords advertisers an idea of how many impressions they might be able to generate by bidding on certain keywords.

If I place a bid in AdWords my ad/website can show on Google's search results, other Powered By Google sites, places such as Ask.com, Shopping.com, etc. My ad can also show on the content network which includes every site showing AdSense ads, parked domain pages, etc.

If I get an organic listing for my site in Google's search results, my site will show on only Google's search results, obviously creating less impressions/visits than the above scenario.

I just think of how many people are still buying guides that teach people to use this tool to estimate how much traffic/$$$ they are going to get from ranking their website. Next time you see someone claiming to know that they are doing but still recommending this tool you should ask yourself if they really know what they are doing...

More background info:
smackdown.blogsblogsblogs.com/2008/07/15/why-the-google-keyword-tool-is-useless-for-seo-even-with-exact-numbers
BishopMartin is offline  
Unread 1st September 2010, 09:08 AM   #17
Freeman
War Room Member
 
JackPowers's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2009
Posts: 753
Thanks: 86
Thanked 104 Times in 78 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Quote:
Originally Posted by BishopMartin View Post
The point is that this is the Google AdWords Keyword Tool, not the Internet Marketers and SEO's keyword tool. It was created to give AdWords advertisers an idea of how many impressions they might be able to generate by bidding on certain keywords.

If I place a bid in AdWords my ad/website can show on Google's search results, other Powered By Google sites, places such as Ask.com, Shopping.com, etc. My ad can also show on the content network which includes every site showing AdSense ads, parked domain pages, etc.

If I get an organic listing for my site in Google's search results, my site will show on only Google's search results, obviously creating less impressions/visits than the above scenario.

I just think of how many people are still buying guides that teach people to use this tool to estimate how much traffic/$$$ they are going to get from ranking their website. Next time you see someone claiming to know that they are doing but still recommending this tool you should ask yourself if they really know what they are doing...

More background info:
smackdown.blogsblogsblogs.com/2008/07/15/why-the-google-keyword-tool-is-useless-for-seo-even-with-exact-numbers
So what is a better tool in your opinion? Doesnt the other tools use Google API as well?

JackPowers is offline  
Unread 1st September 2010, 09:26 AM   #18
Active Warrior
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 33
Thanks: 13
Thanked 6 Times in 5 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Quote:
Originally Posted by JackPowers View Post
So what is a better tool in your opinion? Doesnt the other tools use Google API as well?
I have not used it as much, so I can't speak with authority, but I believe the Google Search-based keyword tool gives an idea of potential traffic based on searches exclusively: google.com/sktool. Those number should be more accurate to what you can expect to see from an organic Google ranking.

I like using Google Webmaster tools for keyword ideas, but you cant really do this if you are building crappy micro niche made for adsense or thin affiliate sites..
BishopMartin is offline  
Unread 7th September 2010, 12:00 PM   #19
Super Advanced Warrior
War Room Member
 
Matt Helphrey's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2007
Posts: 983
Thanks: 17
Thanked 158 Times in 60 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Quote:
Originally Posted by JustToWriteThis View Post
Ok, i've just opened this profile to reply to the threat.

Today morning was really shockin! Until today, i didn't really care to login to see the stats. My search term had global monthly: 74 000 and seemed no serious competitor. I began a project based on the number and soon it will be launched. But today morning, by a chance, i logged in to the adword tool and searched my term.....................it's 2200. almost 30 times lower than the result without login. Well, i feel so dumb! I put $$$$+11 months to develop my complex website with many modules and apis. Now, i really feel something.......bad!

I really believe logged in result is the closest one to actual number. My other website's keyword impression ranged between 500-700 but logged out result used to show 3000-3500. I used to always wonder why there's such discrepancy. Now i'm logged in to the Adword tool and checked the keyword and it shows me 700. Exactly my keyword's impression number.

My hypothesis:
Logged Out result: repeated, not unique searches
Logged In result: absolute unique searches (from visitor point of view)

But Shaun's post is disturbing to my hypthesis. He's same result to the both cases.

Sorry my bad english though! I'm lost! I go and listen Beatle's Yesterday.
2 months ago I did some research using the tool and went after a set of keywords that were showing 550,000 Local (exact) and 368,000 Global (exact). I got a little excited today as my website took a huge jump up in the search engines due to all of the work I have been putting into it, so I decided for whatever reason to check the tool again...

...today it shows 8,100 Global (exact) and 6,600 Local (exact). I understand where you are coming from. It is a tad bit frustrating to say the least. That's quite a difference. And this isnt just for the one website, I checked keywords on my other websites and they all were showing VERY drastically reduced numbers.

What gives? Is anyone else noticing the same?

If this is a true and more accurate reading, then fine...thank you. But now it seems I will have to reevaluate my keyword approach from scratch again.
Matt Helphrey is offline  
Unread 7th September 2010, 07:19 PM   #20
HyperActive Warrior
War Room Member
 
blueboy9's Avatar
 
Join Date: 2010
Location: Canada
Posts: 102
Thanks: 20
Thanked 13 Times in 12 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

I just took a look at some keywords I've been working on and have found the same thing however the difference I've found is between the "new" tool and the previous interface.

The new tool is reporting significantly lower global monthly searches than the classic tool. Not sure which one to believe in!

Last edited on 7th September 2010 at 07:31 PM. Reason: clarification!
blueboy9 is offline  
Unread 28th December 2010, 04:07 AM   #21
Warrior Member
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 8
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

If you are logged in you are using Search Wiki and Web History [if you signed up for it]. Both will allow customization of search results.

Maxy28 is offline  
Unread 21st April 2011, 09:23 AM   #22
Active Warrior
 
Join Date: 2010
Posts: 81
Thanks: 1
Thanked 4 Times in 4 Posts
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

for Traffic Estimator tool results are different because Google utilizes account history for trying to predict better values.

As for the keyword tool, it is possible that Google uses some of your AdWords account options like campaign targeting or something else to differentiate results.

CikaPero is offline  
Unread 25th May 2011, 08:10 AM   #23
Warrior Member
 
Join Date: 2011
Posts: 4
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Even MORE critical than the insane number difference, is the difference in results which confuse when you're trying to isolate the principal keywords you should target with SEO.

Interesting experience today. In the Google keyword search tool I ran the following variables on my primary keywords for my business and got these USA average monthly results:
homeowners associations websites................3600
homeowner association websites...................1600
homeowner association website.....................1000
homeowners association website.....................720
The presumption of course would be that the term with all plurals generates by FAR the most t r a f f i c. So we set our SEO work up around principally that term and we launch a new AdWords campaign today covering each term and expect the impression numbers to roughly track the above.

NOT EVEN CLOSE:
homeowner association website...........1,044
homeowners association website............361
homeowners associations websites...........92
homeowner association websites..............60
Now the singular variation dominates, not the plural.

I should note we bid so as to be #1 or #2 on each term so you would expect every input of the keywords into Google would generate an impression.

Any ideas what's going on????
mwvandor is offline  
Unread 25th May 2011, 08:52 AM   #24
Warrior Member
 
Join Date: 2011
Posts: 4
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Default Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

BTW, I just used Google Insights and got a THIRD set of results on which of these keywords get the most traffic. The #1 I experienced in Adwords through PPC doesn't even register, the #1 from the logged in keyword search tool doesn't register either. But one of the other 4 terms does.

Is there any reliable data? WTF is Google trying to accomplish with the mass data confusion?
mwvandor is offline  
Unread 30th October 2011, 12:20 AM   #25
Old Dog new Tricks
 
Join Date: 2010
Location: Clarkston
Posts: 23
Thanks: 35
Thanked 27 Times in 22 Posts
Lightbulb Re: New Google AdWords Keyword Tool - Different results if Logged In or Logged Out

Personally, I subscribe to the theory, that the big G has done a very efficient job of monopolizing a large portion of the web. The more they keep everyone in the dark, and keep throwing curve balls every time one turns around, most certainly leads me to believe they quite like it that way, and will do all things possible to insure it stays that way.
trelli is offline  
Closed Thread

  Warrior Forum - The #1 Internet Marketing Forum & Marketplace > The Warrior Forum > Search Engine Optimization

Bookmarks

Tags
adwords, google, keyword, logged, results, tool

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off




All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:21 PM.