2 Backlinking Questions

Banned 13 years ago

Originally Posted by sharger

Basically he was doing 50 backlinks from PR4+ sites.

What is a "PR-4 site"? Most people would understand it to mean a site of which the home page has a page-rank of 4. You see my point, perhaps? "Sites" don't have "page-rank". Pages have page-rank. Are the pages on which your links were placed themselves PR-4 pages? Or (as usually turns out to be the case) PR-0 pages? Have you asked this?

Originally Posted by sharger

I don't think it would be seen as 50 high pr links otherwise why not put 100 on each profile and have 1000(if that makes sense).

Your logic's correct in the sense that the "weight" attributed to a backlink by a search engine depends, in principle, among other things, on the number of outgoing links on that page, and can get "diluted", albeit not on a straightforward, linear scale.

Originally Posted by sharger

Also if I was a forum moderator surely this would look spammy?

Yes indeed. Your best chance with it is perhaps that a search engine will see it and nobody else will.

Originally Posted by sharger

2. How can you find out what sites are dofollow for linkbuilding process?

There's a Firefox add-on that will readily show you (there are other ways, too). I don't look at them, myself, because I like no-follow backlinks, too, and get value from them, but I recognize that many people feel they don't.

Originally Posted by sharger

Hope point 1 makes sense

It does. You're right to be concerned, I'm afraid.

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802443].message }}

sharger

13 years ago

Many thanks for the detailed answers Alexa. Sorry I didn't explain the first bit right. Yes the home pages are PR4+ but as you say the profile pages are not ranked.

Luckily I did not pay for the service as I got a review, however it does concern me that the sales pitch is misleading with regards to PR as it indicates that the link will be left on the ranking page.

Would it be advisable to remove 4 links and just leave 1 myself? Also politically would it be the done thing to voice my concerns in a testimonial or would it just be best to leave none at all (just thinking about people who actually pay for the service)

Thanks again...

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Cobra Golf Clubs - Start Fitness - IP Cameras - Carp Fishing Rods - Celtic Pendant - Garmin GPS Watch - DJ Mixer - Inflatable Kayak

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802479].message }}

Alexa Smith

Banned 13 years ago

Originally Posted by sharger

Luckily I did not pay for the service

Ooh, well, it's all a plus, then: whatever was done certainly won't have done your site any damage ... so no great problem.

Originally Posted by sharger

it does concern me that the sales pitch is misleading

Call me a skepchick, but I have seen it said that that tends, sometimes, to be the case with "backlinking services". People have mixed feelings about them. Their promotion was more or less banned here not long ago. I'm not certain, but I think that may have changed very recently.

Originally Posted by sharger

Would it be advisable to remove 4 links and just leave 1 myself?

I wouldn't think you need to do that. Opinions always differ about these subjects, but it's difficult to envisage anyone thinking that your site would actually show a net gain from doing that. I'd just leave it all alone and go out for dinner, myself ...

Originally Posted by sharger

Also politically would it be the done thing to voice my concerns in a testimonial or would it just be best to leave none at all (just thinking about people who actually pay for the service)

Opinions will differ. (When don't they?!). Personally, I'm opposed to "testimonials for 'review copies' ", really, but that's an extremely unhelpful (and perhaps unkind) observation from me, sorry. :p

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802492].message }}

sharger 13 years ago

Alexa... thanks for the guidance and taking your time to answer my questions, appreciate the feedback.
- [ 1 ] Thanks
Signature
Cobra Golf Clubs - Start Fitness - IP Cameras - Carp Fishing Rods - Celtic Pendant - Garmin GPS Watch - DJ Mixer - Inflatable Kayak
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802527].message }}

Joseph Michael

13 years ago

Services like this are crap.

Profile links I have never got my head around how people can sell them. They normally have absolutely no PR regardless of the homepage, and why on earth google would give weight to links from profile pages is beyond me also.

Proper links that work are from other websites within the content on sub pages... this is a hell of a lot of hard work...

So sign up to either, 1waylinks, 3waylinks or thelinkjuicer.com <- these are great, i'm signed up to all 3 for my video game sites.

[ 1 ] Thanks
3 replies

Signature

STOP WORRYING ABOUT LINK BUILDING:
>> How To Build Your Own PBN In Less Than 60 Minutes For Less Than $50 <<

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802524].message }}

Alexa Smith Banned 13 years ago

Originally Posted by Joseph Michael

Services like this are crap.

Now that's what I call "succinct and accurate". Call me long winded, but it took me about 8 paragraphs above to say what you just (wisely) said in 5 words.
- [ 1 ] Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802533].message }}

sharger

13 years ago

Originally Posted by Joseph Michael

Services like this are crap.

Profile links I have never got my head around how people can sell them. They normally have absolutely no PR regardless of the homepage, and why on earth google would give weight to links from profile pages is beyond me also.

Proper links that work are from other websites within the content on sub pages... this is a hell of a lot of hard work...

So sign up to either, 1waylinks, 3waylinks or thelinkjuicer.com <- these are great, i'm signed up to all 3 for my video game sites.

Thanks Joseph... I'm quite a newbie when it comes to IM and it is a bit info overload at the moment. Everyone has something to offer but its just trying to sort the wheat from the chaff.... I'll check out the sites you mention thanks.

Thanks

Signature

Cobra Golf Clubs - Start Fitness - IP Cameras - Carp Fishing Rods - Celtic Pendant - Garmin GPS Watch - DJ Mixer - Inflatable Kayak

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802543].message }}

4morereferrals

13 years ago

Originally Posted by Joseph Michael

Profile links I have never got my head around how people can sell them. They normally have absolutely no PR regardless of the homepage, and why on earth google would give weight to links from profile pages is beyond me also.

Proper links that work are from other websites within the content on sub pages... this is a hell of a lot of hard work...

1. They sell because they work - whether one can get their head around why Google does anything Google does or not.

2. Proper links? on subpages? Ummm ... sounds kinda like a profile page.

- so a subpage on a blog for example with zero / PR n/a is proper - but a link on a subpage of a forum that is PR0/PR n/a is NOT proper?

Ive got forum profiles that are more unique and better quality content than a load of the tripe I have to endure on EZA ...

Pages are pages html is html .... anchor text links inside [ <a ] tags are anchor text links - good n proper just the same - profile page or some archived SPAMMY article blog post on puppy potty training method # 5,012.

So sign up to either, 1waylinks, 3waylinks or thelinkjuicer.com <- these are great, i'm signed up to all 3 for my video game sites.

To the OP - if you seek more in depth information on link building - i suggest you hold of making your next purchase and do some research over on www.backlinksforum.com I wouldnt want to see you toss more $$$ after bad on the above services either - without your eyes fully open.

good luck - sorry you had a bad experience with the original service - at least it was free :-)

[ 2 ] Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Rank Ascend Network - High PR Links / Guaranteed Rankings Increase

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802564].message }}

sharger

13 years ago

Originally Posted by 4morereferrals

1. They sell because they work - whether one can get their head around why Google does anything Google does or not.

2. Proper links? on subpages? Ummm ... sounds kinda like a profile page.

- so a subpage on a blog for example with zero / PR n/a is proper - but a link on a subpage of a forum that is PR0/PR n/a is NOT proper?

Ive got forum profiles that are more unique and better quality content than a load of the tripe I have to endure on EZA ...

Pages are pages html is html .... anchor text links inside [ <a ] tags are anchor text links - good n proper just the same - profile page or some archived SPAMMY article blog post on puppy potty training method # 5,012.

See this is where it starts to get confusing... you are both knowledgeable chaps but have opposite views... I'm all for horses for courses but not when I'm flogging a dead one

I guess its gonna be trial and error and some lost cash to see what works for me

Thanks

Signature

Cobra Golf Clubs - Start Fitness - IP Cameras - Carp Fishing Rods - Celtic Pendant - Garmin GPS Watch - DJ Mixer - Inflatable Kayak

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802580].message }}

janeiro82

13 years ago

DoFollow is overrated

Google won't follow the link but it will count the link as well...

Thanks

Signature

The Bookmark King - 1500+ Social Bookmarks starting @ 15$ - Crush Your Competition Today

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802560].message }}

sharger

13 years ago

Originally Posted by John McEachern

Do you mind if I ask what you paid for this service?

John

Luckily I did not.. it was a review copy as it was a new thread and I'm guessing they wanted to build up confidence in their product. It just didn't sit right with me though hence my questions...

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Cobra Golf Clubs - Start Fitness - IP Cameras - Carp Fishing Rods - Celtic Pendant - Garmin GPS Watch - DJ Mixer - Inflatable Kayak

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802567].message }}

sharger 13 years ago

Originally Posted by John McEachern

That's not a bad way to learn the lesson.

Ain't that the truth
- Thanks
Signature
Cobra Golf Clubs - Start Fitness - IP Cameras - Carp Fishing Rods - Celtic Pendant - Garmin GPS Watch - DJ Mixer - Inflatable Kayak
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2802593].message }}

Suka

13 years ago

The best thing you can do is Learn how to SEO yourself.

Once you understand how it all works, you can outsource and not get ripped off.

Its like being a complete noob at fixing computers, you may just need a cable pluged in but the guy will charge you 500 for his time and wont tell you what the problem was (taking advantage of newbies), were as if you knew what he did you can refuse to pay or simply do it yourself or atleast have a better understanding.

[ 1 ] Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2803055].message }}

2 Backlinking Questions

Trending Topics

Any thoughts on golf's latest phenom...Scottie Scheffler??

best high quality crypto traffic.

Should i Index Author pages?

What's the Best IM-Related Skill to Learn Today That Can Help in the Future?

Some interesting stats about brand comms