Searching for the Ultimate Authority Links, Beware?

I'm perhaps going to be fairly controversial in this post but then perhaps not, I'm not too sure?

I've just received an email a few minutes ago from another marketer who I know quite well and wouldn't want to criticise publicly because I think that would be unprofessional but the email made me fairly uncomfortable and that is going some...

The email revolved around the concept of .mil links and the concept of authority links. Now I think if we're not too careful we all stand the chance of missing the plot big time over this.

Firstly let me state my position and background in this and you will then at least see that this isn't some shameless "lame brained" attempt at jealousy because someone else has "beaten me to the jump" over this.

I've been sitting on a substantial four figure database of .mil domains for the last few months now and those of you who know me really well will have known that I've discussed the prospect of this with you. I've not done anything with them as to be honest I've been completely at a cross roads with what to do with them.

Sure, it would have been very tempting and the easy way out just to unload the database or release elements in snippets and just exploit the living daylights out of it but for the first time in my life I just never found my way round to doing it and that after a few months has told me something.

The turning point came the other day when I ran a test piece of research as to what exactly there was out there in possible link inventory and unearthed a whole series of blogs that were open for comments. I thought OK let's give this a go and see where we go from here and then I read the blog (always a good idea) and thought (as we say over here in Northern Ireland) "catch yourself on here Steve".

The Blog was an exchange between a Lieutenant General and an old soldier who was discussing the merits of basic training at Fort Benning amongst others and related to the basic training and merits of modern methods over the old. Now as I say this was a blog, that was unmoderated, open for comments and was dofollow, it satisfied all the criteria necessary for technically a good inbound link.

The usual ideal criteria were present i.e. massive inbound links amount and all from the usual domain suffixes i.e. plenty of .Govs, .EDU's and so on but then I thought, does this comment I'm about to make and link I'm about to place actually contribute constructively to the "Food Chain" here?

I know damn all about basic training in the US Military, heck I wasn't even a good Boy Scout when I was kid so what am I doing here? Then it all made sense.

Get the heck out of here and then think.

What was it that made me go there in the first place and it all suddenly made sense about what is going on and we're all chasing the wrong dollar in the wrong arena.

You see what was it that supposedly made me go there? It was part of the endless quest for an "Authority Link" and then I realised that by and large we are all getting this massively wrong and by doing so giving the Search Engines a massive laugh at the same time.

You see the initial criteria was, this must be an authority domain as it was very rare, had lots of inbound links pointing to it from very "sexy" and "desirable" domain suffixes i.e. .Gov's, .EDU's etc etc but then I thought hang on here Steve, you're chasing the domain suffix here not the site or content itself.

Now I am sure that if you run a site based around selling US Military Memorabilia or Army Surplus equipment then it all perhaps made sense though I am still not too sure how this old soldier and Lieutenant General would react when they saw my so called meaningful contribution about Training with a link through to a client site about Fitness Equipment.

Now there are certain web domains and categories that you can get away with this i.e. it's fair game on most .EDU's and .Govs as in most cases they want to set up some sort of exchange of dialogue and as long as you comment properly and enter into the exchange of communication responsibly then it doesn't actually make that much difference as to what the domain you are using as your target link is...as long as it's legal.

Now inbound links from somewhere like Kings College in Cambridge, The Physics Lab at the University of London or Yale, Harvard, Stanford etc are true Authority links because of the nature of the site themselves and the kudos of the domain suffix involved i.e. the .EDU suffix.

I am not too sure whether the same applies to .mil suffixes. Sure they are rare but then so is a four leaf shamrock but that doesn't make a site about Irelands very own native vegetation an authority site or source (unless of course you have a site about rare forms of Flora and Fauna).

Also in the current climate with world events being what they are I am not too sure whether I fancied arousing the wrath of the US Military and a certain Lieutenant General.

I don't think this is the case, it is more a case of just thankfully being able to step back and take some time out and re evaluate my thinking and criteria about the search for an Authority Link.

Rareness of a domain suffix does not grant it "Authority Status", 100% top notch gold plated content from an independent source with no axe to grind does.

Therefore in my mind, .EDU's and .Govs still rank top of the pile not because of the domain suffix but because of the nature of the sites themselves and the content by and large to be found on them.

Just my 2p