Comment "widget" for blog - Facebook Comments or Wordpress comments ?

2 replies
  • SEO
  • |
Hi there,

please share your thoughts on Facebook comments (plugin/widget) as opose to ordinary comments in Wordpress itself.

Has anyone done any testing regarding this. Anytime I ve seen a Facebook comment section it was always more lively than ordinary comments. The viral part also plays a factor, cause its pushing it onwards to other FB users. I also see a benefit for adsense users, cause if I am not mistaken the text in the FB comments section is not considered content, as opose to ordinary comments which are content (TOS issues).

Would like to hear your thoughts.

Sincerely, Buyseech
#blog #comment #comments #facebook #widget #wordpress
  • Profile picture of the author paulgl
    If it's a true widget, it's a script. Nothing is seen by
    any search engine, except the code.

    And as far as adsense TOS, it would be against TOS.

    Google has stated they do not want their advertisers
    ads displaying on pages that allow spam comments.

    Since all comments are spam, no matter what value people
    think they add to any thing, why would you put
    adsense on pages that allow it? Comments do not
    have to have a link or viagra to be spam.

    The logic is that advertisers are paying for a specific
    thing. If you allow your users to add whatever they
    wish, you are in effect letting your content be altered.
    Advertisers should not have to keep checking to see
    what you have on your website.

    But, people disregard that and say, what the heck I
    want to allow comments!

    Google readily makes exceptions for certain types of
    forums and other things done by the big boys.

    This is one TOS that oodles of people ignore.

    You cannot moderate spam enough. Spam is spam is spam.
    A comment that says, "great post" is spam.

    Paul
    Signature

    If you were disappointed in your results today, lower your standards tomorrow.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5547979].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author eshapard
    I think I know what you're talking about. I haven't seen that for wordpress though. When I've seen facebook-linked comments, it has been much livelier indeed, but that was on a news site with high PR.

    Not sure if Paul's correct about search engines only seeing code. I guess you could test that by searching for the exact text in one of those comments.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5548133].message }}

Trending Topics