Blog commenting on auto

Alexa Smith

Banned 12 years ago

Hi Arthur,

Originally Posted by Kronom

I know aleady, manually created comments are better I agree

This is perhaps "understatement of the decade"?

It's not just that "manually created comments are better". It's that automated comments have absolutely no value at all, either to yourself or to the owners of the blog. It's just a form of spam - pure and simple.

Not only will the great majority never be published, but the few that are will be on blogs which accept automatically, and can therefore bring you no traffic and their backlinks aren't worth having, either.

For blog commenting, you have to start from the perspective of adding value. Otherwise not only is their no benefit at all to yourself in doing it, but you're simply adding to the spamming problem, and the collective negative reputation of internet marketers.

[ 4 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5932891].message }}

JeromyS

11 years ago

Originally Posted by Alexa Smith

Hi Arthur,

This is perhaps "understatement of the decade"?

It's not just that "manually created comments are better". It's that automated comments have absolutely no value at all, either to yourself or to the owners of the blog. It's just a form of spam - pure and simple.

Not only will the great majority never be published, but the few that are will be on blogs which accept automatically, and can therefore bring you no traffic and their backlinks aren't worth having, either.

For blog commenting, you have to start from the perspective of adding value. Otherwise not only is their no benefit at all to yourself in doing it, but you're simply adding to the spamming problem, and the collective negative reputation of internet marketers.

Agreed!

It is something to be very careful of, auto posting anything. No value comment, no value link = waste of time. Commenting really needs to be something you put some thought and time into. Have you looked at blog finder tools? Those help to find relevant blogs to comment on.

Cheers!

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

How People and Businesses Make Money With Google

Still Smoking?How I Quite Smoking, Cold Turkey, Easy

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7337532].message }}

JSProjects

11 years ago

Originally Posted by JeromyS

Agreed!

It is something to be very careful of, auto posting anything. No value comment, no value link = waste of time. Commenting really needs to be something you put some thought and time into. Have you looked at blog finder tools? Those help to find relevant blogs to comment on.

Cheers!

Scrapebox is still the best tool for finding blogs. (Or anything, really.) It can sort them by PR, check if the posts are open for comments, etc.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7342394].message }}

JeromyS 11 years ago

Originally Posted by JSProjects

Scrapebox is still the best tool for finding blogs. (Or anything, really.) It can sort them by PR, check if the posts are open for comments, etc.

Yes, scrapbox is popular. Another one I have used is Fast Blog Finder, which seems to do well with even the free version.

Good to see others that agree that manually posting to blogs is better. Use a tool like Scapbox or Fast Blog Finder to find the blogs, but review the post and provide a REAL comment. Add value and context, your comment will be more likely to be read, appreciated, left on the site (not flagged as spam as many auto comments are) and potentially clicked. These are the links you want. It take more time, but these links last and have the highest value. Same goes for forum posting. Add value and stay on topic.

Cheers!
- Thanks
Signature
How People and Businesses Make Money With Google

Still Smoking?How I Quite Smoking, Cold Turkey, Easy
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7355992].message }}

StevenJones

12 years ago

Originally Posted by Kronom

Dear warriors,

I just got myself a tool for finding the blogs to comment on, but ideally I would also like to find a software to help me creating comments. Yes I know aleady, manually created comments are better I agree, however this is not what I am looking for now... :-) Do you know a tool which auto creates comments?

Arthur

Still if you want to do auto commenting, try scrapebox. But Alexa is right here, spamming comments will not get you anywhere near where you want to be in the search engines.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5932912].message }}

Tim3

12 years ago

Originally Posted by Kronom

Dear warriors,

I just got myself a tool for finding the blogs to comment on, but ideally I would also like to find a software to help me creating comments. Yes I know aleady, manually created comments are better I agree, however this is not what I am looking for now... :-) Do you know a tool which auto creates comments?

Arthur

You already possess software to create comments, it's called your brain.

Software such as you require has already messed up millions of blogs who's owners have got sick of it and turned off the comments, thus ruining it for everyone.

For pity's sake dude, don't be a another spammer, use this forum to help you build a proper business you can be proud of.

DON'T BE A SPAMMER

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5932939].message }}

Devjeet

12 years ago

Originally Posted by Tim3

DON'T BE A SPAMMER

This is all about your automatic commenting tools. Why do you want to spend time and money in such kinds of junk? Even scrapbook or Xrumer Blast are not that much effective these days.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Providing Cheap SEO Freelancing Services Since 2010 => http://www.FreelanceSEOIndia.co.in

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5933362].message }}

seotothecore

12 years ago

You can use scrapebox to search for blogs to comment to, then do your manual commenting on the ones you find fit. Not really spam if your doing that I would say. Google can also do this to a degree for you already.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5934318].message }}

Hansons

11 years ago

Originally Posted by seotothecore

You can use scrapebox to search for blogs to comment to, then do your manual commenting on the ones you find fit. Not really spam if your doing that I would say. Google can also do this to a degree for you already.

This would be the best work for link building and you would get quality links too...

Thanks

Signature

Is your website Hacked? Try -> www.sitebeak.com
Is Google Analytics installed Properly? Test -> www.GAtective.com
Impersonal Google search? Check -> www.impersonal.me

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8199661].message }}

AndyBlackSEO

12 years ago

To be honest, Alexa has pretty much nailed it with her response.

Thanks

Signature

[FREE SEO TOOL] Build 29 Effective, High Authority Backlinks that Will Increase Your Google Rankings in 2020... CLICK HERE ...
... Instant backlinks that can get you results within 24-72hrs.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5932987].message }}

nicholasb

12 years ago

I hate those stupid automated comments, I literally get thousands of them a day. If you care about your business do not do it, take some time to actually comment and build a relationship with the blog owner as it will be more valuable to you than becoming a comment spammer.

Actually you might want to consider a new career entirely if this is your mindset.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

How to Make $2,000 Over and Over Again... CLICK HERE

My 2,000th Post and Why I'm So Successful

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5933129].message }}

Sillysoft

12 years ago

Originally Posted by nicholasb

I hate those stupid automated comments, I literally get thousands of them a day. If you care about your business do not do it, take some time to actually comment and build a relationship with the blog owner as it will be more valuable to you than becoming a comment spammer.

Actually you might want to consider a new career entirely if this is your mindset.

Hmmm.. This gives me an idea for a website lol Anyone interested?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5933147].message }}

mramp

12 years ago

1 Quality human made, and meaningful, blog comment is worth 1000 auto generated bs comments (which generally never get approved). Honestly, a lot of automation tools are crap...

Thanks

Signature

Stop Sucking: http://skinnyrichguy.com

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5935344].message }}

axix245

Banned 12 years ago

[DELETED]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5935703].message }}

twinspectra 12 years ago

GO AND GRAB A COPY OF SCRAPEBOX....
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5935895].message }}

Matt Broody

12 years ago

Do it manually

Thanks

Signature

Boost your rankings TODAY

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5935886].message }}

GeraldNitram

12 years ago

You can use software that could help you find blogs, but I suggest that you think of blog commenting as more of an interaction rather than as an opportunity to build your links. As Alexa Smith said, your comments are supposed to add value to the post and the conversations on the comments section, if there are any.

Thanks

Signature

Be your own boss by becoming an SEO Reseller!
A white label SEO firm can help you out so that you can start TODAY!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5936331].message }}

Eleanor

12 years ago

Auto blog commenting is a complete waste of time. Most blog owners can spot auto comments a mile away so they will never get approved. The time you spend finding auto commenting software and buying it and setting it up you could have made 10 real blog comments that will actually do you some good.

Hope that helps

Eleanor

Thanks

Signature

Eleanor's Affiliate Marketing Blog

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5937225].message }}

JSProjects

12 years ago

Scrapebox, obviously. But prepared to get most of your comments denied until you've built up your own list of auto approve blogs.

The problem, though, is that most auto approve blogs are already spammed-to-death. I'll admit that I still point links from AA blogs to my tiers, but I wouldn't touch my main site with them.

I MUCH prefer to manually leave comments. Because, really, just a small handful of PR1+ backlinks is much more powerful than thousands of junk links from spammed blogs.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5937885].message }}

sadek

12 years ago

It's always better to comment manually, as at that case you can determine the authority, page-rank, no of back-links, no of comments.

Thanks

Signature

Google Play Â· News Clerks Â· Android Forums Â· Top Ten list Â· Download free Forms

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5938290].message }}

angrybirdrio

12 years ago

use scraper to harvest blogs then do it comment manually.. and if your are trying to spam comments ..take note that dont use direct link .. ^_^

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Free Article Submission | Auto Approved PR4 to PR9 List | Get 200 Comment Backlinks |Get The Best Article Spinner Tool for FREE

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5938472].message }}

JSProjects 12 years ago

Originally Posted by angrybirdrio

use scraper to harvest blogs then do it comment manually.. and if your are trying to spam comments ..take note that dont use direct link .. ^_^

True. I've used Scrapebox to build huge lists of moderated blogs. You can use it to find niche-related blogs, dofollow blogs, high PR posts, etc.

Most people look at it as a comment spam tool when it's really a lot more than that.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5939334].message }}

cloudbacklinks

12 years ago

There is a tool for it (not scrapebox) that looks like its manual, but I'm not going to tell you. Also manual blog comment is better so you should look into that.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5939495].message }}

patco

12 years ago

Scrapebox is perfect for this process, but don't overuse it. It could post comments on blogs that are UNRELATED to your website. I advice you to check the links and assure that the blogs are related. Also manual commenting is recommedned until you make a good list (then post comments automatically!)

Thanks

Signature

A blog that will show you How to Lose Weight with a cool Quick Weight Loss guide...
Also enjoy some of my favorite Funny pictures and photos that will make you smile :)

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5939738].message }}

dodly

12 years ago

automatic comment = spam

Thanks

Signature

- Ø¯Ù‡Ø§Ù†Ø§Øª

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5940782].message }}

phuongle

11 years ago

I am sure this kind of blog commenting considered SPAM , it is useless as all the sites you are sending comments to are a farm links it gives a bad hurt on your site pagerank and it should be banned by panda updates.

I just recommend leave high authority comments on real blogs .

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

New!!! Get Free Online Marketing Tools
HOW TO REALLY MAKE MONEY WITH CLICKBANK and forex

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7307246].message }}

JSProjects

11 years ago

Originally Posted by phuongle

I am sure this kind of blog commenting considered SPAM , it is useless as all the sites you are sending comments to are a farm links it gives a bad hurt on your site pagerank and it should be banned by panda updates.

I just recommend leave high authority comments on real blogs .

Yeah, I don't really see the appeal of creating a link on a page with hundreds (even thousands in some cases) of other links. And many of them to questionable sites.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7337350].message }}

betterwtveter

11 years ago

Don't use auto comments, you will mess up your reputation. Be honest with what you say and you will get results much more effectively than crappy auto comments. I delete those type of comments on my logs anyway

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7337390].message }}

STLSEO

11 years ago

Originally Posted by Kronom

Dear warriors,

I just got myself a tool for finding the blogs to comment on, but ideally I would also like to find a software to help me creating comments. Yes I know aleady, manually created comments are better I agree, however this is not what I am looking for now... :-) Do you know a tool which auto creates comments?

Arthur

How long have you been working in the SEO field?

Automated link building is SO done-zo.

Do yourself a favor and BUILD YOUR OWN LINKS! (or get penalized)

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7337461].message }}

Taswir

11 years ago

I heard about blogcommentingninja and bookmarkingdemon. Specially BMD is more popular in this field. But manually blog commenting is far better as hundred backlinks from related blog is better than thousands of backlinks from unrelated blogs in the eye of search engine.

Thanks

Signature

The Top Blogger
Thesis Theme Coupon

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7342689].message }}

affilorama-portal

11 years ago

I also suggest that you do blog commenting manually. Automated software do not work anymore. They do, but they are not as effective as before.

Still, it is best to find appropriate blog sites and provide good comments (not spam).

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7342962].message }}

MaryPabelate

Banned 11 years ago

But you have to comment manually with quality to get maximum benefit from blog commenting.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7356366].message }}

Yohance j

11 years ago

Isn't that the absolute worst thing to do nowadays?

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Carpet Cleaning Los Angeles

Carpet cleaning Pasadena

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7356593].message }}

JSProjects 11 years ago

Originally Posted by Yohance j

Isn't that the absolute worst thing to do nowadays?

Automated commenting? Yup. But manual commenting is something that is still going strong. Unfortunately too many people are put off by the fact that it takes a little bit of time and effort.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7360027].message }}

b4uindia

11 years ago

Originally Posted by Kronom

Dear warriors,

I just got myself a tool for finding the blogs to comment on, but ideally I would also like to find a software to help me creating comments. Yes I know aleady, manually created comments are better I agree, however this is not what I am looking for now... :-) Do you know a tool which auto creates comments?

Arthur

Automatic blog comments are not a good idea for SEO purpose, however if you are still wanting to do automatic blog comments softwares such as scrapebox may help you in it.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7358663].message }}

nathansaputra

11 years ago

i use manual blogcomment , you can try " type it in " it is very useful software to help you proceed manual coment

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7360070].message }}

bramayadi

11 years ago

you can try imacros for blog commenting

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8199347].message }}

Jamesfranklin

11 years ago

According to me, Don't use any software or tool for blog commenting or any other off page techniques. Auto blog commenting will not approved. So always do the manual blog commenting Bcz Manual Blog commenting will approved. It is better to do manual blog commenting.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8199795].message }}

blingcityusa

11 years ago

I think manual commenting will get fast approval then commenting by any software... Some blog admin will not approve if the commenting is done by any software

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8199885].message }}

JSProjects

11 years ago

Originally Posted by blingcityusa

I think manual commenting will get fast approval then commenting by any software... Some blog admin will not approve if the commenting is done by any software

Especially if the blog is active. A lot of people tend to just go straight for high PR posts and drop comments. This usually leads to disappointment because a small # of their comments are getting approved. Even if they're good.

I ALWAYS make sure there are at least a few recent posts before leaving a comment on a blog. This alone greatly increases your approval rate. (There's no sense in commenting on an abandoned blog!)

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8203434].message }}

nettech4

11 years ago

As a blogger I get many automated comments everyday. I rejects these comments and the same goes with all bloggers where there is a comment moderation is enabled. Automated commenting tool works with blogs where there is no comment moderation is enabled. That itself says those blogs are not much important since the webmaster/blogger is not paying any attention to even read the comment.

If you really interested to know automated tools go with scrapbox, I see a lot of people recommend this.

Thanks

Signature

My Blog

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8203646].message }}

Blog commenting on auto

Trending Topics

Should i Index Author pages?

best high quality crypto traffic.

Some interesting stats about brand comms

What's the Best IM-Related Skill to Learn Today That Can Help in the Future?

Fixing a massive traffic drop after rebranding