Organic Rank or Local Listings?

Ok I have been driving myself crazy trying to figure this out! I have 4 different websites for my business. I listed 2 of them (that have the best SEO applied) in the Google Local Listings about 2 years ago. I used to get an organic rank (#1) and an (A) Local rank on the 1st page of Google. I know things change and over the past year, they have seemed to be blended. Just 1 Local Listing (A) but not an organic ranking for certain keyword phrases. My thought here is what's more important to me, the Local Listing or the Organic rank. I really want both. My main site dominates the SERP's, #1-5 for many keyword phrases in my industry. I have about 6 years of good SEO methods invested in it and counting. I hate to just have it in the Local Listings for some of the main keyword phrases. If I delete my Local Listing account, the site will most like go back to ranking at the top of the 1st pages organically. Not sure I want to do this. (weighing the pros & cons) Now what if I go into my account and just change the URL address to one of my lesser ranking sites or an inner page and leave all the other info. the same? Will I still get an (A) Local Listing? Or will I fall on the 7-pack? Don't want to start over with SEO on a new site for Organic or Local. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks Alan