Facebook vs. Instagram - what is more effective? | Warrior Forum - The #1 Digital Marketing Forum & Marketplace

7 years ago

I think Pinterest is better than both. Lasre targeted free traffic. Money can be made on FB but there are a lot of expensive ads between you and victory. Instagram rocks and if you build a following you can sell shout outs, but otherwise there are not a lot people on there buying non-Instagram stuff on there. If your niche has a lot of visible appeal, you may do well on Instagram and Pinterest.

[ 3 ] Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Mike Allen - Discover the one trick to force Google to send you buyers

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10994937].message }}

iamthore

7 years ago

Originally Posted by mdallen

I think Pinterest is better than both. Lasre targeted free traffic. Money can be made on FB but there are a lot of expensive ads between you and victory. Instagram rocks and if you build a following you can sell shout outs, but otherwise there are not a lot people on there buying non-Instagram stuff on there. If your niche has a lot of visible appeal, you may do well on Instagram and Pinterest.

I heared people mentioning Pinterest as a way to drive leads multiple times now but I can't really grasp the concept behind it. Without going into too much detail, can you outline the concept of advertising on Pinterest. As far as I am aware you can online post pictures can't you?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995865].message }}

discrat

7 years ago

It's really all subjective.

I mean there is a certain segment of the population who think snail mail is still a better medium to advertise than the internet.

And vice versa.
Just depends on your goals, the product and niche, as well as your skill set and personality

- Robert Andrew

[ 1 ] Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10994945].message }}

talfighel

7 years ago

This is something you will have to test yourself and not take others advice. While one strategy works well for one marketer, it may not work for others. So test it to see what kinds of results you are getting.

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

Signature

---> [URGENT] Here's How To Build Wealth With Gold And
Silver And Earn Up To $7,000 Per Week!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995004].message }}

Tesslady

7 years ago

Originally Posted by talfighel

This is something you will have to test yourself and not take others advice. While one strategy works well for one marketer, it may not work for others. So test it to see what kinds of results you are getting.

Exactly.

We have different experiences and outcomes, so what might work for me might or might not work for you.

So, the solution is: Test, test, test.
That's the key to getting answers to your questions!

Thanks

Signature

FREE DOWNLOAD-Gain Expert Status in Any Niche with PLR Starter Pack
Your Guide to the Perfect PLR Business for fast and easy income!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995438].message }}

dkate9

7 years ago

Instagram is mainly a photo/short video sharing service. While On Facebook you can post photos, texts, videos, links, groups, events, pages and many other social activities.

Thanks

Signature

Hire Expert Coders at Reasonable Rates. Get FREE SEO Audit Today.
Digital Marketing Agency Dallas Free Digital Marketing ROI Calculator

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995025].message }}

vansy

7 years ago

For me, Facebook and Instagram are both effective because these two are social medias and many people or let say your target market can easy notice your advertisement, but in terms of number of users, Facebook have it.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995028].message }}

Julio

7 years ago

I know this post is about Instagram and facebook but I prefer twitter I find it more easier to follow and send messages to people. For me there's too much going on in facebook and I haven't really gotten into Instagram yet.

Thanks

Signature

DominioNombres.com Marketplace!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995052].message }}

avemfly619619

7 years ago

Instagram is very good social media site for promotion. facebook is the also good one for promotion but facebook is better than instagram .

Thanks

Signature

digital marketing company in Delhi | seo company in Delhi | SMO Company in Delhi

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995161].message }}

Ben Friedman

7 years ago

Surely it depends what it is that you are promoting.

If it is more visual then obviously Instagram would be better, but if it is more about information then Facebook may be better for getting a message across.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995264].message }}

HalderLee

7 years ago

Facebook is use for work, file sharing , promotion of your business , marketing whereas Instagram is use for only photosharing. So, i think facebook is more effective than instagram.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995266].message }}

rudi

7 years ago

Use both, ads are more effective on Facebook at the moment, but client interactive for me is much much better on instagram.

Yes instagram is owned by Facebook but they are different animals. I think Instagram will be a much more of a force in the coming years but at the moment Facebook i think has the lead. But you need to be using all of the social networks not just focusing on 1 or the other

Thanks

Signature

New Course - Master Level Funnels - Get Multiple High Paying Clients While Living Life On Your Own Terms

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995307].message }}

Forte Trader

7 years ago

I think both are same because of both are social media sites and both contain millions of people. Some difference in both.like size of video, File sharing, promote your business.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995322].message }}

EPoltrack77

7 years ago

They are both social networks and it is really not buyer traffic so I would be building a list with it and you know that is a good question. Facebook is huge and there is a little more social interaction than say with Instagram so thats a tough one to say...

Thanks

Signature

Working to achieve higher results...

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995351].message }}

agmccall

7 years ago

The one that you focus your efforts on will be the most effective

al

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

Signature

"Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work." Thomas Edison

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995358].message }}

dcristo 7 years ago

Originally Posted by agmccall

The one that you focus your efforts on will be the most effective

al

That's true but it's also worth mentioning that some networks cater to certain industries.

For example, Instagram is great for fashion brands.
- Thanks
Signature

Are you wanting to learn all the poker lingo?
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11044806].message }}

ChrisBa

7 years ago

Originally Posted by iamthore

Hi warriors,

I'm constantly looking to expand the channels I advertise on. Even though they are under the same "roof" I find there are different benefits to both of the networks.

Especially when it comes to working with influencer I find it often times cheaper to work with IG personalities (as they don't really know the value of their brand more often than not).

What do you think? What's more effective to marketing your products / services and why?

IMO it depends on the niche, demographics and product.

But at the same time, why limit yourself? Why not do both?

Thanks

Signature

$ POPS GUIDE - YOUR FIRST CONVERSION GUARANTEED! $

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995508].message }}

socialluise

7 years ago

If you are trying to sell your product with Influencer Marketing then Instagram is the way to go. More people are available for product placements on Instagram. If you are looking to build long term trust, you can use Facebook Groups or Pages.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995509].message }}

iamthore

7 years ago

Originally Posted by socialluise

If you are trying to sell your product with Influencer Marketing then Instagram is the way to go. More people are available for product placements on Instagram. If you are looking to build long term trust, you can use Facebook Groups or Pages.

Hi socialluise,

thanks for your reply. Have you ever worked with pages / groups on FB in order to promote products? What was the outcome? How do they normally price their offers?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995872].message }}

Karl Karrlander

7 years ago

Originally Posted by iamthore

Hi warriors,

I'm constantly looking to expand the channels I advertise on. Even though they are under the same "roof" I find there are different benefits to both of the networks.

Especially when it comes to working with influencer I find it often times cheaper to work with IG personalities (as they don't really know the value of their brand more often than not).

What do you think? What's more effective to marketing your products / services and why?

Like a few people have already said, it really depends on your business and what market you're in. Test, test, test, only way to know for sure what works and what doesn't.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995515].message }}

aligouda

7 years ago

Originally Posted by iamthore

Hi warriors,

I'm constantly looking to expand the channels I advertise on. Even though they are under the same "roof" I find there are different benefits to both of the networks.

Especially when it comes to working with influencer I find it often times cheaper to work with IG personalities (as they don't really know the value of their brand more often than not).

What do you think? What's more effective to marketing your products / services and why?

As anyone who uses Facebook and Instagram will tell you, the two platforms are quite different. That’s why so many users still maintain accounts on both of them.

They share certain features in common, but they each have unique strengths and weaknesses from a marketing perspective. Strategies that work wonders on Facebook might fall flat on the photo-sharing platform, and the reverse is also true; Instagram successes might not translate well to Facebook’s mechanics.

Both platforms can be used to connect with friends, family, celebrities and brands, but advertisers would do well to formulate separate yet complementary marketing strategies for each.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

>>Start Your Passive Income Digital Business Now!. Click Here Now!<<

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995520].message }}

iamthore

7 years ago

Originally Posted by aligouda

As anyone who uses Facebook and Instagram will tell you, the two platforms are quite different. Thats why so many users still maintain accounts on both of them.

They share certain features in common, but they each have unique strengths and weaknesses from a marketing perspective. Strategies that work wonders on Facebook might fall flat on the photo-sharing platform, and the reverse is also true; Instagram successes might not translate well to Facebooks mechanics.

Both platforms can be used to connect with friends, family, celebrities and brands, but advertisers would do well to formulate separate yet complementary marketing strategies for each.

Thanks very much for your reply aligouda. Do you have examples as to what strategy / niche would work well on IG or FB?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10995870].message }}

Kaarthik Shrivastav

7 years ago

Besides facebook & instagram I find pinterest and twitter equally effective in terms of social reach.
However, the business category defines which social platforms will be more effective. E.g. for photographers instagram and pinterest are extremely effective in terms or reach & likes.

Thanks

Signature

Mumbai Darshan Cabs | Digital Marketing & Training | Angular JS | Training Institute Pune

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11001325].message }}

fisherjames731

7 years ago

According to me, Facebook is a more effective. Facebook is especially popular among online women, 77% of whom are users of the site. In addition, 82% of online adults between 18 to 29 use Facebook, along with 79% of those 30 to 49, 64% of those 50 to 64 and 48% of those 65 and older. While its user base is dominated by those over 25, Facebook still has over 50 million users under the age of 25. Facebook is more popular with middle-aged adults than other social networks. In the U.S., the average monthly active user of Facebook was 40 years old in 2014.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11004824].message }}

benjamenjuan

7 years ago

Depends on your niche and a lot of other things, we would have to see what you're working with.

I agree with one poster in that they are all the same but really each platform is complex and there are several ways to leverage each platform in ways that you can't on others!

Thanks

Signature

Free Marketing Consultation!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11004998].message }}

uitechsol

7 years ago

I think both are good source of communication.Face book has large audience which includes all sort of people from almost every age group,on the other hand Instagram is mainly used by youth so it has limited users compared to face book but in any case both of them are capable to spread a word!!

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11005732].message }}

rfharris

Banned 7 years ago

Both are effective, if your targeted audience is mainly on mobile then instagram would surely be the better option for you to targer. Otherwise you should work on both.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11005899].message }}

martindam33

7 years ago

I think Instagram is more effective and unique platform.
its Blog posting Feature is very effective.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11005901].message }}

automathings

7 years ago

How do the demographics vary between the two? From Facebook I'm getting a lot of the 45-65+ female demographic. I would imagine that Instagram skews younger?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11008738].message }}

mandylopez

7 years ago

Since Facebook is a lot older than Instagram, it’ll have some advantages in terms of user base and popularity. However, Instagram’s growth has been extremely strong and it’s headed in the right direction. Let’s look at the numbers.
Facebook Statistics
1.4 billion monthly active users
655 million monthly active users that are mobile only
65% of Facebook videos occur on mobile devices
40 million small businesses have Facebook Pages
Instagram Statistics
300 million monthly active users
75 million daily users
20% of Internet users are on Instagram
27% of the US population uses Instagram
47% of Instagram users access the app on their phone and 53% on their tablet

As you can see, Facebook might have larger vanity numbers but Instagram’s stats are very impressive—particularly in terms of engagement. Instagram has built itself up as a platform that thrives on users being able to engage with the visual content brands share.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11011642].message }}

whowhatwhere

7 years ago

Definitely more people use Facebook, so if it's quantity you're after, then Facebook can't go wrong. IG is a very specific market, but if your product or service is quite millennial, then do it.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11011909].message }}

Rickyarora

7 years ago

My perspective, Facebook is more effective than Instagram because it increases your more website visitors when you share some posts in Facebook groups as compared to Instagram.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11012332].message }}

John Jonas Phil VA

7 years ago

That would depend on your market, niche and content. Lifestyle niches are often better suited in Instagram or Pinterest. Marketing niches seem to perform better on Facebook and Twitter

Thanks

Signature

Hire a Filipino virtual assistant and make your business better through outsourcing.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11012551].message }}

martindam33

7 years ago

Both are effective media ,it totally depends on how you are optimizing and working on it.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11012811].message }}

DigitalDasher

7 years ago

Originally Posted by iamthore

Hi warriors,

I'm constantly looking to expand the channels I advertise on. Even though they are under the same "roof" I find there are different benefits to both of the networks.

Especially when it comes to working with influencer I find it often times cheaper to work with IG personalities (as they don't really know the value of their brand more often than not).

What do you think? What's more effective to marketing your products / services and why?

I'd advice IG because a lot of people using IG don't really understand how to market efficiently on there so you can come as an authority figure and put a recognizable stamp on your target niche

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11012972].message }}

nirajan

7 years ago

For me, Instagram works better if the products are fancier than regular products.

Thanks

Signature

Social Media & Web Resources

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11013165].message }}

mdallen

7 years ago

Digital products only sell well if they are fancy as you put it, as far as picture oriented sites like Instagram and Pinterest

Thanks

Signature

Mike Allen - Discover the one trick to force Google to send you buyers

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11013191].message }}

JohnAdam1

7 years ago

Facebook is use for longer period of time as compared to Instagram and it has a large database of users as compared to Instagram. Most people prefer Facebook because it has more possibilities. Instagram is limited to video/photo, whereas Facebook's posts can just be text, photo, video, link, etc. Instagram is becoming popular as time is passing, but Facebook definitely has more users. All the users who are using Instagram are also using Facebook too.

Thanks

Signature

John Adams
Classic PDF|| Best PDF converter/Editor

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11013435].message }}

Susan Green

7 years ago

Instagram is used mainly for providing one with the options for posting images, videos. But when it comes to Facebook, it not only provide you with the ways for posting your images, videos, but there are a lot more things that one can do in it. And as per my thinking it is best for people who are looking forward for promoting there business.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11015600].message }}

missmystery

7 years ago

For me, 100% Instagram.

It really depends on what your niche is. If it's something like internet marketing then probably Facebook as people don't really want to look at pictures to do with that.

Thanks

Signature

Geek Girl Fi

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11017302].message }}

Uchiha Itachi

7 years ago

Facebook because it is page with traffic ranked third in the world and can be purged to pick out potential customers, it's also completely free.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11017416].message }}

brookeharper08

7 years ago

@iamthore: I recommend you test out the waters and see what fits the bill. Instagram may work better than FB for some while it works the other way around for others.

What I do agree on is how Pinterest can help you grow your online presence and market your products/services. You can take Pinterest for a spin as you continue to use Facebook and IG and see what works best for you. It might be a combo of all of these social media platforms, a mix of both of these, or just one channel would work. Good luck!

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11023178].message }}

katerinavaiou

7 years ago

Although Facebook has more traffic compared to Instagram, in recent times it is noticed that reach of facebook has been reduced. So even if you post something useful, you are only reaching 5-10% of your total audience. You need to consider this reach factor also while comparing the two giant social media.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11023246].message }}

KiethJohnson

7 years ago

There are more people on Facebook, but if you're looking to sell/advertise to the younger generation, Instagram is the safer way to go. And Instagram is also a good way to market if you have pretty photos. However, Facebook is easier to navigate in terms of posting content and has a wider reach.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11024634].message }}

Bud B Elliott

7 years ago

Facebook is more effective

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11028255].message }}

Tamica N Huddleston

7 years ago

Both are very effective and helps to get more traffic to your sites

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11028267].message }}

innn

7 years ago

Test both the system and compare the results.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11028468].message }}

Son Phan

7 years ago

i would recommend FB. due to more people use it and have lots of function that help you SEO-offpage. and fb service look cheaper than insta

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11029649].message }}

AnissamcGary

7 years ago

I like facebook.. its more effective than Instagram

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11034454].message }}

Tahreem Saeed

7 years ago

Facebook shook up the social media marketing world with its data-driven approach, Instagram with its strict focus on mobile users and visuals.And the two are closely linked together since Facebook owns Instagram. Despite the close bond between them, they're two separate platforms that need to be approached differently.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Creative Designer and Developer !

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11037557].message }}

Ryan Tran 7 years ago

If you want to drive traffic to your web, Fb is better
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11073614].message }}

Son Phan

7 years ago

i think Facebook will take advantage since instagram only focus on picture stuff where fb u can share article and write post

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11039759].message }}

overtonis 7 years ago

Originally Posted by Son Phan

i think Facebook will take advantage since instagram only focus on picture stuff where fb u can share article and write post

That is so wrong. Instagram allows videos now and incorporates 'stories' similar to snap chat. Instagram is essentially pinterest (pictures), snap chat (stories), periscope (live video) and text. The only draw back for instagram is you can't link to urls outside of one they allow in bio.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11044961].message }}

mickyl

7 years ago

I like Instagram, mainly because people there are very engaged, so even if there are less people - for me they are much more targeted and willing to participate, etc.
It really depends on what you are trying to do, though, and I don't see a reason why not combine the two - and invest in both platforms, checking out what works best for you...

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11040227].message }}

HarryJ

7 years ago

It depends on your brand, your offers and the purpose behind your ads.
Instagram is primarily focused on images, if your brand requires more than just a pretty picture to really convey its value, then you might be better off creating deeper content and sharing it via Facebook.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11041100].message }}

NewEnglandah

7 years ago

Facebook is more dynamic in that it can do all of the types of interfacing that the other social media outlets can do. If you study Facebook advertising and some of its fanpage interactions you can do more with Facebook.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11044327].message }}

overtonis

7 years ago

Its not even close. Instagram is better because it is unfiltered by facebook. But that is coming soon. So enjoy it while it last.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11044960].message }}

jw22777

7 years ago

They all are good platforms..Facebook is personally my favorite. But it all depends on your product and what crowd that product is targeted to.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11045327].message }}

mdallen

7 years ago

I like Facebook better. Although Facebook owns Instagram so they get your money either way

Facebook seems to have more options for interaction and I find conversation is my best tool for selling. A picture is worth a thousand words, but I don't feel the same interaction

Thanks

Signature

Mike Allen - Discover the one trick to force Google to send you buyers

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11053065].message }}

voltaireross

7 years ago

As for me, it is purely subjective. It all depends on your target goals, the products/services you are promoting and most specially the reach of audiences you are targeting.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11053237].message }}

Ryan Tran

7 years ago

It depends on your brand, your offers and the purpose behind your ads.
Instagram is primarily focused on images, if your brand requires more than just a pretty picture to really convey its value, then you might be better off creating deeper content and sharing it via Facebook.
<Hary J>

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11073616].message }}

Facebook vs. Instagram - what is more effective?

Trending Topics

Some interesting stats about brand comms

Fixing a massive traffic drop after rebranding

Meta AI now has Google Search results

Looking at the average screen time and socmed usage

What's the Best IM-Related Skill to Learn Today That Can Help in the Future?