Spent $19 at plenty of fish not 1 click

by marv10
59 replies
I got excepted to 2 cpa networks last week and heard a lot of good things about pof.

I tried several offers mostly dating and I did not get even 1 click.

Im really having a hard time with cpa stuff and I know it should not be that
hard.

Anybody got any advice on a good way to start promoting cpa offers?

Thanks
#$19 #click #fish #plenty #spent
  • Profile picture of the author TheAnnoyingOrange
    Originally Posted by marv10 View Post

    I got excepted to 2 cpa networks last week and heard a lot of good things about pof.

    I tried several offers mostly dating and I did not get even 1 click.

    Im really having a hard time with cpa stuff and I know it should not be that
    hard.

    Anybody got any advice on a good way to start promoting cpa offers?

    Thanks
    Try using the search button and looking up CPA guides or case studies or even look around the WSO's and see one that meets the criteria you are after.

    It will save you a lot more time than waiting here for people to re-type the same things they do every time a new member asks the exact same question.

    Best of Luck!
    Signature
    Reserved for TheAnnoyingOrange
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2527090].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author SandyP
    Hi - look for William who is a regular poster here, He has an excellent WSO on POF.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2527118].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author harro1
    Target canada dating offers as there is cheap traffic from canada available on pof, usa traffic has much higher bids, you need to bid like 0.50+ to get good amount of usa impressions.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2527129].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author marv10
      Thanks for the info

      while i was waiting i did what orange said and looked through the forum and
      read some good stuff.

      I paid about .42-.45 in US market and got plenty of impressions but not clicks.

      Thanks guys
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2527277].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Christian Chan
    First, $19 bucks worth of ads is not a good test data. Then again, maybe your ads are not compelling enough for them to take action.

    Originally Posted by marv10 View Post

    I got excepted to 2 cpa networks last week and heard a lot of good things about pof.

    I tried several offers mostly dating and I did not get even 1 click.

    Im really having a hard time with cpa stuff and I know it should not be that
    hard.

    Anybody got any advice on a good way to start promoting cpa offers?

    Thanks
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2527317].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author netbank4all
    Use juicy ads - you can get 1000 banner clicks for less than $10.00. They are purely for clicks not for views. So this will be better for your dating offer promotions. But see the TOS of the offer about promotion methods.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2528164].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author excoder01
      Originally Posted by netbank4all View Post

      Use juicy ads - you can get 1000 banner clicks for less than $10.00. They are purely for clicks not for views. So this will be better for your dating offer promotions. But see the TOS of the offer about promotion methods.
      You can promote more than just dating offers on POF....so JuicyAds may not be appropriate depending on what you offer.
      Signature
      Affiliate Review Templates - get affiliate review templates every week. No tech or marketing skills required!
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2528566].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Steve Ranger
    Am I going mad here - PlentyOfFish do Pay Per Click right?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2528591].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author williamrs
      Originally Posted by Steve Ranger View Post

      Am I going mad here - PlentyOfFish do Pay Per Click right?
      No, only Pay Per Impressions (CPM).
      Signature
      Steal My Profit Strategy



      >> Download Now <<
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2528616].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author williamrs
    As another member said above, $19 is not enough for a good test. However, if you didn't get a single click after spending all this amount of money there is no doubt that there is something very wrong with your campaign.

    I don't know how you're split-testing ads, but here is the normal process:

    1. Get 15 - 25 images

    2. Write 2 ad copies

    3. Create as much combinations between ads and images as possible and start testing them

    It should give you at least 4 or 5 ads with a CTR close to 0.1%, which is decent on PoF.

    You can also spy on your competitors (create fake accounts with the demographics you're targeting) and get some ideas.

    Also, don't forget that only using tags and making ads custom can be not enough. You need to be provocative, make people curious and offer them exactly what they want.

    Here is an example of one of my campaigns:

    {age:30+} and in {state:US}?
    We have 6,125 men who might be interested in you. Join Matchmaker for free and meet them today!

    This one didn't work for women above 30, but then I targeted only women looking to marry soon and used this ad:

    Looking For A Husband?
    Let us help you find a husband in {state:US} - Join "my offer" for Free!

    (Where it says "my offer" I obviously put the name of the site I was promoting)

    Do you see the difference? I offered them exactly what they wanted. You need to make your ads "irresistible" so that people will stop doing what they are doing to see what you have to show them.


    William
    Signature
    Steal My Profit Strategy



    >> Download Now <<
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2528613].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Demiano
      Hi William, do offers for dating services work consistently on POF? I am surprised because people already are on POF! Are they missing some special benefit other offers have?

      I am hesitant to offer these kind of things also because I read that POF traffic for dating offers is not a good traffic meaning not willing to commit or buy anything.

      Is there a way to know for which kind of offers there is already to much competition?

      Thanks,
      Demian

      Originally Posted by williamrs View Post


      Looking For A Husband?
      Let us help you find a husband in {state:US} - Join "my offer" for Free!

      (Where it says "my offer" I obviously put the name of the site I was promoting)

      Do you see the difference? I offered them exactly what they wanted. You need to make your ads "irresistible" so that people will stop doing what they are doing to see what you have to show them.


      William
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2539378].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author jeffrey73
        Originally Posted by Demiano View Post

        Hi William, do offers for dating services work consistently on POF? I am surprised because people already are on POF! Are they missing some special benefit other offers have?

        I am hesitant to offer these kind of things also because I read that POF traffic for dating offers is not a good traffic meaning not willing to commit or buy anything.

        Is there a way to know for which kind of offers there is already to much competition?

        Thanks,
        Demian
        Dating works on PoF when it is targeted specifically. Plenty of Fish isn't the "be all end all" and the users know it. Offer them a free trial to a more specific site with more people targeted to their interests/types and they are more willing to sign up.

        With free trials they don't have to commit or buy. The dating site will get them to sign up later. Usually when that person gets an email or something, they will practically be "forced" into getting a paid membership if they want to be able to view and read their emails, or get better options.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2552169].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Johnny12345
      Originally Posted by williamrs View Post


      Here is an example of one of my campaigns:

      {age:30+} and in {state:US}?
      We have 6,125 men who might be interested in you. Join [b}Matchmaker[/b] for free and meet them today!

      When you promote the big dating sites (like Matchmaker), are you going directly through their own in-house affiliate program or finding a CPA offer from a network?

      Also, are you just direct linking (or redirecting) PoF users to the offer page?

      Thanks,

      John
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2886118].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author marv10
    Thanks guys really appreciate the feed back.

    Im learning
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2530417].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author jeffrey73
      Funny. I usually see a lot of ads getting .15% ctr and above on PoF. That's supposed to be good right? The problem? Maybe 1 conversion, but usually zero. It's so hard to make PoF profitable, yet so many claim you can just move your Facebook campaigns over and scale it. WRONG! Nothing is further from the truth.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2530443].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author williamrs
        Originally Posted by jeffrey73 View Post

        Funny. I usually see a lot of ads getting .15% ctr and above on PoF. That's supposed to be good right? The problem? Maybe 1 conversion, but usually zero. It's so hard to make PoF profitable, yet so many claim you can just move your Facebook campaigns over and scale it. WRONG! Nothing is further from the truth.
        I don't think that PoF is very hard to make profitable, but I completely agree with you when you say that it's not possible simply move campaigns from FB to PoF as if this platform was just an extension of FB. I have been doing very well on PoF and I'm still crawling with FB, and for me it's enough to say that they are not just the same thing.

        PoF is not just like Google, FB, Yahoo!, etc... it's just like PoF! So you need to learn how to use PoF and never think that your knowledge and experience with other platforms are enough;


        William
        Signature
        Steal My Profit Strategy



        >> Download Now <<
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2530544].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BryanC
    Is it just me or does marketing dating to a consumer who is already on one of the largest dating networks seem sort of silly?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2531417].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author jeffrey73
      Originally Posted by BryanC View Post

      Is it just me or does marketing dating to a consumer who is already on one of the largest dating networks seem sort of silly?
      PoF Ben says that the average user on PoF belongs to at least 3 different dating sites.

      How many users do they have?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2531484].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author excoder01
      Originally Posted by BryanC View Post

      Is it just me or does marketing dating to a consumer who is already on one of the largest dating networks seem sort of silly?
      Why dating product? What about health (i.e. weight loss, teeth whitening) products, wealth (make money online), and other non-relationship offers?
      Signature
      Affiliate Review Templates - get affiliate review templates every week. No tech or marketing skills required!
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2531501].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author williamrs
      Originally Posted by jeffrey73 View Post

      Since PoF is CPM "only" would you slow down the impressions to flow more evenly instead of blasting them and showing 5 times to the same person each time?

      One of the things that's tough is the impressions come almost "too fast", and with the CPM base it's more difficult to test. If you've got a definite winner that's great, but usually only 1 or 2 ads out of 300 ads actually might be a winner.
      PoF has a feature called "frequency cap", which allows you to determine how many times your ads will be displayed to the same person. So it's not necessary to distribute impressions evenly to avoid getting to many impressions with the same user.

      I agree that CPM is a bit harder to test than CPC, because you can lose some money until you find ads with a good CTR, but the proportion of good / bad ads uses to be better than 2 out of 300. Maybe 1 out of 5 or 6.


      Originally Posted by BryanC View Post

      Is it just me or does marketing dating to a consumer who is already on one of the largest dating networks seem sort of silly?
      Silly or not, I like the money it makes me.

      In order to combine offers and traffic sources properly you need to understand what people want. People using PoF can be looking for many different things depending on their demographics, but the fact is that PoF is a very general site and, usually, offering something more specific is a good idea.

      For example, if you promote a dating site for BB people to PoF users who are overweight they may consider that the site you're offering them fits their needs much better than PoF.

      Also, most people who uses PoF actively still haven't found the partner that they are looking for, so they are likely to be interested in more opportunities such as other dating sites.


      William
      Signature
      Steal My Profit Strategy



      >> Download Now <<
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2532098].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author indexphp
      Originally Posted by BryanC View Post

      Is it just me or does marketing dating to a consumer who is already on one of the largest dating networks seem sort of silly?
      not at all.

      They have signed up to a dating site already (POF), meaning they will be likely to sign up for another one ($$$)
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2903025].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author POFBen
        Originally Posted by indexphp View Post

        not at all.

        They have signed up to a dating site already (POF), meaning they will be likely to sign up for another one ($$$)
        Huge hint because we can target brand new users on POF or users that have been around for a few months.

        Which do you think is worth more to an advertiser?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2910952].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BryanC
    I completely agree. I would instinctively say anything BUT dating if its targeted properly. From what Jeffrey says, it is a misconception though.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2531562].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Chris Q
    Banned
    I would try that soon enough once I have enough funds on my pocket. CPA Flash 1 and 2 are very potential, but needs a little investment. I'm looking forward for POF.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2531895].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Marc Elrich
      i found that traffic from pof is extremely hard to conversion. I don't know why. I get plenty of clicks, but no conversions. People from pof are more interested in browsing than taking action.
      Signature
      Earn $72.75 Per Sale With This Hot Affiliate Program - Earn An Insane Amount Of Money By Promoting Our Amazing Product. Massive Conversion Rate - Super Low Refund Rate.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2532208].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author jeffrey73
        Originally Posted by Marc Elrich View Post

        i found that traffic from pof is extremely hard to conversion. I don't know why. I get plenty of clicks, but no conversions. People from pof are more interested in browsing than taking action.
        I'm in the same boat with you Marc, but this is obviously not the case. There are guys/girls making a living "strictly" with PoF, but it is a very hard nut to crack. Mostly because you can't control your bidding strategy.

        The key is finding "winners" and you're good to go. Many guys that are awesome on Facebook aren't good with PoF. With their targeting options this should be easy, but it's not.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2532548].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author williamrs
          Originally Posted by jeffrey73 View Post

          Right, the frequency cap. What do you set it at? I think I'm wasting impressions by setting it at 5 or 3.
          I usually start with 3 and increase it gradually until it affects my CTR (negatively, of course ). However, depending on the demographics you're targeting and your bid you may need to use 4 or 5.


          Originally Posted by Marc Elrich View Post

          i found that traffic from pof is extremely hard to conversion. I don't know why. I get plenty of clicks, but no conversions. People from pof are more interested in browsing than taking action.
          Originally Posted by jeffrey73 View Post

          I'm in the same boat with you Marc, but this is obviously not the case. There are guys/girls making a living "strictly" with PoF, but it is a very hard nut to crack. Mostly because you can't control your bidding strategy.

          The key is finding "winners" and you're good to go. Many guys that are awesome on Facebook aren't good with PoF. With their targeting options this should be easy, but it's not.
          Just send an email to william at newestmarketing dot com and I'll help you. Converting traffic from PoF is not really hard, but requires the right approach.


          William
          Signature
          Steal My Profit Strategy



          >> Download Now <<
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2533039].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author marv10
          A little update

          I took Williams advice and I ran several different ads for the same product.

          So far I have used 8 different pictures and with 3 different ad copy.

          I have spent about $10 so far and have gotten 7 clicks.

          The problem before was I was only throwing up one ad at a time and hoping for the best.

          Have not got any conversions yet but i feel good that my ads are getting clicked.

          Thanks again.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2533056].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author williamrs
            Originally Posted by marv10 View Post

            A little update

            I took Williams advice and I ran several different ads for the same product.

            So far I have used 8 different pictures and with 3 different ad copy.

            I have spent about $10 so far and have gotten 7 clicks.

            The problem before was I was only throwing up one ad at a time and hoping for the best.

            Have not got any conversions yet but i feel good that my ads are getting clicked.

            Thanks again.
            Nice! 7 clicks is not enough to say if your CTR really is ok, but it's a good start!

            Now, in order to improve your CVR you need to work on your landing pages and offers. Rotate, rotate and rotate. Create 2 or 3 LPs and rotate them. Choose 2 or 3 offers and rotate them. This is the secret to find winning combinations.


            William
            Signature
            Steal My Profit Strategy



            >> Download Now <<
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2533107].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BryanC
    Makes sense, thanks.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2532185].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author marv10
    Whats up

    In total yesterday I spent $20 got 16 clicks no conversions

    even though no conversions still feel pretty good because im starting to understand the process of testing pic, headlines and ad text.

    I had a picture get clicked 9 times and a headline that did the same

    I divided it into 2 campaigns 12 different ads in each and the difference was the age groups. Later on today i am going to fix the targeting a bit and use the ads that got the most of the clicks and rotate different offers.

    Try to find that winning "ULTRA COMBO!!!" had to add a little Killer Instinct

    I have $10 bucks left I know it is probably not enough but i want to see if i can get the same amount of clicks with half the money and hopefully get a conversion or 2

    I have been direct linking to the offer i am not to comfortable with making my own landing pages.

    Hey guys thanks a lot for all the advice i am learning a lot from this thread and the forum in general.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2534330].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author psynaut
    Good advice william ... to get a good CTR at POF is really all about the getting the right combo of images and ad copy … and a lot of split testing your ads. Ads and offers also go stale quick … u have to mix things up.
    Lately, I’ve found the quality of traffic has been steadily decreasing. A LOT of new advertisers coming into the space along with scraper and other bot traffic.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2552205].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author POFBen
    You guys can always contact me: ben@ pof.com and I'll be able to give you some personalize attention. I'll literally log-into your account and give it a quick analysis and offer constructive feedback on how you can improve on your performance.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2881954].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Herbert S Richter
    Banned
    POf works good if you use catchy images. If it was ****ty and useless guys wouldnt talk about this much!

    It works!

    Now, why would you just leave you campaign to spend more than $10 without a single click?

    PPC need that unless you're sure it works, you keep an eye on it by the minute! Otherwise you'll lose money and hate and blame the system.

    Good luck with your POF PPC campaigns!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2886039].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author blillard
      Originally Posted by Herbert S Richter View Post

      POf works good if you use catchy images. If it was ****ty and useless guys wouldnt talk about this much!

      It works!

      Now, why would you just leave you campaign to spend more than $10 without a single click?

      PPC need that unless you're sure it works, you keep an eye on it by the minute! Otherwise you'll lose money and hate and blame the system.

      Good luck with your POF PPC campaigns!
      im tracking like a mad right now
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3188307].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author laganja
    I only managed a few conversions myself. it's a dating site, so the products you can sell are limited...even weight loss or health products did not do well for me....I assume people are already secure with how they look or they look for people of similar physique.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2886251].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author POFBen
      Originally Posted by laganja View Post

      I only managed a few conversions myself. it's a dating site, so the products you can sell are limited...even weight loss or health products did not do well for me....I assume people are already secure with how they look or they look for people of similar physique.
      Weight loss does well on our site, you just have to target the right demographic. Your gut may tell you to target overweight people... but keep in mind they're overweight for a reason. Are they going to engage in a P90x intensive training program? Are they going to take a magical pill and shell out the $90/month for it?


      Originally Posted by Stiffler View Post

      POf works good if you use catchy images. If it was ****ty and useless guys wouldnt talk about this much!

      It works!

      Now, why would you just leave you campaign to spend more than $10 without a single click?

      PPC need that unless you're sure it works, you keep an eye on it by the minute! Otherwise you'll lose money and hate and blame the system.

      Good luck with your POF PPC campaigns!
      It does work but it does take time to split test. If you were coming in with a $25 deposit, chances are you probably won't get an awesome performing campaign right off the bat. Split test, update your images if they aren't performing... don't give up.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2886629].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author jeffrey73
      Originally Posted by laganja View Post

      I only managed a few conversions myself. it's a dating site, so the products you can sell are limited...even weight loss or health products did not do well for me....I assume people are already secure with how they look or they look for people of similar physique.
      The absolute worst thing you could ever do is assume something, just because it seems that way to you. Many BBW's are looking for skinny partners, just as not all black men are looking for only black females to date. Or single Christians aren't necessarily looking for other Christians to date, etc.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2888613].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ChrisBa
    Originally Posted by marv10 View Post

    I got excepted to 2 cpa networks last week and heard a lot of good things about pof.

    I tried several offers mostly dating and I did not get even 1 click.

    Im really having a hard time with cpa stuff and I know it should not be that
    hard.

    Anybody got any advice on a good way to start promoting cpa offers?

    Thanks
    Just curious, how did you target and what was your CTR?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2886257].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author maricelu
    I think you should change you promoting methods. try something new
    Signature

    I have no signature.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2890687].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author randyman
    I think POF users have seen all kinds of dating ads ever conceived

    guess you really need to offer something they never seen before

    or best yet, try different niches
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2896683].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author jexson_paul
    Use content locking cpa networks like Blamads and Leadbolt . Dont do with Cpalead they are scamer
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2898007].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author blillard
    My am is going to freaking be upset but I have to share what I know about POF that has helped me out a lot int he past.

    1. Use at least 50-100 images of hot girls breast get massive ctr, latino, asian, and indian girls are hot right now use a lot of bikini shots OUTDOORS.

    2. Make at least 5 ad copies using strong words and al ways ask a question in the title.

    3. this is the biggest tip start targeting using the log in count after a while user will get used to seeing the ads so they stop clicking on them.If you target newer user who have not yet had a chance to see most of the ads you get better ctr.

    I hope that helped someone out as much as it helps me I really didnt want to share this but Im an info junkie who believes in good karma.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2902013].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ryodante
    Thanks for all the informations, i keep searching for this 2 days for another traffic source, so far, i just use FB...

    for Google, Miva my account have not been approved, so i don't have the exact data.

    Maybe i should try POF for other source...
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2902389].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BloggerDeen
    Originally Posted by marv10 View Post

    I got excepted to 2 cpa networks last week and heard a lot of good things about pof.

    I tried several offers mostly dating and I did not get even 1 click.

    Im really having a hard time with cpa stuff and I know it should not be that
    hard.

    Anybody got any advice on a good way to start promoting cpa offers?

    Thanks
    I guess you are living in bubble that CPA is very easy. Anyway understand it completely before putting your money in it otherwise you will end up loosing more than just 19$. Just browse through this forum, there is lot of good info here. Also do the Google search and you will find a lot of free info on CPA enough for you to get started right way.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2903314].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Maji
    Originally Posted by marv10 View Post

    I got excepted to 2 cpa networks last week and heard a lot of good things about pof.

    I tried several offers mostly dating and I did not get even 1 click.

    Im really having a hard time with cpa stuff and I know it should not be that
    hard.

    Anybody got any advice on a good way to start promoting cpa offers?

    Thanks
    Your ad was not good. Make sure you ad is good
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3188884].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author mygold
    There are a lots of way but i think is it best for you as bellow.

    1. Market research
    2. Finding Offer
    3. Proper keyword research

    Promote offer You can compare the CPA offers from various networks on sites like offervault,affspy etc.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3189990].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author jeffrey73
    Here's some advice. Start on Facebook where you can use the CPC platform and learn how to create good CTR ads. Then transfer over to PoF and use more revealing pictures and targeted ad copy because they will let you.


    Originally Posted by marv10 View Post

    I got excepted to 2 cpa networks last week and heard a lot of good things about pof.

    I tried several offers mostly dating and I did not get even 1 click.

    Im really having a hard time with cpa stuff and I know it should not be that
    hard.

    Anybody got any advice on a good way to start promoting cpa offers?

    Thanks
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3190015].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author POFBen
      Well anybody who's running POF should be in contact with me OR their affiliate manager. The beginning's a bit challenging but once you get it... ohhhhh boy
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[3200352].message }}

Trending Topics