Is copywriting the same as marketing?

22 replies
Hi guys,

What are your thoughts on this? I mean if you are a great copywriter and can good write copy's does this make you instantly a great marketer?

Do you know then how to market your product or is this an other skill that you must have along with copywriting? In my opinion you must master both...or are they the same? Back to the question, is copywriting, marketing?

Here is what copywriting is for me:

- copywriting: you know how to make people buy,
- marketing: you know how to sell

Am I missing something or just talking with myself in public?
#copywriting #marketing
  • Profile picture of the author Mark Pescetti
    Copywriting IS marketing
    Signature

    Do you want a 9 figure copywriter and biz owner to Write With You? I'll work with you, on zoom, to help write your copy or client copy... while you learn from one of the few copywriters to legit hit 9 figures in gross sales! Discover More

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4718529].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Daniel Scott
      Originally Posted by Reflection Marketing View Post

      Copywriting IS marketing
      I completely disagree.

      Sure, there's some crossover... especially if you do marketing consulting and advise on positioning, strength of the offer etc.

      But killer marketers know how to get the right people in front of an offer... and how to get a lot of them.

      As a copywriter... that's not really my area of expertise. I might be able to give some advice... but if a client asks me how to get their page to the top of Google, I really don't have much more than a vague understanding.

      My job is to make sure anyone who sees the page I put together will buy. And that includes consulting on the design, offer, and position taken in the letter.

      But it's the marketer's job to get people in front of the offer in the first place.

      -Daniel
      Signature

      Always looking for badass direct-response copywriters. PM me if we don't know each other and you're looking for work.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4751202].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author ExquisiteMedia
        Originally Posted by Daniel Scott View Post

        I completely disagree.

        Sure, there's some crossover... especially if you do marketing consulting and advise on positioning, strength of the offer etc.

        But killer marketers know how to get the right people in front of an offer... and how to get a lot of them.

        As a copywriter... that's not really my area of expertise. I might be able to give some advice... but if a client asks me how to get their page to the top of Google, I really don't have much more than a vague understanding.

        My job is to make sure anyone who sees the page I put together will buy. And that includes consulting on the design, offer, and position taken in the letter.

        But it's the marketer's job to get people in front of the offer in the first place.

        -Daniel
        At the same time it takes words to bring them to the product. This is where the words paint the portrait that triggers them to come and find out more.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4753734].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Cam Connor
    Originally Posted by tayuyaa View Post

    What are your thoughts on this? I mean if you are a great copywriter and can good write copy's does this make you instantly a great marketer?

    Not instantly, but your well on your way... When it comes to Internet Marketing, there are two basic components. You have traffic generation, and conversion. Conversion, is 100% about Copywriting, whereas traffic-generation, is maybe about 50-80% about Copywriting.

    SO obviously, as far as conversion goes, there's really not much left to say, Copywriting is Conversion, Conversion is Copywriting...

    However, when it comes to traffic-generation, you have different ways to generate traffic. Obviously, there's things like SEO, and PPV, where copywriting takes NO real role in how much traffic is generated, and at what cost. SEO, because it's based on keywords on the page, and a given Search Engine's algorithm, and PPV, because your paying for views that go directly to your page (ad copy is not involved).

    On the other hand, on MOST types of traffic generation (Search/Content network PPC, Ad Networks, Media Buys, etc... Basically any time there's some sort of ad involved, whether it be a text ad or a banner ad, your ad copy is the most important thing, here's why:

    Your ad copy determines your CTR, and of course, your CTR, determines, 1) How many impressions you get (if your paying on a CPC basis, not a CPM), 2) How many clicks you get, and 3) How much you pay per click (regardless of whether your actually doing CPM or CPC).

    This is because your always rewarded with more clicks, and at a lower cost if you have a higher CTR, more than your rewarded for anything else by far...

    So, in closing, I would say that Copywriting is (IMO) roughly about 75% of the battle...
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4718556].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Andrew Gould
      Originally Posted by Cam Connor View Post

      Conversion, is 100% about Copywriting
      In direct response it's commonly thought that conversion is 40% the offer, 40% the list (traffic in internet terms), and only 20% the copy.

      In other words, make sure you've got a great offer and a hungry crowd to send it to before you start worrying about the exact wording of your ad.
      Signature

      Andrew Gould

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4718754].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Cam Connor
        Originally Posted by Andrew Gould View Post

        In direct response it's commonly thought that conversion is 40% the offer, 40% the list (traffic in internet terms), and only 20% the copy.

        In other words, make sure you've got a great offer and a hungry crowd to send it to before you start worrying about the exact wording of your ad.
        I've never heard of it broken down like that, but really, the "Marketing" part isn't the offer itself, but the way it's being advertised... And it's all about the Copywriting when it comes to whether or not that offer is well-received... With terrible copy, try giving out gold bars for $1 apiece.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4719470].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Hugh Thyer
          They cross a lot of common ground.

          Copywriting is writing the words that SELL.

          Marketing is about the systems that SELL. How you put together your offer, get your message out there, databases etc etc.

          I know many marketers who outsource the copy. And a few copywriters who are lousy marketers.

          But knowing one means at least a good knowledge of the other.
          Signature

          Ever wondered how copywriters work with their clients? I've answered that very question in detail-> www.salescomefirst.com
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4719511].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Andrew Gould
          Originally Posted by Cam Connor View Post

          With terrible copy, try giving out gold bars for $1 apiece.
          Wouldn't be a problem.

          Have a look at this recent thread for a bit more on the offer trumping the copy:

          http://www.warriorforum.com/copywrit...pywriting.html
          Signature

          Andrew Gould

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4725141].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author mrdomains
            I may get burned for this but this is how I see it


            Copy is communication and influence. Good (as in effective) copy is all about psychology and emotion.

            While one might first think marketing is the distribution of concept.. it is a much bigger cookie. Essentially everything a entity projects or does has a marketing effect. Customer support, graphics, innovation, warranties, price, visibility, etc.

            This is of course all in relation to the targeted market. If you sell plastic spoons your marketing will be vastly different from Lexus.

            Copy is a marketing tool. As is branding (although marketing and branding influence each other).
            Signature

            Free action plan : Think less. Do more.

            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4728150].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author ewenmack
              Here's a real case study to illustrate the difference
              and dramatic results from copywriting and marketing.

              Two copywriters of equal ability ran same size ads for fake diamonds
              in the same newspaper approximateley the same time.

              One copywriter's ad made a slight profit,
              while the other was a slight loss.

              The copywriter who made a slight profit
              folded the business because he decided it wasn't worth it.

              The copywriter who made a slight loss
              figured out how to sell more to the buyers.

              He ended up making millions because he had a markerter's mind.

              Story, courtesy of Jay Abraham.

              Best,
              Ewen
              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4728383].message }}
              • Profile picture of the author Raydal
                I think that marketers actually make copywriters look good
                because if you can find a great marketer to write for then
                you have a very powerful testimonial to the effectiveness of
                your writing.

                For example, I have a couple clients who when they first came
                to me to write copy for their products they could hardly afford
                my fees.

                In fact, if the letter had failed they would have been
                in financial trouble. Now those clients are multi-millionaires
                and I could claim that I've created net-millionaires.

                Truth be told, if they had done nothing with the sales letter
                and advice I gave them the results could have been the
                opposite. No use having a sharp tool if it's locked away
                in a box.

                So the bottom line is that as effective as I want to believe
                my salescopy was, I was lucky to get these clients who
                worked hard to bring targeted traffic to the pages
                so I could claim, "My letter did XX% conversion!"

                Effective copy not only involves great marketing but
                needs great marketing in order to work.

                -Ray Edwards
                Signature
                The most powerful and concentrated copywriting training online today bar none! Autoresponder Writing Email SECRETS
                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4731030].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author tayuyaa
    Thank you guys this remind me one sentence that many successful online marketers use to employ:

    "Making money online just requires two skills, the ability to get traffic, and the ability to turn this traffic into money" so as you Cam said, "traffic and conversion" or "Copywriting and Marketing"

    They are different, but linked together...the yin and the yang...

    Thanks guys I'm gonna sleep better now since I know where to focus!

    Best regards.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4718619].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author thetrafficguy
    You'll never find an agreement here as everyone has a different interpretation.

    In my opinion a copywriter should be a great marketer to be the best copywriter they can be. But no, not the same. And driving traffic is def not synonymous with copywriting (although you can argue writing ads is involved).
    Signature
    "SUPER AFFILIATE EXPOSES Highly Profitable Traffic Source!"

    "Use This Trick To Make An Extra $50 - $500 Per DAY!"
    Click Here To Check It Out Before The Price Jumps Up AGAIN!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4719640].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Will Roarke
    Copywriting is important.
    Marketing is important.

    If you're a great copywriter you MIGHT be a great marketer but maybe not.
    If you're a great marketer you MIGHT be a great copywriter but maybe not.

    Someone could be a great writer but have absolutely know idea how to create and run a marketing campaign.
    Lots of great marketers haven't a clue about copywriting. That's why, if they're good at what they do, they know how to leverage their talents in order to get a great copywriter on their team.

    In my experience.

    Regards,
    Will Roarke
    Signature
    - Are You in the Dating/Seduction Niche? -
    Imagine yourself earning up to $1000 from a single customer while we take care of all the hard work.
    You can take advantage of this high converting sales funnel that is designed and tested to maximize and protect your profits. Click here for more information ...

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4719709].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author John_S
    You'll find a lot of complaints about poor offers, poor products, and so on. That's the job of marketing.

    Marketing is the arena copywriters work in. Marketing starts before copy is written, insures a copywriter has something to write about, and continues on past this sale to the upsell, the cross sell, and the lifetime value of the customer and refferals.

    Marketing will say "no" to the product features a sales person or copywriter might ask for. This would be done to insure the long term lifetime value of the customer trumps the immediate sale -- at any cost.

    For example the feature which would turn the product or service into a commodity and slash profits. Marketing might look for to zig when all your competitors zag. And that's how you get a Unique Selling Proposition, later.

    Copywriters, by and large, are like sales people. They'll try to get the sale, even if they lose the customer. Marketing shows its value by always concentrating on the next sale, not just this one. Profits, not merely volume. Refferals and word-of-mouth, not returns and refunds.

    Marketing has degenerated of late. It's where people who don't like to sell go. That's wrong.

    Marketing turbocharges copywriting. Marketing is about knowing the customer, the competition, and the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats to the company and its products or services. Copy without marketing devolves into gimmicks and tricks, techniques without customer insights.

    In addition to copy a marketer would have a say in design, merchandising, pricing, and product development. The stuff out of which a superior offer is developed.

    A marketing driven company would put the marketer in charge of how the invoices look and how the phones are answered.

    That is a pure case. A good copywriter should understand their market. A good marketer should be able to make the sale in copy.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4720406].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Raydal
    Below is a copy of the message I sent out to my subscribers:

    I received a query for a sales letter rewrite from a well-respected online
    marketer. He is having poor conversion from his website. I took a
    quick glance at the website and saw right away why the sales were
    doing poorly.
    And it wasn't:
    • the salescopy -- that was fairly good
    • the product -- it's in demand
    • the layout - I would change the background color but it's fairly clean
    • the product owners - they have been in business for many years with a lot of great products
    So what was the HUGE problem as I saw it?
    It was a POOR SALES STRATEGY.


    A few of my coaching members asked me if they should learn internet

    marketing and my answer was a BIG YES!!


    There is no such thing as a pure copywriter. I mean, someone who
    just writes great copy and sell products. In the final analysis,
    great copywriters are really great SALES PEOPLE!
    I've often heard many people comment that the late great Gary
    Halbert wasn't that great at writing copy but he knew how to
    SELL.
    I have a huge respect for Gary, but I must agree. Gary was a
    great salesman. Mind you, his copy was great but not "out of
    this world" better than any other copywriter out there.
    I've read many of his letters and he himself would tell you that
    it's selling strategies that really made him the sought-after
    copywriter he was.
    The point of all this is that if you intend to write great copy,
    along with learning how to write you must LEARN HOW TO SELL. Read
    books on selling.


    You can write GREAT COPY and still stink in your sales because
    your marketing strategy or selling technique was poor.
    I know a couple mediocre copywriters who are masters at selling
    and they do very well for themselves online. They would sell you
    the shirt on your back-not through words but through STRATEGY.
    So the bottom line is that if you want to be a better copywriter
    you must also learn how to sell.

    Examples:


    1. "Take the puppy home for the weekend and if you don't like
    him you can return it on Monday" -that's selling! Who will
    return a puppy?


    2. If you are selling software give away a FREE TRIAL that last
    for 30 days. Once the use learns how to use the software and get
    accustomed to using it they would have literally sold
    themselves!


    You don't need a lot of words to sell software-just give it a
    away and ask them to 'return the puppy' on Monday.


    3. If you are selling an "unbelievably good" product -- use a
    TON LOAD of testimonials. Now you may say that every copywriter
    knows that but some products need MORE TESTIMONIALS than others.
    Do you know which ones?? -- then that's selling.


    4. Give away INFORMATION and sell the service. That's what
    copywriters and other service providers do. That's why you have
    to write articles, build a blog, give free critiques etc., these
    are all INFORMATION but when they need copy they will seek you
    out. That's selling.


    So while you improve your WRITING skills, learn how to market
    online as well. If you intend to write copy for your clients they
    would expect this from you.


    And you can charge more because you are a MARKETER, not just a
    copywriter.

    Makes sense?

    -Ray Edwards
    Signature
    The most powerful and concentrated copywriting training online today bar none! Autoresponder Writing Email SECRETS
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4724368].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author arfasaira
      Ray,

      A super post from you as always. Great points you cover. As a copywriter, you should be up to date with marketing methods - as Hugh mentioned it's the processes which help you to sell.

      I for one spend a LOT of time learning about marketing and am always hungry to learn more, because if you can't market, then NO ONE is even going to get the chance to read your carefully crafted words.

      I was asked the other day about how I manage to keep my diary full with projects months in advance, and the truth is that it takes work and commitment to market yourself and get your name out.

      Sure I'm a wordsmith and my words help sell people's products, but what use are my copywriting skills if my marketing sucks and I can't even sell myself?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4724833].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Real-TechGuy
    Marketing is built into a product - when done correctly.

    For instance, when I am creating a new product I start out with a survey of my target market.

    I use the survey responses to guide my product creation.

    Then as I build the product I take note of how each bit helps my market.

    I use all that to write my copy at the end when I'm ready to sell.

    Hope that makes sense.
    Signature
    Click HERE for Tons of FREE Internet Marketing Training
    55,515 Fans on Facebook
    63,414 Views on You Tube
    Find out How I did it & How You Can too HERE
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4731805].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ExquisiteMedia
    True writers know how to sell. They paint a portrait with their own words that entices people to make the conversion that's desired. Marketing is a part of writing just as writing is a part of marketing.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4736343].message }}
  • Copywriting is WHY to BUY it -

    Marketing is HOW to SELL it.

    (It's a symbiotic relationship - individual but interdependent.)






    (Of course that's just my opinion, I could be wrong.)
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4749580].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BartsTreasures
    Copywriting is one aspect of marketing...marketing is any activity undertaken to move a product from a seller's hands to a buyer's hands. Copywriting is meant to pursuade buyers to buy a product, so it is one activity in marketing. BUT getting people to SEE the copy is also marketing...one needs both. Lots of traffic to poor copy is not highly profitable nor is great copy that no one sees.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4753771].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author ExquisiteMedia
      Originally Posted by BartsTreasures View Post

      Copywriting is one aspect of marketing...marketing is any activity undertaken to move a product from a seller's hands to a buyer's hands. Copywriting is meant to pursuade buyers to buy a product, so it is one activity in marketing. BUT getting people to SEE the copy is also marketing...one needs both. Lots of traffic to poor copy is not highly profitable nor is great copy that no one sees.
      Yes, it's a pretty vicious circle. You can't remove writing or marketing from it and truly succeed.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[4753906].message }}

Trending Topics