I have been approached to sell one of my sites and wondering if you can give me some feedback on what you think it is worth. The site is the classified site FreeAdvertisingExchange.om
Site age: 12 years
Current members: Nearly 248,000 members.
New members: Averages about 60 new sign-ups every day on autopilot.
Organic Rankings: Ranks on the first page of Google and Bing for over a decade without being dislodged for a lot of high traffic competitive keywords. Some of these include: Free Advertising (2), Free Advertising Sites (4), Advertise Anything for Free (2), and many others. I also do zero work to maintain any of these rankings.
Traffic: About 600 unique visitors a day.
Revenue: Makes nearly $4000 a month, mainly through email marketing as the database is so large, even though I only mail to about half the list. The site also makes money through AdSense and other banner ads.
I think it might be the right time to sell because I put minimal work into the site as I am onto other things. I think someone could do a lot better.
The offer I received I believe to be pretty low, so help from experienced warriors in this field would be most appreciated.