Magic Article Submitter reviews anyone?

13 years ago

I have MAS and I really like it.

You have to use a Gmail account with it.

There are over 1,000 directories; however, some of those aren't valid. I usually get around 800 accounts created on directories.

There are a couple of the bigger article directories on the list, but I usually hand submit to the top 10 and then push the article out through MAS.
Theoretically, you could publish an article to every directory you created an account on through MAS.

However, as the articles are submitted to a specific category, it would be very unlikely to have an article that fit a category on every single directory. Some of the directories on the list are topical too, so only articles in that particular topic would be posted. Most of the articles I'm promoting are specific niches. The widest distribution I've gotten so far is a little over 400 submissions.

It currently has the option to track the publishing status of the articles, which is great. I asked if the link to the published article could be listed in MAS as well so it would be easier to promote it rather than having to track it down on the site. The developer said he would add that to a future release.

[ 4 ] Thanks

Signature

"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools, because they have to say something."
~ Plato

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1708127].message }}

Bruce4573

13 years ago

Hi I have the mas and the rewriter and they work great but I think if you submit your articles slow as possible and submit more articles it works best. Then when you rewrite the articles just take your time and make sure you read them to check the flow and keep up the quality of the articles. Trust me it pays I have an article on google page one now second spot. I am finding more all the time in good position or a climbing the rank. It's a one time payment and that is good also. It does create the accounts I have it submitting up to seven or eight hundred sites at times. It also gets better as you use it. How it works is you submitt a keyword and it pulls up the relevant blogs and you can choose to accept or decline. It also lets you use a few keywords and just ads the relevant blogs. It does not always come up with three or four hundred blogs to submit to but it try's to stay relevant. I think that is more important anyway.

[ 3 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1708325].message }}

FredJones 13 years ago

Pressed the Thanks button to both the early repliers. Thanks a lot.

So it appears that it is a good software, and the one-time payment makes it more worth it. Great.

I'm convinced and I shall make a purchase later this week or early next week. If I am impressed, I shall let know (or anyone reading this thread can PM me after at least a couple of weeks from today, since buying, using and seeing results can not be quicker than that I suppose).
- Thanks
- 1 reply
Signature
Put ANY Product Immediately In Front Of Red Hot Buyers, At Zero-Cost
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1708709].message }}
- FredJones 13 years ago
  
  Came back here to log my feedback - initial one at least.
  
  So far, I have purchased Magic Article Rewriter+Submitter yesterday.
  
  First, I tried MAR. I started offwith an article that I had written earlier. I spinned the words to start with but anything unique was hard to get. Then I restarted with the same article. This time I started by spinning the sentences. Then within the sentences I spinned the words. This second attempt (after the restart) took me 50 minutes to reqrite a 600-word article to 105% unique. I generated 1000 articles, but could not manually check too many of them. From what I saw, the uniqueness of the articles was good.
  
  So, MAR is a product that I believe is worth going for. It also let me add my own words to the dictionary. That helped.
  
  Now the MAS. After I completed the article rewrite, I started my MAS. I used a GMail ID and clicked on the registration button. In the first attempt, in around 30 minutes, it tried to register on 1205 directories. It succeeded for 597 and failed for the rest 608 - which was a more than 50% failure of registration. Then while auto-confirming the email IDs, it hanged after confirming a little less than 500 emails (around 74 emails remained unconfirmed and some other article directories did not send confirmation emails - I don't know whether that is by design or whether the MAS registration actually failed in spite of being successful). I went off to bed last night, somewhat disappointed with the MAS although happy with MAR.
  
  Then today morning I woke up and thought that MAS might let me resubmit the same registration. I tried and yes, I was right. So I started registering the same GMail account once more. MAS remembered the ones that had failed and tried to create the profiles only on those directories. So after the second iteration is succeeded on some more and it stood at 754 successes out of 1205 directories. I tried a third iteration, and that paid a little more. This number climbed up to 786 successes.
  
  That is where I stand right now. I am yet to submit an article. I hope to come back here to leave more feedback after maybe a few more iterations trying to register more directories and then submitting at least one article.
  
  Thanks
  
  1 reply
  
  Signature
  Put ANY Product Immediately In Front Of Red Hot Buyers, At Zero-Cost
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1752839].message }}
  
  FredJones 13 years ago
  
  To cotinue after I posted yesterday, I tried on and on to get more registrations simply by repeating the process. The number of activations went up to 835 after at least 10 efforts, and it refused to go up beyond that.
  
  Then came the activation. It activated 737 out of the 835 directories. In many cases of the 98 that it did not activate, the confirmation link email never arrived. In many other cases, it did not manage to "click the link", so the account did not get activated.
  
  Now I went to the emails that had arrived but the system could not auto-activate. I manually clicked the confirmation links and let the system run. The system (MAS) could pick up the fact that the links had been confirmed and acknowledged that by increasing its success count. Finally, I could scale up to 783 out of 835.
  
  Then I went back and ran the registration process once more. I was surprised to see that rather than 835, it actually took off from 783 (the number of confirmed links) - which meant that the registration system had become aware that not directories all coud be confirmed. This time the registration went up to 842. I came forward once more to confirm links and finally I ended up with 793 out of the 1205 directories advertised.
  
  Now the submission. I used the article that I had written yesterday (check my previous post in this thread), and submitted it to all 793 in one shot. Surprisingly, when I clicked the button, the number went down to 791 confirmed (don't know where the 2 others vanished).
  
  The category selection that I attempted to post spanned across almost all the 791 directories (I guess the number will be in 770-s). I got 100 successful submissions, skipped 2 and 689 submissions were errors of different kinds.
  
  So, that is my experience with MAR+MAS so far.
  
  My rating at the moment: MAR: excellent, MAS: nothing outstanding - can not compare with other automatic submitters due to my lack of experience with automatic submission tools so cannot comment on "relative quality with respect to other such tools" but the "absolute quality in terms of submissions" is ordinary.
  
  [ 5 ] Thanks
  
  Signature
  Put ANY Product Immediately In Front Of Red Hot Buyers, At Zero-Cost
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1757285].message }}

fairyx

13 years ago

Originally Posted by FredJones

I am evaluating Magic Article Submitter for purchase. I do know it comes with a rewritter also at a bit of an extra cost and the rewritter has good reviews. But I wanted to make sure that the submitter is as good as it claims to.

So I would appreciate to hear from anyone who has (recently) used Magic Article Submitter.

1. Does it create accounts only with GMail ID or with any ID (say, yahoo.com or yourcompany.com)?
2. How many accounts does it creat?
3. Does it submit to some/many of the top-notch article submission directories too, such as EZA, GoArticles, Amazine and so on? Or are most of the submissions not up to the mark?
4. How many submissions can it do at most?
5. Are the submissions niche-specific or general? I mean, EZA is something that I would call general although of course you can select niches inside it, but if it would post to ImaginaryGolfDirectory.Commm then I would believe it would post only golf articles. So what I am asking here is that can someone give me a number that "out of X number of directories they claim to submit to, Y directories are general ones like EZA and a total of Z directories are niche-specific, spread across different niches"?

Thanks dear Warriors.

-- Fred

Both software programs are reliable and the owner keeps sending you free updates. They are functional and User-friendly. I have been using both of them for about a year now. Many of my keywords got ranked for my other websites. I write articles on daily basis and MAR does great. However if you want to add your own article directory to the list, it should be created by articledashboard directory otherwise you get error message.
I bought all sorts of article rewriter & submitter on the planet and they all are rubbish. Alex always replies to your message and goes an extra mile to help you if you have problem. This is rare in an online business.
I am not their affiliate or anything. I am only one of their happy customers from North Europe. Maybe I should become their affiliate too?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1851791].message }}

Sheryl Polomka

13 years ago

I am using the 5 day trial of both Magic article rewriter and submitter. I quite like the rewriter but can't say I'm all that impressed with the submitter so far. After letting the program run 4 or 5 times I finally got just over 600 accounts registered, but then when I went to the 'activate email' part I only have 160 activated after letting it run 4 or 5 times. A bit disappointing and I'm not sure that I'll pay for the program if I can't get more than 160 accounts activated.

Has anyone else had this trouble or am I just doing something wrong?

Thanks

Signature

~~ TOP PETZ ~~

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1855039].message }}

imintern

13 years ago

I have used the Magic Article Rewriter in the past. I don't know about the submitter but when it comes to rewriting I think The Best Spinner is equally good if not better (not because it's in my signature). This software is created by Jon Leger. May be you should take a trial and compare the two. The Best Spinner really has some cool features.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1855109].message }}

sentient

13 years ago

This should probably be in the review section, but anyway....

I quite like the sign up process, seems to have gone quite smoothly for me, probably with about 75% success sign up rate.

The software itself is very easy to use, and nicely laid out.

The most important part, however, the submissions, are not so good.

Despite submitting different articles in different niches, a good 70% are still awaiting review by the article directory, several weeks (in some cases months) after submitting. There is little point signing up and submitting to hundreds of directories if the majority don't ever review and publish submissions. And this is after a recent update of the directories that it submits to.

So overall - despite being impressed by the software, no real use to me, because the articles don't get reviewed or published.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2017947].message }}

magentawave 13 years ago

My experience with MAS is that you'll probably get about 800 article directories activated even though it says there are a lot more. To get maximum activation, and if you're using a domain email address, then make sure the spam filter at your host is turned "off" (better to have all your email forwarded to a gmail account anyway and let gmail filter the junk).

Some of those directories will approve your articles immediately and some approvals will trickle in months later.

Steve
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2111135].message }}

raul_s

13 years ago

[DELETED]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2037091].message }}

Global Citizen

13 years ago

Hi Steve,

have you seen the stats yet? Disapproved, pending and approved?

Some of my articles are not even approved after 6 months of submitting.

Here's my stats:

50% articles approved.
40% pending.
10% disapproved.

articles start to get approved after more than two weeks. Most of them after three months.

Not very satisfying. However, the good thing is that perhaps in the long run it can help tremendously.

And yes, the biggest problem is that it hangs and occupies your operating system. Not allowing you to have the best efficiency when you are doing your work.

Server-based submitting system is still the best for me...

Thanks

Signature

Nothing is Faster Than the Speed of Trust

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2559550].message }}

OrganicSeoGuru

13 years ago

Buy and learn how to use The Best Spinner, You Will Never Look Back

Thanks

Signature

Seo Services and Search Engine Optimization Services

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2588816].message }}

cma01

13 years ago

Yesterday I submitted an article with MAS, fine-tuned the categories and it submitted to 380 directories.

A few hours later, I tried to submit a new article . . . same categories . . . and only 28 were submitted.

Has this happened to anyone else? Do you have any idea why practically nothing was submitted for the second?

I had a couple of other programs running during the second run, so I stopped those, restarted MAS, and tried to submit again, but it is still the same thing.

Thanks

Signature

"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools, because they have to say something."
~ Plato

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2628664].message }}

Alexww

13 years ago

I use magic article submitter, and I am having quite good results.
I have over 750 activated accounts, great thing is over 300 directories approve articles automatically...

And with my method of getting submitted articles indexed, the results are awesome

My main category is Software, Internet, Computer and I never had any problem with submission.

Thanks

Signature

In-Depth Product Reviews
#1 Automatic Article Article Submitter!
Article Submitter

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2631077].message }}

Global Citizen

13 years ago

If only MAS is webserver based and submits articles at a super lightning speed.

Those who have tried MAS may want to give article marketing robot a go. A superior product, well at least that's what they say...

Thanks

Signature

Nothing is Faster Than the Speed of Trust

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2631162].message }}

PoolWarrior

13 years ago

I had bad experience with Magic Article Submitter , especially when you submit more than 100 articles .. so i will not recommend it

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2631235].message }}

scrapgirl42 13 years ago

Originally Posted by PoolWarrior

I had bad experience with Magic Article Submitter , especially when you submit more than 100 articles .. so i will not recommend it

What happened?

I have been using MAS for about six months and I am happy with it.
- Thanks
- 1 reply
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2634192].message }}
- dafiz 13 years ago
  
  My preference is for web based solutions for submissions, and favour solutions that accept Spyntax articles alot more heavily.
  
  I also am a big fan of TheBestSpinner for spinning, nothing else comes close IMHO.
  
  Thanks
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2634376].message }}

cma01

13 years ago

I found what the issues was, although I'm not sure why it was a problem.

When I created the article that only submitted to 28 directories, I had pasted a category list that I had saved from another article on the same topic.

I've done this in the past and it has worked. It didn't this time.

When I went back and used the search function to populate the category field and resubmitted it, it submitted to 300+ directories.

Thanks

Signature

"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools, because they have to say something."
~ Plato

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2643279].message }}

Magic Article Submitter reviews anyone?

Trending Topics

A photography Website SEO with 100s of images

Summer vacation for anyone ??

YouTube SEO and Views

How to improve my SEO

For those who own two sites or more: Do you have an LLC for Each?