"The Judge Movie" with Duval and Downey Jr - I owned that .com A Lesson and story!

6 replies
Ok, so 4 years ago I registered thejudgemovie.com I don't remember exactly why. There was no book or anything or if there was, I didn't know it. Certainly no movie in the making that I knew of. I think I read in the paper there was this mobster who was called "the judge". So knowing how hollywood loves gangsters, I paid the $10. 2 years ago I get an email from someone interested in it. Private type of email. Certainly not "This is Robert Walton from Warner Brothers". First name kinda thing. Very casual. I was not experienced at selling domains then, so I probably said "for the right price" or something like that. Didn't know what was up and was guarded giving a price. Oddly, the domain was due to expire in 3 months, so I at least knew to renew it for another yr.

I then later listed it for $1500 thinking maybe something was up. I get an email again a yr later from the same guy offering $1000. I took it via SEDO so I didn't have contact with the guy really. 6 months or so later I see it was registered to Warner brothers, a few months later (now!), a movie with Robert Duvall and Robert Downey Jr called the The Judge is out with those 2 actors on my little $10 domain.

$10 into $1000 is a return we'd all love all day and I try not to speculate what could have or could not have regarding $$$, but I learned something from it. Either these studios do this privately so you don't soak them for big bucks or this guy just heard something was up. I don't know. The time gap between emails was strange though. I'm not big into domain speculation but sometimes I get a hunch. Just figured I share this, since it's topical as the movie is out now and if anyone ever encounters something like that in the future, maybe this will help you with some diligence. Some private little yahoo email inquiry may not be what it seems....

Nick
#downey #duval #lesson #owned #story #the judge movie
  • Profile picture of the author onSubie
    I read a very similar story in another forum about socialgraph.com.

    A guy had registered it for unknown reasons and was contacted by a couple who wanted it for their business. He sold it to a woman for $1,300 who said she wanted it for a personal blog.

    A few weeks later he saw Mark Zuckerberg talking at the Web 2.0 Summit about the "Social Graph".

    He quickly checked his recently sold domain and all the admin contacts were ... @facebook.com

    I am a college student who is looking to start a simple… | Domainerss

    Found it - this is a link to an archive of the original post.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9667287].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Nick SEO
    Wow. Yeah it happens. What was most strange is my guy was not pushing me. It a was a touch in here and there. You'd think if it was WB, they'd make sure they got it from me. Like I said, I don't speculate or squat names and never in trademark territory. It's a noun. This was just a shot in the dark and the movie isn't even about why I registered the name lol
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9667295].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Steve B
    Squatting on domains for future profit rarely produces much. The domainers I know that are making money are mostly of two camps:
    1. High rollers that scout and research for great short money domains that they buy for thousands, hold for a time, then find the right buyer and sell for greater thousands.
    2. Guys who have great systems in place to take any domain that they want to register, add a site to it (develop it), then find a willing buyer that they sell it to for a nice profit (anywhere from hundreds to thousands). Often these domain systems focus on selling the web sites to local businesses.
    Even though hindsight is 20/20, and you might think you could have made a huge profit on your domain, if you haven't developed it out and created a valuable asset, the chances are pretty good you would have been forced to give up the domain name even though you may have purchased it before the movie was even anticipated or announced.

    Steve
    Signature

    Steve Browne, online business strategies, tips, guidance, and resources
    SteveBrowneDirect

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9667296].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Nick SEO
      Originally Posted by Steve B View Post

      Even though hindsight is 20/20, and you might think you could have made a huge profit on your domain, if you haven't developed it out and created a valuable asset, the chances are pretty good you would have been forced to give up the domain name even though you may have purchased it before the movie was even anticipated or announced.

      Steve
      Steve, I don't think in my case I would have been forced to give it up at all. "the judge" would be like "the tree" or "the chef" or any noun with no prior TM or project and how would they know I didn't want to make a movie myself out of it? I agree it's not usually worth it. In my case, it was a $10 quick pick bet with the same odds of winning I mainly posted this to let others know should they have a similar situation.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9671114].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Jason Jacoby
        I've actually bought and sold a couple of domains myself for a decent profit...one for $1500 and another for $530.

        But the one that got away was AmericanIdol.com. I only ever watched the first season of Idol, but I remember at the time they kept telling people, "go to IdolonFox.com". I was thinking to myself, "Why would they tell people to go to IdolonFox.com when the show is named American Idol?"

        So I went online and searched for AmericanIdol.com, and low and behold, there it was...available. I don't know if someone else had let it expire, or if I was the first person to actually ever try to buy it, but it was available. But I was extremely new to IM and naive in my reasoning thinking, "If they keep telling people to go to IdolonFox.com, then no one is going to go to AmericanIdol.com". So I passed on it and didn't buy it. Oh well, lesson learned.

        It's nice to think looking back now that I could have made a fortune for it, but in reality, back then I probably would have sold it to the first person that offered me $1000. That's why you can't live in regret...just learn from the past and move forward.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9671152].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author rodelu
    I believe you did the right thing, with the information you had at the time. Had you known what it would be used for, obviously you would have sold it for more.

    But when you put it in perspective, it was a nice profit. If only you could do it more often
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9668064].message }}

Trending Topics