Is it possible/ethical to bypass a merchant's sales-page?

7 replies
I've seen demonstrations of people doing this by inserting their affiliate id in to the URL at the clickbank checkout page. For instance...

So I was wondering if this was still possible... But also, if there is any risk in doing so?
Like for instance somehow I wouldn't get the commission for whatever reason?

Thanks
#bypass #merchant #possible or ethical #salespage
  • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
    Banned
    Originally Posted by Conchairtoe View Post

    I was wondering if this was still possible
    Yes, it is. You need the vendor's permission, though, per ClickBank's rules.

    You can write your own sales page, that way, but the vendor may well want to see it, to check what you're saying.

    Originally Posted by Conchairtoe View Post

    But also, if there is any risk in doing so?
    Like for instance somehow I wouldn't get the commission for whatever reason?
    Yes, there are risks.

    You'll often get your commission if the customer buys immediately, having clicked on your link. But the normal hoplink takes priority over this link, so you won't get paid if that customer has previously used another affiliate's hoplink and has that cookie on his computer (can easily happen, it seems to me?). And you won't be setting a cookie, yourself, if you do it legally, so you also won't be paid if the customer later returns to the site without using that link (as some people do - not so many people buy ClickBank products at their first visit to the sales page).

    I don't and wouldn't do this, myself, but I know people who do (for various reasons, and successfully).


    .
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9860178].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Conchairtoe
      Originally Posted by Alexa Smith View Post

      Yes, it is. You need the vendor's permission, though, per ClickBank's rules.

      You can write your own sales page, that way, but the vendor may well want to see it, to check what you're saying.



      Yes, there are risks.

      You'll often get your commission if the customer buys immediately, having clicked on your link. But the normal hoplink takes priority over this link, so you won't get paid if that customer has previously used another affiliate's hoplink and has that cookie on his computer (can easily happen, it seems to me?). And you won't be setting a cookie, yourself, if you do it legally, so you also won't be paid if the customer later returns to the site without using that link (as some people do - not so many people buy ClickBank products at their first visit to the sales page).

      I don't and wouldn't do this, myself, but I know people who do (for various reasons, and successfully).


      .
      Does ClickBank allow cookie stuffing if the merchant approves?

      I'm not trying to steal anything! I'm planning on making a video version of the sale-page and don't want people to see vendor's ridiculous flash video.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9860234].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
        Banned
        Originally Posted by Conchairtoe View Post

        Does ClickBank allow cookie stuffing if the merchant approves?
        I don't know, but I doubt it very much indeed. You'll need to ask them, and clarify exactly what you want to do, because different people understand different things from the term "cookie-stuffing".

        Originally Posted by Conchairtoe View Post

        I'm not trying to steal anything!
        No, I'm sure.

        Originally Posted by Conchairtoe View Post

        I'm planning on making a video version of the sale-page and don't want people to see vendor's ridiculous flash video.
        I understand. Wanting to replace the vendor's sales page with a page of your own is one of the entirely legitimate reasons for wanting to do this, of course (and very advisable, clearly if he has a ridiculous flash video - I'd also want to avoid that, for sure, but in my case by promoting another product instead!). But if you do it the proper way, it does carry those little risks I mentioned above.

        I'm always pretty nervous when Steve Browne and I give different answers to something. That clearly raises the possibility that I've given a bad answer. So I really do think "asking ClickBank" (if they don't post in the thread) is a good course for you.


        .
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9860244].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Steve B
    Is it possible/ethical to bypass a merchant's sales-page?


    Yes, it's possible. IMO, no it's not ethical. It's called stealing someone's commission.Would you like others to bypass your sales page if you were the merchant?

    Steve
    Signature

    Steve Browne, online business strategies, tips, guidance, and resources
    SteveBrowneDirect

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9860182].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author dmarc
      Originally Posted by Steve B View Post

      Is it possible/ethical to bypass a merchant's sales-page?


      Yes, it's possible. IMO, no it's not ethical. It's called stealing someone's commission.Would you like others to bypass your sales page if you were the merchant?

      Steve


      Doesn't seem like stealing to me. He's still selling the merchant's product, the merchant is still getting paid, he's still getting the same commission. He's just using a different sales page.


      Run it by the vendor. As long as your sales page doesn't misrepresent their product, I don't see why it would be a problem.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9860259].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author myob
      Originally Posted by Steve B View Post

      Is it possible/ethical to bypass a merchant's sales-page?


      Yes, it's possible. IMO, no it's not ethical. It's called stealing someone's commission.Would you like others to bypass your sales page if you were the merchant?

      Steve
      By-passing vendor sales pages actually has become an acceptable and welcome alternative for many product owners who are marketing-challenged. Using this method (with the explicit consent of the vendor) can set you above other affiliates competing for buyers who often have already seen the same old tired or hokey ad copy hundreds of times. Incentivizing buyers with a bonus to clear cookies prior to purchase is a common practice in this scenario.

      Consider also using the JV contract feature that Clickbank offers. If the vendor adopts your custom sales page, you may potentially have an additional income stream on a mutually agreed percentage for all future sales. Note there are a wide variety of ways besides direct affiliate marketing that allow for many other types of income-producing relationships to be supported with the ClickBank platform.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9860475].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author ClickBank
        Hi All,

        There are a number of questions in this thread and I will do my best to address each of them. Let me know if you have any follow-up questions afterwards.

        The Technical Implementation

        Our platform does accept a paylink where the affiliate attribution is set as part of the URL. For example, if the affiliate nickname is WARRIORXYZ and the desired outcome is to have that affiliate nickname earn the commission when product T123Z is sold by vendor SUPERSALE, then use the following formatted URL:

        http://t123z.warriorxyz_supersale.pay.clickbank.net

        That is the technical implementation for this type of paylink.

        Attribution Priority

        It is important that you understand a few caveats related to this feature. First, the underscore affiliate attribution model (which is what we refer this as here at ClickBank) is lower in priority for affiliate attribution then other methods; the cookie detection system and supplemental fingerprinting systems both take priority. If there is no match in those systems, then the affiliate attribution will belong to the affiliate nickname set on this paylink.

        Second, this attribution only holds for the first purchase. Subsequent sales will not include any affiliate attribution.

        Reasons Why You Would Use This

        The pros of using such a model are that the vendor can work with partner affiliates to enable a model where the affiliate is driving sales direct to the order form for a given product. This partnership is likely better served using JV Contracts, as mentioned by myob above. It is also possible for a vendor to provide lifetime commissions, albeit at some risk of other methods taking priority, for subsequent sales to the same consumer long beyond the 60 day attribution methods.

        The Downside To This Method

        The cons of using this method should be weighed heavily, however. When an affiliate chooses to use this model to bypass the vendor's pitch page, they are running a very high risk that they are promoting a product SKU that the vendor may no longer support or sell. Often, vendors are testing different combinations of SKUs to see what converts best and at which price points. You may have elected to promote the wrong price point to maximize conversion.

        Next, you are likely loosing out on the ability to enter the consumer into an upsell funnel. Without visibility into the way the vendor has configured their PitchPlus OTO sales, you cannot know how best to push that consumer through the upsell funnel and even if you did, you would miss out on any affiliate commissions that you may have otherwise earned had you used the ClickBank hop system.

        Also, your ability to leverage the vendor's custom order form skin is minimized. Many vendors will test different layouts and styling for their custom order form (and even more so with the advanced CSS controlled order forms we released last year) so your conversions will not be as high, costing you more money.

        Requirements For Affiliates Who Use This Method

        When you create a custom lander, you must be absolutely certain that you are complying with both ClickBank terms and conditions and the vendor's affiliate terms. Certain promotional methods can result in a suspended account or getting blacklisted by the vendor from promoting their service offering. See our client contract for more guidance on this point.

        How The Cash Flows

        Early in the posts, SteveB mentioned stealing commissions. This method does not impact the revenue earned by the vendor; they continue to earn all sale value less affiliate commission when a customer buys the product from this type of paylink.

        Cookie Stuffing

        It is against our policies for any client to engage in manipulation or alteration of our referral tracking system by using techniques such as cookie stuffing. This is considered fraud and has resulted in criminal litigation in the past with several high profile criminal cases involving the FBI, other retailers and affiliate marketers. See section 3.d of the client contract linked above regarding this. In short, avoid these techniques. I posted a similar statement on a related thread here.

        Final Recommendation

        Our best recommendation is to contact the vendor directly and offer to work with them to improve conversions as a team. Our system is ready-built for such partnerships with trusted revenue share models through our JV Contracts. Ultimately, if you're successful, you will create greater revenue streams and customer experiences for both of you.

        I hope this helped.
        The ClickBank Team
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9861643].message }}

Trending Topics