Craigslist - New $5 fee for posting to skilled trade services | Warrior Forum - The #1 Digital Marketing Forum & Marketplace

IGotMine

3 years ago

How are people handling this change?

I would guess by paying $5 or not posting.

[ 11 ] Thanks

Signature

Make Money! I Let You Test My System With NO Payment Info. Needed! Start Now!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329418].message }}

craigsposterpro

3 years ago

There is no way around it. There will obviously be people who shift their ads to sections which are still free. However, you should realize that one of the primary reasons for ad flagging is posting in non-relevant sections. You cannot use gift or pre-paid credit cards to post with their payment gateway. The good news is now that all the spammy posts will be weeded out, each of your paid ads will get a lot longer shelf life on page 1 and be more prominent meaning they should attract a lot more leads. Also, readers on Craigslist will place a lot more trust on companies who post paid ads perceiving them as more legitimate.

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329568].message }}

businesswarrior121

3 years ago

Originally Posted by craigsposterpro

There is no way around it. There will obviously be people who shift their ads to sections which are still free. However, you should realize that one of the primary reasons for ad flagging is posting in non-relevant sections. You cannot use gift or pre-paid credit cards to post with their payment gateway. The good news is now that all the spammy posts will be weeded out, each of your paid ads will get a lot longer shelf life on page 1 and be more prominent meaning they should attract a lot more leads. Also, readers on Craigslist will place a lot more trust on companies who post paid ads perceiving them as more legitimate.

Paid service can always be trusted. But how much expect from posting paid ads for a long time? Suppose one person need to post 20 ads per day. Then 20*5=100 Per day. 100*30=3000$ per month.

Isn't it too much costly for small business? When you have very small business then you will always look forward have some free ads section always. Spamming is the most reason for Craiglist tfor taking this decision. But in the meantime it brought bad news for small business entrepreneur.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Read Ultimate CPA Evulation
How I Make $5,000 Per Day from CPA Traning

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11377436].message }}

craigsposterpro

3 years ago

Originally Posted by businesswarrior121

Paid service can always be trusted. But how much expect from posting paid ads for a long time? Suppose one person need to post 20 ads per day. Then 20*5=100 Per day. 100*30=3000$ per month.

Isn't it too much costly for small business? When you have very small business then you will always look forward have some free ads section always. Spamming is the most reason for Craiglist for taking this decision. But in the meantime it brought bad news for small business entrepreneur.

Actually, you wouldn't need to post 20 daily ads any more since the paid Services section has seen a 70 - 80% drop in overall daily section post volume. Our clients are seeing a definite increase in call/lead volume per ad now. So, in the end, you may end up getting a better return without the need to constantly spam the site.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11377553].message }}

Thomas Barton 3 years ago

The main issues is if you type in craigslist.com and type in graphic design in the search engine it will go to "For Sale" half the time. I feel like I'm being screwed over since other people post in spam areas but when I do mine get deletes quickly. As soon as I find a better solution I'm leaving craigslist for good. I've wasted to much money with craigslist.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11426070].message }}

Regional Warrior

3 years ago

Originally Posted by Menachem Pritzker

Craigslist (as of yesterday), started charging $5 per post in skilled trades.

Anyone know how to get around this? How are people handling this change?

Do what any real business would do factor it into the cost of posting, whining about it does not take way the fact there is a $5 extra charge

I am not surprised this did not happen years ago! marketers have been trying to game the service since it started

Jason

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329579].message }}

bxqzb

3 years ago

Originally Posted by Regional Warrior

Do what any real business would do factor it into the cost of posting, whining about it does not take way the fact there is a $5 extra charge

I am not surprised this did not happen years ago! marketers have been trying to game the service since it started

Jason

Yeah, nobody should be surprised by this.

For ages, cl has been one of the top destinations of people with shady intentions. Software was built, people earned a living offering services on cl, etc. That niche will eventually disappear completely, sorry.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329711].message }}

Menachem Pritzker 3 years ago

I'm not whining, I'm looking for either strategies to workaround, or data on increased effectiveness now that 90% of the ads are gone.

No shady intentions here, just trying to generate skilled trade leads for licensed contractors. CL has been a great source for that, trying to keep it going.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329713].message }}

Kay King

3 years ago

marketers have been trying to game the service

Some "marketers" try to game every service and system - and we don't help them do that here.

[ 5 ] Thanks

Signature

Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world will change forever for that one dog.

I wish offended people would react like fainting goats and quietly tip over.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329593].message }}

Kay King

3 years ago

Seems to me, if 90% of the 'ads' are gone - might that not increase the exposure/results of the ads that remain? Perhaps you could place fewer ads and get better results if much of the 'static' is gone.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Saving one dog will not change the world - but the world will change forever for that one dog.

I wish offended people would react like fainting goats and quietly tip over.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329715].message }}

Menachem Pritzker

3 years ago

Exactly. I'm excited by this opportunity. Looking for somebody who understands a little better what's going on. For example, are VPNs still needed for posting in multiple geos? Will there still be harsh flagging and ghosting of suspected multiple-area-posters?

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329734].message }}

Regional Warrior

3 years ago

Originally Posted by Menachem Pritzker

Exactly. I'm excited by this opportunity. Looking for somebody who understands a little better what's going on. For example, are VPNs still needed for posting in multiple geos? Will there still be harsh flagging and ghosting of suspected multiple-area-posters?

I may have this wrong but why would you need a VPN ? or for that matter posting in Multiple GEOs? missing some thing here but that is gaming the system is it not ??

[ 3 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329898].message }}

IGotMine

3 years ago

Originally Posted by Regional Warrior

I may this wrong but why would you need a VPN ? or for that matter posting in Multiple GEOs? missing some thing here but that is gaming the system is it not ??

It's simple. Some people have no concept of right and wrong, honesty, truth, etc. They literally don't understand.

Things like rules, terms and conditions are just obstacles to be "worked around."

If they can get away with it for a while, they figure it's okay.

I think it's interesting that something that is claimed to be so important can't cover the $5 posting fee.

[ 2 ] Thanks

Signature

Make Money! I Let You Test My System With NO Payment Info. Needed! Start Now!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329904].message }}

Dan Riffle

3 years ago

I would happily pay $5 knowing that my competition dropped considerably overnight.

[ 4 ] Thanks

Signature

If you want me to go on arguing, you'll have to pay for another five minutes.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11329723].message }}

Randall Magwood

3 years ago

Originally Posted by Menachem Pritzker

Craigslist (as of yesterday), started charging $5 per post in skilled trades.

Anyone know how to get around this? How are people handling this change?

Pay the fee. Dont "get around" this.

Thanks

Signature

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11330313].message }}

FreedomBlogger

3 years ago

I just noticed that a few hours ago. I was like what the hell!

I'm not sure what to say about this. I guess, kudos to Craiglist for making more money now!

I don't know what would be a way around it. I don't think there is one!

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

At the beginning, I thought making money online with a blog was super super hard. Not anymore. Learn the art of making money online blogging - step by step - HERE.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11330624].message }}

DWolfe

3 years ago

Originally Posted by FreedomBlogger

I just noticed that a few hours ago. I was like what the hell! I'm not sure what to say about this. I guess, kudos to Craiglist for making more money now!

Glad to see Craigslist charging $5.00 It makes for a better site. To many posters there looking to phish for email address. Its been hard at times to find decent ads that are mixed into the garbage on C.L. Go to the General labor gigs and look at the offers to make money at home, asking if you have Hot Flashes and other junk ! Hope that is the next area they cracked down on.

Play by C.L. rules and spend the money if you want to find legitimate skilled labor or find a business that needs your service in stead of violating the Terms of Service.

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11330772].message }}

dsimms

3 years ago

Originally Posted by DWolfe

Glad to see Craigslist charging $5.00 It makes for a better site. To many posters there looking to phish for email address. Its been hard at times to find decent ads that are mixed into the garbage on C.L. Go to the General labor gigs and look at the offers to make money at home, asking if you have Hot Flashes and other junk ! Hope that is the next area they cracked down on.

Play by C.L. rules and spend the money if you want to find legitimate skilled labor or find a business that needs your service in stead of violating the Terms of Service.

I think CL should charge $5 for all commercial listings. People like the OP is just using CL to capture contractor leads that the business could get themselves.

Even by charging a min fee, then CL will know immediately who is serious, as all the spammers will complain, cry, then try to find other sources of free leads they are making money on...

and this is not about money for CL as they are already $100m+ company. This is about killing off the spammers that are just junking up CL or trying to get a free ride at someone else's expense.

Want to stop mass spam? then charge the spammers.
If you want to reduce hacking/fraud? then use a phone/pin verify system, which is also known as two-step authorization on every login.

[ 1 ] Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11331373].message }}

Terry Hatfield

3 years ago

Definitely, a lot fewer people posting on Craigslist now.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11331470].message }}

JohnVianny

3 years ago

if 5 usd is a problem for you LEAVE INTERNET MARKETING and GET A JOB. first.

Secondly....why are you advertising in CL?

Are you tryin to get leads at no cost and spam them to sell a 15 usd product?

You have to be serious and go in serious places for advertising your business, if CL starts with 5 usd per ads, it could only be better for them and maybe will become a serious place to place our ads.

Thanks

Signature

Email Marketing: how to Make Money sending Emails: Click HERE!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11331520].message }}

raincoast

3 years ago

I think they were trying to reduce posts where it was all about creating a link from Craigslist or generating leads to a site.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11331558].message }}

ryanbiddulph

3 years ago

Hi Menacham,

I'd just pay it since it is inexpensive.

If you receive benefits from it see it as investing in your business. Cheap investment too.

Abundant thing to do.

Ryan

Thanks

Signature

Ryan Biddulph inspires you to be a successful blogger with his courses, 100 plus eBooks, audio books and blog at Blogging From Paradise

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11331618].message }}

Instructor

3 years ago

Don't pay it! Keeping thinking of workarounds.

Thanks

Signature

KILLER SALES LETTERS GUARANTEED TO SELL ANYTHING FAST

PREMIUM ONLINE BUSINESSES FOR SALE

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11331706].message }}

ChrisBa

3 years ago

Either pay it or don't use cl would be the best answer imo.

Thanks

Signature

$ POPS GUIDE - YOUR FIRST CONVERSION GUARANTEED! $

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11332388].message }}

SEO4hire

3 years ago

I have no problem with the fee. I'm surprised it took them this long to charge people to post. Even if you charge a $1 per post, that is a LOT of money generated from each city.

My question is this: If you pay the $5, can you post to any cities that you want? I operate a legitimate SEO business, and work with clients throughout the U.S. Has anyone tried posting to multiple cities?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11332862].message }}

Jamel Hassell

3 years ago

There is a method you can use to post multiple ads in multiple cities plus get leads on auto pilot .

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11345446].message }}

Terry Hatfield

3 years ago

Jamel,

How do you do that?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11345484].message }}

Jon Kim

3 years ago

Hey guys so I know CL started charging $5 per ad in the service section as of recently. I'm interested in paying for the ads as I have been using CL for years for my business. My question is that I live in Thailand currently so am I able to post and pay for a service ad in Denver or Los Angeles even though my IP address is in Thailand? Or am I going to have to get one of my co workers to do it with an IP address in Denver or the respective city? I know CL was strict about this before the paid thing happened but I want to know that since we are paying now that I can post ads in different cities from a Thailand IP?

Please let me know as I'd like to get my ads running again asap... Thank you!

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11353471].message }}

craigsposterpro

3 years ago

Originally Posted by Jon Kim

Hey guys so I know CL started charging $5 per ad in the service section as of recently. I'm interested in paying for the ads as I have been using CL for years for my business. My question is that I live in Thailand currently so am I able to post and pay for a service ad in Denver or Los Angeles even though my IP address is in Thailand? Or am I going to have to get one of my co workers to do it with an IP address in Denver or the respective city? I know CL was strict about this before the paid thing happened but I want to know that since we are paying now that I can post ads in different cities from a Thailand IP?

Please let me know as I'd like to get my ads running again asap... Thank you!

You still absolutely need to use an IP address which matches the target city you are posting to. That aspect has not changed with the new paid ad transition.

Thanks
2 replies

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11353591].message }}

Jon Kim 3 years ago

ok thank you!
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11353988].message }}

Jon Kim

3 years ago

Also does the same flagging guidelines still apply? For example do I need to switch up my main body text and titles and pictures if I'm posting the same ad in different cities? Or since we are paying now can we use the same pictures in different ads etc? I've tried emailing CL about all this but they are of zero help and never answer my questions...

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11353990].message }}

craigsposterpro

3 years ago

Originally Posted by Jon Kim

Also does the same flagging guidelines still apply? For example do I need to switch up my main body text and titles and pictures if I'm posting the same ad in different cities? Or since we are paying now can we use the same pictures in different ads etc? I've tried emailing CL about all this but they are of zero help and never answer my questions...

Craigslist still has the same ad filters in place. However, it is much less likely that your ads can be flagged by competitors since CL staff will now review ads before that human flagging can take effect. It is still advisable for you to mix up your titles, text and images if you want to optimize your ads for different target keywords. Please also realize that there are credit card filters in their payment gateway whereby debit, pre-paid and gift card types are not accepted. Their billing department is reachable by phone and email if you have issues with regular type credit cards. If you want to get specific help, Craigslist does have a user forum with sections dedicated to Feedback, Flag Help and Help Desk here / https://forums.craigslist.org/

Hope that helps

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11354167].message }}

ctrlaltdelete

3 years ago

Oh, that's good. To be honest I tend to avoid Craiglist as a whole even if I'm the one doing the hiring. I just search in sites like Upwork and Onlinejobsph. But I'm glad that Craiglist is doing something to improve themselves.

5 bucks a post'll help weed out the scammers from the genuine people there. Goodness knows that site is filled with shady folks.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11353947].message }}

focusedlife

3 years ago

Want the Craigslist $5 post workaround?

Start posting on other platforms:

LinkedIn Articles (has tons of SEO benefits), Facebook Posts, Tweets, Reddit, Youtube, etc.

Craigslist isn't the only game in town.

Expand your thinking.

Adapt.

Ask "where are my prospects hanging out at?"

"How can I get in front of them?"

Brainstorm ideas.

Hope that helped.

Thanks

Signature

The only group with more actionable info than any WSO → The Parlay Society
Want me to write stuff for you? → Click here to check this out

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11376693].message }}

nicheblogger75

3 years ago

That's a good thing IMO. It will weed out lots of the spam and other crap posts that people are always trying to sneak in there. They ought to charge $10.

Thanks

Signature

FREE 48-Hour Blueprint - How I CRUSH IT With Solo Ads!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11377668].message }}

Jeremy Harrington

3 years ago

[DELETED]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11412451].message }}

OptedIn 3 years ago

Originally Posted by Jeremy Harrington

Craigslist really shot itself in the foot with the new pricing structure.

Right, eliminating losers that won't shell out 5 bucks for an ad is a broken business model. Too funny for words.

would recommend checking out Troolr. They do not charge anything to post on their site.

I want to waste my time posting a free ad on a site that no one has never heard of.

Can you please give me directions to skid row?
- [ 3 ] Thanks
Signature

"He not busy being born, is busy dying." - Bob Dylan â€¢ "I vibe with the light-dark point. Heavy." - Words that Bob Dylan wishes he had written.
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11412464].message }}

moneyg

3 years ago

If cl is going to start charging it'd be only fair to lift the ip restriction IMO. Also, does anyone know if it's a one time cost for the ad? I'm wondering if one is able to repost the ad for free once paid.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

If You Are Interested On Becoming A Partner For Our RTB PLATFORM, Email Us at moneygrtb@gmail.com

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11416332].message }}

OptedIn 3 years ago

Originally Posted by moneyg

I'm wondering if one is able to repost the ad for free once paid.

Why not review their information? It's all there - not, here.

Then, again - you could always invest $5 in an ad and see how it all works. No?
- Thanks
Signature

"He not busy being born, is busy dying." - Bob Dylan â€¢ "I vibe with the light-dark point. Heavy." - Words that Bob Dylan wishes he had written.
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11416480].message }}

boblev

3 years ago

Complaining about craigslist policies will never matter to craig newmark, he takes great joy in chasing spammers off of his site.In fact at one point they seemed to be more concerned about spam than the creepy killers lurking around the personals section.

The problem for marketers is that craig wants the platform to serve local communities and does NOT want to open it up to national advertising. And on craiglist, craig get's what craig wants....it's that simple!

Personally, I left CL years ago because life is too short and I already have enough barriers and hoops to jump through, over, in and around or tunnel under....

Bob

[ 1 ] Thanks

Signature

"The road to success and the road to failure are almost exactly the same." Colin R. Davis

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11416370].message }}

writeaway

3 years ago

Just play by the rules and build a solid SERVICE BRAND

Build repeat customers by under promising and over delivering

This is how I built my business

I suspect the same strategy would work for you, OP

Thanks

Signature

Want To Make More Money Online? Invest in BETTER CONTENT!
Articles - Blogs - Authority sites - Ecommerce descriptions - Emails - Youtube video scripts - AFFORDABLE RATES!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11426114].message }}

cainbrian

3 years ago

I remember I did a Craigslist traffic training back in 2013. When the Job section was the only paid section of the site for $25.

I had always avoided paying it because I would post in Small Business & the gig section. But I put a tracking pixel on the ad itself (don't think we can do that anymore)... I went from 13 clicks onto my ad to 1,300 clicks onto my CL ad page.

I'd doubt it gets that same type of traffic anymore, but I'm sure the paid ads will weed out the tire-kickers and make it easier for you to get a response over other people who now refuse to market because they can't afford $5 (which is a good thing, for you)

Thanks

Signature

Thank you for connecting with me, I really appreciate everytime you respond or have a conversation with me. (hint: I'm an introvert, lol) --- http://attractivesponsor.com

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11426171].message }}

craigslistlivead

3 years ago

[DELETED]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11435283].message }}

OptedIn 3 years ago

Originally Posted by craigslistlivead

Craigslist

Reported as SPAM!
- [ 1 ] Thanks
Signature

"He not busy being born, is busy dying." - Bob Dylan â€¢ "I vibe with the light-dark point. Heavy." - Words that Bob Dylan wishes he had written.
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11435290].message }}
toydistrict 3 years ago

Originally Posted by craigslistlivead

Keyword stuffing on WF lol
- [ 1 ] Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[11435319].message }}

Craigslist - New $5 fee for posting to skilled trade services

Trending Topics

Critique My Copy | What am I missing?

Broke $2,000 for the first time for 3 hours of intra day stock trading...

Goddamn Awful Fashion... Grrr!

Ever Battled With Bright Shiny Object Syndrome? How Did You Overcome It?

My Wife Said I Can't But Find Help Here....