Anyone Else Disappointed With iContact?

by dv8
17 replies
I signed up for iContact's 15 day free trial. At first I liked it, it's easy to use and figure out.

But, when I get emails from iContact, whether it be alerting me that an email was sent or just from them as a company trying to get me to buy, it always shows up in my spam folder.

Kind of ironic....a business thats only job is too send emails gets sent to my spam folder.

And the emails don't get sent right away. I was testing it and signed up for a list I made. The welcome email came like 20 minutes later. And when I used confirmed opt in, same thing, it didn't come right away. Not good!


Anyone else have any issues with them?

Looks like aweber is going to get my business.
#disappointed #icontact
  • Profile picture of the author Chris_Willow
    I took the test drive too.
    All was cool except I didn't like the massive footer at the bottom advertisiing icontact. Ok it probably could have been removed somehow, but I just had no time to mess with it...
    Everything else was cool for me.

    Chris
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[218391].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RGallowitz
    Well this just concretes my original thoughts....steer away from the new guys and stick to the proven chaps. Getresponse and Aweber are tops!
    Signature
    Make INSANE money by promoting PHYSICAL affiliate products.
    The one and only "GALLO Affiliate System" -
    >> Click Here! <<
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[218508].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author NauticalUrge
    First, I want to clearly state that yes I work for iContact as their Online Communications Manager. I believe in complete transparency, so there's my disclosure...

    I'd like to ask what email client you are using, and do you have additional SPAM filters that aren't normally installed/activated?

    I personally use Hotmail, Gmail, and IPswitch Webmail accounts for my personal email correspondence, and emails sent by our clients (that I am signed up with), don't go into my spam folders.

    I also use iContact to send out newsletters for some local non-profit organizations that I personally support, and I rarely run into these sending delays. Yes, there are ocassions where there's an unusually high volume of clients sending at the same time, but this is far a few inbetween. I fear that your observations may have been during one of these rare spikes.

    - - -
    As far as the footer at the bottom of the emails, you can actually have our logo replaced with a custom footer which contains your organization's contact info and logo. Please contact our Technical Support Department about your options for Custom Footers (1-877-968-3996).

    - - -
    In regards to the proven Champs, please keep in mind that every Email Service Provider (ESP) caters to different clients depending on the needs of the client. I would like to think that all ESPs have their own niche markets of clients who prefer their services over others. I would suggest that if you are looking for an ESP, that you try them out and compare their features and pricing...

    topseos[dot]com/rankings-of-best-email-marketing-companies
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[223892].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Dennis Murphy
      Originally Posted by NauticalUrge View Post

      As far as the footer at the bottom of the emails, you can actually have our logo replaced with a custom footer which contains your organization's contact info and logo. Please contact our Technical Support Department about your options for Custom Footers (1-877-968-3996).
      As we recently find out, the ADVERTISEMENT that iContact runs at the bottom of every email you send can be removed...for an extra $5 per month.

      Now, the $5 is not the issue so much as the principle of paying for a service, only to have them insert their advertising, which can lead to clicks away from our promotions. If we had a free account I could understand putting in an advertisement. However, this is a paid account, and it's not even an affiliate link. In essence, we're paying to advertise for them.

      Thankfully, we only have it on an account with a few thousand subscribers to test out their service. Our total subscriber base is close to 100K, and we will now no longer be importing them to iContact as we had been considering.

      Dennis
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[641869].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Jesus Perez
        Amazing. iContact is lost as a company. Glad I ditched them and brought the email delivery inhouse.

        Now I'm getting 29% open rates and 9% clickthrough rates on a list of 8000+ with the use of a dedicated ADSL business line, a WinXP Pro machine and Campaign Enterprise.

        Originally Posted by Dennis Murphy View Post

        As we recently find out, the ADVERTISEMENT that iContact runs at the bottom of every email you send can be removed...for an extra $5 per month.

        Now, the $5 is not the issue so much as the principle of paying for a service, only to have them insert their advertising, which can lead to clicks away from our promotions. If we had a free account I could understand putting in an advertisement. However, this is a paid account, and it's not even an affiliate link. In essence, we're paying to advertise for them.

        Thankfully, we only have it on an account with a few thousand subscribers to test out their service. Our total subscriber base is close to 100K, and we will now no longer be importing them to iContact as we had been considering.

        Dennis
        Signature

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[642001].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Christian Sawyer
          I experienced similar delays when signing up for my own list. I did the 15 day trial and went to Aweber.

          I was not happy with iContact, and they kept calling me until I blocked their number. Not the best way to get a customer IMO.

          -Christian
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[642032].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Dennis Murphy
            I got one detail wrong about the monthly charge to remove their footer... they actually charge 10% of the package price you are on to remove their advertising - it's a $4.95 minimum charge per month.

            So, as we approach the 100K list size, the charge would be an additional $60 per month on top of our base monthly price to keep their advertisements off of our email messages. Nice.

            Dennis
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[642051].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jesus Perez
    Read about my experience here.

    http://www.warriorforum.com/main-int...tml#post176676

    I'm currently using GetResponse. I'm quite happy.
    Signature

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[223920].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author NauticalUrge
    Thanks for the heads up, I frequent quite a few sites, and unfortunately, I haven't visited Warrior Forums as much as I should, I'll read your post and respond back. Thanks!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[223930].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Mary Green
    I liked aweber when I used to have an account there, but I paid for over a year and never (almost never) used it. Since then I have tried iContact, but I want to build large lists and so I looked around and decided to go with Get Response. As far as what I saw you can have as many subscribers as you want and you dont have to worry about getting charged more. That was the only reason I did not go back to aweber.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[223934].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jesus Perez
    I should also mention that despite being unhappy with iContact, their deliverability was fine. All emails penetrated the inbox of major providers.

    However, I did add iContact to my SPF record in DNS.

    Also, take a look at the words and links you used in the body. That may have triggered a junk filter.
    Signature

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[223947].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author NauticalUrge
    Regardless of which Email Service Provider that you choose, definitely fully test their trials. Setup Gmail, Hotmail, Zimbra, Webmail, Outlook, and any others which might be used by your target audiences, and TEST! TEST! TEST!

    There are a wealth of Email Marketing Best Practices white papers available online, which will provide you with insight on the best ways of getting your emails into your audience's inboxes, regardless of whom you use as your ESP.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[223989].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Mike Hill
    Even though aWeber has increased their prices for new members I love them. The emails get sent in reasonable fashion and get through to the end user (and NOT in their spam folder)

    I guess with the price increase it will keep people on their toes to clean their lists every now and then so you are only sending out emails to those that are still responding/reading them.

    This will make aWebers service tops in the industry.

    Mike Hill
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[224003].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author jacktackett
    No Sending MTA can control what goes into your spam folder. This goes for Enterprise Service Providers too. Most will give you a tool to check against standard spam filters (typically some sort of modify spam assassin tool).

    The programs that control what goes into your spam folders are your service providers MTA (Mail Transport Agent) and your client. Those programs will score and decide on what they think is spam and route accordingly.

    Also MTAs along the route might make the same decisions - some use RBLs to block whole ranges of IPs they suspect of sending spam. Which is why most ESP watch what gets sent like a hawk - trying to get off a black list is a royal pain. And many of these folks have a Roman/Napoleon thought process - you're guilty until you prove you're innocent.

    Also, no ESP sends email immediately - doing so would overwhelm any server. Most MTAs spool the mail and send it out as resources allow. Now immediately to you and me and a server are much different time scale. It might look immediate to you, but trust me, in server time its not.

    best,
    --Jack

    Disclaimers - I use iContact and am very happy with their service. My wife also works for them.



    Originally Posted by dv8 View Post

    I signed up for iContact's 15 day free trial. At first I liked it, it's easy to use and figure out.

    But, when I get emails from iContact, whether it be alerting me that an email was sent or just from them as a company trying to get me to buy, it always shows up in my spam folder.

    Kind of ironic....a business thats only job is too send emails gets sent to my spam folder.

    And the emails don't get sent right away. I was testing it and signed up for a list I made. The welcome email came like 20 minutes later. And when I used confirmed opt in, same thing, it didn't come right away. Not good!


    Anyone else have any issues with them?

    Looks like aweber is going to get my business.
    Signature
    Let's get Tim the kidney he needs!HELP Tim
    Mega Monster WSO for KimW http://ow.ly/4JdHm


    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[224088].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Loren Woirhaye
    I did the trial. List import wasn't a problem. But when
    I looked closer at what I was getting it wasn't a good fit
    for me - because I sent email broadcasts often I didn't
    care for the restriction to 6X list size per month - seems
    to me like a strategy to enact "gotcha" charges...
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[224304].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dv8
    Originally Posted by dv8 View Post

    I signed up for iContact's 15 day free trial. At first I liked it, it's easy to use and figure out.

    But, when I get emails from iContact, whether it be alerting me that an email was sent or just from them as a company trying to get me to buy, it always shows up in my spam folder.
    Maybe I wasn't clear enough in my OP.

    It is not an email I am being sent from a opt in form I created and then tested. Therefore it has nothing to do with what was in the message itself.

    It's from iContact itself, nothing to do with my AR list. More specifically when they sent me an email alerting me that my message (AR) went out successfully.

    Anywho, I am still testing them out. Maybe it was a fluke??
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[225330].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dv8
    Btw, I use Yahoo for my email.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[225331].message }}

Trending Topics