Super Bowl Ads Don't Work (Or, The Myth of Absolute Statements)

3 replies
In January 1999, Just for Feet ran an ad during the Super Bowl--one which turned out to be quite controversial. Regardless, they filed for bankruptcy in November of that same year and closed out their last store in 2004.

Pets.com ran a Super Bowl ad in January of 2000. They closed in November of the same year.

It becomes apparent, then, that Super Bowl ads are largely ineffective. In fact, it looks as though running an ad during the Super Bowl can lead to bankruptcy.

Of course, you know of many companies that run Super Bowl ads--some year after year--and are still around.

So an absolute statement that Super Bowl advertising is ineffective is false.

The thing is that a Super Bowl ad is not a cure-all. It is not the be-all, end-all of marketing. It's an option (if you can afford it). It's a tool.

The same goes for so many other things. Twitter, Facebook, article marketing, blogging, etc. These are all tools. There are no absolutes. Some people may never figure out how to use Twitter effectively. That doesn't make Twitter a bad tool, nor does it make Twitter an ineffective tool. It just means that some people are ineffective at using the tool.

Same for anything else.

And that goes for other things as well, things like "Oh, you'll never succeed in that market--it's too saturated or the big boys have it all locked up!"

If you were to believe all these absolute statements people come up with, that this doesn't work or that isn't effective, you wouldn't be able to do anything at all because nothing works!

So, rarely believe absolute statements. They'll most likely only deter you from success--not lead you toward it.
#absolute #ads #bowl #myth #statements #super #work
  • Profile picture of the author Marc Rodill
    Good point, Dan.

    One thing does not necessarily lend itself to another thing.

    Advertising during the Superbowl is obviously not a good idicator of a company's staying-power (just how much they have to blow). Just as post count here isn't a good indicator of someone's income, either. It's used mostly for fun, laughs and brand awareness; not as a direct-response medium.

    When you have millions, it's easy to blow money on silly things.

    In fact one of those company's you mention, Budweiser, actually saw a drop in sales over 2.5% last year for their Drinkability campaign. The ads were shown to actually lead to people not buying. But that doesn't mean they'll go bankrupt because their ads bombed; they take into account long-term profitability.

    Still, the reason why Superbowl ads are mostly ineffective when it comes to the bottom-linef is because they are done wrong...

    Super Bowl XL Exemplifies 'Slash and Burn' Marketing in B2B Marketplace; Jet Powered Group?s Comprehensive White Paper Explores Tactics for Efficient Marketing

    It's not necessarily the medium..
    Signature
    Long Lost Warriors! The Secret Sales System! Act Now! Buy Now! Right Now!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2838821].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author jointaldc
    I think people just think that because so many people watch it, around 70 million, they can capture a whole new market with it
    Signature
    Jointal ---- A CPA network that operates on trust -
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2839833].message }}

Trending Topics