Opt-in Email Squeezing: Favorite method?
1) Javascript pop-up asking for First Name and Email on your sales pitch page, that pops up immediately or say a few seconds after the visitor lands on your page.
2) Prominent box on your sales page briefly extolling the virtues of joining your mailing list and providing the ability to directly sign up for the list with name and email fields. This can be at or near the top of the page, or near the bottom, in my experience.
3) After the person buys the product (or in some cases during the checkout itself), a redirect to a squeeze page asking for name and email.
There are probably other methods that I haven't included. In any case, what is your favorite? #1 is pretty annoying to me personally and honestly has turned me off continuing reading about some products, when I was shopping myself for info. #2 seems less rude and intrusive, but it takes people off the page once they've clicked on "Sign me up" and the golden rule for sales pitch pages is not to have any links that would lose the prospect. #3 has the obvious problem of only picking up mailing list members if they buy the product right away, losing the prospects who don't buy the product but would still sign up for emails.
I can imagine #2 and #3 being used together (does anyone do this?), but #1 and #2 together, or all three together, seems like overkill and I'd think it would put off a lot of people. Thoughts?
Founder of JVZoo. All around good guy :)