Controlling what you see?

6 replies
So I found this video and thought that there's a problem that's growing and growing online. Two major companies, 'Google & FB' are now controlling how you surf the web to display what 'they think' you should see.

How does this affect us marketers? Well simply put, we're waisting money. You're spending money on advertising for example, to advertise to people that might not even see your ad or who you're targeting. In other words, you might be targeting a latest news story, and your search terms are based on the country it's related to and what not, but if they control what the end-user is seeing, then your ad could be getting shown to the wrong audience entirely.

As the example shown in the video below, someone that searches for egypt had results about the major events that day. The protests etc... (you could be targeting that event through ads). Then another searches the same thing but based on what their history of search terms are, they could get shown a list of different results. Therefore, your ad is targeting a certain keyword which could potentially be getting displayed to the wrong audience. This becomes a problem when you're paying per the cost of views. You can be spending thousands on 'un-targeted traffic' even though your keywords show them as targeted?


I saw this and thought I need to let you know that this could be happening to you without you even knowing...

Is this an Advantage or Disadvantage to you?

Let me know what you think.
#ads #controlling #google #online #search
  • Profile picture of the author Clint Butler
    User targeted search results were just bound to happen over time. I think the ultimate signal was Google's integration of Google+ into their search results. Allowing their system to generate search results based on our previous actions. The task now for SEO's is to figure out how to work with this new standard to target the right people at the right time.

    Regards,
    Clint
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5115678].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author latnem
      Thanks for the link to that video very interesting. I know its been going on for a while but just never gave it TOO much thought. Definitely will water down the searchable information on the web if all these search algorithms are based on sales and what not.

      I agree with clint, just another type of system to learn.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5115783].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Joseph Robinson
    Banned
    Well let's see. In the overall sense of being able to choose what you see on the internet, it is somewhat concerning. Sure the intent is that your results are more personalized and thus more likely what you want; but it disturbs me that the choice is being taken out of what I see.

    From a marketing perspective though, it's simple. Adapt or die. Those who are willing to learn this and work it to there advantage will be just fine. They can't really kill marketing, just change the game.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5116042].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author flamewave
    I agree, user targeted marketting is surely going to be king as facebook is showing that at the moment. How will google adjust to this?
    Signature

    Messenger Chatbot Marketing Systems - https://m.me/jaygriggschatbotbuilder

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5116456].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Fahu
    That Facebook and Google will never charge us to use their services proves that you are not their customers you are their product
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5123813].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Global Warrior
    Originally Posted by CPA Andrew View Post

    So I found this video and thought that there's a problem that's growing and growing online. Two major companies, 'Google & FB' are now controlling how you surf the web to display what 'they think' you should see.

    How does this affect us marketers? Well simply put, we're waisting money. You're spending money on advertising for example, to advertise to people that might not even see your ad or who you're targeting. In other words, you might be targeting a latest news story, and your search terms are based on the country it's related to and what not, but if they control what the end-user is seeing, then your ad could be getting shown to the wrong audience entirely.

    As the example shown in the video below, someone that searches for egypt had results about the major events that day. The protests etc... (you could be targeting that event through ads). Then another searches the same thing but based on what their history of search terms are, they could get shown a list of different results. Therefore, your ad is targeting a certain keyword which could potentially be getting displayed to the wrong audience. This becomes a problem when you're paying per the cost of views. You can be spending thousands on 'un-targeted traffic' even though your keywords show them as targeted?

    YouTube - Broadcast Yourself.

    I saw this and thought I need to let you know that this could be happening to you without you even knowing...

    Is this an Advantage or Disadvantage to you?

    Let me know what you think.
    Ive been in Saudi Arabia for the last week. Ive been using a few search engines whilst ive been over here. With Bing, im not subjected to any ads, only organic results, with Yahoo, im only subjected to some ads, the same with Google.

    What i can tell you is this though, i have been looking at "Golf Equipment" as a search term on the .co.uk domain........ and i have been served up with a page full of adverts for this search term. Now if those ads are PPC, thats ok as the advertiser isn't losing money. However, if they're CPM, they are hardly targeted because Google knows im in the middle east because it has been serving me up ads in other areas pertaining to that search term that are targeting middle east companies in the ads.

    If i search for the same term "Golf Equipment" on the .com domain, there is only 1 ad at the top of the page on G.

    So if you are targeting "Golf Equipment" on CPM, the impression on me has been wasted, because, even if the suppliers would ship Golf Equipment out here, it would get held up in customs.

    The above, just FYI

    Regards

    GW
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5123876].message }}

Trending Topics