I've seen good WSOs getting slagged for downright silly reasons. Good systems getting slammed because they don't give you a detailed step by step way to get a million visitors a day (slight exaggeration, but you get the point).
I do realize that the WSO forum is for offers that give warriors an advantage over people who are not members of the warrior forum. I've purchased many great WSOs. IM products that were insanely cheap for what they had to offer. And I've seen several of the marketers making them available getting torn apart by an angry mob.
It makes me wonder if some people shouldn't sit back for 5 minutes and make a reality check.
P.S.: Having said that most reviewers tend to be constructive and keep a positive tone even when they are critical.