I am an old member of another forum that appraises domains and recently, I felt tired of doing so as I believe that domain appraisal is getting useless unless someone explains in details why he gave such a low/high appraisal for a domain.
When can you tell that a domain is valuable? Is the monthly search data enough? How about related suffix, prefix, connected words, etc?
- diaper.com- (taken)
- buydiaper.com - (taken)
- buydiaperonline.com - (available at the time of writing)
Many people would say that the third domain is not good because "buy diaper online" has only around 22 exact searches. In this case, especially for buyer keywords like this, does exact matches matters when selecting a domain even though is sounds good and has a correct grammar?
I have several domains with similar cases but when someone tells me that my domain is not good because of the low exact search for the whole phrase, I just shrug my shoulders...
Let us hear you..