I'm posting this here because I can see that this could become a common occurrance and I would like to form a policy for when it does. Hopefully this will also be usefull to others here.
The site that these links were on was built out of RSS feeds in 2007. It's a big site and still gets a few visitors from Google for long tail keywords. Removing specific links from a site like this would be a nightmare especialy if I were to get requests from other people too. I had considered taking the whole site down but as it's still getting search visitors I decided against that.
The requestor states that they don't even know if my site is a problem but they want to be on "the safe side". Bit of a cheek you might say.
What do the Warriors think about this and how should we handle this new Google policy?