Does having a guarantee reduce refunds?

by troy23
28 replies
I was reading an e-book just now on sales pages which said having a guarantee actually reduces refund requests.

I would have thought the opposite was true.

I realize Clickbank insists on it before it will list a product, but I am using PayPal this time.

Some don't like people people getting the product for free and don't use a guarantee policy.

What has been your experience of having a refund policy in place?
#guarantee #reduce #refunds
  • Profile picture of the author scrofford
    Guarantees do reduce refunds. The thing is though is that you've got to have a good sales letter written. A guarantee is just a cog in the whole sales letter system. The idea behind giving a guarantee is security. The customer feels like he's not out anything when he purchases the product.

    So if you give a great guarantee, the chances of the customer wanting a refund is reduced. Of course you also need to make sure your product is worth the price you're charging, or you'll be getting refund requests as fast as you have sales.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7753934].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author vickybabe
      Personally i think that having a guarantee is the thing least likely to reduce refund rates.

      If the customer feels like you have over-delivered on what you promised, and the product is really top notch, only then will refund rates start to reduce
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754120].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Ryan David
    I don't see how a guarantee would reduce refunds. If you aren't guaranteeing the product, wouldn't "All sales be final". I understand you'd get some chargebacks and whatnot.

    I think guarantees increase refunds, but they also increase conversions and the net result is more money.

    With a lot of ebook type products, I use the "Barnes and Noble" test. I'll buy the ebook because of the refund policy and then flip through it...if it's not what I thought, I refund immediately. My thought process is that I probably wouldn't have purchased it had I gotten the chance to flip through it like I would at a bookstore.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754132].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author evilsaigon
    Increase sales, yes. Reduce refunds? I don't think so. Clients judge your product quality after purchasing, not your guarantee parameters.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754165].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Malcolm Thomas
      Originally Posted by evilsaigon View Post

      Increase sales, yes. Reduce refunds? I don't think so. Clients judge your product quality after purchasing, not your guarantee parameters.
      This. Having a guarantee does NOT reduce refunds, if anything it can actually increase refunds due to there being many serial refunders around nowadays. But nonetheless having a clearly stated refund policy does tend to increase the amount of sales that your product gets.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754193].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author dannygnenerate
        No, guarantees do not reduce refunds but it can make the initial purchase a more comfortable experience for the buyer "risk free". I've sold a crazy amount of products and I never give a "money back guarantee" unless it's over a certain amount. Although this is all subjective to what you're selling and the actual value you're giving people. I tell my students this "if you make a product then make sure it's so good that people in your family will buy it and love it". If you'll sell what you're selling to the people you love with full confidence then it wouldn't matter if it has a money back or not.

        Also I'll suggest if you're releasing a product and want to include a guarantee to remember this.

        Your initial product is only a short burst of information and after they have read over it they may feel like they want their money back but if they were to get things continuously maybe even a month out (30 day money back) even if it's one or two things then you can cushion yourself and you'll have a dramatically less refund ratio.

        Be creative, I even use this when I use to sell affiliate marketing products. I NEVER had a refund because when they buy the affiliate product it was nothing compared to the services I gave them over the next 30 days as long as they didn't get a refund on the product.

        Hope this helps, have an awesome day and I'm so positive that success will find you. Keep moving.

        Daniel Brown - PAL
        Signature

        "How To Get Clients Begging To Pay For Your Services... And Close More Deals FAST!" Get Clients Now

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754273].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author GetMoreCustomers
        Originally Posted by Malcolm Thomas View Post

        This. Having a guarantee does NOT reduce refunds, if anything it can actually increase refunds due to there being many serial refunders around nowadays. But nonetheless having a clearly stated refund policy does tend to increase the amount of sales that your product gets.
        The good thing for sellers is that these "serial refunders" wouldn't purchase the product anyway. If the product came with no money back guarantee, they just wouldn't buy it (or worse- chargeback).

        Personally, I see no reason to not have a refund policy. Most people don't ask for refunds very often. Besides, chargebacks can be expensive and often outweigh the positives of slightly reduced refunds.
        Signature
        Get More Customers - Promote Your Website, Business, or Product (website under construction)
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757451].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author scrofford
    If you've ever done any copywriting or taken any copywriting classes you would understand how guarantees help reduce refunds. They ABSOLUTELY help reduce the risk of having to pay out refunds in that they give the customer a safety net. And what's really funny is that the bigger the guarantee, the less of a chance of having to refund the customer.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754340].message }}
    • Originally Posted by scrofford View Post

      guarantees help reduce refunds. They ABSOLUTELY help reduce the risk of having to pay out refunds in that they give the customer a safety net. And what's really funny is that the bigger the guarantee, the less of a chance of having to refund the customer.
      That doesn't make any sense. I understand that a money-back guarantee helps conversions, but I don't see how it should improve refunds.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754499].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Claude Whitacre
        Offering a guarantee does not reduce refunds. Offering a guarantee increases sales.

        Offering a long money back guarantee reduces the number of refunds because buyers simply put off asking for a refund, and they let it go too long.

        So a one year money back guarantee will get you less refunds than a two week money back guarantee.

        Every test proves it.
        Signature
        One Call Closing book https://www.amazon.com/One-Call-Clos...=1527788418&sr

        What if they're not stars? What if they are holes poked in the top of a container so we can breath?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754637].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author myob
      As an affiliate marketer, I have found that prominently emphasizing Clickbank's refund policy dramatically increases conversion rates, although that is only part of the equation for addressing the refund rate problem inherently associated with some types of products.

      The downside of an unconditional money-back guarantee such as with Clickbank is that it often opens up abuse by "serial refunders", which is typically common among some niches and/or products. This can be minimized by pre-qualifying buyers, setting expectations of the product in presales promotions, offering an unadvertised bonus, followup after purchase, product support, etc.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754654].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
        Banned
        Clearly having a guarantee increases refunds.

        How can there be refunds (other than perhaps some chargebacks) without offering them?

        If you have a "no refunds" policy, you'll have fewer refunds.

        You may not have many sales either, but you'll certainly have fewer refunds ("duh").

        That said, it's true (pretty much throughout marketing, I think, offline and online) that the longer the period of the guarantee, the fewer refunds there'll be. Apparently counterintuitive to some, but very commonly true.

        (And of course I agree completely with what Paul says, just above).
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754828].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author kencalhn
    I've sold a lot, most as all-sales-final no refund/guarantees. I offer generous previews of anything I sell, like video clips from DVDs, or preview webinars, so that potential customers can see an honest sample of what they're getting before they buy.

    Think about it -- Amazon and everyone else who sells DVDs, and video games, it's a multi-billion dollar industry, all with no refunds/all sales final since stuff can be copied. That's what preview video clips (or trial versions of games) are for, is to show a demo, so that no refund policy is needed, to protect against bs refunders/copiers.

    It's also a function of your trust level you've built with customers, and how well known you are, and other factors. The answer of course is to Test with your marketplace, niche, offers, lists.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7754624].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author edd666666
    After hearing that having a one year, no questions asked refund policy will actually result in less refunds, not more I tried in and have been going a year and a half on that site with no refund requests. Apparently people don't feel the need to keep thinking of getting a refund in thirty days and end up forgetting about it. Now of course this will not stop the "instant refund" people from hitting you. One other factor that may keep the refunders away from my info product, is that my product comes with four one on one coaching sessions and the product by itself is not much good without the coaching. And by the time they have had the coaching they are totally sold.

    OK, thanks and good luck, Ed.
    Signature
    “Over 1,000 People Have Used My Unique Pitch System To Achieve Their Publicity Goals... And I’ll Work Personally With You Too, One-On-One To Help You Get On TV!” CLICK HERE
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7755456].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author higherluv
    Having no guarantee eliminates refunds! Ain’t that great?? :p

    You might have more success, conversion wise and refund wise, in having a lifetime or 1 year guarantee than with just a 30 day one. More perceived value. (Just provide the value that warrants such a guarantee, though - unless you’re confident that the product or service sucks - then just take their money :p )
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7755536].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Raydal
    Originally Posted by troy23 View Post

    I was reading an e-book just now on sales pages which said having a guarantee actually reduces refund requests.
    That should be lengthening the period for the guarantee reduces
    refunds. Not just the fact of having a guarantee. Are you sure
    you read right?

    If you did, ask for a refund.

    -Ray Edwards
    Signature
    The most powerful and concentrated copywriting training online today bar none! Autoresponder Writing Email SECRETS
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7755557].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author kencalhn
    Remember too we're in a new economy, so merchant safeguards are necessary, which is why the world's top online retailer, Amazon.com, has a no-refund policy for all their movies, mp3s, DVDs, video games, CDs and the rest (once opened it cannot be returned).

    Amazon.com Help: Items That Can't Be Returned

    The World's #1 retailer online has a no-refund policy (for copyable media). I've sold to thousands of people for years with no refunds, very successfully. Could I have made more sales if I'd offered refunds/MBGs? Yeah, but I'd also have a big overhead admin headache managing them, blacklisting refunders to avoid serial refunders, selling to entitlement mentality lookie loo refunders and all the rest of it. And besides, of thousands of customers I've had a lifetime less than 1.8% dissatisfaction/problem rate, with most of my customers buying from me multiple times. So offering a refund isn't necessary, due to content quality and previews.

    NEW ECONOMY:
    - people search blackhat forums and filesharing sites to steal content for free w/downloads
    - people are much more discerning and cautious about buying... so upfront proof elements, industry credibility and upfront free-sample video clips, webinars are necessary
    - buyers are burned out on all the aff pitches for overpriced launched $2k guru crap
    - in this particular welfare handout political climate we're in, "Entitlement mentality" and "give it all to me free, now" works against ethical marketers, because now you have a bunch of people half-expecting to get a lot of stuff for mooching for freebies. So offering refunds buys into that herd mentality, and you are seeing high refunds most likely if you offer them.
    - The oldschool "never fail to offer MBGs" direct-response/copywriting tactics are not 100% right for all markets and all info-products.
    - Test. Test. Test. Split-test offers, MBG vs no MBG, all those variables, to find what works best in your niche.
    - the correct question to ask vs refunds, is instead "does offering a guarantee/MBG increase net profits and LCV/lifetime customer value", in my niche?

    -k

    p.s. this topic has been done to death, look in the old/archived WF for lots of threads on it, too.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7756040].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jeff Schuman
    I have found over the years that offering a money back guarantee does not increase refunds if the product delivers what you say it will. It does increase sales if you have the right kind of traffic coming to your site.

    On the flip side, some people will request a money back guarantee even if you do not offer one and to those people I just give it to them anyway. It is not worth the hassle to fight over a 1 in 100 or 1 in 1000 request like that.
    Signature
    Jeff Schuman - SEO Blog Writer For Hire! Buy affordable, SEO, quality, MMO niche blog articles. Fast turnaround.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7756051].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author KevL
    Originally Posted by troy23 View Post

    I was reading an e-book just now on sales pages which said having a guarantee actually reduces refund requests.

    I would have thought the opposite was true.

    I realize Clickbank insists on it before it will list a product, but I am using PayPal this time.

    Some don't like people people getting the product for free and don't use a guarantee policy.

    What has been your experience of having a refund policy in place?
    Doesn't really matter whether it does or not given that you need to have a guarantee with most selling platforms, and don't forget you may be breaking trading laws in the buyers country, and / or your own, if you don't offer a guarantee.

    What I have seen however is that having a LONGER guarantee than the norm, can reduce refund rates.
    Signature
    SEO Kev
    Small business SEO / Web Marketing Tips.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7756084].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Cool Hand Luke
      Wow. Four posts in a row giving out false information. Good stuff.

      Ask me how I know none of these posters have successful products of their own or have ever bothered to test whether or not guarantees affect refunds. (Hint: They do. It's not even debateable, and it doesn't matter what you "think". Test it. Having a refund guarantee ALWAYS increases conversion rates and decreases actual refund rates.)

      It's like the blind leading the blind with the posts below.

      Originally Posted by vickybabe View Post

      Personally i think that having a guarantee is the thing least likely to reduce refund rates.

      If the customer feels like you have over-delivered on what you promised, and the product is really top notch, only then will refund rates start to reduce
      Originally Posted by Ryan David View Post

      I don't see how a guarantee would reduce refunds. If you aren't guaranteeing the product, wouldn't "All sales be final". I understand you'd get some chargebacks and whatnot.

      I think guarantees increase refunds, but they also increase conversions and the net result is more money.

      With a lot of ebook type products, I use the "Barnes and Noble" test. I'll buy the ebook because of the refund policy and then flip through it...if it's not what I thought, I refund immediately. My thought process is that I probably wouldn't have purchased it had I gotten the chance to flip through it like I would at a bookstore.
      Originally Posted by evilsaigon View Post

      Increase sales, yes. Reduce refunds? I don't think so. Clients judge your product quality after purchasing, not your guarantee parameters.
      Originally Posted by Malcolm Thomas View Post

      This. Having a guarantee does NOT reduce refunds, if anything it can actually increase refunds due to there being many serial refunders around nowadays. But nonetheless having a clearly stated refund policy does tend to increase the amount of sales that your product gets.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7756202].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author JasonBennet
    The Guarantee message is just part of the whole salesletter and I think it does help to let people know that they can purchase the product risk free. If they do not like it, they can request for refund.

    If the product is not junk and it does provide good value, most people will not request for refund. Of course there will be some serial refunders who try their luck to get the product for free but the good thing is that most of the people on the internet are honest people.

    I would instead focus my effort on giving them more values and getting more sales as that is the activity that will increase the bottom line.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7756798].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Will Edwards
    Very interesting to hear both sides of this. My own initial reaction was completely in line with Malcolm (above) but I also believe that Scrofford's point is completely valid.

    I have always worked on the premise that the quality of the sales letter is what gets the sale and the quality of the product/service is what stops the refund request. Though, of course, you will always get a minority who will want to take advantage of you; it is the price of doing business the way we do.

    Will
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757602].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author WillR
    Well obviously having a guarantee is only ever going to increase your refund rate. No one can argue that.

    But that's not what is important.

    All that matters is the profit you walk away with at the end of the day. That's why we are all in business, right? It's ok to increase your refund rate so long as your sales are also increasing in line with those refunds.

    A good refund policy should make you more money. Yes, by having a guarantee you are going to get refunds but by also having that guarantee you should be getting more sales so those refunds are quite insignificant.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757653].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Cool Hand Luke
      First things first: If you don't offer a refund period of at least 30 days, you will not have a paypal or merchant account for long... You just can't do business like that anymore, the payment processors and credit card companies don't tolerate a "no-refunds whatsoever" product. Your rates will either get raised or your account flagged and closed.

      Even if you didn't have to offer a refund guarantee (which again, you do), here's a fun fact:In the majority of cases (if your product is solid and delivers on the promises in the sales page) adding a prominent refund guarantee not only REDUCES refunds and chargebacks, but also increases sales.

      And refunds go down even further and sales go up further the longer your guarantee is (i.e. 365-day guarantee vs. 30-day guarantee).

      Again, test this for yourself people.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757754].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
        Banned
        Originally Posted by Cool Hand Luke View Post

        Wow. Four posts in a row giving out false information. Good stuff.
        There's a lot of talking at cross-purposes in this thread, and plenty of confusion about what some of the terms mean: that's why substantial parts of the discussion make no sense.

        It's simply factual that having a refund guarantee increases sales, and that having a refund guarantee with a longer period almost always reduces refunds compared with the number of refunds produced with a shorter-period refund guarantee. These points shouldn't be in contention at all.

        However, it's also trivially obvious, by definition, that if you don't offer refunds and have no guarantee, you'll get fewer refunds than if you do. That doesn't necessarily make it a sensible or an advisable thing to do, of course, but undeniably you'll have fewer refunds if they're not available. How could it possibly be otherwise?!

        Originally Posted by Cool Hand Luke View Post

        If you don't offer a refund period of at least 30 days, you will not have a paypal or merchant account for long...
        This really isn't quite right, Luke. There are digital products for sale, by PayPal only (including some WSO's!) which specify very clearly that there are no refund rights.

        Originally Posted by Cool Hand Luke View Post

        You just can't do business like that anymore, the payment processors and credit card companies don't tolerate a "no-refunds whatsoever" product.
        I think what you're really saying here is that you "shouldn't" do business like this any more, that it's "inadvisable" and so on. Not that you "can't". Clearly people can, and a few do, inadvisable though it may be. This is simply factual.

        Originally Posted by Cool Hand Luke View Post

        And refunds go down even further and sales go up further the longer your guarantee is (i.e. 365-day guarantee vs. 30-day guarantee).
        This is well known - nobody here is disputing it. But even a 5-year refund guarantee will clearly product more refunds than not having one at all - there's nothing smaller than zero!
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757789].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author malcsimm
    Troy23 - there is a ton of evidence that shows that, other things being equal, the better the guarantee, the more you will sell.

    It's definitely a bit worrying offering a fantastic guarantee. You just think: "everyone's going to cancel". But in practice this doesn't happen.

    When I introduced a lifetime, money-back guarantee to my mail order herbal company, 25 years ago, other people in the company were very, very concerned. But, happily, we did not get a flood of refunds and even now a refund is very rare.

    Online it's a little bit different in that it so easy to refund an electronic product and refund rates of 10 to 20% are not uncommon.

    However, you have to accept that there is a core of serial refunders who will always refund anyway and you get nowhere by trying to squeeze their money out of them – except aggravation to yourself.

    Those people aside, I will always lean towards having a solid guarantee. As others have commented, the product has to be good. That's a given.

    Jason Fladlien is one person who takes a guarantee very seriously. In at least some of his offers he really big is up the guarantee and actually offers a double guarantee - it's worth checking out his methods.

    One way to reduce refunds, incidentally, is to send a physical product. This can be done easily enough at the checkout by having a deal with Kunaki and a check box. Not everyone will take it: but every little helps. And, if it's an expensive product, how about sending everyone a bunch of physical flow-charts, diagrams, checklists - and to refund they have to return them? I am not saying make this a major feature because you want to cut refunds: but if you did do it, it would make a serious plus in your sales letter (and as a happy by-product, reduce refunds.)

    Good luck! And do think carefully about including a guarantee – it's an important part of encouraging sales.

    Best wishes, Malc
    Signature

    You WILL banish # Procrastination, # Email bloat, # Wasting time, # Wasting money
    Getting Things Done PLUS Evernote turned my life around - read here how I do it
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757655].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author malcsimm
    Troy23 - there is a ton of evidence that shows that, other things being equal, the better the guarantee, the more you will sell.

    It's definitely a bit worrying offering a fantastic guarantee. You just think: "everyone's going to cancel". But in practice this doesn't happen.

    When I introduced a lifetime, money-back guarantee to my mail order herbal company, 25 years ago, other people in the company were very, very concerned. But, happily, we did not get a flood of refunds and even now a refund is very rare.

    Online it's a little bit different in that it so easy to refund an electronic product and refund rates of 10 to 20% are not uncommon.

    However, you have to accept that there is a core of serial refunders who will always refund anyway and you get nowhere by trying to squeeze their money out of them - except aggravation to yourself.

    Those people aside, I will always lean towards having a solid guarantee. As others have commented, the product has to be good. That's a given.

    Jason Fladlien is one person who takes a guarantee very seriously. In at least some of his offers he really big is up the guarantee and actually offers a double guarantee - it's worth checking out his methods.

    One way to reduce refunds, incidentally, is to send a physical product. This can be done easily enough at the checkout by having a deal with Kunaki and a check box. Not everyone will take it: but every little helps. And, if it's an expensive product, how about sending everyone a bunch of physical flow-charts, diagrams, checklists - and to refund they have to return them? I am not saying make this a major feature because you want to cut refunds: but if you did do it, it would make a serious plus in your sales letter (and as a happy by-product, reduce refunds.)

    Good luck! And do think carefully about including a guarantee - it's an important part of encouraging sales.

    Best wishes, Malc
    Signature

    You WILL banish # Procrastination, # Email bloat, # Wasting time, # Wasting money
    Getting Things Done PLUS Evernote turned my life around - read here how I do it
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757658].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author blackli0n
    A little while back I asked the same question you did and got some great answers here on this thread: http://www.warriorforum.com/main-int...my-ebooks.html
    Signature
    wpjohnny.com - Make Money with Wordpress
    Passive income since 2007. Trying to consistently crack 5-figures/month. find what you love - dream big - work hard
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7757679].message }}

Trending Topics